I have a 2017 Model S and the front passenger handle was not presenting and had a clunk on calibration.
My front passenger handle stopped popping out completely. The door still opened with a hard press, but that was it. Running calibration in Service Mode just gave a loud clunk and "Calibration Failed". That clunk was the gear skipping. The motor was fine, it just wasn't driving the handle.
First thing to work out is which handle gen you've got, because 2017 cars could have either (Tesla switched to Gen 3 around July 2017, and mine's an Aug 2017 build). You can't tell from Service Mode. When I requested a handle replacement, Tesla told me the gen, and once the handle was off it was obvious: it had a Hall sensor and magnet clip, not microswitches, so it was Gen 3. Loads of the Gen 1/2 guides and parts I found online were no help.
I bought a £9 steel gear kit from EV Accessories, but never fitted it. The old motor gear looked like it was fused onto the shaft and wouldn't budge. I didn't fancy cutting it off and still ending up with a dodgy magnet sensor, because the magnet clip was sitting crooked too. The bigger gear it drove, the one that pushed the handle out, also looked worn. So I bought a new Gen 3 handle straight from Tesla, part 1100299-00-A (same part front and rear left), for £200 and fitted it myself.
Getting the old handle off was a bit tricky. I had to wind the window partway down just to reach the 10mm nut. Honestly, it's not a great design and feels like an over-engineered solution that's fiddly to work on. Putting the new one in was just as fiddly. I had to swap the paddle and the casing over from the old handle first. Then that same 10mm nut sits right behind the window, and I didn't want to take the glass out or loosen it from its clamps. So I cut a small notch in the handle where that nut goes so I could slide it in past the window. There are three other nuts holding it, so I didn't see it as an issue.
I did it partly to learn how it all works, and I saved myself £212 in labour against Tesla's £412 quote.
What I learned:
- check which version you have before you start
- My replacement had a different looking motor and came without the paddle and casing, so I moved mine across. It was fine because the part number and plug matched.
- I didn't need to pull the 12V. I just put it in Service Mode, lowered the window enough to reach the nut and unplugged the handle before going near the motor.
- I tested and calibrated before clipping the door card back on.
- the clips are rubbish even replacement ones so I need to figure out a solution for that to keep the doorcard fully in, I wish they'd just have a bolt at the bottom corners
Result
All works great now! And also the sound deadening and upgraded midwoofers are fantastic for a straight swap over with stock speakers. I did have to cut out the housing to get these midwoofers to fit but it wasn't super difficult.
Difficulty
I'd say 7/10 don't try this if you don't have tools, a good magnet and are confident you can overcome small setbacks. It's not super clear or easy.