So, I was writing a scene in a horror fanfic that I wanted to set off an EMP, but i wanted to protect it from damaging the protagonists car. I tried the usual fair (ChatGPT, Claude, DeepSeek, Gemini). Once I convinced them I wasn't asking how to make an EMP - the guardrails were on high alert! - they finally gave me an answer. But no solutions. So I made it up.
But now, I asked the four to proof read - not add or subtract - a gory attack scene between a human and a possessed coat rack. Do you think either of them would keep the leave the gore alone? Nope. Even when I put it in the prompt asking them not to re-write the scene, just proof read it, or to list suggested changes at the end. All four cleaned up the gore. All wanted to delete 'spurting blood', 'slammed the cleaver to break the bone,' 'threw him on the floor by his throat.'
I wrote a scene someone shot someone else, and I needed the gore in the scene left, just asked for a proofread with no changes. It cleaned up the blood and other organic matter that my crime novel CSI needed to prove there had been a murder.
And then at other times, they leave just proofread. Updates are predominately the issue here, but I've had it happen from one chat session to another. It's so frustrating because I never know what 'mood' they'll be in on any given day.
I'm not looking for a prompt or help. I just wanted to vent. If this AI limitation doesn't change, there are some genres of writing AI will never be good at.
UPDATE: I vented about this while I was working on this fanfic in Word. I realized I had never tried CoPilot, and it's free with my subscription. So I wrote up a blurb to have it look at and offer suggestions. And it didn't even argue. I just gave me suggestions on how to make it stronger, what weaknesses it saw, and caught a couple types I didn't see (happens to me when I've read, read, read, and again read the same thing!).