World of tanks has evolved into a game that rewarded slow and thought out gameplay into blitzkrieg matches where 90% of the time you lose or win in 5 minutes.
Light tanks are overly aggressive with insane guns and health pools and don't act as scouts anymore when it comes to normal play. Medium tanks are either leaning towards Medium-light, Medium-sniper, or Medium-Heavies.
I could go on and on regarding my personal opinion on the current position of the game but I'll get on with this idea.
WoT Classic. This type of content has shown to bring back a lot of the original older player base due to survivorship bias. Good examples of this are OSRS and even more recently Wow Forever.
Part 1. Restoring the classic feel.
Change 1: Restoration of the original 3 tech trees.
The first and most important change would be restoring the old identity of World of Tanks. World of Tanks initially was slower, heavier, and more calculated. Positioning mattered more. Armor knowledge mattered more. Weak spots mattered more.
Players had to think about when to push, when to trade, and when to hold a position. This was the core identity of world of tanks. Everything was slower but more calculated and to return to this I firmly believe would make a phenomenal game given the advancements within the engine.
World of Tanks Classic should launch with the original core nations:
United States
U.S.S.R.
Germany
This would reset the game to a simpler and more understandable state and it would also allow the developers to focus on re-balancing a smaller number of tanks instead of trying to manage the massive amount of vehicles in the current version of the game.
Effect on the community
This would make the game much easier for returning players to understand. Older players remember these original lines and would immediately recognize the state of the game again.
Newer players would also have a much cleaner starting point instead of being overwhelmed by nearly a dozen branches, mechanics, premium vehicles, battle pass content, campaigns, crew XP mechanics, field upgrades, vehicle upgrades (T11) etc.
Effect on longevity
Starting small gives the Classic version room to grow. More nations and tank lines could be added later through phases or community-approved Classic+ updates.
This also creates a long-term content pipeline as a lot of tanks have been added to the game that would certainly fit the classic feel of the game.
Change 2: Removal of modern tanks.
World of Tanks Classic should remove most tanks that were added far beyond the original era, especially vehicles that changed the pace and balance of the game too much.
This would include removing and avoiding:
Wheeled vehicles
Tier XI vehicles
reward tanks
gimmicky autoloaders/sequential loaders
Overpowered premium tanks
Vehicles with mechanics that do not fit the original pacing of the game
Effect on the community
This would help restore trust with players who feel the game has moved too far away from its original identity.
It would also reduce frustration from vehicles that feel unfair, overly mobile, or just honestly gimmicky.
Effect on longevity
A smaller, cleaner tank pool is easier to balance. If players feel the game is fair and readable, they are more likely to keep playing. Power creep is one of the biggest long-term problems in live-service games, so Classic needs to completely avoid that path again.
Change 3: Keep modern improvements where they help, but restore vehicle weight
World of Tanks Classic should not completely revert the physics, UI, or engine back to the oldest version. Some modern improvements should stay because they make the game smoother and more stable.
However, vehicle movement should be adjusted so tanks feel heavy again. Tanks should not feel jumpy, floaty, or overly arcade-like. The movement should feel grounded and deliberate.
Effect on the community
This would satisfy both older and newer players. Older players get the heavy tank feel they remember, while newer players still benefit from a cleaner UI, better visuals, better performance, and modern stability.
Effect on longevity
Keeping useful modern improvements prevents Classic from feeling outdated in a bad way. The game should feel classic in gameplay, not broken or clunky game mechanics just for nostalgia.
Change 4: Bring back classic map design philosophy
Maps should reward:
Spotting
Crossfire
Flanking
Armor positioning
Map awareness
Bush knowledge
Smart rotations
The game should avoid overly corridor-based maps where every battle turns into the same forced lane fight.
Effect on the community
This would bring back a lot of the skill expression that older players miss. Light tanks, tank destroyers, mediums, and heavies would all have clearer roles again rather than seeing a light tank with 2k+ HP an autoloader and 80km/h speeds.
Effect on longevity
Good maps keep the game repayable. If maps allow multiple strategies instead of forcing the same fights every match, players stay engaged longer.
Part 2. Gameplay and progression
World of Tanks Classic should use a completely separate progression system from the current game
Change 1: Fresh Account progression.
Every player should start again at Tier I.
Modern account progress should not transfer into a Classic at all
Gold - transferring gold would make the game have the exact same issues as currently WOT, christmas loot boxes have also forwarded this problem by having players gain 100k-400k gold. Along with the issue of using gold from the main game to purchase free XP in Classic.
Premium vehicles - transferring vehicles from the main game to classic would have players avoid playing early-tiers and grinding by just hard playing premium tanks.
Bonds - it's a newer system that could be implemented into classic as it's a skill based earning system
Components - this system is overly complex and can change how a tank plays entirely, causing drastic balancing problems.
Boosters - this could be implemented into classic but changed to reward play-time rather than loot boxes or other systems.
Crew books - this speeds up and removes the progression needed to train your crew.
Reward vehicles - these could be maintained but would need to be a separate idea to what it currently is, rather than relying on players fearing missing out on content have it be a consistent thing players can grind towards.
Experimental equipment - same issue as components
Field modifications - same issue as components
Battle Pass rewards - same issue as components and the current structure for reward vehicles.
WoT Plus benefits - This could be kept and transferred in a meaningful way. Wargaming has to make money, they're a company. this could apply differently to WOT Classic in many ways. limiting how powerful it is but still providing bonuses to players actively supporting the game.
Premium days - Same with WoT Plus benefits, but should not be transferred from the main game due to the insane gold inflation caused by loot boxes.
Effect on the community
This gives everyone a fair starting point. Returning players, new players, free-to-play players, and paying players would all begin on equal ground. That is important because Classic needs to feel like a fresh start, not another mode where old account power dominates immediately.
Effect on longevity
A fresh start creates a major launch moment. It also makes early and mid-tier gameplay active again. Instead of everyone instantly jumping into high-tier tanks, the whole community would progress together.
Change 2: Slower progression
Progression should be slower than modern World of Tanks. Reaching higher tiers should feel meaningful again, getting out of the M3 Lee and into the next tier should feel like a meaningful push.
Tier V, VI, VII, and VIII should all matter. Players should not feel like they are just rushing through the entire tech tree to reach Tier X as quickly as possible.
Along with increasing the costs to run these higher tier tanks like in the original feel for WOT, making the lower tier tanks matches significantly more viable for grinding credits and so new players aren't stuck waiting to try and play low tier matches later into the games life-span.
Effect on the community
This brings back the feeling of earning your tanks. Players would spend more time learning each vehicle, each tier, and each map. It would also make mid-tier battles more populated and more enjoyable.
Effect on longevity
Slower progression extends the life of the game naturally. It gives players long-term goals without needing constant artificial events or Battle Pass pressure to attempt to maintain the player base through FOMO. This is how WOT maintained it's players originally. Later on this will go over how to implement more gameplay and goals for players without needing to implement events or by using FOMO to maintain players.
Change 3. Remove battle pass and boost progression systems
World of Tanks Classic should not use the modern Battle Pass system or the current booster heavy progression system as it makes building from a Tier 6 to a Tier 7 tank feel like a nuisance rather than proper gameplay progression. Working through tech tree lines shouldn't feel like a race to the top rather a long-term goal.
Things to completely avoid.
Battle Pass power rewards
Constant XP booster stacking
Credit booster stacking
Blueprint shortcuts
Event systems that rush players through progression at drastically increased rates.
Effect on the community
This would reduce the feeling that players have to constantly log in or spend money to keep up. The game would feel less like a chore and burn players out using FOMO tactics.
Effect on longevity
Players are more likely to stay long-term when the game respects their time. Pressure-based systems drive short-term player numbers but burn people out, monetization can be done in different ways to properly care for players time while also providing Wargaming with the money needed to maintain servers and pay devs while making a profit.
Change 4. Reworking the crew system.
The Classic version should either return to the original crew system or use an improved version of the original crew system.
Crew progression should matter, but it should not become an overwhelming power gap as it is currently. The system should avoid modern mechanics that stack too many bonuses and make veteran crews feel impossible to compete against when grinding through tiers which also compounds onto the problem of tech tree progression.
Effect on the community
Players would still feel attached to their crews, but new or returning players would not feel permanently behind. This keeps progression meaningful without making it feel like you're outclassed entirely.
Effect on longevity
A balanced crew system gives players long term goals without ruining matchmaking. Crews should add identity and investment, not create impossible gaps between old and new players.
Change 5.
These systems should not exist in World of Tanks Classic at launch.
The Classic version should focus on simple tank progression that plays to the specific type of tank their using. (Scout, Sniper, Support, Etc.)
Research tank -> Buy tank -> Upgrade modules -> Train crew -> Learn the vehicle -> Improve through skill
Effect on the community
This makes the game easier to understand and less exhausting to manage. Players would no longer need to track multiple currencies through layered upgrade systems just to stay viable in a tank.
Effect on longevity
Simplicity helps the game age better. The more layered systems that get added, the harder it becomes to balance the game and bring new players in without them feeling like they're at an extreme uphill battle with no way to win except pay.
Part 3. Monetization
Monetization is one of the hardest subjects to talk about, It is completely understandable that Wargaming needs to make money.
The issue is that the current model with constant loot boxes, limited-time premium tanks, Battle Pass pressure, and power-based monetization, has pushed many players away from what the game used to be and turned WoT Into a JRPG MMORPG, rather than what it once was.
World of Tanks Classic would still make money, but it needs to be built around trust and systems that are good for the longevity for the game
Change 1: Remove loot boxes
Loot boxes should not be part of World of Tanks Classic.
Effect on the community
This would immediately build goodwill. A lot of players are tired of loot box-driven events and limited time gambling style monetization. Removing that from Classic would make the mode feel cleaner and overall be more respectable of players time.
Effect on longevity
Trust is more valuable than short term loot box revenue. If players believe Classic is fair they're more likely to support it long term through premium, cosmetics, and other optional purchases.
Change 2: Premium tanks.
Premium tanks can exist within Classic, but they should never be stronger than tech tree tanks.
Even using systems where you're unable to buy a premium tank at a certain tier until you've unlocked one of your own. (Unlocking a main line Tier 7 means you can then purchase tier 7 premiums)
Effect on the community
This prevents Classic from becoming pay-to-win. Players will be much more willing to accept premium tanks if they are useful but not dominant.
Effect on longevity
Overpowered premium tanks damage the game permanently. Once they are sold, they are difficult to nerf without upsetting buyers. Keeping premiums balanced from the start or even initially underpowered protects the future of the game.
Change 3: Reworking gold rounds/ammo
Gold rounds would have to be handled carefully.
Bringing back gold only premium ammo would be a massive mistake as it would bring back the old style of Wallet Warriors (Old Clan from 0.6/0.7) However, keeping premium ammo as it currently exists would keep it's current issue of being just "the best to use in any circumstance"
A better option would be to make premium ammo available for credits only, but with real true tradeoffs.
For example:
Higher penetration but lower damage
Higher cost
Worse normalization
Lower shell velocity
Less penetration at range
More situational use depending on shell type as listed above.
Effect on the community
This would make premium ammo feel like a tactical option instead of the default answer to every problem. Players would feel rewarded for aiming at weak spots and learning armor layouts along with managing their position to give them a true advantage.
Effect on longevity
Ammo balance is one of the most important long-term issues. If premium ammo is too strong, armor becomes meaningless. If armor becomes meaningless, heavy tanks lose identity. If the identity of tanks disappear, Classic loses its purpose entirely.
Change 4: Focus on fair and time respecting monetization.
World of Tanks Classic could easily monetize through the following.
Premium account time - reduced partially from what it is currently.
Garage slots - the old 100-300 gold system for buying garage slots AND the ability to buy them for credits (More people will buy this for gold than you'd think. Credits have to be earned, gold can be purchased.)
Cosmetic camouflage - This needs to be in-line with the gameplay style, finding ways for players to earn these cosmetics while also allowing them to be purchased through gold.
Historical decals - This is self-explanatory I believe.
Commander portraits - the ability for tanks to have portraits of their commanders on the sides of the turret, etc.
Voice packs - This is already in the main game, but could focus on historical figures and be a permanent item in the shop, even with variants.
Garage customization - changing how the garage looks, etc.
Name changes - the need to pay gold for name changes.
Cosmetic achievement displays - self explanatory and currently within WoT Plus.
WoT Plus - WoT Plus could work for both the main game and classic, while classic gets less bonuses from WoT Plus and potentially other bonuses that make more sense given the gameplay loop.
Effect on the community
Players are more willing to spend money when they feel the game is not selling power. Cosmetic and convenience-based monetization keeps the relationship between players and developers healthier.
Effect on longevity
A fair monetization model keeps the game from repeating the same problems that caused many players to leave modern World of Tanks with power-creep and insanely over-powered premium tanks
Part 4.
The biggest mistake WoT Classic could make would be launching as a pure nostalgia project and then doing nothing afterward, no new progression lines, no new branches, etc.
This version would essentially classic+, this is the same ideology of Old School Runescape.
This means new content could be added, but only if it respects the original design of the game.
Change 1: content release.
Classic should not launch with everything available immediately.
A possible structure for an initial roll-out would be
Phase 1: U.S, U.S.S.R, and Germany up to tier X. allow medium Tier X but keep light tanks at tier 5/6 and scale them appropriately to reach Tier X games where they fit a role as proper scouts. Arty to Tier X as well.
Phase 2: Classic Clan Wars, fighting for land to give players motivation to push for clan buildings, etc. this needs to be slow and rely on the clan itself not just land they own. players working towards shared missions, etc.
Phase 3: First roadmap given out to show future content which players can vote on through polling, etc.
Phase 4: Roll out future roadmap changes.
Effect on the community
This gives the players the initial content they need to play through and give feedback on along with content coming down the pipeline to support future play.
Effect on longevity
It prevents the player base from burning through everything in the first few weeks and feeling like there's nothing really "new" to do.
Change 2: Community voted updates
Major changes should be voted on by the community in classic (and use some sort of system to combat multi-accounts/bots.).
This could include:
New tank lines
New premium tanks
Major ammo changes
Major economy changes
Major map reworks
New mechanics
content additions
What should not be voted on.
Balance changes, dev-required changes.
Effect on the community
This gives players ownership over the direction of the game. It also helps prevent the Classic version from slowly turning into modern World of Tanks again.
Effect on longevity
Community voting builds trust. When players feel heard, they are significantly more likely to stay invested over multiple years.
Change 3: new content that respects the old design philosophy.
Classic content could include:
New historical tank branches
New tactically designed maps
Historical campaigns
Nation-based events and missions
Tank Company seasons
Classic Clan Wars
Cosmetic reward tracks
Effect on the community
This gives players something new to look forward to without betraying the Classic identity. It also gives returning players a reason to stay after the nostalgia wears off.
Effect on longevity
This is the Old School RuneScape lesson. A classic game cannot survive forever by staying frozen. It needs new content, but that new content has to respect why players wanted the classic version in the first place.
Part 5: What's needed to protect the classic identity.
World of Tanks Classic must have a clear set of hard lines from the start. This would protect the identity of the game and help players trust that Classic will not slowly become what World of Tanks is now.
No Tier XI. - potentially in the future but needs to be designed around better tanks rather than gimmick based systems within Tier XI.
No wheeled vehicles.
No artillery stun.
No Battle Pass power progression.
No experimental equipment.
No field modifications.
No full repair/revive using base repair kits and medical kits.
No overpowered premium tanks.
No loot box exclusive vehicles.
No gold-only insane ammunition advantage.
Major content additions should require some sort of community approval or something of the like.
Bring back credit incentivized gameplay, Ammo rack kills causing a full loss of ammo, etc.
Effect on the community
This would make players feel safer investing their time into the game and that the time they spend within it will not be disrespected by limited events, etc. A lot of players are worried that any Classic version would eventually be monetized or changed into the same thing they left.
Effect on longevity
A clear rule set protects the game from power creep and identity loss. It gives the developers a foundation to build on without constantly pushing the game toward short term monetization methods that in the moment provide a lot of income but kills the games identity.
Reasons why WoT truly needs this change and why I decided to write this.
Wargaming has acknowledged they're struggling to get new players and to even keep returning players. This is obvious due to the multiple free Tier 1-10 tech tree releases at the release of 2.0
I've made a large sum of friends online playing this game and have met up with a chunk of them in-person, everyone's said the same thing. The game has become gimmicky and braindead strategies are extremely effective due to the gimmicky tanks given out in loot boxes or by other means.
Background about me (if you're interested)
I was introduced to world of tanks in 2008 by my grandfather, I've been playing this game since I was a very young child and I've seen this game go through every rough patch since alpha. The original clan system to the release of the Type 59 and many more "game breaking" things.
Now that I'm in college and play this game sparingly in my free-time and other games I grew up with are taking a classic route and succeeding massively I had a spark of hope WoT could too.
Extra:
This is written in an extremely odd way I know, but I had to organize my thoughts into something remotely readable so this is best formula I came up with. Main Idea -> Parts -> Cause and Effect on players.
So I apologize if this comes off jarring and repeats the same point in multiple areas.