TL;DR
Why does non-dual awareness often remain a temporary state that experienced practitioners can access, rather than becoming a more stable shift in their ordinary sense of self? How can someone like Sam Harris, with so much experience and the ability to readily access non-duality, report that duality is still his baseline?
I wonder whether three related learning mechanisms could help explain this:
- The deep generalization problem: Repeated practice might teach the brain an unintended higher-order model: "I am normally a separate self, but I can temporarily enter a non-dual state through meditation, and eventually return to my ordinary self." Even genuine non-dual glimpses might therefore leave the broader autobiographical self-model largely intact. The practitioner continues to relate to non-duality as something a separate self does or achieves.
- Autobiographical memory as a possible route to deeper updating: What if we brought non-dual inquiry directly into emotionally significant autobiographical memories? Rather than producing another temporary glimpse in the present, this might challenge the sense of a continuous, independently existing self across the personal history through which we understand who we are. This could offer a distinctive opportunity to update the deeper self-model, although the proposed role of memory reconsolidation remains speculative.
- The escape-pattern hypothesis: If we mainly turn to non-dual inquiry when suffering arises, it may become a way of escaping uncomfortable experiences. This could inadvertently reinforce the idea that ordinary, dualistic experience is something “real” and dangerous to get away from, rather than an illusion. This opposes allowing non-dual recognition to become integrated into everyday life.
Some practical experiments I'd be curious to try:
- Experiment with bringing non-dual inquiry into moderately emotionally significant memories, and other memories with a strong sense of self.
- Practice non-dual inquiry not only when distressed, but also during neutral, positive, and ordinary social experiences.
- When difficult emotions arise, first allow them to be present without immediately using non-dual practice to make them disappear. The same goes for the sensation of being dual itself, try to occasionally focus on it and just let it be.
My central question is whether moving from "I can access non-duality" to "the self-model organizing my present experience and autobiographical history may itself be mistaken" requires something beyond accumulating more present-moment glimpses.
Disclosure: AI helped in writing, but the ideas originated from me, I edited the entire essay and wrote some parts completely myself
[Start of post body]
Is There a Huge Missing Piece In Non-Duality?
Sam Harris has spent decades practicing with some of the most respected Dzogchen and Vipassana teachers alive, and has arguably introduced more Westerners to non-dual awareness than anyone else in the last decade. Yet, by his own candid admission, his experience of non-duality remains a "glimpse" he can drop into—not a permanent, baseline shift in consciousness. For example here:
https://youtu.be/ccb8GnHWlEQ?t=5220&si=hsQoJ6iU8cgB45Dg
If someone with his intellectual clarity, discipline, and access to top-tier instruction hasn't crossed that threshold, it’s worth asking: is the bottleneck the practitioner, or is something structural missing from the modern non-dual toolkit? Here are a few hypotheses on why glimpses so rarely stabilize into a lasting shift.
The Deep Generalization Problem: Learning That Non-Duality Is a Temporary State You Enter
Consider how we typically learn to recognize non-dual awareness:
- We sit down to meditate.
- We follow a pointing-out instruction.
- We direct attention toward the supposed observer.
- We recognize that no separate observer can actually be found.
After repeating this process, the experience might become strongly associated with the conditions under which it was learned.
This is why people like Yongey Mingyur Rinpoche advocate for “anytime, anywhere meditation”, and indeed Sam also seems to practice in varied contexts.
But I suspect there may be a more fundamental generalization problem than simply associating non-dual awareness with particular meditation contexts.
Through repeated practice, the brain might actually learn a conditional model of non-duality: "I am normally a separate, dualistic self, but only when I meditate deliberately, I can temporarily enter a non-dual state. Eventually, the experience ends, and I return to being my ordinary self."
This is where I think autobiographical memory work could be particularly valuable, and potentially much more effective than simply accumulating additional present-moment glimpses.
When we bring non-dual inquiry directly into an emotionally significant memory, we are not merely recreating a previous meditation experience. We are revisiting a situation that was originally encoded and subsequently maintained as part of our ordinary personal history: "This happened to me. I was the person experiencing this. This is part of who I am."
If the recognition that no independently existing observer can be found is meaningfully integrated into the experience of that memory, it may challenge the continuity of the dualistic self-model across time, rather than merely producing another temporary state in the present.
Crucially, this could weaken the implicit narrative that non-duality is something a dualistic person periodically achieves. Instead, the inquiry directly addresses the autobiographical framework through which that person understands their entire history.
Could autobiographical memories be an overlooked part of the equation?
Our ordinary sense of self isn't maintained only by present-moment perception. Autobiographical memory plays an important role in constructing and maintaining personal identity.
Conway and Pleydell-Pearce (2000), in their Self-Memory System model, describe how autobiographical memories and our current self-representations interact dynamically. Conway (2005) further discusses the relationship between autobiographical memory and the self.
My question is whether present-moment non-dual inquiry can change the immediate experience of being a separate observer while leaving many of these autobiographical representations relatively untouched. Perhaps this helps explain why someone can have repeated non-dual glimpses while continuing to experience their ordinary identity as a deeply established fact.
An experiment: Bringing non-dual inquiry directly into autobiographical memories
Recently, I've been experimenting with combining non-dual inquiry with emotionally salient autobiographical memories.
The basic procedure is:
- Bring to mind a moderately emotionally charged memory involving shame, rejection, embarrassment, pride, accomplishment, or a strong sense of personal identity.
- Allow the memory and its associated bodily sensations to become present, rather than merely thinking about it abstractly.
- Once the experience is sufficiently vivid, apply non-dual inquiry within the remembered scene itself.
- Rather than only asking whether there's an observer in present-moment experience, investigate whether a separate, independently existing observer can actually be found in that remembered experience.
- Allow the emotions to remain present without trying to suppress them or make them disappear.
The interesting thing I've noticed is that recalling some of these memories later, without deliberately meditating, can sometimes evoke an immediate sense of doubt about the solidity of the self in the present moment.
This feels different from remembering a previous meditation experience. The latter can feel like recalling something that happened to me in the past. In contrast, revisiting an emotionally significant memory through non-dual inquiry seems to sometimes change how the memory itself is experienced and how strongly it supports the self-narrative.
I also experimented with following bodily feelings of separateness back to earlier autobiographical memories (resembling the Affect Bridge technique).
Some childhood memories emerged that I rarely think about, involving social rejection, hiding aspects of myself, or pride, accomplishment and wonder. Exploring these memories through non-dual inquiry produced an interesting subjective shift: the narrative of "I am a dualistic person trying to become non-dual" temporarily felt less convincing. Instead, I felt like “I” was always non-dual, the screen on which the movie of life is projected, and there's just this character of me trying to become non-dual.
I wonder whether deliberately working with emotionally significant memories could help integrate contemplative insights into our ordinary sense of identity.
Could memory reconsolidation explain some of this?
There is a potentially relevant connection to memory reconsolidation research. When a previously consolidated memory is retrieved under certain conditions, it may become destabilized and susceptible to updating before being reconsolidated.
An important finding is that prediction error can be necessary for this process under particular experimental conditions (Sevenster, Beckers, & Kindt, 2013, 2014).
This suggests a possible connection to non-dual inquiry. When we revisit an emotionally significant memory, we may reactivate not only its narrative content but also the self-representation and emotional expectations associated with it. If we then experience something that meaningfully violates those expectations, the memory and its associated self-representation can be updated.
For example, a memory originally experienced through an intensely solid sense of "me being humiliated" might be revisited while investigating whether that experience actually required a separate observer or owner.
Could this produce a meaningful prediction error and facilitate updating?
I find this plausible enough to investigate, but there are several important caveats:
- Retrieving a memory does not automatically trigger reconsolidation.
- Prediction error is not sufficient by itself to guarantee destabilization.
- New learning, reappraisal, and changes in the interpretation of autobiographical memories could explain the effects without requiring reconsolidation.
So I would describe this as a reconsolidation-informed hypothesis rather than an established reconsolidation technique. For an overview of the underlying theoretical framework, see Sevenster et al. (2014) and Lee et al. (2023).
The "fire extinguisher" problem: Can non-dual practice negatively reinforce the sense of duality?
Something Sam has mentioned in various discussions has caught my attention: using suffering or anxiety as a kind of mindfulness alarm that reminds him to recognize the open nature of consciousness. Example here:
https://youtu.be/ccb8GnHWlEQ?t=5220&si=hsQoJ6iU8cgB45Dg
I wonder whether there could be an unintended learning effect.
In anxiety disorders (and phobias and OCD), safety behaviors and compulsions can provide immediate relief while sometimes maintaining the underlying perception that a situation is threatening. These safety responses strengthen the brain's assumption that the feared concept is indeed dangerous & real, because it feels like you had to perform a safety behavior in order to stay intact. This is one of the mechanisms discussed in the literature on safety behaviors and inhibitory learning (Blakey & Abramowitz, 2016).
Could something analogous happen with non-dual practice?
Imagine the following sequence:
- An unpleasant experience arises.
- We recognize non-dual awareness.
- The sense of separation diminishes, and we feel relief.
- The brain learns to use non-dual recognition whenever unpleasant experiences arise.
- (Potentially) The brain learns that dual experience is dangerous and real, and requires meditation to escape. That is rather than a non-dangerous illusion to see through.
There is nothing inherently wrong with the first 4 steps. In fact, the ability to recognize that thoughts and emotions don't require a separate observer may be very helpful.
But there might be a subtle difference between two ways of using the practice:
- Escape-oriented recognition: "I'm suffering, so I need to get out of this dualistic experience and return to the peaceful open awareness” (similar to spiritual bypassing).
- Acceptance-oriented recognition: "This unpleasant experience can remain exactly as it is. There is no need to escape it, and I can recognize the nature of experience without trying to change its contents."
The first could potentially reinforce that the dualistic experience is something real and bring on step 5, whereas the second might facilitate a more flexible relationship with difficult experiences. This could inadvertently preserve the very dualistic framework the practice is intended to undermine.
One practical implication is to deliberately practice non-dual inquiry during positive and neutral experiences, too. Pride, success, social validation, enjoyment, and ordinary conversations may be just as interesting contexts for examining the sense of self as anxiety or suffering. And to try practicing out of curiosity and truth seeking rather than aversion.
A Buddhist Parallel: The Buddha's Own Journey
I find it interesting that there are at least two potentially relevant parallels in the traditional accounts of the Buddha's awakening.
First, in the Mahāsaccaka Sutta (MN 36), the Buddha recalls a childhood experience of entering the first jhāna while sitting under a rose-apple tree. This memory becomes pivotal: he recognizes that this accepting, non-aversive state may actually be the path to awakening, and explicitly recalls no longer being afraid of that kind of pleasure. One possible psychological reading is that this memory helped him recover a relationship with experience that was not organized around aversion, rejection, and the need to escape ordinary experience. This resonates with one of my hypotheses: perhaps an important part of the path is not learning to escape dualistic experience, but changing our relationship to it — so that we no longer regard it as something that must be overcome before genuine freedom is possible.
Second, in the same discourse, the Buddha describes recollecting his past lives as the first of the three knowledges attained on the night of his awakening. From a traditional Buddhist perspective, this concerns literal previous lives. From a secular or psychological perspective, one might instead explore whether there is a useful analogy with revisiting earlier periods of one's own life and examining the assumptions about selfhood, continuity, and personal identity that were formed there. I am not suggesting that these are equivalent practices, or that this is what the text literally means. Rather, I find it intriguing that recollection of one's past is given such a prominent place in the traditional account of awakening.
More broadly, Buddhist traditions have long included practices involving recollection, reflection on one's life, contemplation of the aggregates and the construction of personal identity, and the examination of how the sense of "I" is maintained through time. These themes appear in early discourses as well as in later contemplative traditions and modern Buddhist teaching. “Enlightenment books” like The Mind Illuminated, MCTB, Mindfulness: A Practical Guide to Awakening, etc. detail stages where core memories arise spontaneously and how to deal with them in a non-dual fashion.
Practical experiments I'd suggest
Putting these ideas together, here are several experiments I'd be interested in hearing people's experiences with.
A. Don't only use suffering as a mindfulness alarm
Try deliberately recognizing non-dual awareness during positive and neutral experiences. Notice what happens when there is no unpleasant experience to escape from.
B. Practice tolerance before non-dual inquiry
When anxiety, shame, or frustration arises, spend some time allowing the bodily sensations to remain without immediately trying to shift into a more peaceful or spacious state (similar to Exposure and Response Prevention with anxiety). This might help using on-dual recognition coexisting with the full intensity of an emotion, rather than functioning as a way to get rid of it.
In addition, try to practice mindfulness, acceptance and welcoming to the sensation of being dual. I found that to be especially helpful, to focus on the feeling of duality and to think “this is completely OK to feel like a self”.
C. Bring inquiry into autobiographical memories
Choose a moderately charged memory that still carries a recognizable sense of personal identity. Revisit the experience, notice the associated emotional and bodily responses, and explore the sense of an independent observer within that remembered scene.
D. Vary the contexts in which you practice
Try applying the same recognition during conversations, work, social situations, enjoyment, and emotionally challenging interactions. Notice whether recognition becomes less dependent on formal meditation or deliberate effort.
E. Track changes outside meditation
Perhaps the most important experiment is to pay attention to what happens when you're not actively practicing. Does recalling a previously explored memory change how you experience yourself? Do familiar situations trigger less identification? Does the sense of being a separate observer return with the same apparent solidity?
It would be useful to distinguish temporary state changes from enduring changes in everyday experience.
What would I like to hear from the community?
I'm particularly interested in three questions:
- For those who have experienced a lasting shift in non-dual awareness, did it emerge primarily through repeated present-moment pointing-out instructions, or did working through autobiographical memories and emotional patterns play an important role?
- Have you noticed that using non-dual recognition primarily in response to suffering can sometimes turn it into an escape strategy? Have you experimented with practicing during positive or neutral experiences instead?
- Has anyone deliberately brought non-dual inquiry into emotionally significant memories, rather than waiting for memories to arise spontaneously during meditation? If so, did you notice changes in how those memories relate to your present sense of self?
References & Recommended Readings
- Blakey, S. M., & Abramowitz, J. S. (2016). The effects of safety behaviors during exposure therapy for anxiety: Critical analysis from an inhibitory learning perspective. Clinical Psychology Review, 49, 1–15.
- Conway, M. A., & Pleydell-Pearce, C. W. (2000). The construction of autobiographical memories in the self-memory system. Psychological Review, 107(2), 261–288. https://doi.org/10.1037/0033-295X.107.2.261
- Conway, M. A. (2005). Memory and the self. Journal of Memory and Language, 53(4), 594–628. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jml.2005.08.005
- Hanley, A. W., Nakamura, Y., & Garland, E. L. (2018). The Nondual Awareness Dimensional Assessment (NADA): New tools to assess nondual traits and states of consciousness occurring within and beyond the context of meditation. Psychological Assessment. https://doi.org/10.1037/pas0000615
- Laukkonen, R. E., & Slagter, H. A. (2021). From many to (n)one: Meditation and the plasticity of the predictive mind. Neuroscience & Biobehavioral Reviews, 128, 199–217. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.neubiorev.2021.06.021
- Lee, J. L. C., et al. (2023). The challenge of memory destabilisation: From prediction error to prior expectations and biomarkers. Brain Research Bulletin. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.brainresbull.2023.01.010
- Sevenster, D., Beckers, T., & Kindt, M. (2013). Prediction error governs pharmacologically induced amnesia for learned fear. Science, 339(6121), 830–833. https://doi.org/10.1126/science.1231357
- Sevenster, D., Beckers, T., & Kindt, M. (2014). Prediction error demarcates the transition from retrieval, to reconsolidation, to new learning. Learning & Memory, 21(11), 580–584. https://doi.org/10.1101/lm.035493.114