The talk when the Steelers used a third-round pick on Penn State’s raw yet talented Drew Allar centered on how the team could develop a quarterback with 42-year-old Aaron Rodgers as the starter, Mason Rudolph as backup insurance, and former national championship signal-caller Will Howard also in the room and in need of growth.
Apparently, the plan is to push Drew Allar to exhaustion and a little past that.
Allar hasn't even been elevated to emergency quarterback on game days yet, but the behind-the-scenes development has been ongoing and intense for him and Howard.
“We have a nice setup and structure for Drew and Will,” quarterback coach and mentor Tom Arth said.
Whether it will pay off comes next year, when the Steelers move forward without Rodgers and potentially without free-agent-to-be Rudolph; one prerequisite for McCarthy getting hired in January was to flesh out and develop a quarterback.
Since Ben Roethlisberger retired in 2021, they’ve started Rodgers, Mitch Trubisky, Rudolph, Russell Wilson, and Justin Fields; used the 20th overall pick on Kenny Pickett, a third-rounder on Allar, a sixth-rounder on Howard, and a seventh-rounder on Chris Oladokun, and still aren’t any closer to figuring out a long-term solution.
Heck, they might even draft a quarterback in April because of the pressing need that general manager Omar Khan has put on figuring out who the next franchise guy will be.
With McCarthy being the one who signed off on him in the draft, Allar is seen as the best bet to do that as early as next season, and he’s putting Allar and Howard through the wringer now to make sure there is real development happening.
“They do a really good job, even in practices, like still getting a good number of reps for how different the practices are compared to camp and preseason,” Allar said. “I always felt like it helps me a lot; the more reps I can get, whether it's drawing it up on a whiteboard or just walking through it, helps me a lot. Just get the feel for everything.”
So, what does a typical in-season day look like for Allar when the main goal is to prepare for the next opponent and help Rodgers in any way during the week, all while having limited reps during practice since the start of September?
You might be shocked, or at least a little surprised.
• Allar wakes up around 5:45 a.m. every morning, leaves his house about 20 minutes later to get to the UPMC Rooney Sports Complex.
• After some time in the sauna and a mandatory weigh-in (every Thursday), Allar is off to the ‘young guys meeting’ over at the indoor facility with both Arth and Howard, where the two walk through the day’s practice script with the quarterback coach for about 45 minutes.
• Then come the meetings. There’s a team meeting, the offensive meeting, and the quarterback meeting.
• The team then goes outside for a walkthrough before heading back inside for a few more meetings before getting ready for the day’s practice.
• Allar and the rest of the team head to the fields where they participate in the two-hour practice. There might not be many team reps, but it lets him work on the physical side of his game.
• After practice, Allar is one of the last guys off the field as he gets some more throws in with receivers before grabbing a quick shower and more meetings (especially on Thursdays).
“First, it's like player-led, so it's usually Aaron going over the game, playing with everybody, giving reminders to the receivers and tight ends and running backs of what to expect from the defense, what he's thinking about in certain situations, calls he likes, and things that he might get to in, like, a 2-minute situation,” Allar said. “And then it's more QB meetings after that.”
It’s back home for Allar after that before Arth sends over the next day’s script, and then the entire process starts over the next day.
“They are in a really good spot,” said Arth, who also runs a mock game-like session before most of the team gets onto the field for that Sunday’s game. “They know the plan. If they had to go out there and play, I think they would be ready. Certainly mentally.”
Allar has seen significant benefit from the in-season schedule the coaches have him on, as it has kept him involved and learning.
“The main focus is Aaron and getting him ready to go, but they don't put us on the back burner,” Allar said. “They do a really good job, and I'm very conscious about still making sure that Mason, Will, and I are involved in some capacity, which, you know, I appreciate, because I'm not just sitting there. I'm still learning a ton every day, gaining a lot of knowledge.”
For Allar specifically, his knock coming out of college was in his fundamentals, not his arm talent.
During rookie minicamp in April, Allar looked like a quarterback who was told to forget everything he had learned about footwork, and it showed. It created buzz because Allar was so deliberate in his movement; he looked slow and confused.
Fast forward seven months, and the difference is notable not only to the naked eye, but to himself.
“I'm not thinking about it anymore,” Allar said. “ Rookie minicamp, OTAs, and even the first part of camp, I'm out there thinking about everything, and I might be purposely slowing it down to get the right feel of what Coach Arth, Coach McCarthy, and Aaron are emphasizing. To me, throughout each drill, I feel like I'm at the point now where I can go out and play game-like speed and really push myself to, you know, not just go out and play fast and still watch all the film from our QB (individual drills) to make sure I'm staying on top of the little things that I worked a lot on. It was very intentional throughout camp.”
Allar might not be the future, but he has the arm talent to be.
Allar appeared in 45 games for Penn State, with 35 starts. He completed 633 passes for 7,402 yards and 61 touchdowns in four seasons for the Nittany Lions. He had his best season in 2024, starting all 16 games and completing 262 of 394 passes for 3,327 yards and 24 touchdowns.
Allar showed flashes in the preseason, but he hasn’t seen a real snap since the final preseason game.
Considering the last time the Steelers invested a third-round pick on a quarterback and didn’t provide Rudolph with much support, let alone a quarterback coach or a veteran quarterback who was openly willing to help, Allar feels like he is in a good spot.
“I think the biggest part right now is pretty consistent, which has always been the focus around myself and with just my game in general,” Allar said. “I feel like I'm reaching that point where I feel really confident in that process that I've been going through. So, right now it's just about not letting those things go to the side, because it could be easy in season when you're preparing for a new opponent every week to forget about the things that you worked on the last nine months, when you're kind of in season. So, I still try to make sure I go into every drill as intentionally as I can.”