Hi All - question about spells like Brimstone Cascade. When cast and the target has a Defense stat (say 3), does the caster have to make an Defense <-- Accurate to see if the target can defend the physical attack.
I put this question into ChatGPT and got the following answer which surprised me:
"Yes — Defense can be used against Brimstone Cascade, but there’s an important distinction in how the roll works.
In Symbaroum, the general combat rule says you may attempt to defend yourself against any attack you are aware of, and Defense is normally tested as [Defense ← Accurate]. A successful Defense means the attack misses completely.
However, Brimstone Cascade is written differently from a normal weapon attack. The caster makes a [Resolute ← Quick] test against the target. If successful, it does 1d12 damage; on a failure, it does 1d6.
So how does it work?
For Brimstone Cascade, the target does get a Defense reaction. If the target successfully defends, the Cascade misses and no damage is rolled.
If the Defense fails, the spell hits and the caster then determines whether it deals 1d12 or 1d6, based on the caster's Resolute → Quick test.
In other words:
Caster: Resolute → Quick
⬇
Target: Defense → Accurate
⬇
If Defense succeeds: Miss
If Defense fails: Spell hits → 1d12 or 1d6 damage
There is some ambiguity in the wording because Brimstone Cascade itself doesn't explicitly say "the target may make a Defense test." But the general Defense rule says all attacks can be defended against, and the spell is treated as an attack. The Foundry implementation of Symbaroum also treats Quick as the resisting attribute for Brimstone Cascade.
One important caveat: If you're asking because of a specific ability such as Tactician, Sixth Sense, Feint, or Robust, the answer can change depending on whether that ability modifies Defense or specifically changes the attribute used in a [Resolute ← Quick] test."
Let me know your thoughts on this. Thanks in advance.