I’m a high school English and theatre teacher. Our school’s fall play is happening this week, and I offer extra credit for students in my classes to come attend the production and write a review. In the instructions, I specify that students should support their opinions with valid reasons, and be sincere, objective, fair, and constructive. I remind students not to be overly critical and to approach a performance with an attitude of enjoying it. “Be humble, kind, and remember the challenges of doing live theatre.” I don’t explicitly spell out audience behavior expectations in the instructions, which will matter later…
Last night, a group of students from one of my classes attended the show and demonstrated disrespectful audience behavior. Unfortunately, I didn’t directly witness any of it as I was busy with the box office, backstage, etc. but my student ushers and other crew members shared what happened with me.
During intermission, someone in the group spilled an energy drink in the theatre, where food and drinks are not allowed. When my ushers came to help clean it up, no one in the group took responsibility, which delayed resuming the show. The group also made numerous loud comments during the performance, including that “no one would come to the play” without the extra-credit offer and that the show was “stupid,” as well as inappropriate remarks about the actors, characters, and story.
After intermission, several audience members moved seats after repeatedly asking the group to stop talking. Following the performance, several people approached me to share that the group's comments had disrupted their viewing experience and upset them. They shared photos to help identify the students involved. One student audience member was particularly distressed and hesitant to repeat the words that had been said by the group.
I emailed the parents of the students involved explaining what happened and stated that “Respectful behavior is an expected part of attending a production, so I will not grant Student extra credit for attending. I’m concerned about the impact of the group’s behavior on the performers, audience, and ushers, as well as the lack of respect shown to the students who worked hard to create a production for the community. I would like to arrange a meeting to hear Student’s perspective of what happened and to discuss next steps.”
I got an email back from one of the parents this morning stating the following:
“I have a few concerns. I don't think a teacher should offer extra credit for attending a paid event outside school hours. Not every student can buy a ticket or come back to school in the evening.
As you described it, the offer was extra credit for seeing the production and writing a review. Behavior was not one of the conditions, so I don't think it should be the reason to withhold the credit. The district's grading guidance also says grades should reflect academic work and that behavior is recorded separately.”
I’m not quite sure how to respond, or if I was in the wrong to state that I was rescinding the extra credit opportunity based on behavior. Any advice on how to respond would be much appreciated! I’ve also looped the student’s admin in to the correspondence.
ETA: We offer fee waivers for qualifying students so that cost is not a prohibiting factor. I recognize not all students have time/transportation access to attend, hence why this is an optional assignment and not required. I also offer non-event extra credit opportunities throughout the year.