This is a character tier list for HOD, assuming random old gods and backgrounds. I try not to re-roll the mysteries in order to get a better sense of a characters strength, simply because any character can be amazing if you roll for eels and 4 non boss mysteries for example. I may be wrong in some of these rankings, especially with the new characters as there may be strategies I'm not aware of, but this is the overall feeling I've gotten after completing multiple HOD runs. I also tried my best to order them from right to left. Let me know what you think, and here are my explanations:
The history club merchants
(give me liberty, give me fire, give me the history club or I retire.)
Toshiaki: He can do what he wants. -50% passive doom, can lower doom by 3% for 15xp, and if you pair this with metro, monument, and aka manto's mask while also knowing the doom reduction events – you simply can't die to doom. If you have this much doom spare, you can rest whenever you want so reason and stamina isn't an issue either, and book strap is an incredible prepare item to top it all off.
His stats are bad, but when his gimmick is that powerful it doesn't really matter because you can heal anything his bad stats cause. Even on Zhetcast he's still perfectly playable because of his passive and F'toth flash as long as you have the history club.
Ayaka: As long as you have the history club and blood mania, you won't have a problem with combat. If you don't have combat issues then you'll have plenty of reason and stamina to spare as long as you know your events. (I'm pretty sure 5 curses is the threshold for her power spike but I could be wrong.) As long as you remove the really bad curses and avoid dying early to a stat decrease, she basically plays herself, especially when you have her other perks too which are really good.
Kana: Easily the best spellcaster in the game because of ghostly spear. You can spam this without any drawbacks because of her max health being fixed so if you get it early from the history club then every combat encounter is free. You can still get really unlucky and die to doom but with the newly added metro this is even more unlikely to happen if you're playing well.
The best of the rest
Aiko: While not as game breaking as the other three, everything about Aiko is simply above average. She has good stats, good perks (her passive combat speed and fast swimmer being a standout because they trivialise combat.). Her prep item is essentially just having another kana and her personal events are also good. I can't really point to any major flaws other than the fact she's not called Toshiaki, Ayaka, or Kana.
Kiriko: I could very well be wrong with this placement and maybe she should be lower, but fortunes favour is genuinely insane. As long as you've built well you can get through most fights without taking any damage at all, which indirectly saves on doom because you don't have to rest as much. Her other perks aren't awful either.
That's not mentioning her tarot cards either and her overall survivability because of them. The only bad tarot card that comes to mind is the one to do with spells, but some of these tarot cards are actually better than a lot of perks in the game in my opinion (good perks too), and all for 2 reason (I usually pick that option anyway because I want to level up for fortune's favour, it's possible it could be history club worthy though.)
+2 stamina and reason after a mystery is better than the Moriko and Yumiko versions.
She has Mimi's perk of reason after killing but with Stamina instead.
+2 strength is insane as it's usually hard to increase strength and makes combat so much easier because of bracing.
-1 dmg received in combat if you have no allies is really good.
-5% doom will always be good.
No doom in the lighthouse means she can get away with later lighthouse entries assuming you know your second encounter and mystery. 93% is the max you can do with other characters but with her it'll be even higher.
The only issue I can see with this character is if you get bad RNG on tarot cards but when pretty much all of them are good I don't think it's really an issue. I don't think she's Toshiaki, Ayaka, or Kana level but I feel like she has more going for her than the characters below her. I don't think bottom of S is a completely stupid shout at the very least.
The A-tier lions
Moriko: The new mysteries help her out quite a bit, +2 perception from the telescope and the headphones really help out gun builds. But if you're not running those two mysteries then ringing ears is still a big commitment and you really need her perks to make her feel good because ammo is expensive and perception isn't exactly the greatest stat in the game.
Her amazing starting weapon makes up for her pretty meh stats but if you don't get deft handling then her gun outside of shooting isn't anything crazy. It's strange because despite how important her perks are, they aren't really game breaking enough to warrant using the history club over.
I think simply having a gun, good perks, and in the best case scenario having access to something that counteracts her main weakness makes her very strong. I just can't bring myself to put her in S because she has more notable flaws than the character above her.
Miku: Miku is very strong despite her personal events. Her passive makes her an amazing scaler that can breeze the lighthouse with ease, and paired with adrenaline her combat is also really good. Doomed already gives her good survival too, so overall she is a very solid character. The reason she isn't higher is because Aiko and especially Ayaka are just better. The high stats and attack speed gimmick is just done better by them because they either get a lot of it for free, earlier or surpass the highs Miku can reach. While it's definitely playable, Miku doesn't have the greatest early game compared to them either.
Maybe its unfair to compare her to other characters because she's still good in a vacuum, but I just can't justify putting her higher.
Mimi: While starting with less reason than everyone else, Mimi is surprisingly durable if you combine her reason perk and the ritual dagger. Starting with a weapon is good but I'm not a massive fan of the scalpel even though it's alright so it's basically a glorified +1 fund.
Knowledge builds have Definitely gotten stronger as you can get a free +1 knowledge from the lab coat in the library, and +1 damage to humans is always nice from anatomy class, because it also helps with some events. Her personal events are also solid.
Mimi is a very honest character, no real gimmicks compared to those above her which is partly why I can't put her higher because she doesn't have anything that makes her broken.
Satoshi: Similar to Kiriko, there's a possibility Satoshi is too high but I'm confident in saying he's at least the second strongest out of the 3 new characters. The way I see Satoshi is that he fundamentally makes HOD less punishing and rewards your event knowledge.
You basically avoid threat levels so the extra -1 penalties from events don't exist, and with one of his perks you can ignore the doom gain too.
Depending on the events you get, you can avoid a considerable amount of stamina, reason and doom across the course of a run. Of course if you only get -1 events then his passive is useless, but the ability to turn -2 events into -1 really does add up, and even makes some risky gambles not as risky, or uncontrollable events less punishing. Because you're losing less, you're resting less too which means you have more doom spare as an indirect result of the passive.
His stats are pretty good too, especially strength and dexterity (Just hope you don't run into a ghost lol) but his perks aren't that good in my opinion, especially compared to the characters above him. The survival items are usually a +1 fund or throwable item depending which one you get and +5 exp on dex check isn't amazing either. Ignoring doom from the threat level is good, but it's not anywhere near the same level as F'thoth flash for example.
I think Satoshi is good and has a lot more going for him than the other characters in this list that don't have very good perks either.
Haru: You can definitely argue Haru is better than Satoshi for quite a few reasons. Haru has amazing strength, the best stat in the game, and his nicotine rush makes his combat really strong. The gun he can get from his event is also great, however it's too luck based for me to consider it a consistent strategy. Core strength and CQC training are really good perks (Assuming you got the gun.) but his other perks are pretty bad. His prep item does help with his cigarette usage but Haru's problem stems from how many funds he needs over the course of a run.
To fully set up you either need to eat a lot of doom preparing for enough funds, coinflip curses on the tree, or sell the free items you can get which could be used elsewhere (Handcuffs for example.)
It's definitely workable and the positives of Haru outweigh this in my opinion, but other characters don't have to go through any of that and can get attack speed for less cost.
The Frauds
Mizuki: Fame is a good perk and can be a free win in the right circumstances which is why I've put her at the top of B tier. She has a better win condition than all the other characters in this tier but is severely outclassed by those above her because fame has it's limitations. Ally attack is really inconsistent and you'll take a lot of damage trying to use it, though it can also be really strong in the right circumstances.
This list is also assuming you can't just roll for eels and festival every run so I'm also factoring in runs where you'll have none of that, and in those circumstances Mizuki is pretty underwhelming. Fame is her only good perk. Her stats aren't great outside of charisma either so building elsewhere doesn't feel very good, and her prep item is useless.
(Give me fame, or give me death.)
Kouji: Kouji is the most factory made B-tier character in any game ever created. His stats mean he can go down multiple different build paths and starting with a camera is also really solid. However, his perks are genuinely some of the most pointless perks I've seen and you're usually better off just picking stats instead. Basically you're just playing a glorified stat stick which actually isn't that bad because it means, combat, skill checks and climbing the lighthouse usually go quite well.
I think if you have a good fundamental understanding of HOD and the game then Kouji is pretty good, but he has nothing that makes him stand out really and isn't really special or unique in any way.
Juri: Juri is one big nothing burger. 50 XP level ups are really good, but what are we levelling up for? +2 Knowledge? +2 dex? -5% doom? She has nothing. Her stats are pretty good at least and she is a functional character but she's the potential man of WoH. Playing her on all perks is really fun though and she'd be much higher on this list if that was the default.
Kirie: I don't think Kirie is a bad character, but there's a lot of RNG that goes into spells and most of them aren't worth using because of the cost. There are some extremely powerful ones such as the +1 dmg or -1 dmg received rituals, book of gore, regeneration, and ghostly spear, but because of the inconsistency I think B-tier is fair.
Lab coat and ritual dagger feels pretty good and if you get some good spells then that's a bonus, plus her perks are okay and you can always use the spells as extra reason if needed.
I guess the most glaring thing is that Kana overshadows her completely and is simply a better spellcaster.
Yashiro: Being able to fight ghosts normally is nice, but I feel like there's better items to have in the B-slot. His perks are decent but its harder for him to get them because he needs more XP and if you don't keep his faith up he levels up even slower. You can't really go for a low faith build because with more damage and strength you'll naturally take less damage meaning you'll end up with pretty high faith anyway.
You want to run away to avoid taking damage but that means you'll get less XP so you'll level up even slower, and the 10XP per runaway perk isn't really worth it. Max reason isn't that impressive in HOD because you're unlikely to have that much health anyway and +1 dexterity doesn't mean anything if you're building strength or knowledge so the only bonus of high faith is the extra XP but that means nothing because he needs 120XP to level up anyway so he also just kinda feels like one big nothing burger that's at war with himself. Zeal is just a worse version of core strength (It's still good.) and all high faith does is half it's downside.
To me at least, Yashiro kind of just feels like your nerfing yourself and you're forced into keeping high faith in order to be as strong as the baseline of every other character so it all just kind of feels pointless. Mizuki has the high of fame for example, but what high does Yashiro have?
Maybe I'm missing something.
C-tier Makoto Demon status
Makoto: I really like Makato and I've spent alot of time trying to justify putting her higher but I simply can't. Her meat puppet heal simply doesn't outweigh the downside of her overall lowered healing. Makoto is like a worse version of Kana in my eyes because she can't really die to stamina or reason, only doom, and being able to always have a heal available no matter what situation you're in feels pretty good, but you lose so much for it to the point its not worth it. Here is a list of some of the healing you lose:
-Bath (You have contaminated water from the start.)
-Tireless (No +1 all at the end of the mystery.)
-Water bottle, milk bottle, wine.
- Any plus 1 event
- Spells don't regain reason
- No healing from Ritual dagger or carpenter hammer
- resting at home stops being optimal (2 all for 3 doom is better than 1 all for 2 doom in my opinion)
- trading 1 stamina for reason or vice versa during battle
- Certain foods
There's probably more but these are the ones that come to my head. Every other heal isn't as good either so meat puppet has to do a lot of heavy lifting but taking away that many healing sources and replacing it with one just isn't worth it. It's like she's Satoshi's opposite, where instead of making bad events okay, she makes good events pointless.
Her stats and perks are pretty decent though, especially the +1 damage and strength perk and -10% doom does help with her healing, alongside the metro and monument. Aka manto mask helps out a lot too but that's assuming you get it. You can get rid of meat puppet by fixing the VHS tapes in fear festival, but I'm also including runs where that doesn't happen.
Makoto is arguably the worst character in the game, but I'd much rather play her than the next character. Which says a lot, considering Makoto isn't even alive.
Despair
Yumiko:
The old gods must have licked their lips and rubbed their hands together when they realised Yumiko was supposed to stop them. In a game called world of horror the scariest thing is picking a random character and getting Yumiko. The Baseball player with four dexterity and less strength than a literal corpse. But I'll give credit where credits due regarding Yumiko, because It's very inclusive of Pantsasz to include an amputee within the roster. Yumiko is the type of character to miss a prepared attack, which is why I think she should have access to desperate struggle even when she's at full health because it's the perfect encapsulation of how it feels to play as her. Yumiko shaved her hair off to be more aerodynamic but has still ended up slower than every other character. The 0 power next to an enemy after using Yumiko's baseball is only there to show how hard she threw it.
0 Useful stats above five
0 Luck checks completed
7 failed dodges