r/algotrading • • 20h ago

Education Arrogance of novices

54 Upvotes

I've been reading and posting comments in this sub now for a few months, and what really strikes me is how arrogant some other commentators are who by their own admission are very new to this domain.

In the last 24 hours I have had discussions with one guy who argued that paper trading is no different from production, and the results there will 100% transfer to production results, and by the way this guy has never traded in production yet. So where is that confidence coming from given he has no experience?

Then another topic was around extreme volatility, I had a guy say that he's building an algo that can handle ANY market conditions, and that's what a "professional" algo should do. That's almost by definition impossible. If the market behaves in a way that is outside any conditions seen during the period the models were trained on or the execution was simmed on, it's very likely the algo will not perform well in those conditions. To claim you have made an algo that can perfectly extrapolate to any situation, it's implausible.

I've been doing this for 15 years, and I want to help others who are starting out, and yet I find myself getting into arguments with people who haven't even run an algo in production! I just don't get how these people have so much confidence in what they are saying at this stage.


r/algotrading • • 21h ago

Strategy SPX options trading strategy

Post image
34 Upvotes

I'm looking into selling spreads in certain conditions. This is paper.

15 years of experience trading with options and real money. Five figures.

Paper is run over realistic bid / ask in options, I have a crawler every 10 seconds of every contract (distance 300 points from spot price) for SPX, then I store it so backtesting is close to reality.

I will put real money in January.


r/algotrading • • 3h ago

Data AI/Algo Trading (Paper) Multi-week update - Part 2

Thumbnail gallery
6 Upvotes

Thanks for everyone's input! If you can, check out my other posts/comments as it really answers a lot of questions and goes over a few obvious concerns.

A few things about the above snapshots:

The pile:

  •  About 150,000 total number of setups and variations we've backtested before moving forward with what we have now. This covers hand-built setups, all-day versions, workbench copies, and every tweak to stops, timing, filters and windows. Done through loads of online research, articles, popular methods, etc. All by Claude
  • There is also a setup generator that I told to randomly screen about 27,000 machine-made rule ideas. We logged 1,136 research ideas and built 274 setups. 228 have traded live and of that, maybe 5-10% have good value right now.
  • Today: 208 running across 10 paper accounts. 54 of them are in the Graveyard (still trading, just for data), and 12 are retired.
  • 36 are in the green, and about 15 show real promise. Only 4 make Primary.

Leaderboard image: our top 10 right now. Ones marked * are machine-made. The top two have only 7-8 days of history, so we're excited but patient. This is just top 10 though. The most promising setups are in the primary account or in "On Deck" and have had much more extensive testing.

Busiest money-makers image:

  • Gap-Down Recovery Fade: a stock opens way down and bounces, and we bet the bounce fades. +64R over 4 weeks.
  • Gap-Down Early Bounce Short: same idea, earlier and pickier. +60R, but bumpier.

Hot streaks:

I track streaks mainly to see what setup has withstood a few brutal consecutive days. Have about 15 setups with various consistent green streaks but below are some of the current ones.

  • Late Quiet-Day Short (shorts weak stocks late on days the Nasdaq is down): 5 green days in a row.
  • PM Upper-Wick Short and Late-Morning New-High Short: 4 each.
  • Lunch New-Low Short: 3.
  • We see streaks like this all the time, and most cool off. Midday Stretched Dip Buy looked great, then gave back 28R in 5 days. A setup needs weeks, not a streak, to get promoted.

Fun what-if: if Primary had only ever run its three gap-down shorts, it would be +77R on 550 trades over the past 5 weeks of trading. Everything else it ran: −207R. Gap-Down Recovery Fade alone in Primary: 188 trades, 67% winners, +36R.

Glitches we fixed:

  • Broker close-out glitch (11-05/06): a position didn't close and showed a fake $11.5k paper loss. Positions are now checked every minute, and closing retries until it works.
  • Runaway bursts: one setup fired 100 trades in minutes on 11-20 (−99R). A burst brake starts Monday.
  • Sleepy safety check: our outage watchdog wasn't actually running. It's now started by the trading jobs themselves.

Quick facts:

  • Paper money only.
  • Every number is after costs. A cost bug fixed this week made the older numbers look worse, but honest.
  • Promotion = a move up, not a copy.
  • The Graveyard never deletes.

Thanks as always!


r/algotrading • • 11h ago

Strategy Is it a gamble?

3 Upvotes

Been into this for a year now. Intense coding and trials using real money. Still managed to keep the balance on the positive side, despite some mistakes, some attributable to me, other not so, which resulted in effort just to restore my balance to neutral, which is, after all, a cost in opportunity over and above the trading costs.

The thought is starting to evolve, that all this, every decision at any point going forward, is a gamble to one degree or another. I have amassed a year of tick data and countless algorithms. At any point, no matter the setup, there's an equal possibility for it to go up or down. And for those setups that have a mathematical edge, the +/- band is eaten by the costs.

Nothing new here, of course.

The point of this post is to encourage an exchange of experience, and if there are any pointers for further exploration.