r/UserExperienceDesign • u/FewHex • 11h ago
What objective criteria separate "completed easily" from "completed with difficulty"?
I'm running a usability evaluation of standard web tasks, such as account creation and finding prices, across several user groups. Each task is scored on a three-point scale: completed easily, completed with difficulty, or failed.
The challenge is the boundary between the first two. Users often finish only after reading through dense text or hunting for a buried call to action. Without clear criteria, one evaluator scores that as a success and another as difficulty, which makes my results inconsistent.
What established rubrics or thresholds (for example, time-on-task compared with a baseline, misclick counts, or specific behavioral signs) work best for telling easy completion apart from completion with difficulty?