I’m on the eStockes team. Reality Check is the part of our web app that compares a simple stock or ETF rule with holding the same instrument. I’d like feedback on one small piece of the result screen: the row labeled “Made money in most periods.”
I ran the 50-day/200-day moving-average crossover on IWM from Nov 22, 2021 through Nov 20, 2026. The rule returned +14.0% after modeled costs, compared with +17.8% for holding. It recorded four simulated trades. The periods row showed “4 of 5,” and the headline said “Not enough trades.”
Those two fours count different things. The periods row counts positive results when the rule is rerun over five equal stretches of the historical data. The trade count belongs to the full-period run. A window check and the full test can therefore give different impressions, even when the counts happen to match.
If you already have a stock or ETF you want to check, change the ticker, choose a Simple preset and press Run historical test. If a previous result opens, select Change rule first. It’s free without an account. In one line, I’d like to know the ticker and rule you ran, what the result said versus holding, and whether the periods row was clear on first read.
To audit the count after your first read, open Method, costs and all trades, followed by Historical stability checks. Two IWM windows show positive returns with zero simulated trades. The simulation credits interest while the rule is in cash.
Open the free IWM guest test