r/ableton • u/petpetpetpetpet • 2h ago
[Tutorial] Trying to record external audio without latency in the waveform clip (overbridge + another external device)
Hello, I'll just lay out what is set up - it might make what I'm asking clearer.
- I'm using Ableton 11, so if keep latency is the solution, I don't have that.
- I am using Overbridge with a Digitone II. When i record from this, i get a small 3ms latency. This is fine, and is not what I'm worried about.
- I also have a hardware synth plugged into my audio interface. It is sequenced by the Digitone.
- External synth is on an audio track.
- When I record a click track both on the digitone, AND from the external synth track, the external synth transients come in 59ms late.
Now, I'm assuming what's happening is that Overbridge is actually introducing 56ms of latency, it knows this, tells ableton that, and ableton sorts that all out. But, since the digitone is sending the midi to the synth, that trigger is delayed by 56ms (giving us the 59ms total), resulting in the audio arriving back into ableton late.
Anyways.
To rectify the problem I put a -56ms track delay on the Audio track, and it all sounds perfect.
BUT
If I record that audio, the waveform in the clip still has the 59ms delay - as in you can see the transients appearing 59ms past each beat marker. This makes sense since track delay is probably just affecting when the track hits master rather than actuall altering the input.
- I tried creating a 2nd audio track with 0, and later +56ms track delay and recording from the first, but that - unsurprisingly did not work.
It would be convenient if I could get rid of that somehow so that I don't need to manually shift it around if i want to chop up the recorded audio.
Is there a way to do that?
SOLUTION OH WAIT: I have just figured it out, but i'll post this here just so anyone else can see.
The second audio track needs to be POST MIXER (I had it just POST FX when I made this post).
Thus:
- Digitone on Overbridge track playing a click track (a hi hat)
- Synth on audio track 1 - audio track one has -56ms track delay (which I calculated by recording the waveform, and then zooming the fuck in and highligthing the space between a beat and the transient start.)
- audio track 2, monitoring off, records from audio track 1 POST MIXER. 0 track delay.
When I record all 3, audio track 2 records the output of track 1 on beat (or well with the same 3ms delay as the overbridge track which is fine.) and I can then treat that recording as an on-time audio clip.