I’ve read through all the comments on my previous post, and I wanted to take a moment to give a proper update and clarify a few things I brushed over too quickly the first time.
First, for context: I’m a man in my 20s, not from the US, and yes - my diagnosis is real, not a label I threw in for sympathy. I was diagnosed with high-functioning autism (HFA) in my 20s, so I’m still learning how to navigate how my brain processes things.
A quick note on how HFA and alexithymia actually affect me:
For me, autism isn’t an excuse for bad behavior—it’s simply how my brain processes information and emotions.
Alongside HFA, I experience alexithymia (difficulty identifying, feeling, and expressing internal emotions). In daily life, I rely heavily on being cognitively "on" 24/7—reading people’s body language, tone, and facial expressions to understand emotional context—and my brain depends on strict logic and clear closure to process events. When a conflict or thread is left unresolved, my brain gets stuck trying to close the loop.
Earlier that day, my girlfriend walked away from an discussion/argument before we finished resolving it, I waited around hoping we could finish talking, until I eventually had to leave for a celebration I already had planned. Heading into a loud, chaotic night out with an unresolved conflict already overloading my system and then adding alcohol on top of it - caused my usual cognitive filter to break down completely. That’s actually how my psychologist explained the breakdown in my impulse control , especially knowing that I’ve been just as intoxicated (and more) plenty of times before without ever doing anything remotely like this. It explains how the failure happened, not why it’s okay. It isn’t.
What actually happened and why I posted here:
Thank you to everyone who took the time to share unfiltered, honest thoughts. I didn’t write that post to be pitied, forgiven, or excused. Not at all
Before I even posted here, I had already come completely clean to my girlfriend and talked through the fallout with her over several days. I had even brought up the dilemma regarding "the other woman," and my girlfriend actually told me that if reaching out would give me closure on that front, she didn't see an issue with it.
Even so, I never intended to contact the other woman. Still, a quiet, persistent part of my brain kept nagging at me that leaving things unfinished was not the way to go. So I posted across two subreddits to expose that thought to as many outside perspectives as possible, essentially using the comment section to simulate how she and others would actually view it, so my brain could get the external data it needed to close the loop without me ever intruding on her life. And it worked. The consensus here helped quiet that urge completely.
For the record: my girlfriend actually forgave me after we talked through everything, but I chose to end the relationship anyway. People make mistakes, yes, but there are levels to them. Cheating is a coward's act - it hides from truth and consequences - and after years of being loyal, crossing that line meant I couldn't ask or let her carry the weight of my actions with me, not this time, this is something I brought upon her, so it’s mine to deal with going forward.
One final reflection (not fishing for sympathy, just sharing the reality of it):
The hardest part isn’t getting called out online, not at all. it’s the disconnect inside my own head.
It’s waking up wanting to scream, punch the mirror, or sink to the floor and cry every ounce of regret out of your bodyand physically not being able to. Because of how my brain is wired, my body doesn't know how to conjure those feelings on command, especially when my logical brain says: "You put yourself in this situation. You caused this. Why would you get to feel sorry for yourself?"
So you just stand there in front of the mirror, looking at a reflection that doesn't feel like the person you’ve been for the last four years. Just emptiness, paired with the cognitive reality that you are the one who did it. "I’ve never done anything like this before"—"Except you just did."
Being unable to emotionally process or express regret the way neurotypical people do doesn't mean the regret isn't there; it just means you’re stuck carrying the weight of it in silence.
Thanks again to everyone who gave direct, honest perspective. I’m leaving the other woman completely alone and focusing on moving forward with full accountability.
ORIGINAL POST: https://www.reddit.com/r/WhatShouldIDo/s/9dn979w3Yb