TL;DR: Are Shopify stores losing more customers on product pages, in the cart or during checkout? And are we spending too much time fixing the biggest drop-off percentage rather than finding out what's actually costing us sales?
I'm curious where Shopify stores are losing the most customers lately. Is it getting people to add something to their cart, or are they making it all the way to checkout and then leaving?
What interests me is that the stage with the highest drop-off rate isn't always the one worth fixing first.
For example, a product page might have a fairly low add-to-cart rate, but if it’s one of the store’s most visited pages, even a small improvement could make a noticeable difference to sales. Meanwhile, a checkout issue might look worse in percentage terms but affect far fewer customers.
Of course, the numbers alone don't explain why people are leaving.
On Shopify, I'd be interested in what's happening between the product page and checkout. Customers are having trouble picking sizes or variants on mobile? In the cart drawer, is the delivery cost visible? Are discount codes working as expected, or are customers only finding out about shipping charges once they've started checkout?
I've also wondered how many stores are making changes based on funnel reports without checking whether the tracking is reliable.
Shopify and GA4 can show different conversion figures for several reasons, including consent settings, attribution and how events are collected. That doesn't automatically mean something is broken, but I'd still want to compare the trends with actual orders before deciding there's a serious conversion problem.
Session recordings can help explain what happens on product pages and in the cart, although they won't always show what customers experience inside Shopify checkout. Sometimes customer feedback or testing the purchase journey yourself tells you more than another dashboard.
Then there's the stock availability issue, which becomes particularly pertinent during peak shopping periods.Even if the site is functioning flawlessly, customers may abandon the purchase if popular sizes are out of stock or if delivery estimates have shifted.
I’d be cautious about making big changes just because a certain funnel step has a high abandonment rate, with Black Friday traffic. I'd rather understand how many customers are affected, what might be causing the problem and whether there's enough evidence to justify changing anything.
A checkout redesign might sound like a worthwhile improvement, but if customers are leaving because shipping costs are higher than expected, it's probably not where I'd spend the team's time.
For those managing Shopify stores, where have you found the biggest conversion problem recently, and was the actual cause what you initially expected?