I've been experiencing a few issues with my 2023 Model S Plaid that I've had for 8 months (CPO with 30k miles), and I'm wondering if anyone has experienced something similar or knows what might be causing them.
1. Knocking/clunking noise during acceleration, braking, and steering (main concern)
There's a distinct knocking/clunking sound that I can consistently reproduce under a few conditions:
- Acceleration: Starting around 15 mph, applying 25% throttle produces an audible knock/clunk.
- Braking: Moderately firm braking produces a similar knocking sound.
- Steering: Quick, aggressive left-right steering transitions can also produce the knocking sound as direction changes.
It sounds like it's coming from somewhere toward the rear, but I can't tell for sure. I don't feel anything unusual when it happens. No noticeable vibration or change in handling, just the audible knock. The car otherwise seems to drive normally.
Since it happens under acceleration, braking, and lateral load changes, I'm wondering if something in the suspension or drivetrain is shifting around under load.
Has anyone experienced this? Control arms, bushings, suspension links, motor mounts, loose hardware, or something else?
2. Front half-shaft/driveline vibration under acceleration
I've also been experiencing the apparently common Model S Plaid acceleration shudder.
Under moderate to hard acceleration, there's a noticeable vibration/shudder that sometimes becomes stronger when accelerating while turning. I exclusively drive with the suspension set to Low.
One interesting detail I just remembered:
When I first bought the car, I occasionally accelerated hard with the suspension set to Medium. The car felt surprisingly unstable under acceleration, almost like it wasn't tracking straight or settling properly. I eventually read that hard acceleration should be done in Low, so I switched to that permanently, and it made a huge difference. The car felt much more stable.
I later had a four wheel alignment performed, and I noticed the car drove smoother and felt more stable afterward. However, I haven't tried Medium again since that alignment, so I don't know whether the original instability was caused by the alignment or the ride height.
I'm wondering if the acceleration shudder is just the known Plaid half-shaft issue or if it could be related to whatever is causing the knocking.
Has anyone had the half-shafts replaced under warranty? Did it completely resolve the vibration?
3. Possible uneven tire wear on the passenger side
This one isn't fully confirmed yet, but I've noticed something strange with the tire wear.
Both passenger-side tires were replaced around 4 months ago, and Tesla performed a four-wheel alignment at the same time.
Despite being much newer, those passenger-side tires already appear to have worn down to approximately the same tread depth as the older driver-side tires.
For context:
- Driver rear: Original tire from when I purchased the vehicle CPO around 8 months ago. Approximately 7/32" at pickup. Now its at 6/32".
- Driver front: Replaced by Tesla around CPO delivery due to a tire defect. Approximately 9/32" when new. Now its at 7/32".
- Both passenger tires: Replaced only 4 months ago, but now appear to have similar remaining tread to the older driver-side tires at 6/32" for both.
I'm aware of the notorious inner rear tire wear issue on the Plaid, but this seems different since both passenger side tires may be wearing faster.
Could a worn suspension component, loose bushing, or something shifting under load cause uneven tire wear even after a recent alignment?
4. Could these issues be connected?
This is what I'm most curious about.
I've got:
- A knocking/clunking noise during acceleration, braking, and quick steering transitions.
- Acceleration shudder, especially while turning.
- Previously unstable-feeling acceleration at Medium ride height.
- Noticeably improved driving behavior after an alignment.
- Possible accelerated tire wear on both passenger-side tires.
I'm wondering whether these are separate common Plaid issues or symptoms of something wrong with the suspension/drivetrain.
I will do a service request soon, just waiting for wheels to come back in stock as I want to switch to 19's, but I'd like to hear from anyone who has experienced similar problems, especially if you've had them successfully repaired.
What ended up being the cause? What parts were replaced? Did the repairs actually fix it?
Thanks in advance!