r/WhatIfMarvel • • Dec 30 '23

Series+ Just the God of Stories Blessing everyone

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

40 Upvotes

r/WhatIfMarvel • • Aug 13 '26

Community Update Spoiler Policy That Should've Been Obvious Spoiler

30 Upvotes

DON'T PUT SPOILERS FOR NEW RELEASES IN THE TITLES OF YOUR POSTS.

They don't always hide correctly, & the title is the one thing you can't edit after you post.

I shouldn't have to explain this.


r/WhatIfMarvel • • 4h ago

Story Idea What If Rogue recieved the Carnage Symbiote during her grieving?

Thumbnail
gallery
5 Upvotes

The Watcher: Now normally... I only focus on every variation of one singular timeline but it wouldn't hurt to dive into another reality with an alternate timeline... And believe me this one breaks my heart the most...

In one universe Spider-Man joined forces with Iron Man and Venom to vanquish Carnage through a dimensional portal sending the symbiote to another Peter Parker with hatred to become Spider-Carnage

But in another universe there was a malfunction in the Inter Dimensional Probe causing the Symbiote to travel across time and space and into the distant future

Meanwhile a brutal attack by a massive Sentinel was sent onto the land of mutants and one in particular lost the man she loved dearly... Her beloved Gambit... She couldn't feel him anymore...

In a state of depression Rogue went on a rampage across the globe taking it out on others going against other heroes and backing away from the X-Men the only family who cared about her but this universe's version of Rogue was different she could not side with anyone anymore

When it came face to face with Magneto to choose a side she didn't... She took her rage on everyone attacking them one by one and this is where the two events come face to face

Out of nowhere from a mysterious portal the Carnage Symbiote appeared and drawn to Rogue's anger it bonded with her driving her insane and creating a different kind of monster

In horror on the faces of Charles the X-Men and Magneto Rogue flew off with the Symbiote to begin her invasion

This... Was the beginning... Of The Rogue Carnage!


r/WhatIfMarvel • • 3h ago

Story Idea What if Pietro and Wanda Maximoff had their powers swapped?

3 Upvotes

Like in way so Wanda now becomes speedster and Pietrio gains chaos magic telekenisis and mind manipulation magic. Also let's say Pietro somehow still dies here protecting Clint so how could that later influence this new Wanda?


r/WhatIfMarvel • • 1d ago

Story Idea What If Wanda was found by the Ten Rings and took the throne to end Tony Stark?

Thumbnail
gallery
54 Upvotes

The Watcher: In every universe an infinite amount of power can change someone into a being catastrophic but... What if two amount of powers can fulfill that power hungry phase?

In one side Wanda Maximoff with a power of chaos and the other side the Ten Rings items from an unknown land... What If Wanda came into contact with those rings?

In your universe Wanda and Pietro Maximoff grew up together and were experiments under Hydra but in this universe Pietro was long gone during the attack with Stark Tech on her home of Sokovia...

All alone for years her emotions struggled she wouldn't been captured by Hydra if it wasn't... For the Ten Rings...

Xu Wenwu (The Mandarin) found Wanda and saw potential in her so for years he trained her to control her power and become the ultimate assassin but one day everything change

Wanda sees potential if she wore the rings herself so with him defenseless Wanda murders Xu putting the blame on his son Shang Chi and takes the rings for herself leading the organization in her name

Now with full power (during the events of Iron Man 3) she takes her army to finally defeat the man who caused her pain... Tony Stark...


r/WhatIfMarvel • • 1d ago

Story Idea What if Thor brought Tony's dead body to eternal flame and chanted "with eternal flame you are reborn!"

14 Upvotes

So like at end of avangers thor realizes previous movies already established resurrection magic and decided in cooperation with rest of avangers to bring Tony's dead body to whatever eternal flame is at moment and ditch it there while performing same ritual Loki did to bring Surtur back to his full form. Or would it just result in some sort of demonic undead Tony Stark but could still be kinda interesting?


r/WhatIfMarvel • • 1d ago

Fan Creation Some what ifs i came up with(you can rate them if you want)

2 Upvotes

What if….Captain America gotten Admantium instead of The Super Soldier Serum

What if….Spider-Man actually died from punishers bullet (in Brand New Day)

What if…the Avengers formed differently(instead of Hulk, Thor, and Ironman joining ,nick fury decides to get Captain Marvel,Hercules(who would be on earth instead of Thor),Abomination, to join and fight against Loki

What if….Ironman Fought the real Mandarin

What if The Other half got Snapped

What if….Hawkeye was blinded and became Daredevil

What if…Quicksilver survived

What if….Civil war happened again

What if….Black widow,Ironman and Captain America(who decided to stay in the present, but pass the title to Falcon) survived, and Thor,Hawkeye, and Hulk didn’t

What if…Beta Ray Bill

What if…Blade tracked Werewolf by night and Manthing down

What if…Everyone gotten different powers or origins


r/WhatIfMarvel • • 1d ago

Story Idea School for gifted youngsters

2 Upvotes

Good evening, just a thought, what if whenever it’s more established in the MCU if the professor recruits or encourages all different heros. Not just mutants ? Was there something like that in the comics . In my head right now I’m thinking , something like Golden U (the gen V school ) but Disney would spin it their way. A superhero school . Sky high meets ?


r/WhatIfMarvel • • 3d ago

Story Idea What if...Tony Stark won in the final fight of Civil war?

173 Upvotes

I'm surprised this comment hasn't been posted here (well not that I've seen anyway), how different do you think Infinity War and Endgame would've panned out if this happened?


r/WhatIfMarvel • • 2d ago

Story Idea What if.. the rest of the Avengers saw what Tony saw in the wormhole?

Post image
63 Upvotes

I imagine they'd be a lot more understanding with the whole Ultron thing.


r/WhatIfMarvel • • 3d ago

Fan Creation What if this was how the multiverse saga played out?

Thumbnail
gallery
40 Upvotes

r/WhatIfMarvel • • 3d ago

Story Idea What if... Frank Castle was revived by Konshu and became Moon Knight?

4 Upvotes

This isn't a story I've written. It's a question I'm asking, with follow-ups.

Heres the set up, Konshu's statue has been retrieved without incident from Egypt by Marlene & her father. As a publicity promotion, they arrange for the statue to go on display in Central Park. While its there, the Castle's are assassinated. Frank is then revived by Konshu as his Avenger.

Considering both Marc Spector & Frank Castle are both soldiers, & both kill, do you guys think there would be any difference between the two versions of Moon Knight? Would Frank suffer the split personalities that Marc does? If he did, what would those personalities be like?


r/WhatIfMarvel • • 5d ago

Story Idea What if they Introduced T’Challa differently?

20 Upvotes

I was thinking what if he wasn’t introduced in Civil War? How different would it have been imagine if he was introduced in his solo movie? And then civil war later?


r/WhatIfMarvel • • 5d ago

Multiverse & Crossovers What if Natasha and wanda were partners or lovers in the old west?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/WhatIfMarvel • • 6d ago

Comics What if instead of just Angela, marvel bought all of Spawn

Post image
9 Upvotes

(chose this because it was the closest to Spawn with MARVEL from an actual spawn comic I forget which one)


r/WhatIfMarvel • • 6d ago

Fan Creation Rank All Maria Hill Ships From Worst To Best Which one Could Be Perfect What if Marrige

Thumbnail
gallery
17 Upvotes

1# Maria Hill x Phil Coulson. 2# Maria Hill x Natasha Romanoff. 3# Maria Hill x Nick Fury 2. 4# Steve Rogers x Maria Hill. 5# Tony Stark x Maria Hill. 6# Bruce Banner x Maria Hill. 7# Scott Summers x Maria Hill. 8#


r/WhatIfMarvel • • 7d ago

Multiverse & Crossovers What If?

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

Who is this Spider-Man? (Earth-2149 Lore)

In this What If...? scenario, Ned accidentally opens a portal to Earth-2149—the universe of the original Marvel Zombies comics. Unlike mindless walkers, zombies in this universe retain their full intelligence, memories, and superpowers, which makes this Peter Parker’s story one of the darkest in the entire multiverse:

• The Infection: The plague began when an infected, Sentry-like hero crashed into New York. While trying to contain the outbreak alongside the Avengers, Peter was bitten by an infected Colonel America (Captain America).

• The Ultimate Tragedy: Driven by an uncontrollable, agonizing hunger, Peter rushed home to save Aunt May and Mary Jane—only to lose control and devour them both. Because he kept his human conscience, he was forced to live with overwhelming guilt and self-hatred every time the hunger subsided.

• The Missing Leg: During a brutal clash with Magneto (one of the last surviving humans), Magneto used his powers to slice off Peter’s left leg with Captain America’s shield.

• Cosmic Power: Alongside the other zombie heroes, Peter eventually consumed the Silver Surfer and Galactus, absorbing the Power Cosmic and becoming a planet-eating cosmic threat.

• Redemption: Years later, after being transported to another universe (Earth-Z), Peter finally overcame his hunger through sheer willpower. Realizing he could never be cured, he teamed up with Sandman to create a nanobot virus that wiped out the remaining zombies—sacrificing himself in the process to finally find peace.


r/WhatIfMarvel • • 8d ago

Fan Creation What if emma frost was in Spider-Man: Brand New Day by _artisticalmaniac_

Thumbnail
gallery
6 Upvotes

r/WhatIfMarvel • • 9d ago

Story Idea What if Wanda and Vision only get Tommy back, while Billy stays with the Kaplan family?

9 Upvotes

I've been thinking about a possible direction for Wanda and Vision's family reunion in the MCU.

What if Wanda and Vision eventually reunite with both of their sons, but only Tommy actually comes to live with them?

Here's my reasoning:

Tommy Maximoff (Speed) could be reunited with Wanda and Vision because his soul is currently inhabiting another person's body, and he might not have a stable or loving family situation. Wanda and Vision could give him a home, parental guidance, and the family he originally lost.

Billy Kaplan (Wiccan), on the other hand, already has a loving family through Jeff and Rebecca Kaplan. They raised him, loved him, and gave him a home. Even though Billy has rediscovered his identity as Wanda's son, that doesn't mean he needs to leave the family that raised him.

I actually think this could create an interesting family dynamic:

- Wanda and Vision become Tommy's parents again.

- Billy continues living with the Kaplan family.

- Wanda reconnects with Billy and develops a relationship with him without taking him away from his existing parents.

- Tommy and Billy remain brothers, even if they grow up in different households.

Wanda doesn't necessarily need to get both children back under the same roof to rebuild her family. Sometimes, being a family means respecting the lives and relationships your children have already built.

What do you think? Would you like to see Tommy reunited with Wanda and Vision while Billy remains with the Kaplans, or should both twins eventually live with Wanda and Vision?


r/WhatIfMarvel • • 10d ago

Story Idea Who wins: Hawkeye and Black Widow vs. Doctor Strange and Wanda?

0 Upvotes

Saw this debate come up and I can't stop thinking about it.
On paper it's a blowout. Strange and Wanda can rewrite reality, and Clint and Nat have arrows and batons. But Hawkeye and Black Widow are the best at fighting people way above their weight class. They've got stealth, prep, teamwork, and years of experience working together.
So let's make it interesting:
**Round 1:** Random encounter, no prep
**Round 2:** Clint and Nat get 24 hours of prep and full SHIELD gear
**Round 3:** Strange and Wanda can't kill
Can the two humans take any of these rounds? Or is it a clean sweep for the magic users?
Explain your pick.


r/WhatIfMarvel • • 12d ago

Multiverse & Crossovers What if Abomination appeared in what if Episode 3?

Post image
55 Upvotes

I find it weird that Blonsky never appeared in the episode because Incredible hulk set in Fury big week, which episode is based on and its bit weird he never show up. Maybe because they had too many characters to use, but it would be interesting to see.


r/WhatIfMarvel • • 12d ago

Fan Creation Colourisation of Moon Knight Cover

Thumbnail
gallery
10 Upvotes

My colourisation of Moon Knight 37 cover (printed in Moon Knight 36) both '84. What'd you all think?


r/WhatIfMarvel • • 13d ago

Story Idea What if Janet Van Dyne stayed trapped in the Quantum realm, and never forgot out for a long time?

Post image
13 Upvotes

She gets stuck down there, and waits for a long time to be found and lives there almost for eternity, until Hank comes down to find her. And has to live and survive for even long gap of years and decades.


r/WhatIfMarvel • • 14d ago

Fan Creation What if Ultron Never Existed? - Marvel What If..?

Thumbnail
youtu.be
3 Upvotes

r/WhatIfMarvel • • 14d ago

Story Idea What if the non-MCU 2010s Marvel heroes formed the Ultimates

Post image
29 Upvotes

So at the time of writing this, I came up with this idea 3 years ago back in 2023 when I was inspired by a comment made on the "If I Had Written Tobey Maguire Spider-Man 6" video made by the YouTube channel Missedthepart. It said:

What if the non-MCU 2010s Marvel heroes formed the Ultimates and the roster was made up of:

Andrew Garfield Spider-Man

2015 Fantastic Four

Tom Hardy Venom

James McAvoy X-Men

Ryan Reynolds Deadpool

Ray Stevenson Punisher

Edward Norton Hulk

Sticky Fingaz Blade

Now, the reason why I liked this idea so much is that it felt like the Avengers 2000 concept got a 2010s reboot.

I liked the idea so much that I even made a post about it on Marvel Amino, but at the time I really didn't put much thought into it and wrote what I thought of at the time in my head, leading to a not well-thought-out story.

But now, because I've had 3 years to think about my idea, I decided to remake my pitch to make it better.

Now, unlike Avengers 2000, which when it comes to that concept usually has the story where the team gets formed either taking place in 2008 or 2009 chronologically, with all the movies taking place prior.

To me personally, I would have the first installment where the team comes together takes place in 2019, and this is what I think the timeline would be like prior to the events of the Ultimates:

2006 - Sticky Fingaz Blade series takes place

2008 - The Incredible Hulk and Punisher: War Zone takes place in the same year

2012 - The Amazing Spider-Man 1 would take place

2014 - The Amazing Spider-Man 2 would take place

2015 - Fantastic Four would take place

2016 - Deadpool 1 would take place

2018 - Venom and Deadpool 2 would take place

Now, the story of the Ultimates would begin on Planet Zero during the final battle in Fantastic Four 2015, and just like in the movie, Doctor Doom would get defeated and punched into the portal on Planet Zero by Ben Grimm, where it seems as if the portal pulled him apart, killing him.

However, he actually survived and would get teleported back to Earth in Tibet, where he would be found by Tibetan monks and healed back to full strength. However, it would be revealed that his appearance in Fantastic Four 2015 was actually him in a cocoon, and at the monastery he would fully hatch out of it, revealing that his face was scarred by his experience on Planet Zero, but he was human again. Afterwards, he would be trained by the monks on how to fully utilize the powers he gained from Planet Zero.

Soon, the monks would help him forge his iron suit, fully making him look comic-accurate. He would thank the monks and would begin the long walk back to Latveria. Once he reached his country, he would ally himself with a rebel leader named Zora Vukovic, who was leading a resistance movement against the current ruling government of Latveria. They would overthrow the government and would place Doom on the throne, with Zora Vukovic as one of his closest subordinates who commanded his armed forces.

After taking over the country, he would actually begin to improve the living conditions in Latveria, advancing the country technologically and improving his people's lives, which would actually cause people to love him as a leader.

This would gain the attention of S.H.I.E.L.D., who, thanks to spies sent into the country by Nick Fury, would discover that Doom has allied himself with Magneto, and realizing the threat that is at stake, he would activate the Ultimates Initiative.

He would first go to the Franklin Storm Research Center, where for the last 4 years the Fantastic Four have been operating. Fury would tell Reed about Victor's survival and that he has taken over Latveria.

Realizing the threat that is at stake, the Fantastic Four decide to join the team. Afterwards, Fury would contact the X-Men and would tell them of the threat as well.

Afterwards, the rest of the team would get recruited and would go to the Triskelion in New York City, where they would discuss their plans to stop Doom and Magneto.

However, Mystique secretly broke into the facility and, in the form of a guard, successfully caused a massive mutant breakout, which would force the Ultimates to fight together for the very first time.

They would be able to contain some of the mutants that were captured. However, a majority of them would still be able to escape and join Magneto and Doom's growing army.

After this failure, the Ultimates would come up with a plan to directly go to Latveria in hopes of stopping Doom. They would airdrop into the country alongside S.H.I.E.L.D. forces directly in Doomstadt to attack Doom's castle.

However, they would get ambushed by Doombots and Latveria's military, and it would result in Reed getting captured and the Ultimates and S.H.I.E.L.D. forces retreating back to America.

Doom and Magneto's forces, fueled by the morale of their last two victories over the Ultimates, would plan their attack on New York City.

Meanwhile, Reed and Doom would have a conversation in his castle after his capture, revealing that he in fact survived the final battle on Planet Zero and was teleported back to Earth. He would explain to Reed that instead of bringing Earth to Planet Zero, he would just terraform Earth itself into his image, where he would rule humanity and Magneto would rule the mutants.

Unknown to both Doom and Reed during the Ultimates retreat the Quinjet that had Blade in it got shot down and the rest of the team assumed he died but he actually survived and got left behind in Latveria where he would actually go to Doom's Castle and would save Reed.

Meanwhile, in New York City, the Ultimates would be licking their wounds at the Triskelion. However, it would be the low point in the story where the team would actually begin to argue amongst each other, similar to the Avengers in Avengers 2012. It would seem as if the team is about to fight one another, but right at that moment Doom's army of Doombots, alongside Magneto's mutant army, would attack the city.

This would force the Ultimates to fight to save the city from being conquered. Magneto and Doom would begin to wipe the floor with the Ultimates, but unknown to both Doom and Magneto, Deadpool had set himself up in a sniper position and, with a lucky shot, was able to hit Magneto from behind, injuring him but not killing him.

The team would take advantage of this opening and would neutralize both Magneto and Doom. The remaining Doombots would flee back to Latveria, and Doom and Magneto would get captured.

The city would rejoice at the Ultimates victory, and the team would officially have their main base of operations be the Triskelion.

I think the end of the story would be similar to Avengers 2012, with the same team going their separate ways, and Maria Hill would ask, "If we get a situation like this again, what happens then?" and Nick Fury would respond, "They would come back." Maria would ask why, and Fury would respond, "Because we'll need them to."

Now Doctor Doom would be imprisoned for a couple months but his sentence would end very quickly because he planned for the outcome if he lost and got imprisoned so he implanted latverian agents and sympathizers within the US government making sure he would get out quickly because from the sympathizers point of view, he is the sovereign leader of a country that he brought order to and improved.

Credit to this image goes to

where the image came from