I want to approach Scripture a little differently, and I think it starts with a simple question: Are we sometimes so familiar with the way we've been taught to picture a biblical event that we stop investigating what the text actually tells us?
My background is in criminal law and justice, so naturally, I tend to look at things through an investigative lens. When examining a case, you don't just look at one statement or one moment and assume you have the whole story. You look at the circumstances, the people involved, their actions, their motives, the sequence of events, and how the testimony connects with other evidence. Sometimes something that seems insignificant on its own becomes much more interesting when you put it alongside something else. That's actually one of the reasons I find Luke's approach interesting. In Luke 1:1–4, he explains that he carefully investigated the accounts and set them down in an orderly manner. He wasn't asking people to accept a story without examination. He wanted them to have an accurate understanding of what had been taught.
So why shouldn't we bring that same willingness to investigate when reading the rest of Scripture? Take Genesis 3, for example. Most of us grew up picturing Satan as an ordinary snake crawling through the Garden, approaching Eve and having a conversation with her. But have we ever stopped to ask whether that familiar picture actually answers all the questions the passage raises? Genesis 2 tells us Adam was given dominion over creation and was responsible for naming the animals. He wasn't presented as someone unfamiliar with the creatures around him.
So here's something I've always wondered: if Adam and Eve were living in an ordered creation, and they had been given responsibility over the animals, would an ordinary animal suddenly questioning God's command and engaging in a theological conversation have seemed completely normal to them? The Bible doesn't tell us exactly what they knew about animal communication, so I'm not claiming that this proves anything. But I think it's a fair question.
And it leads me to another one: What if the deception in Eden involved more than an ordinary serpent speaking? What if the real deception also involved the identity and appearance of the one approaching Eve? Could Satan have presented himself in a way that Eve didn't immediately recognize as something hostile to God? Could he have appeared familiar, authoritative, or even associated with the heavenly order? I'm not saying Genesis identifies Satan as a seraph, or that the Bible explicitly tells us he transformed into another being. It doesn't. But I think there are some interesting passages worth putting alongside one another. Isaiah 6 describes seraphim in God's presence, while Isaiah 14 and Ezekiel 28 contain descriptions of pride, heavenly imagery, and rebellion that have historically been discussed in connection with Satan. Revelation 12:9 then directly identifies the ancient serpent with the Devil and Satan. That establishes a connection between Satan and the serpent in the biblical narrative, but does it tell us exactly what Satan looked like when he approached Eve? Does it establish that he appeared as an ordinary animal, or is the serpent also identifying the spiritual adversary behind the deception? I think those are two different questions, and we shouldn't automatically assume that answering one settles the other. Even the Hebrew word nachash, translated as serpent in Genesis, deserves attention when examining the original language and its use throughout Scripture.
I'm interested in understanding whether the language, imagery, and later biblical references give us a fuller picture of who was actually involved in that encounter. Think about how deception works in the first place. Someone impersonating authority doesn't necessarily approach you looking like an enemy. In fact, deception can be most effective when the person presenting the lie appears trustworthy or familiar. So could Eve have been deceived not simply by what was said, but by who she believed was saying it? And look at what the serpent actually does. He begins by questioning God's Word: "Yea, hath God said?" Then he challenges God's warning, offers an alternative explanation, and presents disobedience as an opportunity for something greater.
The result is much bigger than eating a piece of fruit. It produces shame, blame, a breakdown in the relationship between humanity and God, and ultimately separation. I think we need to pay attention to that entire sequence, not just the final act. Could the deception in Eden be the first example of a much larger pattern that continues throughout Scripture? Could understanding the identity and methods of the deceiver help us better understand why the Cross was necessary in the first place?
That's really what I'm interested in investigating. I don't want to manufacture connections or make a theory fit just because I find it interesting. I want to put the passages beside one another, examine the language, look at the context, and see whether the connections actually hold up.
This is also why I find the Jewish interpretive framework of PaRDeS interesting. It recognizes different levels of approaching Scripture: Peshat, the plain meaning; Remez, hints and allusions; Derash, deeper examination and interpretation; and Sod, the hidden or deeper dimension. I don't believe that means every passage has some secret meaning waiting to be discovered, but it does remind us that there is more than one way to investigate what Scripture may be communicating. We should start with what is actually written, examine what it might point toward, compare it with the rest of the biblical testimony, and be careful about the difference between what we can establish and what we're only proposing.
My goal isn't to tell anyone that my interpretation is automatically right. I'm inviting people to question familiar assumptions, including mine. After all, if we're going to examine Scripture seriously, our own conclusions should be subject to the same scrutiny as everyone else's. I believe the Holy Spirit should guide that process, because gaining knowledge of Scripture without seeking the heart and purpose behind God's Word can become an exercise in knowledge alone.
☆I'm not interested in winning an argument or creating another interpretation for people to defend.
☆I'm interested in understanding the events that led to the Fall, the nature of the deception, and how those events connect to the coming of Jesus Christ. Because ultimately, this isn't just a case about a serpent in a garden. It's about the beginning of humanity's separation from God, the adversary behind that separation, and the reason the Cross became necessary.
●So here's where I'd like to start: Have we really examined who Satan was in Eden, or have we simply inherited an image of the encounter without questioning whether the biblical record tells us more?