r/acotar • u/emmyeggo • 3h ago
Spoilers for AcoSH GUYS, I think Koschei's master plan is to... Spoiler
CHANGE THE ORDER OF THE COURTS IN PRYTHIAN!
The Summer Court will turn into Winter! The Day Court will turn into Night!
-- -- --
As a starting point for this theory, there is a repeated theme in ACOSH of balance.
However, the text repeatedly hints that this balance is about to end. During Nyx’s Naming Day celebration, items representing each element (and thus, the seasons) are weighed on silver scales -- it’s said that this is a gift of balance from the Mother for the year ahead.
“The ceremony was boring. Beautiful, but boring, despite the mandatory Equinox weighing with the silver scales atop the altar, each element endlessly explained and honored by the High Priestess before she placed it into one of the dishes. A gift of balance from the Mother for the year ahead.”
But we know how this offering ended -- in disaster.
Debris rained down on those very scales. And Elain’s flowers, representing all 7 Prythian courts, were turned to ruin. It just feels like intentional and purposeful foreshadowing to me.
“Bryaxis laughed again, the sound sending the remaining flowers shriveling into rot and dust.“
Knowing that Koschei is the likely cause of any impending chaos, one particular quote from Feyre REALLY stood out to me: “Even Koschei cannot change the seasons.”

But Feyre is wrong. It is possible to change the seasons.
We are told as much in ACOSF: with the Harp.

We know that Koschei has been hunting for the Trove for some time. So, what if this is Koschei’s end goal? That Feyre’s quote is foreshadowing:
Koschei will obtain the Harp, and will use it to change the seasons and order of Prythian.
With the Harp, Koschei could:
- Turn Summer to Winter. Tarquin’s oceans would freeze, and Kallias’s frozen terrain would melt.
- He could turn Spring to Autumn, wilting all bloom.
- And as the Harp also manipulates time, he could reorder the solar courts: Day becomes Night. Night becomes Dawn. Dawn becomes Day.

We also know that for Prythian Fae, their magic is tied to the land. Completely reordering the seasons and order of the courts is likely to render their magic severely weakened. In that respect, Koschei doesn’t need war, invasion, or armies -- he can bring Prythian to its knees by the music of the Harp.
And isn’t it fitting that, given the music theme of these books, the villain’s story will involve music, too?
A symphony of total destruction.

Moreover, this aligns with existing fan theories that The Valkyrie Cycle, in part, is inspired by Wagner’s operas – ‘The Ring Cycle.’
Part 4 of Wagner’s opera is known as ‘Twilight of the Gods.’ This is another term for Ragnarok in Norse myth; the end times. In the Ragnarok mythos, there is a series of apocalyptic events:
- We see the land freezing over – like the Summer Court turning into Winter?
- We also see floods – like Winter Court turning to Summer, and melting all the ice?
- Then darkness, as the sun is devoured – like Day Court turning to Night?
Knowing SJM’s old Pinterest boards -- with one dedicated to Twilight of the Gods (FULL of Valkyrie imagery !!), I really don't think it's that implausible!

And, if this theory is correct... doesn't it make this ACOFM teaser quote a little more ominous?
"You're going to help me remake the world."
