r/algotrading • u/RLJ05 • 20h ago
Education Arrogance of novices
I've been reading and posting comments in this sub now for a few months, and what really strikes me is how arrogant some other commentators are who by their own admission are very new to this domain.
In the last 24 hours I have had discussions with one guy who argued that paper trading is no different from production, and the results there will 100% transfer to production results, and by the way this guy has never traded in production yet. So where is that confidence coming from given he has no experience?
Then another topic was around extreme volatility, I had a guy say that he's building an algo that can handle ANY market conditions, and that's what a "professional" algo should do. That's almost by definition impossible. If the market behaves in a way that is outside any conditions seen during the period the models were trained on or the execution was simmed on, it's very likely the algo will not perform well in those conditions. To claim you have made an algo that can perfectly extrapolate to any situation, it's implausible.
I've been doing this for 15 years, and I want to help others who are starting out, and yet I find myself getting into arguments with people who haven't even run an algo in production! I just don't get how these people have so much confidence in what they are saying at this stage.