r/Yazidis • u/rkurdistanmod • 1h ago
Yazidi Genocide: Who else was there?
Samih, a survivor of the Yazidi (Êzîdî) Genocide, traveled thousands of kilometers to Berlin to say only one thing in public: when the Islamic State (ISIS) came to Kocho in August 2014 to massacre the Yazidi community, the people who blocked the road out of the village were not strangers, but neighbors.
“There wasn’t a single stranger from somewhere else,” he told The Amargi on the last day of the hearings. He had joked with them, gone to school with them, and sat in their houses. After the peshmerga abandoned their positions, he said, those same men stopped the village residents from escaping and came to kill them, because they refused to give up being Yazidi. Samih survived the mass grave in Kocho, counting 450 people killed that day.
He was one of around 30 survivors and experts who gave evidence over three days at the Community-Based Truth Commission for the Yazidi People, held at the German Bundestag from November 16 to 18 – in what its organizers describe as the first commission of its kind for the Yazidi Genocide.
The commission openly stressed that it has no legal power but aims to amplify survivors’ voices and shed light on questions that remain unanswered. Matthew Travis Barber, an advisor to the commissioners, told The Amargi that the commission will produce a public report and present it to governments and parliaments in several Western countries.
A UN commission of inquiry concluded in 2016 that ISIS committed genocide against the Yazidis; in 2021 UN investigators said they had “clear and convincing evidence” of the same; and the Bundestag formally recognized the genocide in January 2023.
A 2017 PLOS Medicine survey estimated that 3,100 Yazidis were killed and some 6,800 abducted over a period of days in August 2014, with wide margins of error. According to the UN inquiry, thousands of Yazidi women and girls were sold in slave markets, forcibly married to ISIS fighters, and subjected to systematic rape and sexual slavery. Older women were executed, and young boys indoctrinated. Yezidi men and older boys who had converted rather than be killed were held prisoner and enslaved, according to the Free Yazidi Foundation.
One of the deadliest parts of the genocide was in the village of Kocho. ISIS took control of the area on August 3 and held 1,200 residents under siege for 12 days. On August 15, they were systematically gathered at the school and separated by gender and age. Men, adolescent boys, and women deemed too old for sexual slavery were killed. Women, girls, and young children were abducted and forced into slavery.
Human rights organizations and news outlets reported between 400 and 600 people slaughtered in Kocho. Later, in 2018 and 2020, 17 mass graves were exhumed in and around the village. Twelve years on, the Kurdistan Region’s Office for Kidnapped Yazidis reports around 2,500 people still missing, of whom approximately half are women and girls, and more than 200,000 people still displaced.
The commission heard survivors’ testimony on who had been present when the massacre took place. They all described a similar sequence of events. According to the witnesses’ accounts, the peshmerga and officials instructed local residents to stay, even when fighting reached nearby villages in Sinjar (Shengal).
Weapons were collected by the peshmerga forces, and the families who tried to leave were stopped by them at checkpoints, promised they would be protected, and sent back, according to the testimonies. However, on August 3, the Peshmerga withdrew without warning. A man from Kocho said he and others were urged to stay even as more than 50 ISIS vehicles approached.
Barber, who has a background as a historian and has written extensively on the Yazidis, said the withdrawal of Erbil’s Kurdistan Democratic Party (KDP)-led peshmerga was deliberate and amounted to co-perpetration, with ISIS carrying the greatest responsibility and KDP the second greatest. “They didn’t pull the triggers on the guns,” he said, “but they didn’t stop the people who did.”
The Kurdistan Regional Government in Erbil rejected the claim that the Yazidis were deliberately abandoned, stating that ISIS overran its positions. At the time, a Kurdish forces spokesman reportedly said there had been negligence but “categorically no order to withdraw,” while Masoud Barzani stated that the military officials should have sacrificed themselves defending the area, and that he had sent those responsible to a board of inquiry.
Human Rights Watch reported in August 2014 that peshmerga who had been protecting a village of Yazidis fleeing to the mountains pulled back without explanation, with the local commander saying they had no orders to engage. As the peshmerga withdrew, Kurdish fighters from the People’s Protection Units (YPG) and the Kurdistan Workers’ Party (PKK) arrived. Many survivors credit these groups with opening the route through Syria that broke the ISIS siege of some 50,000 Yazidis sheltering on Mount Sinjar.
Samih wants ISIS, his Arab neighbors who took part in the massacre, and the peshmerga forces who left their positions without warning the community to be held accountable. Researchers at the European Council on Foreign Relations found that local Sunni supporters helped ISIS take over the district, while Yazidi survivors testified to neighbors having joined in, providing names. But there are also stories of rescue. Reportedly, one woman who gave evidence worked with smugglers to free captives. She said an Arab driver who helped with five escapes was caught and beheaded.
Yazidis who tell the true version of accounts, Samih warned, are arrested and humiliated on return to Iraq and its Kurdistan Region. In one case, a photographer who documented the events surrounding the genocide had his evidence seized by security forces and is now unable to return. Barber noted how the Asayish – the KDP’s security service – threatens relatives of people who speak out abroad. Human rights groups have repeatedly warned of the repression of journalists and activists in the Kurdistan Region.
Samih said he hopes to see his homeland gain autonomy so that Yazidis can govern and protect themselves from threats. Survivors are also demanding an international tribunal to hold perpetrators to account and secure justice. Organizers of the truth commission told journalists at the event that their final report is planned for 2027, pledging to call for a tribunal and urging the UN to rise to the occasion. Samih said he will go wherever he is able and tell it again, because he saw 450 people killed.