Essentially, title. I have no idea how/if/etc. Dashers see how much we tip before they accept. I do a lot of (admittedly "quick") mental math when I place an order re: tipping.
I live in NYC, so a pretty dense area and am mostly ordering from resturaunts within a mile or so.
I make the assumption that it takes about 20 minutes to get the food, drop it off, and be on your way to the next; I should be trying to make up about 1/3 of what is bare minimum "liveable" in NYC... so give or take 10-15 bucks. If the order is bigger or the food is heavier, I will tip a bit more than 10 because obviously, this is a crap ton of food and the dude is on a bike #respect.
Let's say I order $200 dollars worth of food, but it is A LOT of food; I will probably tip about $50.
Or if I order from far away, I will always tip at least 25%
If I order one milkshake for myself and it's about $15 (which I do quite a bit), I will still tip about $13.
BUT recently my husband was really sick. He does not eat sushi or any seafood, so about once a month I take myself out to "secret Sushi" (it is not that big of a secret... he knows what is up), but he was so sick I did not want to leave the apartment in case he needed me.
Since I was bummed I was missing "secret sushi," I decided to splurge and order some exceptionally expensive sushi that was literally down the block from us. I realize that I probably could have ordered it for pick-up, but I kind of smelled like vomit, and also, I was just feeling a bit lazy.
The total order was for about 4 rolls of maki and 16 pieces of "omakase" nigiri. The total was about $200 (I think). Since the order was very light (to carry) and it was literally 900 feet away, I only tipped about $15.
When the dasher was handing me my food, he said: "only $15 when you are rolling in it this hard is crazy." To me.
I kind of shrugged it off, thinking that he was a kid, but it has stuck with me and actually kept me up last night...
So should I be tipping more just because I am spending more on orders? AKA, make the tip proportional to the order, or should I continue to tip what I believe is proportional to the work?