From a long time ago, especially ever since the Enlightenment, humans have pride themselves on the supposedly unique ablility to reason. This is what's supposed to separate the humans from the unthinking animals, the creative minds from the mere machines.
This anthropocentric conception of humanity has been stable for basically forever, because it does feel like humanity uniquely possesses many things: complex language, ability to reason about abstract math, a very general intelligence, etc. In short, this kind of anthropocentrism has been backed by humanity being at the top of the intelligence pyramid.
And that in turn creates a tendency to view things relative to humanity. For example, math has been sometimes framed to be *about human understanding*. Not just finding truth about abstract mathematical objects, or constructing proofs. It has to be about human understanding.
But the logic behind math itself is never human-oriented, and one major contribution of mathematical logic has been to provide a foundation on which math can be securely done, regardless of whether anyone understands it or not. And that line of development eventually led to proof assistants like Lean, among others.
So it interests me when I see a sentiment from various mathematical communities lately that a big Lean proof that compiles, despite establishing the mathematical correctness of the theorem, is *not a proof at all*, because it doesn't by itself facilitate human understanding. I've even seen someone saying that such a proof is *actively harmful*, for reason I never understood.
I think what this shows is that we are undergoing a large-scale transition from anthropocentrism/humanism to, if I may use the term, "posthumanism". (Not transhumanism, just to clarify.)
The psychological impact is very apparent, although I'm not sure why this happens. My guess is that many perceive the emergence of an superhuman-intelligent entity as an "ontological threat": it threatens what a human or a machine *is*, by threatening the very thing anthropocentrism takes much pride on: unique intelligence.
I think the Claude-Alpoge proof represents a new form of information now (or at least soon): knowledge that is out of reach for humanity because they lack the necessary level of intelligence. This is *unprecedented*: when humanity was at the top, the greatest and most complicated discoveries are undoubtedly discovered *by humans*. Now, this new "incomprehensible" knowledge becomes a hard proof that humanity is not at the top anymore.
I think it's pretty ridiculous to demand the universe to be fully comprehensible by our little brains, or to demand, for example, a proof of RH (which, according to an account by Tao, should genuinely involve a lot of new techniques and connections, which I believe we do see in the Claude-Alpoge proof) to be short. It's probably time to recognize that humans might not be *that* smart, and that's not gonna change no matter how someone feels about it.