r/TankieTheDeprogram • • 15m ago

News/Communist Propaganda ☭ "Neutral" Ireland: Trinity College Dublin hosted arms lobbyists, pro-NATO thinktank experts and the Ambassador of Ukraine at a propaganda event co-organised by the university’s Ukrainian society and its Society for International Affairs.

Thumbnail
gallery
1 Upvotes

Trinity College Dublin hosted arms lobbyists, pro-NATO thinktank experts and the Ambassador of Ukraine at a propaganda event co-organised by the university’s Ukrainian society and its Society for International Affairs.

The panel, which was dubbed as a discussion on what “Ukraine’s road into the EU” means, was attended by 100 people. The panelists were pro-NATO, pro-Zelensky and pro-war industry, and also expressed sentiments critical of Irish neutrality. Larsya Gerasko, Ambassador of Ukraine to Ireland, Leena Gardemeister, Ambassador of Finland to Ireland, were joined by Dr. Ben Tonra, who is involved with Lockheed Martin and the war-industry as director of the Irish Defence and Security Association (IDSA).

Cian Fitzgerald, who is a senior researcher in security and defence policy at the Institute of International and European Affairs (IIEA), was also on the panel. The IIEA hosted NATO Deputy General Secretary Radmila Shekerinska in August 2026, which led to the building being defaced by anti-imperialist activists. Former TD Cathal Berry also spoke. He is a voice against Irish neutrality, having reprimanded former President Michael D Higgins in June 2023 over his pro-neutrality stance. The moderator of the debate was Pavlo Bogachenko, co-founder of the Ukrainian Irish Chamber of Commerce.

Ambassador Gerasko opened the panel by stating that Ukraine is defending Europe from the Russian threat. She stated that Ukraine is winning, and making technological developments. At the same time, she condemned the Russians for targeting energy infrastructure. She talked of the need for continued funding to the Ukrainian war effort by European partners.

Ambassador Gardemeister began by gloating about the fact that Finland, a neutral country at the time, managed to give military aid to Ukraine. “We found a way to do it, “ she said. She celebrated that Finland is no longer neutral, and celebrated its joining to the imperialist NATO. She then promulgated the myth that Finland, in 1939, was overtaken by Soviet invaders, comparing it to the 2022 invasion of Ukraine by Russia. The historical fact that these are completely unrelated, and different, contexts, clearly evaded her understanding.

Warmongerer Cathal Berry stated that he sees Ireland as a “demilitarised zone”. He criticised the “moderates” in government. He essentially stated that Ireland is reliant on imperialist powers for its defences, citing the lack of airspace defences, the inability to track drones which became apparent last time Zelensky visited, and foreign frigates defending Dublin during the EU Presidency. “Where is the thank you to Paris and London? “, he stated. He proceeded to speak of the bomb in Monaghan and parts for a bomb in Louth as examples of the failure of "the moderates" to say "thank you" to the big states. He claimed that this has created a growing generation of sympathisers to “obtaining political goals by violent means”. He claimed that while one person is responsible for the invasion of Ukraine, Vladimir Putin, Ireland needs to face its own “responsibility”. According to him, Putin looked at us, saw that we were “weak”, and this somehow contributed to his belief that he could attack Ukraine without pushback.

Dr Ben Tonra echoed the words of Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney on Europe’s weakness. He stated that the European Union is a “peace project” - tell that to the Palestinians - and slammed the people as being naive about the Russian threat. He said that Putin is fielding candidates in the second round of the upcoming French presidential elections, in reference to Le Pen and Melenchon, also equating the far-left and the far-right. He also stated that he expects to see such candidates in other nations.

Cian Fitzgerald of the IIEA said Russian hybrid warfare targets "you, me, our families", spoke of the salami technique which makes all attacks look non-serious individually, and reaction would seem disproportionate. He started listing alleged Russian attacks. One of these was “anti-semitic graffiti” across Europe to “divide the population”. He suggested to the audience as advice to “be vigilant” and “call your MEPs and TDs”.

It was at this point that the Q/A session started. One of our Aontacht Media journalists put up their hands to ask a question critical of the Zelensky government. The moderator of the panel, Pavlo Bogachenko, stated that the questions must be submitted via the Google Forms, which would undoubtedly be filtered by the organisers.

“I would like to pose my question to the Ambassador of Ukraine directly “, dissented László Molnárfi.

“Ambassador Gerasko, and I would like to pose this question to everyone here, why is no one addressing the elephant in the room? Ukraine is committing grave human rights abuses “, he continued.

“We have seen forced conscription in Ukraine, men being thrown into unmarked cars, sent to be slaughtered in war. People Before Profit, Paul Murphy TD, raised this in the Dáil, condemned bussification. It's called bussification“, he stated over increasing attempts to drown him out.

“And the FFG government here is turning back Ukrainian refugees on the orders of Zelensky and the European Union. And in Ukraine, the borders are closed and men who want to escape the war can't do so. They can't do so. And those who protest against it are put on the Myrotvorets database of state traitors, “ he continued, attempting to make his voice heard over the shouts of the crowd.

“Shame on the Zelensky regime! Shame, shame on all of you! And Dr. Ben Tonra there, he is an arms lobbyist who works with Lockheed Martin! “, he stated, as the crowd began chanting “out, out, out!”, and called security.

Molnárfi was escorted away by security, as Cathal Berry compared him and others like him to “Putin’s men in Ireland”, later stating that “he’s just like Putin and his friends in Europe”. In the hallway outside, he said to Molnárfi that “you are off your meds” and that “you have blood on your hands”.

Meanwhile, inside the room, an activist with the Communist Party of Ireland, Harun Šiljak, drew attention to Dr. Ben Tonra’s links with the war-industry. Ironically, this was not received as a shock by the audience, despite the attempt to expose his warmongering. Tonra gleefully described his work, and asserted that much insight can be gained from the war-industry for European matters.

Later on, Olesia Zhitkova spoke of her PhD research - disinformation studies at DCU - which is centred around the claim that all references to corruption in Ukraine are Russian propaganda, not only by Russia, but also by its supposed proxies in Ireland and EU. Olesia also noted that the “EU’s biggest strength is its biggest weakness”, that because the EU is so dedicated to free speech, it cannot stop Russian propaganda and sanction it properly. This can be understood as support for sanctions such as the one which were recently handed down by Brussels to Irish journalist Chay Bowes.

Claudia Bădulescu made a reference to Molnárfi in answering a question about EU enlargement. The question was whether Eastern European countries would feel threatened by Ukraine's agricultural production entering the EU market, and she said that "threat of conscription, as witnessed earlier, is strong, and that Poles would rather see Ukrainian wheat threaten their economy than conscription in Poland".

Ireland has already taken side in the war: Zelensky’s side against the Ukrainian people. “Neutral” Ireland is enforcing conscription against Ukrainians as part of its refugee policies. As Paul Murphy’s parliamentary request revealed, 173 Ukrainians were refused protection in Ireland since 5 August 2026. Gerasko et al seem to be happy with their compatriots being turned back, as their lives as “Professional Ukrainians” are settled with careers linked to the war’s continuation.

Members of the TCD Ukrainian Society, growing up in emigration and receiving free taxpayer-funded education at the most prestigious university in Ireland via the BOTP tuition fee scheme, seem to be unable to critically reflect on the different material realities that EU external rule subjects their working-class compatriots to - being hunted in the streets like wild animals and dragged into unmarked vehicles.

Ukrainian middle classers in Ireland left the working class and its problems back in the country with no elections, closed borders, permanent busification and Azov torture chambers. Unfortunately, they seem to have no compassion for the working class of their own country, shouting down the very possibility of questions about human rights violations in Ukraine. By doing this they condemn the working class to be slaughtered in the West’s proxy war until the last Ukrainian.

Despite their inability to put themselves in the place of their busified compatriots, they should remember: the fact that they will themselves reach conscription age someday. And considering that FFG excludes years spent on Temporary Protection from the time recognised for naturalisation purposes, and that Zelensky is openly asking EU governments to send refugees back, their own future may indeed be unpleasant.

The war scenario they promote will inevitably lead to open EU-Russia confrontation if escalation continues.

We advise them to critically reflect on the future of social welfare supports to non-citizens and the BOTP tuition scheme in the case of this scenario, and on the future of people living in the EU on the basis of precarious Temporary Protection, who will be considered by the EU warmongers as the first candidates to be sent into the meat grinder prior to their own citizens.

https://aontachtmedia.ie/where-is-the-thank-you-to-london-and-paris-ask-nato-apologists-at-trinity-propaganda-event/


r/TankieTheDeprogram • • 41m ago

Reactionary Mockery How to masterfully parody Jewish supremacist Zionists

Thumbnail
gallery
11 Upvotes

r/TankieTheDeprogram • • 49m ago

Discussion Need some help to find based subreddits

6 Upvotes

Hi, comrades!

Since I'm new here, could you recommend some subreddits that are actually communist—not just "left-wing," liberal, or social democratic?


r/TankieTheDeprogram • • 53m ago

Communism Will Win China is featuring scientists in massive drone swarm shows in the sky. These are some of the real stars we should follow. They lifted China from weak to strong in defense, food, health, and technology…

60 Upvotes

r/TankieTheDeprogram • • 1h ago

News/Communist Propaganda ☭ Saturday, November 21, 2026: Protesters filled the streets of Berlin marching in powerful solidarity with Gaza. They condemned Germany’s ongoing support for Israel and protested against the heavy crackdown on pro Palestine rallies with the slogan: Solidarity Is Not a Crime – Free Palestine"

29 Upvotes

r/TankieTheDeprogram • • 1h ago

History Andriy Biletsky, Founder of the Ukrainian Nazi Azov Corps, held several Intermarium Conferences ("between the seas" proposed political union of Poland, Ukraine, and Baltics) during the first phase of the war from 2014 to 2022. Military attaches / politicians from Poland and Baltics attended

8 Upvotes

The Intermarium concept itself goes back hundreds of years.

https://x.com/rinalu_/status/2124231435603358121


r/TankieTheDeprogram • • 2h ago

Solidarity With Palestine San Juan Puerto Rico : Miss Israel was booed during the ongoing Miss Universe 2026 national costume presentation while wearing an unfolding AI-designed shawl featuring the word "peace".

180 Upvotes

r/TankieTheDeprogram • • 2h ago

Weekly Discussion (General discussion thread) The Monthly Review ft. Arun Kundnani - Ep 260

Thumbnail
youtu.be
4 Upvotes

Previous discussion > Breitbart - Ep 259


r/TankieTheDeprogram • • 2h ago

News/Communist Propaganda ☭ Another 240 million to Ukraine this winter bringing Britain's total contribution to about 35 billion to continue fighting until the last Ukrainian.

Post image
11 Upvotes

r/TankieTheDeprogram • • 2h ago

Reactionary Mockery Eric Weinstein is a Fraud

13 Upvotes

r/TankieTheDeprogram • • 2h ago

Discussion Private Profit, Public Failure: What America's Power Grid Reveals About Privatisation - The Left Views

Thumbnail
leftviews.in
9 Upvotes

Transmission lines are not merely engineering assets. They are the arteries of a modern economy. They determine whether electricity generated in windy plains, sunny deserts, hydroelectric regions, or industrial centres can reach homes and workplaces hundreds of kilometres away. They determine whether one region can support another during a heatwave, blizzard, or hurricane. They influence whether families receive reliable electricity at a reasonable cost or face rising bills and recurring uncertainty.

In the United States, much of this strategic infrastructure is owned and operated by investor-owned utilities whose primary obligation is to shareholders. Their financial model rewards growth in invested capital and the returns earned on that capital. The evidence increasingly suggests that this model has struggled to deliver transmission development at the scale and speed required to meet broader public needs. While shareholders have received stable returns, consumers have faced rising congestion costs, growing reliability concerns, lengthy delays in connecting new power projects, and increasing electricity burdens.

The Profit Engine Behind the Grid

Investor-owned utilities earn profits through a regulatory framework that allows them to recover costs and earn an authorised return on equity on investments in transmission lines, substations, and related infrastructure. In 2024, the average authorised return on equity remained around 9.7 percent. Several independent analyses have concluded that the returns granted to regulated monopoly utilities often exceed their actual cost of equity, resulting in substantial transfers from consumers to investors. Research from the University of California Berkeley estimated that excess utility returns have imposed costs averaging roughly $7 billion annually on U.S. consumers over long periods.

The significance of this system is not limited to the level of profits involved. It lies in the incentives it creates. Because earnings are tied to the value of assets included in the utility's rate base, additional investment generally leads to additional profits. The result is a financial framework that rewards expansion of utility-owned assets more reliably than it rewards system-wide efficiency or social benefit. Projects that increase the asset base move naturally to the front of the queue, while projects whose benefits are widely shared across regions often advance more slowly.

Electricity consumers may require lower costs, greater resilience, and stronger interregional connections. Investors, however, are rewarded for capital committed and authorised returns earned. The priorities are not always the same.

America Is Not Building the Grid It Needs

The consequences are visible in the pace of transmission development.

The United States is entering a period of rapidly growing electricity demand driven by industrial electrification, electric vehicles, artificial intelligence, data centres, and advanced manufacturing. Yet high-voltage transmission expansion remains remarkably slow. Recent assessments show that only a few hundred miles of new high-voltage transmission lines were added annually, while Department of Energy analysis indicates that several thousand miles per year may be required to ensure reliability, support economic growth, and enable efficient movement of power across regions.[cleanenergygrid.org],[rtoinsider.com]

Most transmission projects continue to be developed within regional boundaries. Large interregional projects, capable of moving substantial quantities of low-cost electricity across the country, remain comparatively rare. The result is a system in which regional bottlenecks persist even as demand grows rapidly.

This is not simply an infrastructure gap. It is an investment pattern that favours what is easiest to recover financially rather than what may be most valuable for the nation as a whole.

Consumers Pay for Congestion

When electricity cannot move efficiently from areas with abundant low-cost generation to areas where it is needed, consumers ultimately bear the cost.

Transmission congestion occurs when the network lacks sufficient capacity to transport cheaper electricity to demand centres. Grid operators are then forced to rely on more expensive generation sources, increasing costs throughout the system.

The economic consequences have become significant. Grid Strategies estimates that congestion costs exceeded $17 billion in 2025, up from approximately $12 billion in 2024. Even after adjusting for inflation, average annual congestion costs have nearly doubled compared with the late 2010s.

These costs do not disappear into spreadsheets. They are reflected in wholesale market prices, utility procurement costs, and ultimately the electricity bills paid by households, schools, hospitals, farmers, and businesses. Every year that transmission bottlenecks remain unresolved, consumers continue paying more than necessary for electricity.

Clean Energy is Being Wasted

One of the clearest signs of transmission inadequacy is the growing volume of renewable energy waiting for access to the grid.

According to Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, more than 2,060 GW of generation and storage capacity was seeking grid interconnection at the end of 2025. That figure is nearly double the capacity currently installed across the United States. The median project timeline for projects that eventually reach operation has exceeded five years.

Large volumes of renewable electricity are also curtailed after construction. Solar facilities in California regularly reduce output because transmission networks cannot move electricity to other regions when generation peaks. Wind facilities in Texas and parts of the Midwest face similar constraints. Clean electricity that could lower costs and reduce emissions is frequently left unused because the transmission system cannot accommodate it.

The challenge is not primarily a shortage of generation. It is an inability to move electricity efficiently from where it is produced to where it is needed.

When the Grid Falls Short, Ordinary People Bear the Burden

The consequences of transmission shortcomings are not distributed equally.

Extreme weather events have become increasingly disruptive to electricity systems across the United States. Major storms have contributed to substantial increases in outage durations in recent years. Stronger interregional transmission connections cannot prevent hurricanes, wildfires, or storms, but they can improve resilience by enabling regions to share resources more effectively before and after disruptions.

The social impact of electricity disruptions extends beyond technical reliability metrics. Rural communities often experience more frequent service interruptions. Lower-income households spend a larger share of their income on electricity. Communities with fewer economic resources frequently face longer and more difficult recovery periods after major disasters.

Research examining major hurricanes has found that lower-income communities often wait longer for power restoration than wealthier areas. At the same time, growing electricity demand from data centres and other large industrial loads is driving new infrastructure investment whose costs are frequently shared across the wider customer base.

For affluent households, rising electricity costs may represent an inconvenience. For struggling families, they can mean difficult choices between electricity, food, healthcare, education, and other necessities. Energy policy is therefore not merely an economic issue. It is a question of social justice.

Why the Private Model Fails Strategic Infrastructure

The American experience raises a fundamental question about the governance of essential infrastructure.

A transmission network is not simply a collection of private assets. It is a national system whose benefits extend far beyond the financial returns earned by its owners. Its purpose is to support economic activity, maintain reliability, promote regional development, integrate energy resources, and ensure that citizens have access to affordable electricity.

Yet private capital responds primarily to financial incentives. It seeks investments that maximise risk-adjusted returns. It does not automatically prioritise national integration, regional equity, long-term resilience, or affordability for vulnerable households.

This is not a criticism of individual companies. It is a recognition of how incentives work.

When a transmission line creates benefits that are spread across multiple states, regions, industries, and millions of consumers, private investors may capture only a fraction of those gains. Society may need the project urgently, but the financial incentive to build it remains weak. As a result, projects with large public value but limited private upside often face years of delay.

The outcome is predictable. A system organised around shareholder returns will tend to deliver shareholder returns. It will not necessarily deliver the transmission network society most needs.

Lessons for India

India has followed a different path. The development of the country's interstate transmission system has largely occurred under public leadership, with Power Grid Corporation of India playing a central role in creating one of the world's largest synchronised grids. Public ownership continues to dominate the strategic backbone of the transmission network.

India undoubtedly requires massive investment in transmission infrastructure to support industrialisation, urbanisation, electrification, and the target of 500 GW of non-fossil capacity. The financing requirements are substantial, and mechanisms such as asset monetisation may have a role in mobilising resources.

However, financing and control are not the same thing.

The American experience demonstrates that private ownership and profit-driven incentives do not automatically produce outcomes that serve the broader public interest. The United States today faces transmission congestion costs exceeding $17 billion annually, a queue of more than 2,060 GW of generation and storage projects awaiting connection, growing renewable-energy curtailment, and persistent challenges in developing large interregional transmission corridors.

These outcomes are not isolated failures. They reflect the limitations of a model that treats strategic infrastructure primarily as a vehicle for financial returns.

India's transmission network is more than a commercial asset. It is a foundation of national development, energy security, economic integration, and social welfare. Public investment in such infrastructure is not merely an economic choice; it is a commitment to ensuring that the grid serves citizens before shareholders.

The central lesson from America is therefore clear. A nation's electricity grid cannot be judged solely by the returns it generates for investors. It must be judged by its ability to deliver affordable, reliable, and equitable electricity to the people who depend upon it. When those objectives come into conflict, the evidence from the United States suggests that a privatised, profit-driven model too often places shareholder value ahead of public need.

Copied from the LeftViews article which licenses its text under the CC-BY-NC-SA 4.0 copyleft license.


r/TankieTheDeprogram • • 3h ago

News/Communist Propaganda ☭ A compilation of street shots from a recent visit to the DPRK! Thankfully, Russian and Chinese people can now travel freely to North Korea so we'll be seeing a lot more content from there recently.

91 Upvotes

r/TankieTheDeprogram • • 3h ago

Capitalist Decay Meet the fairly new "Labour" Prime Minister of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland LARPing as a DJ to pre-Madchester sounds. His policies are exactly the same as the last guy's, he even looks like the last guy, and nobody can remember his name...

33 Upvotes

r/TankieTheDeprogram • • 4h ago

News/Communist Propaganda ☭ Be honest, does Pyongyang look better than your hometown?

53 Upvotes

r/TankieTheDeprogram • • 4h ago

Solidarity With Palestine Israeli settlers attack a Palestinian family harvesting olives in Wadi Ma’in, Masafer Yatta, assaulting family members and stealing their olive harvest.

30 Upvotes

r/TankieTheDeprogram • • 4h ago

Reactionary Mockery Have you ever noticed that libs don't consider PRC and Russia the successors when push comes to shove?

Post image
110 Upvotes

r/TankieTheDeprogram • • 5h ago

News/Communist Propaganda ☭ Friday November 20th 2026: Spanish neo-Nazis mourn death of Franco: Far-right demonstrators marched through Madrid, with many performing Nazi salutes on the 51st anniversary of the dictator’s death.

32 Upvotes

Supporters of Spanish dictator Francisco Franco marched through Madrid on Friday night, with some performing Nazi salutes during commemorations marking the 51st anniversary of his death and the 90th anniversary of the execution of Jose Antonio Primo de Rivera, the founder of Spain’s fascist Falange movement.

The demonstration was organized by the far-right Falange Espanola de las JONS, which published several videos of the procession with the slogan: “We won’t stop until we have reconquered Spain.”

The march began on Genova Street, home to the headquarters of the conservative People’s Party (PP), and proceeded toward Ferraz Street, where the ruling Socialist Workers’ Party (PSOE) is headquartered.

In another video, demonstrators sing the Falange anthem, ‘Cara al Sol’, outside the PSOE headquarters. “We have passed and we will pass again,” the organizers said.

The commemorations came less than two weeks after police arrested 14 suspected members of another neo-Nazi organization, Nucleo Nacional, which has documented ties to Falange Espanola de las JONS. Members of both groups have taken part in joint demonstrations, including a protest outside the Moroccan Embassy in Madrid in July.

According to an investigation by El Pais, Nucleo Nacional militants traveled to Ukraine in August, where they established contact with the notorious neo-Nazi Azov unit, now part of Ukraine’s National Guard.

The Spanish militants reportedly trained with AK-47 assault rifles to acquire combat skills they can pass on to recruits in preparation for an armed uprising in Spain. The investigation also uncovered images of the militants posing with weapons and displaying Nazi symbols while in Ukraine.

Earlier on Friday, Franco supporters gathered at Mingorrubio Cemetery in Madrid, where the former dictator was reburied in 2019 after his remains were removed from the Valley of the Fallen mausoleum.

Franco ruled Spain from the end of the Spanish Civil War in 1939 until his death in 1975. His dictatorship imprisoned and tortured political opponents; more than 35,000 postwar executions were documented across 33 Spanish provinces in the decade following the Civil War, according to research by Spanish historian Julian Casanova.

The documented count excluded several provinces, including Madrid, due to gaps in the available data. Casanova estimated that at least 50,000 people were executed during that period.

https://x.com/rbg4lif/status/2124185569395687688


r/TankieTheDeprogram • • 5h ago

News/Communist Propaganda ☭ Another 240 million to Ukraine this winter bringing Britain's total contribution to about 35 billion.

Post image
13 Upvotes

r/TankieTheDeprogram • • 7h ago

Shitposting The British have been good neighbors to anyone?

56 Upvotes

r/TankieTheDeprogram • • 8h ago

Meme It needs to be said

Post image
792 Upvotes

r/TankieTheDeprogram • • 8h ago

Meme 'Spreading civilization and democracy'

Post image
54 Upvotes

r/TankieTheDeprogram • • 9h ago

History the final victory of the counter-revolution in Russia.

Post image
214 Upvotes

Black October, 1993.

Photo by Vladimir Velengurin.


r/TankieTheDeprogram • • 10h ago

Meme Nothing ever happens —> Unity of opposites —> HAPPENING🥹🥹🥹

19 Upvotes

r/TankieTheDeprogram • • 10h ago

Meme Explaining the 'but at what cost?' Western media meme

59 Upvotes

r/TankieTheDeprogram • • 11h ago

Stalin Approves Rare goated tweet translated from Turkish

Post image
153 Upvotes

Most of the other Turkish posts on my Xitter feed are reactionary Islamist/Pan-Turkist slop for some reason, so I was pleasantly surprised by this one lol