I bought this for 360, not sure if that makes a difference, off the back of it seemingly being well reviewed, well recommended especially on here and the fact reTHAWed exists means it obviously clicked with some fans enough to bring it back.
Controls are tight and the game is quick and arcadey which is my favoured approach... "and then the bell rang" as they say.
Soundtrack is okay. In the past the songs I don't know have been easy to get a long to but some of the songs in this are quite abrasive and not fun to skate to. Mercifully there is an option to pick and choose which songs play and I ended up with quite a good selection.
The game feels like one large tutorial level. From pillar to post its teaching you the new mechanics and then... the game ends. Sure there's a big open world to skate in after* but... I've done all the goals. The levels themselves aren't super interesting and I'd argue skate ranch might be the worst of the bunch. Lots of the new furniture around it (I got all of them) don't flow well in my opinion and it feels like a lot of the new mechanics exist solely for those goals and then you don't really use them afterwards.
*though dont get me started on the loading zones. Just have loading screens if you need zones. They're bland and the lines are nothing at all exciting to trick on.
I just don't think it has the replay value of any of the games that came before it. Is this an issue of me not playing it at the time and hindsight being 20-20 and I have no nostalgia for it?