r/Utah • • 14m ago

Other Elroy Tillman was initially sentenced to death in 1983 for the murder of an alleged romantic rival in Salt Lake City. He was resentenced to a natural life term on appeal

0 Upvotes

In 1982, Elroy Tillman and his girlfriend broke into a Salt Lake City apartment and hacked the tenant, 28 year old Mark Schoenfeld, with an axe head as he laid sleeping in bed. Using cigarette butts, Tillman and his girlfriend set Schonefeld’s bed on fire and then fled to their residence. According to autopsy reports, Schonefeld succumbed to smoke inhalation, but his head injuries were sufficiently fatal on their own accord. After the murder, Tillman and his girlfriend tossed the axe into a river.

During the investigations, Tillman’s girlfriend cooperated with police, and handed over bloodied clothing and a burnt towel to them. At the time, Schoenfeld was dating Tillman’s ex-girlfriend, and the woman testified of Tillman stalking and harassing them. By her account, her relationship started with Tillman when she was a runaway teenage girl that he took into his home, and she described herself as "his prey for many years" after leaving him for his abusive behavior.

Tillman’s girlfriend also claimed that Tillman’s ex-girlfriend was their initial target before settling on Schoenfeld, and they previously planned on poising or carrying out a bombing attack against them. Per the prosecutorial narrative, Tillman killed Schoenfeld for seeing the woman, but Tillman personally attested to carrying out the murder to steal cocaine allegedly hidden in Schoenfeld’s stereo equipment.

After a year of proceedings, Tillman was sentenced to death by the state of Utah for Schonefeld’s murder. Due to her cooperation with police and testifying for the prosecution, Tillman's girlfriend was granted immunity.

In 2001, Tillman’s death sentence was vacated by the Utah Supreme Court over misplaced evidence only weeks before his scheduled execution by firing squad, and he was resentenced to a “natural life sentence” in 2005. Schonefeld’s girlfriend testified against Tillman during his parole hearings afterwards, and she expressed fears of him targeting her and killing again if he was ever freed from prison to media outlets.

Although Tillman’s appeal against his life sentence was last rejected in 2021, he is absent from Utah Department of Corrections’ online records. If he still alive, Tillman would currently be in his early nineties given that a Deseret News article published in 2009 mentioned him to be 75 years old at the time, and thus my assumptions are that he is deceased.

Sources:

1.https://www.deseret.com/2009/10/6/20344518/tillman-to-spend-his-life-behind-bars/

2.https://law.justia.com/cases/utah/supreme-court/1987/19000-0.html

3.https://www.starnewsonline.com/story/news/2003/01/25/utah-inmate-on-death-row-has-sentence-thrown-out/30506291007/

4.https://www.deseret.com/2001/6/14/19591411/ex-girlfriend-lives-in-fear/

5.https://law.justia.com/cases/utah/supreme-court/1993/890322.html

6.https://www.fox13now.com/news/local-news/court-rejects-convicted-killers-appeal-of-natural-life-sentence

7.https://archive.sltrib.com/article.php?id=54659843&itype=cmsid

8.https://www.deseret.com/2009/2/25/20303831/killer-offers-a-new-version-of-events-in-1982-slaying/


r/Utah • • 2h ago

News The letter from Rocky Mountain Power

61 Upvotes

I equate this to the state of Utah asking for donations to support the unhoused.
RM Power is asking their already cash-strapped citizens to do what they should be investing in themselves. The CEO earns 650k per year with a 1m bonus.
It’s time for pushback.

https://www.sltrib.com/news/2026/11/19/what-is-4-clean-energy-fee-rocky/


r/Utah • • 3h ago

Q&A Recommendations for PPF + ceramic coating shop near Brigham City / Northern Utah?

0 Upvotes

I've got a Tesla Model Y Premium AWD on order, supposed to show up late Nov or December. Want to get PPF and a ceramic coating done soon after it lands. I'm up in Brigham City but don't mind driving to Logan, Ogden or SLC if the shop is worth it.

Probably going full front at least, maybe full body depending on price. Anyone have a shop they'd recommend, or one to avoid? Also curious what you paid, just so I know if a quote is in the ballpark.

Pics of your car if you've had it done would be great.


r/Utah • • 14h ago

Meme What’s the 3 Fingers Moment to tell someone’s not from Utah?

Post image
0 Upvotes

Following the trend, but honestly curious about the serious and funny answers to this


r/Utah • • 20h ago

Photo/Video The Wellsvilles always show off!

Thumbnail
gallery
86 Upvotes

r/Utah • • 1d ago

Photo/Video Lehi Mills flour preventing famine in Occupation Japan

Post image
179 Upvotes

After WWII, Japan was at the brink of starvation. General McArthur ordered the distribution of military food stores to feed the people of Japan. If you read the labels on these bags you can see that this flour came from the Lehi, Utah flour mills.


r/Utah • • 1d ago

Art Utah Flag with Utah Colors

Post image
90 Upvotes

r/Utah • • 1d ago

Other Where in SLC can I get fresh horseradish root?

2 Upvotes

I need it for a recipe! Thank!


r/Utah • • 1d ago

Announcement Utah Environmental Protest

Post image
33 Upvotes

r/Utah • • 1d ago

Photo/Video I turned around and found this rainbow over Wild Horse Butte in Goblin Valley, Utah

Post image
588 Upvotes

I was having a great time running around photographing the desert in the rain. Everything looked incredible, and then I turned around and spotted this rainbow. Definitely one of those moments I’m glad I didn’t miss.


r/Utah • • 1d ago

News Box Elder County sheriff arrested in connection with fatal Ogden crash

Thumbnail
standard.net
188 Upvotes

r/Utah • • 1d ago

Other I don't understand the concept of open range cattle

0 Upvotes

I was driving and in the middle of the valley of the gods, I see two cows. I don't really understand the concept of open range. Considering the geography of Utah, it seems to me that many cows, who are income for ranchers, are just lost in the middle of the desert. Or could even be taken by other farmers.
What am I missing ?


r/Utah • • 1d ago

Other Delta 8 products and marijuana

0 Upvotes

Okay I moved here a few months ago and I cannot keep driving to Nevada when I need stuff. I have panic attacks and the only thing that helps is weed. I prefer carts because they are just easy and it’s a quick solution when I’m having panic attacks. Does Utah really not sell ANYTHING? Those cbd gummies don’t do it for me. Like even if I take the whole bag. I don’t want to sound like an “addict” but my God… I can’t do this


r/Utah • • 1d ago

Other Gunnison valley farm house - Photo circa 1935 ▪︎

Post image
55 Upvotes

This house was built in 1916 by my grandfather. He was 24 years old and got married that year. He and Grandma raised 5 children in this house. Their life was a life of hard work - farming and ranching, fortitude, survival, countless family gatherings over many decades, bad times, good times. They survived 2 world wars, the depression, and so much more in this house. It saw several remodels over the years, but we all knew it was "home" to the entire family.

A home is what you make of it. It was only 1800 square feet... but to grandma and grandpa, it was their beloved castle. Grandma was as proud of that newlywed house as anyone could be.


r/Utah • • 1d ago

Art Hand made gift ideas please

4 Upvotes

I am looking for hand made gifts for adult women between $50-$150.

Would love to support local makers and craftspeople. Please share your links/contacts.

Located in the greater salt lake area. Can travel to pick up between Brigham city and nephi!


r/Utah • • 1d ago

News I've been seeing so much skepticism and vitriol about the Community Clean Energy Program...

Thumbnail gallery
37 Upvotes

So as a hopeful person, who has spent HUNDREDS OF HOURS in city council meetings, public service committee meeting, legislative committee meetings, you know, participating in our democracy -> I thought I would try to provide some SUNLIGHT on the situation.

I'm your neightbor... be kind! And if nothing else check out SLIDE 8. Its the real winner.


r/Utah • • 1d ago

Q&A Predatory Apartment Fees (Specifically Internet)

Thumbnail reddit.com
5 Upvotes

r/Utah • • 1d ago

Travel Advice Fastest way to get passport in salt lake or Utah county?

5 Upvotes

Preferably a place that does passport photos as well.


r/Utah • • 1d ago

Q&A Questions - potential move

0 Upvotes

Hello everyone,

I had a couple of questions regarding Utah in general and SLC as a whole. My fiance just got an amazing job offer in SLC but we live in Texas and are very excited that our state is finally blue and it is tugging at us a bit because we were planning on moving to Colorado initially before this offer.

What is it like in Utah? LGBT specific is it accepted or are we just moving into another awful situation for us personally.

We are also concerned because we like to partake occasionally in Delta products offered in Texas is this an issue or concern is there anything similar or will we have to travel?

It is pretty sudden so I wanted some real world experiences also given that I have only ever driven through Utah I haven't even gotten a hotel there before.


r/Utah • • 2d ago

Photo/Video Morning after the First Snow @ Utah State University (11/18/26)

Thumbnail
gallery
587 Upvotes

Woke up around 6:30 to capture the stillness of the morning with the first snow. Was hoping for untouched snow like my photo last year, but that unfortunately didn’t happen. Still was very pleased with how good these photos came out!

Nikon Z5II
Nikon Z 50mm f1.8S


r/Utah • • 2d ago

Other In desperate need of help

42 Upvotes

Help/Advice I haven't been able to come up with any of my rent this month. I was able to pay 5 bills, but am so behind on everything. I'm paying past due and just struggling so much. I dont make much at my job, and have been looking for something that pays more but need it to work around my children's school schedule. Unfortunately I do have loans so really dont want to take out another but will if I absolutely have to. They definitely eat up my paychecks.

Any advice, please.

I can't donate plasma at the moment, and i do doordash when Im able to.


r/Utah • • 2d ago

Travel Advice 2100 North closure Part 999

11 Upvotes

Edit for clarity because someone in the other sub needed it: This is in Lehi

We're back at it again!
🚧 Crews will return tonight, Nov. 20, at 9 p.m. through Sunday, Nov. 22, at 10 p.m., to finish sewer work that couldn't be completed last weekend.

Here's what to expect:

  • 2300 West: Closed between the frontage roads. Traffic will detour via U-turns at Ashton Blvd. and 3600 West. The westbound-to-eastbound U-turn at 3600 West will reopen for the weekend to help ease detour traffic.
  • Eastbound 2100 North: Reduced to one lane.
  • Westbound 2100 North: Reduced to one lane at night.
  • Jordan River Trail under 2100 North: Temporarily open to pedestrians and cyclists this weekend, closing again Monday morning.

🚧  Additional overnight closures: Westbound 2100 North will be closed from 1200 West to Ashton Blvd. at night from 10 p.m. to 5 a.m. on Sunday night, Nov. 22, Monday night, Nov. 23, and Tuesday night, Nov. 24. Crews will be working on water and irrigation lines in the area.

During these closures:

  • No right turns onto westbound 2100 North from Thanksgiving Way and no left turns from State Street or the northbound I-15 off-ramp.
  • The eastbound-to-westbound U-turn at Ashton Blvd. will be closed.
  • Traffic will be detoured via Digital Drive to Triumph Blvd. and back to 2100 North.

Please avoid the area or use alternate routes when possible.

Expect delays, be careful and have a great weekend!


r/Utah • • 2d ago

Photo/Video Helicopter flies over Salt Lake City with Twin Peaks of the Wasatch Front in the background.

Post image
0 Upvotes

Air-med helicopter flies toward the University of Utah Hospital with snow-covered peaks in background.


r/Utah • • 2d ago

Travel Advice Veterans Association Information

10 Upvotes

As a veteran and soon-to-be new resident of Salt Lake City I wanted to know if there are any Veterans that can speak to their experience with regard to the SLC VA’s pros and cons. Thanks 🤟