I'm a woman in my 30s, and last year I met a man (early 40s) I'll call M. We matched on Hinge while both recovering from difficult breakups. I briefly disappeared after reconciling with my ex, J, who subsequently got me pregnant, abandoned me again, and left me dealing with an abortion and A LOT of trauma. A couple of months later, I reached out to M, and we started dating. He was handsome, masculine, successful, incredibly funny and intelligent. But what really stood out was how safe and understood I felt around him. We shared an almost identical sense of humour and could talk endlessly about politics, psychology, careers and life. One Saturday, when I was crying over J, he invited me out for coffee. We ended up spending six wonderful hours exploring London, laughing and talking. That day became one of my favourite memories of the year.
Over the following months, we became incredibly close. I've genuinely never felt so understood by another person. He was an extraordinary listener, unbelievably patient with me, and seemed to understand how my mind worked better than anyone I'd ever met. I'm a PhD student, and he works in AI, and he constantly encouraged my ambitions. Around him, I felt like the best version of myself: happier, more productive, disciplined, confident and content. We eventually became intimate over Easter weekend, and the chemistry was incredible. He was honestly the best kisser I've ever had, and our sex life was amazing. It felt like having a best friend and lover in one person. I told him how much I liked him, and he felt the same. For a brief period, I thought I'd found something really special.
But there was a major problem. He had an extremely complicated on-and-off relationship with his ex, S, who discovered me and started contacting him obsessively, reportedly calling him around 100 times on one occasion. He struggled to establish boundaries. He later explained that she had allegedly threatened to make false police allegations against him and interfere with his immigration status if he left her. He was on a UK visa and terrified of losing everything he'd built. He was also separated but still legally married to another woman because, according to him, he was helping her obtain permanent residency before divorcing. I couldn't verify these threats, and I didn't know all the details initially. I just saw a man who couldn't get his ex out of his life. I ended our romantic relationship in April because I couldn't tolerate the instability. But part of me wondered whether I was being unfair to someone genuinely struggling to leave a volatile relationship.
We reconnected as friends in June, and our chemistry never disappeared. He continued supporting me emotionally, even listening patiently while I cried over J, who was now getting married. I was financially struggling with around £5,000–£6,000 in credit card debt, and over time M helped me with approximately £1,500–£2,000, including gifts, without expecting anything in return. Once, I casually mentioned that I couldn't afford to do anything for my mother's birthday, and he unexpectedly sent me £200 to take her somewhere nice. My mother was so touched that she asked to meet him. They got along incredibly well, and afterwards she kept telling me what a wonderful man he was. When I explained why we'd broken up, she said, "You should have fought for him." That really stayed with me. A few days later, while drinking with my cousins, I drunkenly begged him to come see me because I missed him and wanted him sexually. He said he couldn't because S was coming over and he didn't want another confrontation. I lashed out and told him to fuck off. He patiently explained his situation again, and I apologised a few days later.
Things got worse when S began contacting me directly, leaving around a dozen furious voice notes and claiming she knew where I lived and worked. It genuinely frightened me. In August, M told me he still loved our connection and wanted another chance, but I refused until he resolved his situation. The frustrating thing is that he was probably the most compatible man I've ever dated. In almost every way, he had the qualities I wanted in a partner, except the emotional stability I desperately needed. In September, he said he'd finally made a firm decision to leave S. By then, I was seeing someone else. He admitted that hurt but wished me happiness. When that relationship ended abruptly, I reached out to M, devastated, and he comforted me again, reminding me not to change who I was for anyone. Looking back, I realise I was still emotionally attached to my own ex throughout much of this time, while expecting M to have completely resolved his situation.
In October, M told me he'd started dating another woman. He'd apparently been upfront with her about his circumstances, and they were keeping things casual. He sent me a photograph of them together, and I unexpectedly felt jealous. Two days later, S contacted me angrily again, claiming she was still involved with him and knew nothing about this new woman. M apologised and explained that he'd recently helped S and her daughter with some shopping, accidentally left our email conversation open on his phone, and she'd discovered he was dating someone else. I didn't know whom to believe anymore. I stopped responding. Over the next two weeks, he sent three emails: two apologies and one funny Instagram reel teasing me, something we'd always done throughout our friendship. I'd already blocked him everywhere else. Eventually, I replied very harshly, telling him never to contact me again and threatening legal action if he continued. He hadn't threatened or insulted me, but I was exhausted and wanted the chaos to end.
Now I'm reflecting on the whole experience, particularly my own behaviour. I repeatedly told M we couldn't be together, yet I continued relying on him emotionally, accepted his generosity, introduced him to my mother, occasionally initiated contact, and even became jealous when he started seeing someone else. He wasn't perfect, and his inability to establish boundaries with S genuinely affected me. But he was also one of the kindest, most patient and supportive men I've ever known. I sometimes wonder whether I confused a genuinely good man in a very difficult situation with a man who was fundamentally bad for me. I also wonder whether I contributed to the emotional confusion by keeping him close while refusing a relationship. And perhaps threatening legal action after those final three emails was unnecessarily harsh, even though I had every right to want no further contact.
I'm interested in other women's experiences of this distinction. Can someone consistently show you kindness, generosity, respect and emotional maturity, yet still be too entangled in their past to be a healthy partner? How do you distinguish a genuinely good man dealing with difficult circumstances from someone whose actions are telling you he simply isn't available? And have you ever walked away from someone who had almost everything you wanted because one unresolved issue made the relationship impossible?