https://substack.com/home/post/p-222941348
Article text reprinted below:
How Homogeneous Groups Can Get Outside Their Bubbles
All groups are susceptible to group psychology
by David Cycleback Ph.D. (retired Director of Center for Artifact Studies, member of the British Royal Institute of Philosophy, and author of the university textbook Cognitive Science of Religion and Belief Systems and The Power of the Crowd: How Group Psychology Influences Beliefs and Behavior).
My post How the Unitarian Universalist Church Became a Racial, Political, and Social Bubble examined how many Unitarian Universalist congregations, despite presenting themselves as non-creedal, pluralistic, freethinking, and welcoming of diversity, have become narrow demographic, cultural and ideological bubbles.
Many healthy and productive groups form around shared identities, interests and beliefs. Problems arise when these groups become echo chambers and develop a self-righteous, tribalistic “us versus them” mentality. This creates bigotry and false stereotypes about outsiders and a distorted perception of the world, while imposing unhealthy expectations of conformity on members.
This post addresses the question of how a congregation, or any organization whose members share similar backgrounds, identities, and beliefs, can counter these unhealthy group tendencies.
Teach members how group dynamics distort thinking
Humans evolved to survive in groups, and all humans and human groups are vulnerable to the forces of group and social psychology.
All human worldviews are necessarily limited, subjective, and distorted. Yet humans tend to believe they see the world objectively and as it really is, a cognitive bias Stanford University psychology professor Lee Ross called naive realism. This often leads people to regard those who disagree as irrational and ignorant. Homogeneous groups reinforce this tendency, treating their shared worldview as the only correct one and dismissing other perspectives before considering what they might learn from them.
Confirmation bias favors information that supports existing beliefs and encourages people to discount contradictory evidence. Groupthink creates pressure to agree, discouraging members from questioning assumptions and decisions. Echo chambers reinforce shared beliefs while dismissing outside perspectives. Spirals of silence arise when people fear disapproval and withhold their doubts, creating a misleading appearance of consensus. Self-righteousness and dogmatism deepen these problems when members treat disagreement as evidence of ignorance and bad character.
These dynamics in part operate automatically and unconsciously, and no group is immune. Members should learn to recognize these and other tendencies in their groups.
I have written before about these and related topics in the posts below:
Human Herd Behavior is Instinctual
The Evolutionary Psychology and Neuroscience of Tribalism
Echo Chambers and Epistemic Bubbles
What is groupthink?
10 Signs You’re in an Echo Chamber
The Human Tendency of Turning Beliefs into “Moral Truths”
Everyone Has Bigotry
The Dangers of Demonizing Opponents
Read and discuss The Righteous Mind
A useful first book to read together is social psychologist Jonathan Haidt’s The Righteous Mind: Why Good People Are Divided by Politics and Religion. It examines how people prioritize the standard moral values of care, fairness, loyalty, authority, sanctity and liberty.
People across different cultures, religious traditions and political groups can be equally moral and ethical but give these values different weight. These differences help explain why people talk past one another and mistake different moral priorities for a lack of morality. For example, American political liberals and conservatives often regard each other as immoral, when in reality they are prioritizing different values.
Use the book to examine which values your group emphasizes or dismisses, and apply the same questions to other cultural, religious and political groups. Look for shared values and consider how to discuss disagreements in terms that address others’ moral concerns.
Learn about other lives and perspectives
Even educated people with good intentions can misunderstand other communities. Learning what people actually believe and how they live helps correct those misconceptions.
Books and documentaries offer access to unfamiliar lives. Read memoirs, novels and histories about people from different social classes, religions, cultures and political traditions. Include authors writing about their own communities, and seek several accounts rather than treating one author as representative of everyone.
I belong to a book club where we read about people different from us. Books have included Donald Kraybill’s Simply Amish, Amy Tan’s The Joy Luck Club, Azar Nafisi’s Reading Lolita in Tehran, and Jeannette Walls’s The Glass Castle about growing up in a poor, nomadic family.
The book club, made up of predominantly upper-middle-class white professionals in politically progressive Seattle, also chose Clarence Thomas’s memoir My Grandfather’s Son. His childhood in poverty in racially segregated Georgia, his upbringing by deeply religious grandparents in a strict household, and his conservative-libertarian political philosophy offered perspectives very different from our own.
Invite people who give different perspectives
Outside speakers can introduce unfamiliar religious beliefs, political perspectives, occupations and life experiences. Choose people who explain their positions thoughtfully, and allow time for sincere questions. Examine whom you invite, taking care not to choose people simply because they confirm the group’s preconceptions.
I belong to a foreign affairs discussion group. Twice a month, we read an article from Foreign Affairs magazine and discuss it over coffee. Because we shared similar political views and backgrounds, we invited people with different worldviews to join so we would get a fuller perspective and a broader range of arguments.
Recognize diversity and question assumptions
Our impressions of other groups often come from narrow sources that confirm what we already believe. A few acquaintances, news stories and prominent public figures can become our picture of an entire population.
For example, predominantly white progressive groups typically learn about minority communities only from progressive minority and “white ally” writers, speakers and activists. They often then mistake those perspectives for the views of the wider communities. Yet Pew Research Center polling shows that only a very small percentage of blacks, Latinos, Asians, and other racial minorities are progressives. Most racial and ethnic minorities are more moderate and conservative. Listening only to a narrow slice of voices that confirm the group’s views produces a highly distorted and often outright false understanding of what these communities believe.
When someone in your group says “conservatives believe,” “Christians want,” and “working-class people think,” ask which people and how widely the belief is held. Compare the claims with reliable surveys and firsthand accounts.
I examine this in more detail in “The Consequences of Ignorance and False Assumptions in Activism.”
Build relationships beyond your group
Organizations can build ongoing relationships through shared meals, visits, speaker exchanges and neighborhood projects. Both groups should help decide what they do and how they do it. Social psychologists Thomas Pettigrew and Linda Tropp found that contact between groups generally reduces prejudice, especially when it involves equal standing, cooperation, shared goals and institutional support. Organizations such as Braver Angels offer workshops and conversations across political differences.
Individual members should strongly consider belonging to multiple organizations and other groups, knowing that any single organization has the tendency to become narrow.
Make disagreement welcome
Organizational leaders must model open-mindedness, curiosity and a willingness to listen to different viewpoints. They should ask for objections before announcing their preferred decisions and gather written opinions before meetings. Taking unfamiliar ideas seriously, admitting uncertainty and acknowledging useful corrections give members examples to follow. Invite newer members and people outside the usual leadership circle to help shape programming.
Members need evidence that disagreement will leave their standing intact. Someone who questions an institutional position should remain able to serve on committees and participate in community life. Jokes, dismissive labels, and remarks such as “No intelligent person could believe that” can discourage people from speaking.
Collect confidential feedback on whether members feel free to disagree and whether they feel they belong. Survey former members about why they left and visitors who chose not to return about what influenced their decision. An organization can often learn more about itself from people who leave or choose not to join than from those who remain.