r/Xenoblade_Chronicles • u/Raelhorn_Stonebeard • 10h ago
Xenoblade 3 SPOILERS Shimmer - Alternate Origin Theory Spoiler

Alright, this is something I've been dwelling on the last few days... and I'm mostly putting the theory out there for posterity, in the event that Shimmer isn't exactly who she appears to be (the Mythrakid). So, let's start with the root question here:
If Shimmer is not Mythra's Child, then who could she be?
Let's just start off with the obvious details:
- She has a Pneuma core, which must at least tie her to the Pneuma bloodline - she must be descended from either Pyra or Mythra.
- She possesses Foresight, as stated in the trailer, which is another link to the Aegis abilities. Mythra displayed this trait explicitly, but you could argue that Foresight is similar to Alvis' visions and it may be a common trait among the other Trinity Core processors.
- As noted in another post a few months ago, she is recruited in the Erythia Sea, after meeting up with the City and getting the boat. Location is a bit north of the Lavi Sandbar (and the remnant of Addam's Tomb in the Place of Hero's Rest) and the entrance to the Lost Colony.
- Aside from the obvious nods to Mythra and Rex's designs, Shimmer's design is very much different from that of other soldiers in XC3. Specifically, it's not military in any way (even Ouroboros keep elements of their military uniforms, even if it's just her underwear in Sena's case); the design is closer to that of XC2 Blades and much more casual.
- The previews have shown Shimmer and Mio in the Memorial Hall, where the Founders' statues are found. This means Shimmer's questline will take her to the City, though the purpose for doing so is still unknown.
- While a simple case of being covered by clothing is possible, Shimmer's term-mark has not been seen; we can't confirm whether or not she has one. Feel free to correct me if I missed this somewhere.
- There was a curious discrepancy between the English and Japanese versions of the trailer, in that she was shown to be affiliated with Agnus in the former and the City in the latter. This post first brought it to my attention. This also extends to her weapon in the trailer, which shows an Ouroboros gauge on one and a classic Flame Clock on the other (as does her concept art above). Even if one is the case of an old build... it's a curious discrepancy to have made it all the way to the trailer, yes?
So the argument being made here is that Shimmer is from the City, rather than being the Mythrakid. So what dots do we have to connect for that theory to be plausible?
------------------------------------------------------
For Shimmer to be from the City, we have an interesting argument - and a void with the City's political structure:
We do not know who the head of House Rhodes is.
All the others have been accounted for, more or less:
- House Vandham is headed by Monica.
- House Doyle is headed by Garret.
- House Ortiz is headed by Timna.
- House Cassini is headed by Masha.
- House Reid is presumably headed by Shania's mother.
When it comes to House Rhodes, there's not much to go on. Doc Hollis is likely the most senior member we meet, but it's not clear if he's actually in charge. The other two named ones are Kryto (one of the Ouroboros candidates) and Tessa (part of Masha's ascension quest). Let's get some visuals on those two:


While not quite as evident with Kryto (very much a light brown hair colour), Tessa has very prominent blonde hair. It's also been a thousand years, plenty of time for some variation to occur, but it could easily have a variety of sources. However, it does confirm the presence of blonde hair in House Rhodes.
Which leads to the key statement of the theory here:
Shimmer could be the head of House Rhodes.
Now, to suggest the very blonde Shimmer is the head of the house on hair colour alone is a bit weak for evidence, but we can certainly explore the possibility. However, the question of her having the Pneuma core is curious by itself, especially since no other member of House Rhodes appears to have it.
Well, perhaps the Pneuma core (like the Aegis before it) is something of a special case - only one copy may be passed down per generation. And naturally, because the Pneuma core itself grants some enhanced abilities, this person becomes the nominal head of the House. It's actually somewhat interesting that Rhodes seems to want little-to-do with the Lost Numbers (Tessa nearly got disowned for wanting to join up, though Kryto's case wasn't discussed)... but the idea that they've concentrated their strength in their special successor might lead to them not wanting to risk other members in the broader fight. In short, Shimmer might be the only expected member of House Rhodes to participate in the conflict - mostly because she's naturally powerful, and her special status and the inheritor of the Pneuma core gives her greater power. Possibly even Ouroboros-related abilities without needing to be enhanced by an Ouroboros stone.
Also an obvious lead-in for recruiting her, in that we might be on a "rescue mission" to retrieve her before bad stuff happens. Such as dying before passing on the Pneuma core to the next successor.
------------------------------------------------------
One theory I have seen floated, but has its own complications, is that of Shimmer not being multiple generations later than the Founders. Rather, the direct child of Glimmer and Nikol (let's assume they had another kid who would go on to found House Ortiz if this is the case)... and maybe some Queen/Moebius kind of agelessness to muddy it up. Certainly would be a fluke if Glimmer's child has a surprising resemblance of to her half-sibling because the father is also blonde, but in any case, let's take a peek at some traits and how they could be passed on.
- As stated in the previous section, the Pneuma core is passed down once per generation. Only this time the generations functionally stop with an ageless Shimmer (from Glimmer herself). Other traits like facial structure and build would be passed on as well.
- Hair is an interesting case here, actually. Besides the colour, Shimmer's hair style has a vague resemblance to Nikol's... and he has a pair of hair antennae as well, which could have combined to give Shimmer her giant curl:

- For another tangential point, Shimmer's weapon has a segmented sheathe which wraps around the glowing blade of ether. While a bit of a stretch (pun not intended), the segmented sheathe appears to vaguely resemble the arms of Nikol's backpack as seen above.

- This does beg the question of where the Foresight-like ability comes from, as neither Pyra nor Glimmer showed the trait explicitly. And neither does Nikol have visions like Shulk. Then again, I would not be surprised by Alvis/A's meddling to "add it in", especially if it was merely an untapped feature of the Pneuma core for Glimmer.
Now, much of the stuff in this section could easily be applied to a later generation as well, without the need to make Shimmer an ageless character on Aionios like the Queens or Moebius. Still fun to muse over.
------------------------------------------------------
Now then, as stated at the start, I'm mostly putting this out there for posterity - in the event that Shimmer isn't exactly who she appears to be. The Switch 2 update is coming out in less than two weeks, so putting it out now as a "just in case".
There's no denying that the most likely scenario is that Shimmer is the Mythrakid... but that inconsistency with the affiliations is just enough to introduce a modicum of doubt. The scant possibility she could be someone else.
So while it's incredibly unlike, let's entertain the thought in the closing days before this particular quandry gets a proper answer. Probably. Maybe. I guess we'll find out.
Until then...
