So, once again, I'm looking at health insurance for open season. Seemingly everyone I work with in my large plant has blue cross basic, some have standard. Almost nobody has anything else.
To me, the APWU Consumer plan is far and away better for APWU members eligible for the special rate. Not even a discussion. Lightyears apart from my perspective. Even APWU High seems better, though less significantly.
For those who aren't eligible for the APWU special rate, I still think it's far better than Blue Cross Basic, by miles. Although GEHA HDHP is probably best for them. MHBP was far better until it got nuked this year. NALC plans are pretty strong for letter carriers.
My question is what am I missing? Why does everyone insist on having Blue Cross? Are there some advantages that I'm not seeing on paper? Or is it just because they send a whole bunch of reps to our annual health fair and give away a lot of cool things like nice pens, eyeglass cleaners, bags, water bottles etc. and the rest of the plans basically just leave their flyers on a table.
Is it just because people like the "no deductible, $35 to see your doctor" simplicity over the complicated "large deductible minus PCA/HSA contribution then 15%/5% coinsurance" and are not willing to see that the latter is almost certainly far better?
What am I missing? Every year I feel like I'm making a bad decision because everyone has Blue cross, but I've been so happy with APWU. If there is something I'm missing, please let me know.
Btw, in my region, every doctor and facility is in network with both, so it's not a network advantage.