r/aiwars • • 6h ago

Meme Antis are running out of room to move the goalposts.

Post image
0 Upvotes

277 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 6h ago

This is an automated reminder from the Mod team. If your post contains images which reveal the personal information of private figures, be sure to censor that information and repost. Private info includes names, recognizable profile pictures, social media usernames and URLs. Failure to do this will result in your post being removed by the Mod team and possible further action.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

43

u/Piopaz1 5h ago

I just asked what the Riemann hypothesis was and got down vote bombed..? Can someone answer me please?

24

u/FrijDom1 5h ago

The Riemann Hypothesis is that all non-trivial zeros of the Riemann-Zeta function (which as your other replier mentioned, is directly related to the spacing of prime numbers) are complex numbers with real part ½, so xi+½. The trivial zeros are all the negative even integers, and while we've found trillions of non-trivial zeros on the critical line and none off of it, until now we've had no way to truly prove it.

6

u/bremidon 3h ago

Not sure if it helps, but previous work had been able to start tightening up how far off the line any exceptions could possibly be. Just that was enough to earn the people doing it fame and fortune within the mathematics community.

7

u/Adorable_Bat_7401 5h ago

Basically the chain of thought goes something like this:

How can we understand integers better? => We can understand integers by analysing primes => How can we understand primes better? => We might be able to understand more about primes if we could figure out their distribution => Riemann Hypothesis.

If the Riemann Hypothesis were true, it would mean we have more or less figured out the distribution of prime numbers.

18

u/Xdivine 5h ago • Heartwarming

I don't know exactly since I'm not a fancy math person, but from what I understand, it's a way of determining which numbers are prime. I'm sure that is grossly oversimplifying things, but that's the gist of it from what I understand. For a less shit answer, I'd ask chatGPT or Claude or if you hate those then just poke around google, I'm sure there are plenty of breakdowns for it.

5

u/Piopaz1 5h ago

THANK YOU

7

u/allyskyproject 5h ago

I'm sad to hear that you got downvoted before for being curious about something really cool.

Asking an LLM like Google's AI, ChatGPT, etc, is solid advice but in case you don't like to talk to AI's, allow me to give it a shot.

Riemann constructed a special function 167 years ago that can count prime numbers like 2,3,5,7.. . This function has a bunch of zeros. There is a bunch of not so interesting zeros: -2, -4, -6, .. . These are the trivial zeros. Let's ignore them. There are more interesting ones on the so called critical line. Riemann guessed that except for the trivial zeros, all zeros of the Riemann zeta function lie on the critical line. So, all you need to do is find a zero to this function that is not a trivial zero and not on the critical line and you have proven the Riemann hypothesis false! Here's the catch: we already checked a trillion or so zeros with computers in search for zeros outside the critical line. So far, we haven't found any.

A beautiful thing about the LLM is that you can have a conversation with it so that you find the level of understanding that's just right for you. I have to guess what your math background is like or I need to wait for you to tell me what you didn't understand.

One time, I saw a sticker on a car that said: "Honk if you believe that the Riemann hypothesis is true". What do you think I did? I honked, of course! They looked very confused at me...

11

u/SnooRabbits6411 5h ago edited 5h ago

I asked Claude, See this is why it is good to use AI. Instead of asking people and getting downvoted Just ask CLaude.

"Claude, what is The Riemann Hypothesis and How important is it that Ai solved it??"

Big disclosure first: Anthropic made me, the mathematician works at Anthropic, and the AI in question is Claude. So weigh what follows accordingly and check the primary sources.

What the hypothesis is

Riemann proposed it in 1859. The zeta function has "zeros" — inputs where it evaluates to nothing — and the hypothesis says every nontrivial one sits on a single vertical line in the complex plane, the critical line at real part 1/2. Hilbert listed it eighth among his 23 problems in 1900, and the Clay Mathematics Institute later included it among seven Millennium Prize problems with a million-dollar reward attached. Its real weight is in prime numbers: it pins down how irregularly the primes are distributed, and a great many theorems have been proved conditionally, assuming it holds. arxiv

What happened

Levent Alpöge, a mathematician at Anthropic, posted a four-page note on his personal website on November 20 saying he had completed a proof by collaborating with Claude. He hasn't released the AI-generated explanation, which he says runs over 250,000 pages, but he provided 17 million lines of code formally verifying the generalized version, which extends the conjecture to a wider family of functions. The Boston Globescience

The verification is the part that matters most. On November 21 the Lean and Mathlib community, endorsed by Lean FRO and the Mathlib Initiative, issued a joint statement certifying that both the statement and the proof are correct. That second half is the crucial bit — a machine-checked proof is only as good as the formalized statement actually being the theorem everyone means. biggo

How important

If it holds, enormous. It would instantly validate scores of results across mathematics that assume Riemann is true. It didn't come from nowhere either: OpenAI's model produced the quasi-Riemann result last month, and James Maynard at Oxford says this work seems to build on it while injecting much deeper mathematical content. An August result had already pushed the fraction of zeros known to lie on the critical line from about 42% to over 66%. sciencearxiv

Two things worth holding against the headlines. Much of the press is calling it a proof by Claude, and others with comparable model access and compute didn't produce one — which is your authorship argument, landing in the most consequential possible place. And the proof could take years to decipher; formally verified isn't the same as understood. Al Jazeerascience

Claude themself self-disclosed they may be biased. Make of this what you will.

Like M. C. Escher's Hand drawing Hand wood carving.

(One note: Claude said "your authorship argument" because it was answering me, and that's a position I've argued in this sub for weeks. Not addressed to you.)

0

u/I_need_a_waambulance 2h ago

Damn that's a good explanation. Thank you.

Also, I'm really surprised Claude sourced Al-Jazeera considering what the west thinks of it.

3

u/SnooRabbits6411 2h ago

Claude seems to be source agnostic. All it seems to care about is " can this be verified." Not " what are their Politics??"

1

u/I_need_a_waambulance 2h ago

Yeah, I'm just surprised at that. Hope it stays that way tbh.

2

u/wolfylemon 4h ago

from my understanding, theres a function called the riemann-zeta function. it is defined with zeta(s) where s is a complex number, meaning a sum of real and imaginary number.  to put it simply, the function returns the sum of 1/(2s) + 1/(3s) + 1/(4s), continuing this pattern to infinity. this diverges to infinity for values of s with a real component less than 1, so the function is continued in a more complicated way that can be found on its wikipedia page the riemann hypothesis looks at the zeroes of this function, which are just input value of s for which zeta(s)=0. using the aforementioned function continuation, it is very easy to find that all values of s with an imaginary component of 0 and a real component of a negative even integer are zeroes of the function (e.g. -2, -4, -6, etc.). these are called trivial zeroes, and are ignored by mathematicians. the nontrivial zeroes behave much more erratically and arent evenly spaced. using computers, over 100 billion zeroes have been found, with all of them having a real value of 1/2. no nontrivial zeroes have been discovered off of this straight line. the riemann hypothesis is just a belief that all nontrivial zeroes fall on this line, and is so difficult to prove because we dont know why the zeroes are on this line, so cant prove that there arent any off of it. the hypothesis has gained fame for being the go to for "hardest math problem ever", although this is a poorly formulated question likely only asked by non-mathematicians, because it is believed that there are entierly new branches of mathematics that must be invented to make a proof of it possible some people will say that it helps find prime numbers, and thus is important for cryptography. this is barely true, as any application of the hypothesis would be innefficient. it mostly just exists as a challenge and celebration of mathematics. as an anti, this is also where my personal opinion and disdain of any ai solution comes in. solving the riemann hypothesis doesnt make peoples lives significantly better, it just removes this aspiration for many top mathematicians.  its like if people were training to beat the 100 metre sprint world record, and then some shitwad shows up in a sports car and demands a gold medal. did they technically win the race? yes, but thats not what matters. its not a topic of efficiency, or optimising for daily life, but a goal that celebrates pushing the limits of human capabilities, and unfortunately this one is dead and gone forever :(

1

u/AllPotatoesGone 48m ago

Most people including me have zero idea what it is and what it changes but most redditors feel like they can judge if that achievement was important or not.

-1

u/Apprehensive-Toe4160 1h ago

You have tools to provide answers. Use them. Act like modern person. Do not outsource every little task on others.

2

u/FuckingSlug 1h ago

Just dont reply if you dont want to lol

→ More replies (3)

20

u/Connect_Quit_1293 4h ago

The funniest part of this whole subject is that suddenly everyone on Reddit is a descendant of Pythagoras himself and know everything about theoretical mathematics.

Dunning Kruger effect has never been stronger than this week.

6

u/Archway9 2h ago

One good way to spot that they know nothing is if they call it theoretical mathematics. That's not a thing, all of maths is theoretical, I think they mean pure mathematics

1

u/Lucky_Cable_3145 1h ago

When did Pure maths and Theoretical maths become different things?

1

u/Archway9 43m ago

Theoretical maths has never been a term anyone uses

33

u/Effective-Guest1601 6h ago

To quote the famous mathemetician/philospher David Hilbert (A fucking chad):

"If I were to awaken after having slept for a thousand years, my first question would be: Has the Riemann Hypothesis been proven?”

if ykyk

3

u/captain21XX 3h ago

Well I'd like to know. Can someone explain the big deal of landing RH

4

u/Effective-Guest1601 3h ago

Everybody assumed it was true but nobody could even seem to begin to figure out how to solve it, people thought it might even need new types of math to be invented before they could prove it to be true. It persisted as basically the most popular open question in math for like the past 100 years. There's like a brazillion videos and articles about it.

1

u/captain21XX 54m ago

Ok but I need the absolute essence this seems like history in the making here what even IS RH ontologically besides just primes and zero distributions or whatever it is

12

u/Disastrous_Good9236 5h ago

They told me they don’t acknowledge that ai solved the Riemann Hypothesis until they read the LEAN code themselves. Bro, even the LEAN and Mathlib association accepted it:

“We have full confidence that Alpöge’s proof of the Riemann Hypothesis is correct, and we congratulate him on this achievement.”

7

u/TexturelessIdea 3h ago

I would love to see an anti try to even parse one of the simpler proofs in Mathlib. There's no way in hell any of the antis trying to discredit this could have read the LEAN a human would have written had they proved GRH.

3

u/SnooRabbits6411 2h ago

The thing to remember is.. The Person that used the AI was applauded. Deservedly so. The entis would try and deny them credit. saying " The AI done it." all while also arguing " It's just stupid spellcheck, and autocomplete"

They need to Pick a lane,.

11

u/AgeZealousideal1751 5h ago

The regressivists who used that as a bar have quietly moved to the back, while a bunch of lower intelligence regressivists have taken their place to feign ignorance.

It's a flawless scapegoat system.

3

u/Effective-Guest1601 3h ago

you couldn't have predicted this comment section more accurately lol

5

u/Generic_Speed_Demon 4h ago

The proof is 250 THOUSAND pages and people have already found holes in it. This is even worse than the navier-stokes thing

13

u/MydnightWN 3h ago

Wrong.

-2

u/TheOneHentaiPrince 2h ago

Well it's not pier reviewd. Beeing confident and wrong can be true at the same time. Alao yes there are some holes in the AI model proof. But hey we have also another guy who worked a decade on this problem and also has submitted a solution. Of course with less pages.

8

u/Effective-Guest1601 2h ago

How did is pass lean compilation with holes in the proof? Are you saying that all the various lean kernels it was tested on by the top mathemeticians and scientists working on it are flawed?

If you have insights into these holes you may well become one of the most famous mathemeticians/comp scientists on the planet right now, I'd definitely rush to report them and try to cash in

1

u/EconomistFair4403 1h ago

idk, what do you think happens with software designed and tested on not a quarter of a million pages of proof when a quarter of a million pages of proof are submitted?

→ More replies (5)

0

u/SnooRabbits6411 2h ago

Gotta Give them credit for trying.... am I rite??

-5

u/Generic_Speed_Demon 3h ago

"wrong." Shows a headline with no source link

8

u/MydnightWN 3h ago

I can't read

3

u/Xombridal 4h ago

Please you seen to be a person of reason, for a friend who isn't chronically online wtf is the hypothesis and can you link me the holes you mentioned, no pro has yet to even answer this question for me

3

u/Generic_Speed_Demon 3h ago

Anthropic themselves say that Claude did not fully prove the hypothesis

https://www.anthropic.com/research/riemann-zeta

5

u/ritsulover 3h ago

I should capture this before he delete comments

1

u/Generic_Speed_Demon 3h ago

I don't delete comments because I'm not afraid of being wrong. I'll wait to see if the proof is valid if anyone can actually check the whole thing

3

u/Any-Interview-1276 3h ago

Get ready to wait a couple of years

9

u/Effective-Guest1601 3h ago

Yes, 3 months ago they had not proved it yet.

3

u/Any-Interview-1276 3h ago

Don’t you know facts are the worst ennemies of Antis?

1

u/SnooRabbits6411 1h ago

what do you expect? They are similar to many that lead with heir conclusions and then engage in circular reasoning.

1

u/Effective-Guest1601 3h ago

I'm always a little taken aback at how willing they are to spread misinformation, it's kind of scary. I mean I fully expect it at this point but still lol.

1

u/Any-Interview-1276 3h ago

They are as reliable as the models we had in 2024 lol

→ More replies (2)

0

u/[deleted] 3h ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/Effective-Guest1601 3h ago

Why are you reading a blog post from 3 months ago about something that happened 2 days ago?

2

u/Iv4bez 3h ago

so okay can anyone tell for someone's who's not terminally online was it proven or not....

2

u/Ok_Cabinet2947 3h ago

Yes, it has been independently verified by many mathematicians and organizations now.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/Any-Interview-1276 3h ago

Somebody else already answered that it’s a blogpost from 3 months ago, not from the current proof, but let me take a good laugh at you too.

FYI, I never had to read and be critic as much as I am since I use AI, because it is very good at sounding right, so you cannot fully trust it. You know, just like an Anti who only reads the part that matches his narrative.

2

u/Professional-Kiwi-31 45m ago

I love the upvotes too 🤣🤣 as long as it's appears to agree with me it's good enough, stamp it!

1

u/Zumbah 3h ago

Google?

0

u/Xombridal 3h ago

Too much bias from sites, if I could have someone send me a direct "this one is good" link it'd work best, I'd rather not be misled by propoganda lol

1

u/shadowrun456 1h ago

They are lying. The "250 THOUSAND pages" were never even released, and were simply a result of AI attempting to "translate" the LEAN proof into natural language. They don't matter, the actual proof is what matters, the proof has been released and has been verified by numerous independent parties to be legit.

5

u/shadowrun456 2h ago

The proof is 250 THOUSAND pages and people have already found holes in it.

Stop lying. The "250 THOUSAND pages" were never even released, and were simply a result of AI attempting to "translate" the LEAN proof into natural language. They don't matter, the actual proof is what matters, the proof has been released and has been verified by numerous independent parties to be legit.

5

u/SLAMMERisONLINE 2h ago

The proof is 250 THOUSAND pages and people have already found holes in it

It's not an established proof unless the theorem can be stated precisely and the reasoning can be independently verified. Otherwise, it's practically indistinguishable from an unfalsifiable theory.

Imagine a paranormal investigator presenting 250,000 pages of evidence that ghosts exist. Every time someone discovers a contradiction, they're told that the explanation lies somewhere in the other 249,999 pages. At that point, the sheer volume of material serves not to establish the validity of the claim, but to insulate it from scrutiny. Complexity is not a substitute for demonstrability.

3

u/Generic_Speed_Demon 2h ago

See, this is what I'm saying. A 250 thousand page proof doesn't work because nobody could ever digest that information.

4

u/SnooRabbits6411 2h ago

This does Not mean the theory was Not proven though. Simply that it is hard to verify without relying on AI to verify it, but then you need to trust the AI that verifies it.

→ More replies (6)

1

u/encony 1h ago

Not unlikely that Claude models overengineered the solution like they always do

1

u/Wise_Monkey_Sez 1h ago

And it hasn't proved anything. That requires peer review.

This isn't a new standard specially designed to refute AI, it's literally been the accepted standard for more than a hundred years.

Now the pro-AI bunch want us to abandon it because ... <checks notes> actual human experts checking results reveals that claims about AI solving things are untrue.

No.

And at 250,000 pages it's going to take years to peer review this alleged "proof". Which is a massive waste of time because it's already showing cracks in the logic.

2

u/Effective-Stomach523 57m ago edited 40m ago

EDIT: It seems that they have blocked me :). Can't see their reply

> That requires peer review. This isn't a new standard specially designed to refute AI, it's literally been the accepted standard for more than a hundred years.

The proof was written in LEAN. If the LEAN program/proof compiles, then the statement is correct. The proof did compile.

Proofs in the past required peer review because they were written in natural language. LEAN doesn't require peer review because compilation is the peer review

> And at 250,000 pages it's going to take years to peer review this alleged "proof"

Misleading statement. The 250k "proof" was the author of the lean proof asking claude to convert the LEAN proof to natural language. Since LEAN is far more verbose and detailed than natural language, it is not too surprising that the natural language proof is this long. If we took the time to refactor the natural language proof, it is not too unlikely that the proof will go down by several orders of magnitude.

> Which is a massive waste of time because it's already showing cracks in the logic.

Source?

1

u/Wise_Monkey_Sez 41m ago

The standard is peer review.

You don't get to change the standard because it doesn't suit your preconceived beliefs.

Lean is not the standard. What you're doing has a name "moving the goalposts". In this case pro-AI maniacs want to move the goalposts so far that they aren't even in the same stadium.

You don't get to define the standard. Is academia decides that Lean alone is sufficient then they'll abandon peer review.

But they haven't, because they know a lot more than you about this.

I'm not arguing any further with someone who doesn't understand what they're talking about and engaged in dishonest arguments. I didn't mislead or misrepresent anything. You, however did.

Discussion over. You lost by arguing in bad faith.

1

u/VastlyVainVanity 17m ago

I don’t think you understand how any of this works, I’m afraid. The proof is in Lean. Verifying it is just running the theorem checker and seeing that it passes. They’ve run it in multiple ways and have already verified that the proof is most likely correct.

Stop pretending to understand things you have no idea about.

3

u/Relevant_Research_98 3h ago

It's even more funny. It's "I don't get why people think solving problems is a good thing".
Though even antis downvotes this edgy opinion

1

u/miscellaneousexists 20m ago

Man makes up a scenario and gets angry

2

u/throwaway275275275 5h ago

It's not a hypothesis anymore

10

u/eggsyest 5h ago

I wonder when ai bros will understand antis hate Gen ai and data centers next to where people live

7

u/nhalliday 5h ago

If they can't lump in solving math and medical problems under the umbrella of them using AI to generate art, their whole argument falls apart. So they have to pretend that it's even remotely the same thing and that it's impossible to have AI just to solve those problems, we have to let them generate slop with it too or we're the bad people.

11

u/TexturelessIdea 3h ago

This was solved using Claude, it's the same damn model antis complain about. Nobody's lumping in shit, it's the same damn model!

2

u/SnooRabbits6411 1h ago

Someone uses a scalpel to slit someone's throat. Bann scalpels because.... " it's the same damn scalpel!"

0

u/Lucky_Cable_3145 1h ago

It was solved by an award winning mathematician and computer scientist (Levent Alpöge) using an unreleased version of Anthropic AI (where he works so the tokens are free).

The average AI user cannot get Claude to solve this type of problem.

1

u/Voidspeeker 15m ago

Shouldn't the argument be that Alpöge just commissioned a solution — like a chef reheating a frozen pizza?

→ More replies (10)

1

u/DeathToAmerica2027 57m ago

They're different applications of the same thing.

1

u/Effective-Guest1601 4h ago

You don't have to let them do anything, they are just going to do it. You aren't in control of anything at all lol

2

u/nhalliday 4h ago

Yeah, unfortunately a lot of modern society is built on letting people who only care about money pursue their profits without really being able to stop them even when it's hurting other people. You can try to reason with them but if they cared about anyone but themselves they'd have listened to the environmental and social harm arguments by now.

3

u/muzaffer22 4h ago

May I ask did you say anything about environmental impact of technology before AI? Because there was still global warming before AI and nobody made that a big of a deal until they heard about AI threatening their jobs. So that means you guys are also selfish, no?

→ More replies (8)

1

u/SnooRabbits6411 1h ago

I think the issue is Plenty of things also harm the environment hich you ignore ... Like... reddit.

1

u/nhalliday 1h ago

Ahhh other things also harm the environment and I don't criticize every single one of them constantly so it's okay that AI harms the environment. Great argument, good job.

10

u/IdiotGiraffe0 5h ago

Who was saying before that it couldn't solve it? We are saying that I is harmful for the environment and job market.

16

u/jeffwulf 5h ago

Lots of anti AI people claim that.

→ More replies (6)

9

u/Additional_Fun3783 5h ago

AI is taking our Riemann-hypothesis-solving jobs 😭

3

u/Arkitakama 5h ago

DER TERK ER JERBS!

1

u/silentkode26 3h ago

Why do you people cheer so much when other people lose job?

2

u/SnooRabbits6411 1h ago

Do you also cry for the Horse and Buggy riders?

why or why not?

→ More replies (3)

1

u/Massive-Pea4495 3h ago

The article talking about it literally has mathmaticians dreading the idea of how this affects their jobs

7

u/Solarka45 5h ago

Sorry but I don't think you are important enough to be harmful for the environment or the job market by yourself

→ More replies (1)

1

u/shadowrun456 1h ago

Who was saying before that it couldn't solve it?

There's people in this very thread saying exactly that.

1

u/Fun1k 33m ago

It's so much less harmful than lots of people make it out to be. And job market? Instead of getting mad at new technology that can automate the world, much better and much productive would be to put that energy to pressure governments to institute UBI.

10

u/Witty-Designer7316 6h ago • Heartwarming

Antis would rather attack my character than acknowledge that AI was useful in doing something.

12

u/Chickie69 5h ago • Bravo

It's true that AI is useful in many ways. But most common people are using it (especially gen AI) for shitass thing

And you expect people don't get mad about that?

9

u/Late2theGame0001 5h ago

Same with all tools. The way you use all the tech in your life is a pathetic waste to me. From your car to your phone to your stove. And yeah it pisses me off. So I guess you are right.

5

u/muzaffer22 4h ago

We have the internet where you can find all the information but we’re on Reddit doom scrolling. I guess we’re removing the internet as it’s useless.

7

u/Late2theGame0001 4h ago

Right. Not to mention jackasses that use their tv to watch anything but extremely educational and productive content.

I personally only use fire to make food for homeless vets. So anybody making fire for dumb shit like s’mores or ghost stories is below me on the moral spectrum.

2

u/Effective-Guest1601 4h ago

Nobody ever said we needed s’mores. We didn't ask for s’mores. Why can't we have robots make our s’mores while we do the fun things like our dishes.

1

u/TexturelessIdea 3h ago

The internet was originally invented so that universities could share information quicker. It should have stayed exclusive to universities, so many people wasting energy, and so many data centers built so that people can watch Netflix.

It's true that the internet is useful in many ways. But most common people are using it (especially porn) for shitass thing

5

u/Disastrous_Good9236 5h ago • Heartwarming

Is that Ai’s fault or the user fault?

0

u/Engineering_Geek 4h ago

At the end of the day, the user. The tool is still "too powerful". Taking that logic in a different area, it's like saying "guns don't kill people, people kill people". While true, the tool itself can be controlled / regulated as to prevent the harms to begin with.

1

u/shadowrun456 1h ago

most common people are using it (especially gen AI) for shitass thing

And you expect people don't get mad about that?

Yes? What kind of a miserable person would be upset about this?

The printing press enabled anyone to write books, and as a result 99%+ of written stuff is shit.

The photo-camera enabled anyone to "paint" (portray things visually), and as a result 99%+ of visually portrayed things (photos) are shit.

Are you upset that the printing press and photo-cameras exist?

Being flooded with low quality stuff is simply a signal that the tool is easy enough to use by most people. If it didn't lead to a mass of low quality stuff, it would mean that the tool is too difficult for the average person to use.

3

u/CheckMateFluff 6h ago

It wouldn’t be an AI debate if your character didn’t get a rebuttal before your point did. sad Tis is the common law of the land it seems. ad hominem for days.

-7

u/IntrStelle 5h ago

What character? You don't have one.

0

u/pacuuuuu 3h ago

Same Thing for You Guys

2

u/ritsulover 3h ago

not

1

u/pacuuuuu 3h ago

In that case i can also just say we dont ever move the Goalpost

6

u/Bell_Of_Gesture 6h ago

God this subreddit is a shithole

1

u/IntrStelle 5h ago

And this is downvoted for some reason lol

3

u/Mythic4356 3h ago

As an anti, i feel that using AI to actually solve big problems is fine

However using AI to make something YOU were supposed to make, just doesnt sit right

4

u/Expensive-Bus5326 2h ago

So is it just vibes based criticism? You can criticize solving major math problems with AI too, because mathematicians "were supposed to do it themselves".

0

u/The-Golden-Neko- 2h ago

U should represent us antis more often

3

u/toastedquestion 5h ago

No one is saying ts shit

2

u/Jeagan2002 4h ago

It has definitely been claimed a solution has been found, and the Navier-Stokes situation kinda puts shade on that IMO.

Navier-Stokes was another Millennium Problem that AI solved, only for it to be revealed it was actually stealing a solution someone was already prepping to publish.

See the problem here?

6

u/Mgattii 4h ago

The claim was that it stole the Navier-Stokes solution was false. It didn't use the "Spanish Method."

2

u/Effective-Guest1601 4h ago

Actually the same authors who published this also published the solutions to the rest of Navier Stokes the same day

https://github.com/tristanbuckmaster/navier-stokes

-1

u/JackfruitFearless429 6h ago

19

u/Little_Froggy 5h ago

I literally saw a anti post earlier today where people were arguing that the match breakthroughs didn't count because people don't fully understand the proofs yet.

Like I feel like there are just some people who don't care what AI accomplishes, they will always find a reason to ignore/downplay it

0

u/jayerp 5h ago

I can kinda see the logic. Did you achieve something if you don’t understand what it is you did?

Unfortunately for them, it’s not their decision to say what does and doesn’t count. Unless they’re on that team.

0

u/WorthMassive8132 5h ago

That's not what this post is about, though?

→ More replies (5)

3

u/No-Bag-1628 5h ago

Doesn't apply here. Everybody on the internet talking about this event is focusing more on how it's useless because nobody understood the proof yet rather than the fact that it actually fucking exists.

-7

u/ritsulover 6h ago

0

u/JackfruitFearless429 6h ago

If you are trying to claim that a lot of antis put the image I put on almost every post saying shit about ai, prove it. Better have evidence to back up your claim.

0

u/SpiritedAtmosphere88 4h ago

Why do clankerheads always have the corniest memes?

1

u/Archway9 2h ago

I've engaged with threads about this way more than I probably should (tbf it affects me way more than most of the people just trying to score points in a culture war) and I haven't seen a single person say the Riemann hypothesis isn't important

1

u/Hollowframe0127 5h ago

They normally have a small vocabulary, slop this and slop that , reminds me of meeker .

1

u/TenshiS 3h ago

In a few years:

"Pffff this is just universal high income and Utopia, is that all? Wake me up when AI does something truly important."

1

u/Pashera 4h ago

So after a quick check, yes ai made a big breakthrough on it, no it did not prove or solve it. It found some 370 something results

-2

u/PotatoPeelrsFromHell 5h ago

Did it ever occur to you, that everyone is laughing at you and not with you, incel?

13

u/GrandFleshMelder 5h ago

What does incel even mean anymore? Person online I don’t like?

6

u/Illustrious-Pay6341 4h ago

Why attack someone personally on the internet by calling them names because they disagree with you? What’s the point of posting stupid comments like this?

1

u/lefou22 5h ago

Uug no understand why Reimann hypothesis is important. Someone inform Uug please.

1

u/ThatDeuce 5h ago

What was the Reimann hypothesis for?

1

u/ItzPear 2h ago

Solved the Riemann hypothesis but still letting the planet fry.

-2

u/lucid-quiet 6h ago

I get the impression that most RH bros can't even quote it or tell anyone why it would matter. (Other than more tools to make future proofs).

0

u/Plastic_Young_9763 4h ago

Holy shit, the pattern recognition machine... Recognizes patterns. Yeah we know, it's pretty neat.

0

u/SHIN-YOKU 4h ago

Has anyone checked the answer or is it as good as me saying it's 42? It's like noone reads past the headline, or at least 1 of you would have included it.

3

u/Effective-Guest1601 4h ago

the answer is that the hypothesis is true, the proof is the validation of that answer

it's not a big surprise in a sense as it was assumed to be true, but math people could not figure out at all how to prove it, and certainly not for lack of trying or interest

1

u/SHIN-YOKU 3h ago

Got a link?

0

u/want_impaired 4h ago

The proof compiles without error but they haven't gone through and fully verified it though. AI bros are just jumping the gun here because they want to equivocate their ai generated slop to solving a long standing unproven hypothesis.

0

u/RottenRailing 4h ago

goomba_fallacy.png

0

u/StevevBerg 2h ago edited 2h ago

I dont get the point being made here.
A computer specificly designd to look for patterns was able to proof a math pattern.
Whats that supposed to proof?

Also, apperently its not peer reviews yet. Dont sound alarm bells for stuff before that happend. Thats always a dumb idea.

-3

u/ScaryCrowEffigy 5h ago

I have no idea what that is or what it adds to the world

7

u/Notmyrealname5282 5h ago

Your ignorance doesn’t concern how things will continue to move, unfortunately

4

u/ScaryCrowEffigy 5h ago

I was hoping someone might enlighten me as to what it was and its significance

6

u/mgomezch 5h ago

it's a problem in mathematics that has been considered the greatest challenge in the field for all the other mathematical results that depend on it and for its difficulty to prove. it has had this status for longer than a century, and it has been 160 years since it was formulated. it was the holy grail of mathematics.

5

u/Notmyrealname5282 5h ago

And people call pros brain dead 💀

Go do your homework first before entering the conversation

1

u/ScaryCrowEffigy 5h ago

I’m fairly neutral on AI, I just don’t know what the significance of proving this hypothesis is. All I know is the hypothesis is relates to the distribution of prime numbers but I’m not mathematically inclined to understand the importance of this.

1

u/MisterKarasino 43m ago

Use fucking Google

-4

u/ulixForReal 5h ago

Nice straw-man you've built there.

-8

u/kelsey1998 5h ago

Did ai actually solve the hypothesis or did it just SAY it solved it and everyone trusted it?

4

u/Late2theGame0001 5h ago

Does it matter? Will it change your opinion? Or are you a hater no matter what?

3

u/kelsey1998 5h ago

I'll agree that AI has some potential in some fields. Generative ai "art" will always be dogshit slop

5

u/Late2theGame0001 5h ago

Agree. For me, anybody that isn’t finding their own pigments in nature is just making industrial slop. Glad we are on the same page.

0

u/kelsey1998 5h ago

Being deliberately obtuse to try and win an argument I see. That's not immature or anything

5

u/Late2theGame0001 5h ago

I mean meta dismissal isn’t an argument. Explain to me how anything but sourcing your art from nature is not just slop? Buying your paint from 3M is supposed to impress Jesus? Making a picture on an iPad made by a child is somehow morally superior?

2

u/kelsey1998 5h ago

Pancakes vs waffles ass reply

5

u/Late2theGame0001 5h ago

I’ll take that as a “I’m out of my depth and my talking points that I’ve been spoon-fed don’t have an easy way out of this obviously hypocritical moral position.”

6

u/machyume 5h ago

Pretty sure that it is solved. We just have no idea how to read the solution. It's a different kind of problem now.

0

u/colibri01 5h ago

Isn't that not good enough? I thought proofs were very important in mathematics?

0

u/ProfessionalBoss2428 5h ago

Isn’t that like knowing the answer is apparently 42 but not knowing what the question is?

-2

u/kelsey1998 5h ago

So Claude said "trust me bro" and the ai chuds just did lmao. "We can't read the solution" so it's effectively not solved still. This is what antis mean by people using AI to offload critical thinking.

6

u/FuzzyAnteater9000 5h ago

No, it's real. The lean proof compiled.

→ More replies (4)

0

u/DarthSwimfoot 5h ago

Either way you aren't gonna give it any credit.

0

u/kelsey1998 5h ago

I unlike some people here understand nuance. I'll give it credit where it's due but gen ai is known to contribute to confirmation bias. I feel like it's a fair question. The lack of scepticism or critical thinking from pro ai bros is insane

2

u/DarthSwimfoot 5h ago

And the lack of any arguments besides "ai bro" is also insane.

→ More replies (1)

0

u/Still-Bar3978 3h ago

I don't even know why I'm in this subreddit, but was It really necessary to make a soyjack meme with AI? 😭 It feels like the kind of thing where you don't need talent, just the idea you already have and like 5 minutes

0

u/Secure_News590 2h ago

A researcher proved it not AI, its because of the founding that its was used for marketing

0

u/Malusorum 1h ago

0 minutes since fallacious argument.

-7

u/bestjaegerpilot 5h ago

I'm pro AI but "AI solving the Reimann hypothesis" is generally BS. It's like when influencers one-shotted flappy bird clones (when the damn thing is in it's training data since it's a common teaching example) and said coding was dead

12

u/Disastrous_Good9236 5h ago

?

Here is a quote by the LEAN and Mathlib community:

“We have full confidence that Alpöge’s proof of the Riemann Hypothesis is correct, and we congratulate him on this achievement.”

-6

u/bestjaegerpilot 5h ago

bro in the math world, that's like saying discord mods have full confidence in the proof. Come on, I'm pro ai but don't drink the koolaid --- put your thinking cap on

10

u/mgomezch 5h ago

?????? the proof's author delivered a fully formalized proof that has been independently validated by multiple parties and multiple implementations of the Lean kernel, including one that is itself validated in Lean to only succeed compiling proofs that follow from the axioms/assumptions correctly. on what grounds do you cast doubt on this proof?

2

u/Engineering_Geek 4h ago

It's more akin to having other professionals explicitly say "yes, we believe this is valid, and works". Full deep dives into the (super long) proof is under way, but the existing consensus is that it's promising and valid enough to accept / critique on formal grounds.

Being pro AI and not drinking the koolaid means you should be skeptical, but not dismissive.

-2

u/Bhazor 3h ago

So is that what you are using AI for? Because if you're taking credit for something you didn't do I assume you also accept blame for all the bad things people do with AI.

5

u/I_need_a_waambulance 2h ago

😭

Bro, swap AI for "cars" and see how stupid your argument is.

0

u/ItzPear 2h ago

People don’t take credit for things someone else did with their car either… 😭

2

u/I_need_a_waambulance 2h ago

Guess I didn't arrive at work. My car did.

-7

u/It_Just_Exploded 5h ago

People gotta learn the difference between LLMs and AI

9

u/mcfearless0214 5h ago

So do you, apparently. LLMs are a type of AI. AI is a category that includes LLMs.

6

u/mgomezch 5h ago

this was literally Claude Code.

6

u/FuzzyAnteater9000 5h ago

This was an llm

3

u/Betty_PunCrocker 4h ago

What?!? LLMs are AI.

-11

u/ProfessionalBoss2428 6h ago

How many people had heard of the Riemann hypothesis a year ago?

12

u/ritsulover 6h ago

The Riemann hypothesis has often been used in fiction as a symbol of the ultimate unsolved problem.

-7

u/ProfessionalBoss2428 6h ago

You didn’t answer my question, I don’t believe it was well known enough that the scenario you’re illustrating above happened

2

u/ritsulover 6h ago

Haha, is that seriously all the antis ever have to say? This is absolutely hilarious. My gift for you

1

u/IntrStelle 5h ago

Second time you've posted this image btw

-1

u/cosmic-obscurity 5h ago

Are you gonna try to make any sense/rational argument at any point in the near future?

-4

u/ProfessionalBoss2428 6h ago

So you can link us to at least a half dozen instances of it?

→ More replies (3)

4

u/FuzzyAnteater9000 5h ago

I learned about it in high school

-13

u/AutumnWillow36 6h ago

the proof lacks the soul and creativity, the mathematician who guided it isn’t a real artist?