r/acotar • • 26d ago

Spoilers for AcoSH !! ACOTAR 6 - A Court of Splintered Harmony // ACOSH Megathread !! SPOILER WARNING Spoiler

427 Upvotes

We know the wait has been long but the time has come!

Please use this megathread to discuss while reading ACOSH. Let's hear your thoughts, theories, rants and all! EXPECT SPOILERS FOR THE WHOLE BOOK.

Rules still apply as normal and ACOSH discussion MUST stay in this thread. Any new posts regarding ACOSH will be put on hold for a minimum 24 hours before we start approving to avoid repeated, low effort submissions. Any comments outside this post referencing ACOSH must contain a spoiler warning and format.

We're as excited as you are to get back into Prythian, so pick up those books and READ! ✨❤️


r/acotar • • 3h ago

Shipping Sunday IT'S SHIPPING SUNDAY!

0 Upvotes

Today is the day we allow shipping of all kind. Feel free to post.

Some reminders:

On this day, you may post and discuss all ships as long as it remains respectful. Fanart and fanfic is always allowed. We will not tolerate ship bashing, ship shaming or any other type of harassment.

Please make sure you're not spamming the same topics. If someone has already posted, please use the current active thread.

In addition, the following topics are still prohibited:

  • No womb arguments.
  • No conversations of Gwyn being underaged.
  • No conversations about how rape victims can't have relationships.
  • No conversations about Elain being unable to be with someone because she can't have children.

Report those violating these rules.


r/acotar • • 3h ago

Spoilers for AcoSH GUYS, I think Koschei's master plan is to... Spoiler

2 Upvotes

CHANGE THE ORDER OF THE COURTS IN PRYTHIAN!

The Summer Court will turn into Winter! The Day Court will turn into Night!

-- -- --

As a starting point for this theory, there is a repeated theme in ACOSH of balance.

However, the text repeatedly hints that this balance is about to end. During Nyx’s Naming Day celebration, items representing each element (and thus, the seasons) are weighed on silver scales -- it’s said that this is a gift of balance from the Mother for the year ahead.

“The ceremony was boring. Beautiful, but boring, despite the mandatory Equinox weighing with the silver scales atop the altar, each element endlessly explained and honored by the High Priestess before she placed it into one of the dishes. A gift of balance from the Mother for the year ahead.”

But we know how this offering ended -- in disaster.

Debris rained down on those very scales. And Elain’s flowers, representing all 7 Prythian courts, were turned to ruin. It just feels like intentional and purposeful foreshadowing to me. 

“Bryaxis laughed again, the sound sending the remaining flowers shriveling into rot and dust.“

Knowing that Koschei is the likely cause of any impending chaos, one particular quote from Feyre REALLY stood out to me: “Even Koschei cannot change the seasons.”

But Feyre is wrong. It is possible to change the seasons.

We are told as much in ACOSF: with the Harp.

We know that Koschei has been hunting for the Trove for some time. So, what if this is Koschei’s end goal? That Feyre’s quote is foreshadowing:

Koschei will obtain the Harp, and will use it to change the seasons and order of Prythian.

With the Harp, Koschei could: 

  • Turn Summer to Winter. Tarquin’s oceans would freeze, and Kallias’s frozen terrain would melt.
  • He could turn Spring to Autumn, wilting all bloom.
  • And as the Harp also manipulates time, he could reorder the solar courts: Day becomes Night. Night becomes Dawn. Dawn becomes Day.

We also know that for Prythian Fae, their magic is tied to the land. Completely reordering the seasons and order of the courts is likely to render their magic severely weakened. In that respect, Koschei doesn’t need war, invasion, or armies -- he can bring Prythian to its knees by the music of the Harp.

And isn’t it fitting that, given the music theme of these books, the villain’s story will involve music, too?

A symphony of total destruction. 

Moreover, this aligns with existing fan theories that The Valkyrie Cycle, in part, is inspired by Wagner’s operas – ‘The Ring Cycle.’

Part 4 of Wagner’s opera is known as ‘Twilight of the Gods.’ This is another term for Ragnarok in Norse myth; the end times. In the Ragnarok mythos, there is a series of apocalyptic events:

  • We see the land freezing over – like the Summer Court turning into Winter?
  • We also see floods – like Winter Court turning to Summer, and melting all the ice?
  • Then darkness, as the sun is devoured – like Day Court turning to Night?

Knowing SJM’s old Pinterest boards -- with one dedicated to Twilight of the Gods (FULL of Valkyrie imagery !!), I really don't think it's that implausible!

And, if this theory is correct... doesn't it make this ACOFM teaser quote a little more ominous?

"You're going to help me remake the world."


r/acotar • • 21h ago

Mirthroot Post/Drunk on Faerie Wine Decisions were made for Mama Maas this day.

Post image
32 Upvotes

What would you put back to get Acosh?

Disclaimer: Those are not items I left there. 😂


r/acotar • • 3h ago

Maasverse Spoilers Cc hoeab x Acotar “the box” Spoiler

1 Upvotes

Chapter 10 of HOEAB Bryce mentions a “jade puzzle box that had belonged to a princess in a forgotten northern land” … do we think this could possibly be koscheis box? Jessiba has it hidden in plain sight?


r/acotar • • 12h ago

Maasverse Spoilers [CC, ACOSH, Maasverse spoilers] I think Nesta is Sarah’s daydream. Spoiler

2 Upvotes

Spoliers for Crescent City, ACOSH, and the entire Maasverse in general, and this is crazy long so there’s a TLDR at the end:

It's pretty obvious to me that SJM is working toward her own version of Avengers: Endgame. I know not everyone likes it. I think it's incredibly fun, and I'm excited to see where it goes. I understand that not everyone feels that way, which is perfectly fine. But since I’m operating off the idea that Maasverse continues to expand and will do that through ACOTAR, I originally felt a little confused by the way the sisters are being portrayed. Why did Sarah give Nesta this huge Maasverse plot, and Feyre the domestic conflict plot?

Nesta is the one who appears in 20% of an entirely different book. She's the one who had the eight-pointed star tattoo. She's the one Bryce connects with, the one who helps Bryce save her home world. She's the wielder of an intergalactic weapon whose missing piece is literally another Fae/human living in another world. She's deeply connected to the Prison storyline. There's something on the sea floor calling to her. She's already entangled in mysteries that extend far beyond Prythian, and every answer seems to lead to another question. Her storyline has so many possible directions.

And meanwhile, what is Feyre doing?

Obviously, she’s bound to any plot involving the NC. She's attending political meetings, navigating the politics of Prythian, and potentially helping orchestrate a war on another continent. Depending on where the High King/High Queen storyline goes, she may even be on her way to becoming High Queen herself. But she has virtually no connection to the Maasverse plot as it currently exists. Yes, of course some of this is understandable considering her role in the NC, but she doesn’t even have a Made weapon, and Sarah gave Eris one before she gave one to Feyre. She cannot wield the Trove. She barely interacted with Bryce. She hasn't explored the Prison. She isn't the character Sarah has chosen to place at the center of these increasingly interconnected mysteries.

Yes, could Feyre being HQ put her in a position for a larger role in the Maasverse? Absolutely, but after how long? We're clearly going to be spending a lot of time on this domestic conflict. Probably the entire length of ACOFM. Meanwhile, Nesta is going to be off doing god knows what, probably finding more plot stings to pull on, finding more answers to these questions we're all asking. It is really shocking to me that Feyre is just... not involved more.

Why?

I think it’s because while Sarah sees herself in both sisters in very different ways. I think Feyre represents the life Sarah has built for herself. She’s a devoted and loving mother, wife, and friend who plays an important role in her family's decisions and happiness. A protector and defender of the people she loves. A woman with responsibilities, relationships, and a home she's fought to build. Someone who goes to bed beside her husband every night after kissing her child goodnight.

And I think Nesta represents the life Sarah gets to imagine. Her daydream. A powerful, ass-kicking, fiercely independent character whose story isn't confined to one world, one conflict, or even one series. Nesta who has led the resurgence of an all-female fighting force. Nesta who has killed so many foes. Lanthys. Briarlyn, who was wielding the crown. A whole ass Asteri (if we believe Vesperus was an Asteri, considering.) Nesta, not not the most powerful High Lord, or the High Lady who healed the Cauldron, is the one who is able to fight Bryaxis, and is apparently on her way to learning how to mist people like Rhys. Altered time and space to save her sister and nephew. Made a pivotal, unpopular decision for the greater good. Nesta who has Made weapons. Who could Make a god (my opinion. I’d love to see her turn herself and her sisters into the Trove. Crown for the HQ, the Harp for the one who can see through time and space, and the Mask for the one who’s called Lady Death, but I digress.) And despite everything she's already accomplished, it feels like Sarah is only just getting started with her.

I'm not suggesting that Feyre's role as a mother and wife makes her less important, or that there's anything inherently wrong with giving her a more domestic, politically focused storyline. Nor am I suggesting that Sarah doesn't love Feyre as much as Nesta. But despite Feyre being the original protagonist of ACOTAR, Nesta increasingly feels like the character Sarah is positioning at the center of something much bigger.

Obviously, this could all be total nonsense. I’m theorizing about a total stranger’s life so what do I know?

TLDR: Feyre is the life Sarah has built for herself, while Nesta is the life she daydreams about.


r/acotar • • 1d ago

Spoilers for AcoSH ACOSH IS GOOD Spoiler

87 Upvotes

I think this is a hot take based on what I’m seeing. So I started reading ACOSH and I was like wow this is a bag of shit. I hated it. And don’t get me wrong: I don’t need to hear about Feyre breast feeding this much. LIKE SJM NO ONE CARE STOP. But then I paused my reading (halfway through) and said f it - I’m gonna re read crescent city. Then I came back to to ACOSH. And wow that helped. SJM is transitioning ACOTAR to be more complex like crescent city is and I LOVE IT

What didn’t make sense isn’t the new stuff - it’s the fact that in the old books no one ever got hurt by loved ones or had opinions. They were all so stuck in trauma that they kept the peace no matter what. WELL NOT ANYMORE. They’ve had some time to think and boy are they reeling. And GOOD they should be!

This is characters growing and changing. It’s messy and insane and doesn’t make sense but that’s exactly what it is like as humans. Elaine has never used a brain cell and now she is and good for her. Azriel is repeating old habits by saying this beautiful sunny woman can fix me and boy is it going to be painful for him

Props to you SJM I get it now!!!!!!!!!!


r/acotar • • 1d ago

Maasverse Spoilers [ToG, ACOSH, Maasverse spoilers] Bryaxis is ____, isn’t she? Spoiler

92 Upvotes

ACOSH and ToG spoilers, marked below

I’m right at the end of Kingdom of Ash, and the scene with Maeve and how she made them all see/live their deepest fears felt really 1:1 to the scene with Bryaxis in ACOSH. In KoA, as this scene is happening, Aelin mentions how it’s Maeve’s inherent Valg power coming out (to be able to make people realistically see their fears/get stuck in them as if they’re real) and then also mentions back to how other Valg have this power of fear as well.

Considering it’s exactly what Bryaxis did in ACOSH (right down to the only person with flame powers/heart of fire being the only one able to break free from it) I feel it’s safe to assume at this point that Bryaxis is a Valg in its true form? Especially as when (KoA spoilers) Aelin is killing Maeve, she mentions how she starts turning into a sort of monstrous shadow.


r/acotar • • 1d ago

ACOTAR Meme Suriel taking much spa time

Post image
47 Upvotes

Moving this Halloween candle to make room for Christmas, but once I put it there I thought of the Suriel having a much needed spa day and thought y'all might enjoy that too


r/acotar • • 1d ago

Miscellaneous - No spoilers Dresses I’d give the ACOTAR girls Spoiler

Thumbnail
gallery
179 Upvotes

last part LOL I could look through these all day


r/acotar • • 1d ago

Spoilers for AcoSH [ACOSH Spoiler] I don’t feel like I’ve heard anyone talk about this… Spoiler

148 Upvotes

Okay, so I’ve officially fallen down the Nesta/Eris rabbit hole, and there’s one thing I haven’t really seen anyone talking about.

In ACOSH, Cassian makes fun of Nesta’s romance novels and tells her they give her unrealistic expectations.
What I find really interesting is that when SJM was on Call Her Daddy, she spent a good portion of the interview talking about how much it bothers her when people dismiss her books as smut or look down on romance novels in general. It was pretty clear this is a huge pet peeve of hers. So I just find it VERY interesting that she would write Nesta’s supposed mate/endgame as someone who makes fun of something Nesta loves, especially when it’s something SJM herself feels so strongly about.

I’m not saying this proves anything (even though I wish it would 😬), but it does make me wonder if that was intentional. Of all the things Cassian could criticize Nesta for, why would SJM choose something she’s personally so passionate about defending?


r/acotar • • 1d ago

Artwork - Spoiler free Our birthday man: “The most handsome High Lord” ✨

Post image
26 Upvotes

Day 1 in the Rhys Week (art by me)


r/acotar • • 2d ago

Artwork - Spoiler free My ACOTAR Inspired jewelry box

Thumbnail
gallery
2.7k Upvotes

I painted it inspired by how Feyre painted her dresser from the first book. Mine is in book lore order; Heaven (Feyre), earth (Elain) and hell ( Nesta) ♥️


r/acotar • • 2d ago

Spoilers for AcoSH Does Cassian have bad hygiene? [ACOSH Spoilers] Spoiler

108 Upvotes

I feel like it’s always been said or implied (possibly in jest) that Cassian doesn’t bathe—at least not frequently. That one line from Splintered Harmony from Nesta “We’re not getting dressed up. You just happened to wash up & change out of your leathers for once.” That line kind of did it for me. Yuck! Is a smelly man supposed to be…attractive? I thought these romantasy novels were supposed to be about hot guys—not about men who hold petty grudges against their mates and smell like onions & butt cheese? 🤢


r/acotar • • 1d ago

Miscellaneous - No spoilers My terrible mental image of Cassian

24 Upvotes

Hope everyone appreciates that when i picture Cassian in my head he is fully a just dracula but if dracula was wearing a sleeveless vest with disproportionately strong arms. Yes i know bat boy does not equal vampire, no my brain does not care.

Also lucien is and will always be fantastic mr fox.


r/acotar • • 2d ago

Fandom Friday Weelllccommme to Fandom Friday!

5 Upvotes

Today is the day to post all your raves and faves. Enjoy yourselves! Time to go wild with hyping up your favs and spreading positivity.

Remember, if a character is not for you and you have no positive notes to add, please continue to scroll! Feel free to make your own appreciation post.

Any critical posts should be saved for Tuesdays or taken to r/acotar_rant

Please report anyone not honoring these requests! Thank you! Happy fan day!


r/acotar • • 2d ago

Miscellaneous - Spoilers Sarah lies? Spoiler

33 Upvotes

Not sure if this is allowed but I've searched for it far and wide but I swear it's as hidden to me as Koschei's soul!

I've seen it mentioned multiple times that Sarah has said that Tamlin and Feyre were soul mates and she was obviously lying but I can't find any sort of video or article or even blog posts about it.

Was hoping if anyone here can point me in the right direction, thank you!!


r/acotar • • 2d ago

Miscellaneous - No spoilers Graphic Audio books, I don’t know if I can cope 😂

64 Upvotes

I just got to the first sex scene and I don’t know if I can do this. So much grunting and growling hahaha, I think I prefer my smut without sounds effects 🙈

What version do you guys prefer?


r/acotar • • 3d ago

Spoilers for AcoSH [ACOSH Spoilers] Small detail I noticed in chapter 20 Spoiler

148 Upvotes

I don't know if this has been discussed already but at some point in chapter 20 there's this line:

"Az didn’t look at either brother. Only at Lucien, burning with white-hot power."

Later Lucien tells Azriel:

“I hope you get everything that’s coming to you. Every moment of suffering you deserve.”

We know Lucien is a spell-cleaver which means he can split or bind spells. With Lucien visibly burning with white-hot power right before saying that, do you guys think he unknowingly put a spell on Azriel or cursed him? Or was he just really pissed off? If he did curse him, how do you think it's gonna play out in the next book? I feel like it would be super interesting if he actually did, especially since we’ve only ever seen spell-breaking in the series so far (unless I'm forgetting something!). It also seems to tie well with the sleeping beauty theme this book had.


r/acotar • • 2d ago

Spoilers for AcoSH Book 8 Theory [ACOSH SPOILERS] Spoiler

34 Upvotes

I am convinced that SJM has not written the “third” book yet because she is waiting to see the fan theories/reactions before finishing the story.

Her including the symphonia recording of Cassian saying “I love you” felt like fan service to me. No way she hasn’t seen the countless posts complaining about him never saying that to her.


r/acotar • • 3d ago

Spoilers for AcoSH The rabbit (ACOSH spoilers) Spoiler

58 Upvotes

Not sure if it was already discussed but I just finished ACOSH and noticed something interesting.

So Koshchei is a known villain in slavic folklore. In tales told to children, Koshchei is usually kidnapping a beautiful woman (👀), then the hero tries to save her.

Since Koshchei is immortal it is not easy, so the hero needs to find a way to get rid of him.

Then the hero obtains the information (usually through another mythical creature) where Koshcheis death is hidden: in a needle, the needle is in an egg, the egg is in a duck, the duck is in a rabbit, the rabbit is in a chest. Sometimes the rabbit is in a wolf and the wolf is in a chest from what I remember but that's besides the point.

Anyway Papa Archeron carves a figure of a rabbit on his travels before the battle, not sure if it was before or after he got Vassa out of the lake. So I wonder if he somehow knew something but couldn't talk about it so he carved a clue. Or maybe it is simply a "coincidence" and foreshadowing.

Anyway just something I noticed and found interesting. Let me know if you have any theories!


r/acotar • • 3d ago

Spoilers for AcoSH After ACOSH - Entire Fandom to Elain Spoiler

24 Upvotes

r/acotar • • 3d ago

Spoiler Theory Elain and Mor Spoiler

15 Upvotes

Hellllooooo- please direct me to the Elaine and Mor love theories!!!!!


r/acotar • • 3d ago

Miscellaneous - No spoilers Any GTA fans in this ACOTAR sub?

Post image
88 Upvotes

So I just saw this in GTA and had to post it somewhere!😂 so Eris has his own brand in the human world??😂 (that’s a spoon in Jason’s hand fyi)