r/YouOnLifetime • • Apr 24 '25

Mod Post YOU (Season 5) - Overall Discussion Thread

409 Upvotes

Overall Season 5 Discussion Thread [SPOILERS]

WARNING: In this thread, you can discuss the entirety of the fifth season with the inclusion of spoilers. If you are not finished with the fifth season, the advisable course of action would be to not view or scroll any further down unless intended otherwise.


DISCLAIMER: Please read and keep the following in mind before posting on r/YouOnLifetime

When making new posts in the subreddit, DO NOT include spoilers in the title of your post. Also, mark all posts containing spoilers for season 5 as SPOILER before you post. Also, FLAIR your post with the appropriate flair, whenever you can.

As noted above, any and all spoilers from subsequent episodes in Episode Discussion Threads are not allowed. For eg: if you are commenting on the discussion thread of the 3rd episode, DO NOT include any events or incidents from say, the 4th episode in your comment.


SPOILER TAGS

Please use spoiler tags, wisely in case you are discussing any content that contains spoilers. You can use the native spoiler tag like this:

">"!Joe will never find true peace and will always kill for his own personal desires!"<" but without the quotation marks.

It'll appear like this Joe will never find true peace and will always kill for his own personal desires.

IF YOU CONTINUE TO VIOLATE ANY POLICY INCLUDING THE ONE FOR SPOILERS, YOU WILL BE BANNED. NO EXCEPTIONS.


Link to Season 5 Episode Discussion Hub


DISCORD for YOU

Please feel free to join the Discord server dedicated to the television series YOU, to discuss theories and thoughts in depth for all seasons. Everyone is very nice and the show is growing, so please help us build a nice community. The permanent invite link is below for your consideration.

https://discord.gg/vcwp4Kb


r/YouOnLifetime • • Apr 24 '25

Mod Post YOU (Season 5) - Episode Discussion Hub

148 Upvotes

Season 5 Episode Discussion Hub

Synopsis: In the fifth season, Joe Goldberg returns to New York City to live a seemingly peaceful life with his wife Kate and their son Henry, but his past and dark desires threaten to unravel his carefully constructed new life.


DISCLAIMER: Please read and keep the following in mind before posting on r/YouOnLifetime

When making new posts in the subreddit, DO NOT include spoilers in the title of your post. Also, mark all posts containing spoilers for season 5 as SPOILER before you post. Also, FLAIR your post with the appropriate flair, whenever you can.

As noted above, any and all spoilers from subsequent episodes in Episode Discussion Threads are not allowed. For eg: if you are commenting on the discussion thread of the 3rd episode, DO NOT include any events or incidents from say, the 4th episode in your comment.


SPOILER TAGS

Please use spoiler tags, wisely in case you are discussing any content that contains spoilers. You can use the native spoiler tag like this:

">"!Joe will never find true peace and will always kill for his own personal desires!"<" but without the quotation marks.

It'll appear like this Joe will never find true peace and will always kill for his own personal desires.

IF YOU CONTINUE TO VIOLATE ANY POLICY INCLUDING THE ONE FOR SPOILERS, YOU WILL BE BANNED. NO EXCEPTIONS.


Link to Season 5 Overall Discussion Hub


Episode Discussion Threads (Season Five)


DISCORD for YOU

Please feel free to join the Discord server dedicated to the television series YOU, to discuss theories and thoughts in depth for all seasons. Everyone is very nice and the show is growing, so please help us build a nice community. The permanent invite link is below for your consideration.

https://discord.gg/vcwp4Kb


r/YouOnLifetime • • 1d ago

Discussion Why does everyone seem to hate Beck 😭

36 Upvotes

I’m so confused by the fact people seem to dislike her? I loved her character soooo so so so sooo much and I don’t really get why people seem to hate her and say she’s evil and stuff whilst not saying the same things about a literal serial killer..


r/YouOnLifetime • • 19h ago

Discussion Season 4 and 5 is overhatted

9 Upvotes

I just finished season 5 and the way you some of you guys talked about these seasons I was expecting some stranger things season 5 bs but it really wasn't that bad it made sense especially the finale like HELLO!?! What did you want to happen? for him to skedaddle away to la la land. The ending made sense and was a decent conclusion. I understand there are some flaws in the show with how some of the characters were concluded and yes could some of it been written better sure but I am defiently not mad at the ending. I think the only true crime committed was the soundtrack the amount of Spotify top 100s that was played was insane because why did Billie eilish, Olivia rodrigo and Chappell roan appear in the sound track of this series it was not the vibe at all(I am a massive pop girlie but like cmon). I am being a bit harsh but I am open to seeing why people hate it so much.


r/YouOnLifetime • • 8h ago

Spoilers continuity error s2 e8

Post image
0 Upvotes

just noticed when rewatching but in the bar when forty initially doses joe he writes ā€œ8:51ā€ on joe’s arm, however in the rest of the episode it’s ā€œ8:52.ā€ when he’s trying to piece together where he was when he went to go get the moon juice (delilah’s death) he literally has a flashback to when forty first writes ā€œ8:51ā€ then looks down at his arm that clearly says ā€œ8:52ā€ and says ā€œdosed at 8:52pmā€

i know it’s stupid but i never noticed it before and i thought it was mildly interesting because of how blatant it is.


r/YouOnLifetime • • 1d ago

Discussion Bronte storyline plot hole

15 Upvotes

Not sure if this has ever been discussed on here but i feel there’s a major plot hole in season 5. Joe looked into every close friend of every woman he was obsessed with before Bronte. Yet he doesn’t do this with her.
He very likely could have saved himself from prison (at least a while longer) if he had looked into her friends. Mainly Clayton for obvious reasons.
My only counter argument as to why Joe wouldn’t have done this is that he was dealing with cleaning up all of the messes relating to Kate, but I don’t think that’s strong enough. He was constantly juggling so much and still got as far as he did. Also, part of his motivation for helping Kate eventually became in his own interest of pursuing Bronte.
What do yall think? Am I missing something?


r/YouOnLifetime • • 3d ago

Discussion Show got ruined after Season 1

33 Upvotes

EDIT: The 2nd half of Season 2 actually retroactively fixes the first half. Definitely not the worst drop in quality thorughout the show's run. The 1st half might actually be the worst stretch of episodes in the show's entire run, but it's just setup for the incredible 2nd half, when the tension picks back up and the complexity of the characters begins to truly shine through.

I still like it the whole way through, mind you, but the bar of quality drops massively. And I don't really think Season 2 is outright bad, but Season 1 was a genuinely tense and atmospheric experience, with grounded and well-paced conflicts that highlighted character traits and created tension, and when Neftlix got their paws on it they turned it into just another one of their corporately-designed, high-dopamine dramas. The episode where Joe sneaks into Henderson's place is actually written as if he is a YouTuber vlogging, as opposed to the tense inner monologues from Season 1. From the very first scene of the season, Joe's twisted and preverse point of view is set up and built upon to the point of boil in moments that are allowed their full gravity in the season's atmosphere, like the murders of Benji and Peach, while Season 2 just feels like it tries to shove as much shit in there as possible in a desperate attempt to appeal to the lowest common denominator, and none of it is given the same emotional emphasis.

I don't think any drop in quality throughout the show's run is worse than that

Season 3 is an improvement from what I remember (as of writing this, I'm on Season 2 of my rewatch), and Seasons 4 and 5 are a mess but at least they got the emphasis on psychological horror right. Season 2 just feels like a desparate attempt at making this show more "fun" so they can make it into a money-maker and thus justify having bought it


r/YouOnLifetime • • 4d ago

Meme This guy when anything happens: šŸ‘šŸ‘„šŸ‘

Post image
200 Upvotes

r/YouOnLifetime • • 4d ago

Discussion This image but Joe Goldberg šŸ¤” (fun art challenge lol)

Post image
25 Upvotes

I would love to draw this image with a Joe Goldberg twist but I haven't got the time to tonight. But I wanted to share to see everyone's thoughts šŸ¤”šŸ’­

Idk it reminds me a lot of him, maybe around season 4 or so, but I think any season can work lol :3c


r/YouOnLifetime • • 5d ago

Discussion I would love to have Love Quinn as a wife

Post image
496 Upvotes

I cannot understand why one would not


r/YouOnLifetime • • 4d ago

Casting Familiar face on newest ā€œGilded Ageā€ episode!

Post image
31 Upvotes

(*Sorry for the photo not screenshot/ didn’t have my laptop to grab a better screen grab)

For later helpfulness, s4e3 of Gilded Age for those curious, but I’m sure he’ll be in every episode the rest of this season with his character

Edit: Actor who plays Forty for anyone who doesn’t recognize


r/YouOnLifetime • • 5d ago

Discussion Do you believe Love could have committed any atrocity during her relationship with her first husband?

Post image
34 Upvotes

Do you think she may have done something similar to what happened to Forty's nanny, or do you just think she was merely controlling and that's why James asked her for a divorce?

Or did she actually commit a murder similar to what Joe did with Benji—seeing a girl talk to him and killing him under the excuse of protecting him when it was really just jealousy?


r/YouOnLifetime • • 5d ago

Shitpost Oh shi thanks google šŸ™šŸ™ Spoiler

Post image
14 Upvotes

r/YouOnLifetime • • 5d ago

Discussion Rewatching YOU and I'm curious: which scene or episode impacted you the most, and why?

6 Upvotes

I'm rewatching YOU and currently on season 4, and it's crazy how differently I see the characters and their behavior this time around! From season 1 to the finale, which scene or episode impacted you the most, and what's your psychological take on Joe and his relationships?


r/YouOnLifetime • • 5d ago

Discussion What does this mean?

Post image
96 Upvotes

r/YouOnLifetime • • 5d ago

Discussion Dante should’ve been BrontĆ«

14 Upvotes

In other words, Dante (the blind gay librarian in season 3) should’ve been the character who figured out who / what Joe was and secretly set out to get Joe put away for his crimes.

Basically, I’ve been thinking that what really annoys me about season 3, and Marienne being Joe’s worst You, and Love getting killed off - is that the wrong woman died in the season finale. And that because the writers realized that they made a mistake by getting rid of 1 of probably the best female characters in TV series history - they created Kate, who is essentially Love Quinn But Snappy and British.

IMHO, Marienne should’ve been killed by Joe at the end of season 3, and this is how I think it could’ve worked and kept Love alive for at least 1 more season, but possibly indefinitely!

- Love, finding out that Joe is in love with Marienne, paralyzes Joe for a week and forces him to sit and sleep in his own filth as punishment, with the intention of giving him the antidote after he’s sufficiently learned his lesson. Meanwhile, Cary and Sherry escape from the box, but by the time they get to the police nobody believes them because Love has cleaned the entire place and it looks like a simple storage space for the bakery. Theo wakes up in the hospital with no memory of Love or his dad, and Scott Speedman is devastated, breaking down into tears because he’s wracked with guilt that the last thing he told Theo was to get out of his house before Love hit Theo so hard it caused a factory reset. Solemnly he takes Theo home to pack some bags and go on a year long father-son trip hoping to rebuild his relationship with Theo. Love sees them coming out of the car from the hospital, Theo looks at her blankly, and she realizes that she has nothing to fear - to her shock and good fortune. (This way those characters can fuck off for good LOL). Back to Cary and Sherry, they see Love in the streets of Madre Linda and are terrified of her. People in town think that Sherry made the whole thing up for Instagram traffic, and she’s lost some respect and clout almost overnight. Joe, stuck in the sofa at home, thinks incessantly about Marienne. Marienne realizes by day 2 that Joe never showed up to run away with her, and she believes that Joe ghosted her: she lashes out by calling the house leaving a long angry fuck-you-Joe-your-sex-was-trash-and-Love-you-should-know-your-man-cheated-on-you-plus-he-told-me-he-killed-someone-before message. Joe hears the message as it’s being recorded while he’s paralyzed on the couch, and goes Hulk internally: ā€œyou were never my you all along.ā€ When Love lets Joe out of time out, he starts secretly planning to murk Marienne. He then murks Marianne. He ends the season feeling a new appreciation for Love; she gets pregnant with a girl, and Joe’s first non-romantic You is his daughter - he’s immediately obsessed with her, almost neglecting Henry.

This is where I think Dante could’ve been clutch in season 4:
- Dante doesn’t understand how come ever since Joe came to town, Marienne’s ex died, then Marienne died, not to mention that around town and on their social media platforms Cary and Sherry swear that Joe and Love killed Natalie and locked them in their bakery basement, and that their injuries yes DID happen because of Cary’s gun, but they were accidental in the course of trying to escape the box.
- Dante being blind would be the last person Joe would suspect of secretly watching him. Dante would keep volunteering to babysit Henry and act buddy buddy, Joe being none the wiser because he’s pampering his new baby girl.
- by the end of season 4, Dante knows and has proof of Joe and Love’s crimes, but they murk him. Love also gets angry when this time a woman becomes obsessed with Joe and tries to pull his focus away from his baby while Joe himself isn’t interested in an affair. Love kills the woman and some other people related to the woman. At this point Joe could be like ā€œk, I don’t want this kind of influence raising my daughterā€ and NOW he really wants to divorce Love. But we’d get at least 2 more seasons of Love this way and she’d get her due justice of being the ā€œfinal bossā€, plus we’d get to fully explore the fascinating dynamic that the writers introduced of a killing couple being a metaphor for husbands being negligent of dedicated wives + people trying to make marriage work.

I love reading what ifs about this show, please share yours too if you want! :)


r/YouOnLifetime • • 6d ago

Discussion This look??!

Post image
63 Upvotes

I know this is right before he killed Beck but FAWK he looks so good here dudeeeee😭😭


r/YouOnLifetime • • 5d ago

Discussion Love's friend's reaction

6 Upvotes

how do you think Love's friends in season 2 reacted to the news at the end of s3 (thinking Love killed him) and then at the end when the truth comes out


r/YouOnLifetime • • 7d ago

Discussion Season 4 taught the important lesson of why you should mind your own damn business šŸ’…

Post image
365 Upvotes

r/YouOnLifetime • • 5d ago

Discussion Alternative Season 1 Ending: What if Karen Minty, Paco, and Officer Nico teamed up to expose Joe?"

0 Upvotes

Karen is watching the evening news. Guinevere Beck’s photo appears on screen with the headline: "Young writer murdered by her therapist". Joe Goldberg’s face briefly shows up as the heartbroken boyfriend who helped publish her posthumous book.

Karen turns off the TV, frowning. Something doesn't add up. Joe dumped her out of nowhere to get back with Beck, and suddenly Beck ends up dead. Karen starts connecting the dots: Candace’s disappearance, Benji’s sudden death, Peach Salinger’s supposed suicide, and now Beck. Everyone died or vanished right when Joe was around.

Suddenly, Karen’s eyes widen as she remembers a key detail: the night she took care of Paco’s mom, Claudia, during her detox. She remembers the massive glass cage in the basement of Joe’s bookstore. A cage way too big and reinforced just to store old books.

Return to Mooney’s Bookstore

Interior. Mooney’s Bookstore – Day.

The bookstore is closed for mourning after Beck’s death. Karen sneaks in through the back door using an old spare key Paco once gave her for emergencies. She heads straight to the basement.

Turning on her phone’s flashlight, she inspects the glass cage. Even though Joe cleaned everything up, Karen searches the corners carefully. She finds a tiny piece of Beck’s broken bracelet wedged beneath the metal base of the cage and fresh scratch marks on the inside of the glass door.

Determined to dig deeper, Karen tracks down Ethan, Joe’s former coworker, at his new job. Although she tries to subtly get information out of him, Ethan fiercely defends Joe. Completely unaware of Joe's crimes, Ethan insists Joe is a loyal, good guy who would never hurt anyone. Karen realizes she won't get anything from him.

Paco’s confession

Exterior. Street outside Joe’s apartment building – Afternoon.

As Karen walks away from the building, Paco spots her from the sidewalk and runs up to her looking nervous.

PACO: Karen? Do you know where Joe is? He disappeared right after Beck died.

Karen kneels down to his level and speaks softly, making sure not to pressure him.

KAREN: I don't know where he is, Paco. But I'm really worried about what happened to Beck and your mom. Have you talked to him lately?

Paco looks down, gripping the straps of his backpack. The guilt of locking the basement door on Beck that night has been eating him alive.

PACO: He went far away. He told me sometimes bad guys have to leave to protect the people they love. But... I know Beck wasn't crazy, Karen. Dr. Nicky didn't do anything to her.

Karen places a gentle hand on his shoulder to reassure him...

KAREN: Paco, if you know something, you have to tell me. Nobody is going to blame you, I promise, but an innocent man is taking the fall for something he didn't do.

Paco hesitates for a second, then trusts her. With a trembling voice, he confesses the truth: he saw Beck locked inside the exact same cage where his mom stayed, screaming for help, and Joe was down there with her before everything ended.

The alliance in Connecticut

Interior. Greenwich Police Station, Connecticut – Night.

Karen knows the NYPD has already closed Beck’s case and won't believe her without solid backing. Instead, she looks up the public records for Peach Salinger’s death and finds the name of the investigating officer in Greenwich: Officer Nico

Karen takes the train that very night and arrives at the station with a folder full of timelines, the broken bracelet piece, and Paco’s recorded statement. She places it all on Officer Nico’s desk.

The officer looks up tiredly, but the moment he reads the name "Joe Goldberg" and sees his photo, he freezes. He immediately recognizes the suspicious, bloodied man he pulled over near the Salinger estate the night Peach died.

OFFICER NICO: (Closing his office door) I knew that bastard wasn't a tourist. Tell me everything from the beginning.

The net closes in

Parallel Montage – New York, Connecticut, and Los Angeles.

With Paco’s testimony, physical evidence from the cage, and the reopened Peach Salinger file (where Joe left biological evidence at the scene), Officer Nico escalates the investigation to federal authorities.

While Joe tries to start a new life under a fake identity in Los Angeles, news outlets across the country broadcast his face as the prime suspect in multiple murders. Dr. Nicky is released from prison, Beck’s real manuscript is published without Joe’s edits, and law enforcement tracks Joe’s every move until he has nowhere left to run.


r/YouOnLifetime • • 7d ago

Video Unfortunately it’s taken 5 seasons for some people to get it, Penn lmao

148 Upvotes

I love this man so bad😭 ā€œwhat, he shaved?ā€

But in my personal opinion, I think what made the ending of S4 scary is the fact that he went on a full murder spree and got away with it. Like wdym you got married to a rich woman and she covered up your past? GtfošŸ˜­šŸ˜‚šŸ˜‚


r/YouOnLifetime • • 6d ago

Discussion Why didn’t Joe like the fact that Love was a killer in season 2

27 Upvotes

Please don’t spoil season 3 for me but why didn’t Joe eventually come around to the idea and love the fact that Love was just like him.

I thought he would find her reasons reasonable and similar like he did and realized he loved her because of everything. She’s willing to keep his secret, she loves him and she is pregnant. He loved her before he found out etc

What is his sick minds way of processing the reason he doesn’t like her?

Edit: Thank you all for replying and I think I understand it now but my post first sentence was literally to not spoil the show beyond what I had watched and I have seen like 4 comments mentioning some Kate and what happened.

It makes me really sad because now I can’t continue the show because I absolutely hate spoilers and it ruins everything for me. Is it so hard to not spoil a show?


r/YouOnLifetime • • 6d ago

Article You y Gossip Girl.

Post image
15 Upvotes

Joe es un hombre encantador y atento por fuera, pero obsesivo, manipulador y peligroso por dentro. Se obsesiona con las mujeres que le gustan y las acosa hasta controlar toda su vida.( you )

Mismo actor Penn Badgley Dan Humphrey en Gossip Girl (Chica Indiscreta) es el chico bueno y discreto de Brooklyn, escritor y enamorado de Serena. Al final se revela que Ʃl era Gossip Girl.


r/YouOnLifetime • • 6d ago

Discussion Joes letter to Dante w/Henry

5 Upvotes

Just finished re-watching season three and it kind of feels like a plot hole almost? What do you guys think it said in the letter? How does he explain the premeditation of leaving his child and the letter there before he was supposedly killed? For a second I assumed maybe he wrote it as if it was coming from love like he did her suicide note, but he says ā€œ no one says no to the guy who gets turned into a pieā€ so the only way it works, must be something along the lines of…

ā€œmy house is not safe and I feel trapped. I have reason to believe that my wife is plotting to kill me. I want you to have Henry. Please keep him safe and raise him as your own should something happen to me tonightā€

That’s the only way to me that it makes any sense, but I feel like the fact of the premeditation of it and of dropping him off would look kind of sus? Especially considering his last romantic partner ended up murdered as well.

Thoughts?