r/andor • u/reyansh6759 • 3h ago
r/andor • u/RiskAggressive4081 • Aug 16 '25
General Discussion Any shows or films that feel like Andor?
r/andor
•
u/simplysudzzzy
•
May 20 '25
Mod Announcement Politics and this Subreddit
Hi all,
I know there has been a lot of discussion, especially recently, about politics in this sub. Before reading any further, please know this -- politics are and will always be allowed on this subreddit. Star Wars (particularly Andor) is inherently political. We as mods believe it would be a disservice to you all to not allow discussion of the political themes of this show and the connections it makes to our real world...even the difficult ones.
This post is not changing that whatsoever.
However, we do understand that some of the community doesn't wish to see those types of posts, and that is OK. Some of us use social media (even Reddit) as escapism from the real world, and there is nothing wrong with that. We are seeing an uptick in reports on posts of a political or sensitive nature, and despite efforts to cull said reports the mods are overwhelmed. This is only worsened by the fact that we have a handful of people on the subreddit going around and spamming reports - most of them being baseless.
Reddit doesn't give us the best tools when it comes to managing reports on posts and comments, so all we can really do about that is ask you all to use the report button sincerely. The more reports that we get that are unsubstantiated or are just pissed-off-reports, the harder it is for us to recognize the real ones. But I digress.
The point of this post is to announce a new sidebar option on the subreddit, a content filter. If you click on the "No Politics" button, you will be shown a version of the subreddit that does not include any posts with the Real World Politics flair. The hope is that this will make it easier for those who do not wish to see those posts (either all the time or sometimes) a way to enjoy the subreddit. We want as many of you to be a part of this community as possible. Remember, this is a 100% VOLUNTARY option. If you do nothing, you will continue to see the sub as you always have.
Thanks,
- sud
r/andor • u/Dear-Yellow-5479 • 3h ago
Theory & Analysis First scene: Ruescott Melshi
It’s fascinating that it was probably only those of us who were very familiar with Rogue One who would have recognised Melshi in his first appearance in Andor. Those who had seen the film only once and many years ago would have had practically no chance. Especially because the scene itself doesn’t in any way frame this first meeting as anything particularly significant: there’s no dramatic music or framing. He’s just another new face at the table, introduced by name by another prisoner. We are sharing Cassian’s perspective so this is entirely appropriate.
Melshi’s first significant moment comes a few moments later: he is the man who remembers ‘Keef’s name and uses it rather than ‘New Guy’, gently correcting Xaul’s colder use of that term. It’s a little detail, but one that on a rewatch already suggests that Melshi is something of a kindred spirit: observational and sharp but also empathetic.
Melshi’s bigger scenes come later in the Narkina 5 arc. He’s the cynic, with a brutally realistic view of the prison system and as a result he is seen more than once on the receiving end of Kino Loy’s anger. Being the voice of truth carries this risk, when the man desperately clinging to a different belief system is at odds with that. Melshi’s obvious growing bond with Cassian happens largely offscreen and obviously during Season 1’s only significant time jump: the ‘thirty shifts later’ one. Kino refers with scorn to Keef’s escape plan being one worked out with ‘You and Birnok and Melshi!” and there’s real venom when he says the man’s name, but it’s made clear that the three men have been working on it for a while and have obviously tried to get Kino on board.
I think this sets Melshi up as a genuine ride-or-die character. His remaining season 1 scenes establish the kind of long-lasting friendship forged in the heat of adversity in a short space of time. ‘Comrades in arms’ might sound like a trope but I think it’s behind some of the strongest bonds in the whole story. In season 2 we see that fate/the Force is playing some hand here, if we want to see it that way, when Vel recognises Syril’s blaster from Aldhani. ‘Keef’ gave the weapon to Melshi three years before on the beach of Niamos before they parted ways, with Melshi saying “We have to tell people what’s happening!” in a way that connects absolutely to the Messenger motif once again.
Melshi’s last scene in the series connects with his last scene in Rogue One: he is briefly glimpsed in the final montage training the Pathfinders, and there are many faces there who are seen in the film too. Melshi’s death on a rewatch feels strangely detached now - he’s shot, communicates with Bodhi and then is seen dead on the ground moments later. He’s a Tony Gilroy character; Gilroy and Duncan Pow really hit it off during the Rogue One reshoots and the character was effectively promoted to named part on the back of that. He even leads the mission to extract Jyn on Wobani, which makes even more sense on the back of his ep 11 and 12 heroism and how well he works with K-2SO. But his death is unceremonious, one like so many others, and yet another person who Cassian never got to say goodbye to.
TLDR: My favourite Melshi line is a simple one, from the series, and is when Cassian says he needs an extra hand for the mission to investigate the distress signal (from Kleya). “Anything you need, Cass,” is the reply. There’s a comfort in knowing that Cassian had two of the best possible friends in Brasso and in Melshi. Both were always there for him; for as long as they could be.
Next time: Doctor Gorst
r/andor • u/MetallicaDash • 3h ago
Meme Anyone else think Darth Vader was a bit out of character here?
r/andor • u/GargantaProfunda • 8h ago
Articles & Links Eva Victor (they/them) on the 4K release of Andor S2: "I can make a call if it would be helpful. I'll call Disney."
Please do 😭
r/andor • u/Embarrassed-Phrase30 • 1d ago
General Discussion I got a picture with Denise Gough (Dedra Meero) in comic con today
I told her that I felt very bad for Dedra at the end of the show. She told me she didn't feel bad at all, you know your evil when even your actress hates you.
r/andor • u/Dear-Yellow-5479 • 5h ago
General Discussion The Eye (1.06) rewatch thoughts
- Every time I rewatch this I’m absolutely stunned by the visual beauty of the Eye itself and all the shots that incorporate it, whether as the focus or the background. On a good quality sound system you can really appreciate the craft Nicholas Britell put in to creating the literal sound of the Eye too. This natural phenomenon was first teased two episodes ago so the payoff is very important, and they landed it. I also love the genuine sense of awe created by focusing on the faces of those watching it.
- Cassian and Nemik’s conversation in the mist is so good. “Your my perfect reader” is a sentiment that Nemik might have rethought since discovering that Clem is a mercenary, but just as he says that an insurgency adapts so too he has adapted to the new information. It gives the moment when Vel hands over the manifesto even more poignancy. Of course it turns out that Cassian will be the perfect reader - he’s a Messenger, and this is one of the most important things that he ‘gathers as he goes’. But “You’ll sleep when it’s done” - ouch.
- Beehaz is so despicable. He’s still spouting racist comments about the stench of the Dhanis right up until the moment the rebels reveal themselves by pointing their blasters his way.
- Vel’s nerves really help to ramp up the tension in the first half of the episode as our suspense about whether she is going to give the go-ahead is shared by the men in the team. Her first time leading, and genuine danger. Sprinting across the top of the dam while Kimzi is occupied on the comms must be one of those ‘we just have to hope it works’! parts of the plan. I like the way Cinta gets her to lock in: I think Vel finds a lot of motivation from the relationship in a way that Luthen would probably find… complicated. A theme returned to in season 2.
- A nice pragmatic use of the Eye is the way the team use the early meteors as distractions and cover: eg. Vel and Cinta entering the water when they hear two coming knowing that the Imperials on the dam are likely to look up at them rather than across the water towards them. Skeen is also distracted by one but Cassian doesn’t look up: he’s fully locked in now.
- Still seeing Clem as the expendable-yet-skilled one, Vel instructs him to go first into the vault room. That plus calling him “ a disgusting bastard” when he tells her he killed Skeen shows how much their relationship will change in time. But there’s clearly a realisation that he might be right, and a decent man, when he returns the Kuati Signet. Great payoff for Skeen’s challenge over it in the previous episode.
- Beehaz dropping with a heart attack is such delicious irony remembering that he told his son “You’ll make an effort tonight if it kills you!”
- The shootout is vicious and very rapidly edited. Gorn is the first to fall but it is easy to miss. Horrible but realistic that the team don’t seem as affected by his death as by Taramyn’s - they didn’t have as much time with Gorn over those last five months.
- Nemik getting crushed is still horrific to watch - and hear. Horrifically realistic sound design. The weight of capital, indeed. I feel bad for Vel here as well because Skeen in particular paints her as the cold hearted pragmatist that we later know she isn’t: “She doesn’t want to jeopardise the mission” by taking him to the doctor, Skeen tells Clem.
- Great moment when you can see Cassian’s natural empathy kicking in - great subtle acting from Diego Luna too - when he simply goes back to the cockpit and says “How do we get to the doctor?”
- Killing Skeen is the only time when Cassian looks angry when taking a life. He’s not just rejecting that version of himself in the mirror Skeen was holding up to him, he’s also hating the proposition of leaving people behind. And lying (or at least being misleading) about a lost sibling. There’s real disgust as well as pragmatism behind that quick-draw kill. Skeen pushed Cassian’s berserk buttons without even realising it.
- Unexpected for me on the first watch that Cassian isn’t all-in with the rebellion after that but fully understandable. He’s not there yet. But he’s on the way, even if it’s the “long way round”.
- Luthen’s laugh and sigh of relief : no words. Literally. Great way to end a genuine masterpiece of a ‘pay-off’ episode.
Your thoughts?
r/andor • u/SirVulpes- • 7h ago
General Discussion Andor really showed why the Empire was doomed (systemically.) Spoiler
Spoilers for the end of Andor and the Star Wars trilogy (not the sequels or prequels.)
I don’t think we’ve ever really gotten a good look at the politics of the Empire from the inside at least not like we did in Andor (well maybe in legends, I haven’t read it). We usually see things from the rebel alliances perspective although that limits how much we know about the Empire. If you really want to understand a society you have to look at how the average person lives in it and also its officials.
Andor made it pretty clear the Empire is a people crushing machine similar to it’s real life counterparts although leaving aside our reality for a moment; you can see some of the trends that led to the empires downfall mainly sadism, arrogance, vanity..
The rebels finest agents were not Cassian, Luke, Leia, etc but Palapatine and Tarkin. These two men formed the Empire and its basis for oppressing the galaxy (the Tarkin doctrine) and by extension set in place the policies that would destroy what they made.
In the context of the show; the Empire cracked down far too hard on Ghorman, Ferrix, etc and created the circumstances that would led to the galaxy joining the rebellion just as Lutheran wanted. The Empire turned civilians who otherwise would have continued living out their regular lives or possibly sympathized with the Empire into rebels thanks to the Tarkin doctrine and Palpatine’s vanity project (the Death Star, which in itself was a representation of the Empire putting its own vanity ahead of actually governing.)
Tarkin and Palpatine created the conditions that allowed someone like Director Kreenic to rise through the ranks and have power over competent ISB officers would have been a lot better to the Empire alive and serving rather than dead or in prison.
r/andor • u/Dear-Yellow-5479 • 8h ago
Articles & Links The Ferrix funeral sequence was shot on phones first like a “science project”
instagram.comInteresting clip from a podcast interview with Tony Gilroy, discussing the use of diegetic music in Behemoth! and Andor.
Real World Politics "We are the Ghor." Today is the 13th anniversary of a protest that ended in February with 108 civilians dead, except this time, they sang their anthem and won.
This footage is from Kyiv's Independence Square (Maidan) on February 18, 2014, near the end of Ukraine's Revolution of Dignity, which began 13 years ago today on November 21, 2013. Peaceful protests started after President Viktor Yanukovych abandoned a promised EU association deal, then grew into a mass movement after riot police beat students and parliament passed sweeping anti-protest laws in January.
That night, security forces tried to clear the square with stun grenades, water cannons, and live fire. Across three months, 108 civilians (the Heavenly Hundred) and 13 police officers were killed, mostly by snipers on February 20. By February 22, Yanukovych had fled, parliament voted 328 to 0 to remove him and restore the 2004 constitution, and democratic elections followed in May.
The Ghorman sequence felt as real as it did because moments like this actually happen, right down to a cornered crowd singing their anthem in a burning square.
r/andor • u/Independent-Dig-5757 • 23h ago
Media & Art Thanks to Andor, you can now make the French flag with Imperial officer tunics
r/andor • u/Accomplished-Job3522 • 1d ago
Question Would Luthen have sacrificed Mon Mothma for Lonni?
I’ve been thinking about this. If there was someone from the ISB on Bale Organa’s team—and Luthen knows this because Lonni told him—then why allow Bale’s men the chance to reach her? If you already know something is wrong within the other team, why not tell her so she can go straight to Cassian, without the added risk of being arrested by Bale’s team? Well, I think that for Luthen, protecting Lonni was more important than protecting Mon Mothma. It was extremely risky for anyone to know that information, or even to suspect it. It was more practical—from his perspective—to let Mon be killed after her arrest (should that happen) than to risk losing Lonni.
r/andor • u/GargantaProfunda • 1d ago
Articles & Links [Polygon] EXCLUSIVE: Andor's creator wonders if Star Wars is 'brave' enough to continue his story
At a press junket for Gilroy’s upcoming film, Behemoth!, Polygon asked the director about the future of the Andor story. Could we see more stories featuring the characters he introduced, especially considering how much he and the rest of the Andor team introduced to Star Wars' overall canon?
“I don't see how it cannot affect it canonically,” Gilroy said. “We built a lot of canon over 24 hours. I mean, we stuck to canon a lot, but we created a lot of IP, a lot of characters, a lot of different things. I left them with a baby. One would think that at some point someone's gonna continue that."
More in the link
r/andor • u/Dear-Yellow-5479 • 1d ago
General Discussion “Why Disney hasn’t tried to milk ‘Andor’ for all it’s worth” and thoughts on expanding the story
The recent Polygon article re. whether “more Andor is on the way” quoted Tony Gilroy as saying that it would be down to “What the appetite is from the audience and what the bravery is of the people that are gonna sign the checks”. I think this links more to what he’s said before about how Andor is unlikely to be the kind of production that would be green-lit again, considering the huge financial cost, the on-location shooting and the way it first came out at the peak of the streaming era. But another article has posited another reason:
“As for why Disney hasn’t tried to milk Andor for all its worth, well, that’s one of the smartest Star Wars decisions it’s made outside of making Andor. It’d be like asking a Speak & Spell to write Shakespeare” writes Mike Redmond in this article https://www.pajiba.com/news/tony-gilroy-actually-wants-disney-to-make-more-andor-without-him.php
Redmond also states that he disagrees ‘with my Lord and Savior’ Gilroy over wanting more. Hmm, I don’t personally get the impression from his quotes that Gilroy particularly wants them to expand on his story, just that he would be surprised if they don’t.
Like a lot of people, I’m torn. If you find something you love and that is effectively perfect, it’s natural to want more. At the same time, more can risk not only not being as good but damaging the original by association. To look at the most commonly proposed ‘spin-offs’:
Kleya and Vel hunting Imperial remnants in the New Republic, with possible help (Hannibal Lecter style) from Dedra. Advantages: Kleya is a fan-favourite and it could follow a procedural format allowing for extra seasons if it does well. Alternatively, it could be a film. Disadvantages: this is exactly the ‘adventure a week’ format that Gilroy was wary of because it would quickly run out of steam. Plus, it could ruin the complexity of the characters in the way some have already claimed has happened with Ahsoka and Mon Mothma (I can’t comment - I haven’t see it).
Something set decades later featuring Bix & Cassian’s child as an adult. Advantages: the child is a complete blank slate so there’s none of that ‘having to get the character right’ challenge. The child could be male or female. It could be Force sensitive (the hints about Bix’s slight powers paying dividends). It could even be an ‘Andor’ as it’s left open as to whether Cassian and Bix were married for real. Disadvantages: the inevitable comparisons with the original. Also, I for one love the way the ending implies that this child will have a happy and peaceful life because of their parents’ sacrifices… and any spinoff is going destroy that as no-one is going to watch something about a peaceful farmer or mechanic or whatever.
I think the single biggest disadvantage with both ideas is the probable absence of the Andor writers.
Far better, imho, to keep Andor characters appearances as brief cameos in other productions, just as is happening with the novels due next year.
I seriously hope they leave Andor be. Having said that, I think that of the two options the child is the one they would be more attracted to simply because it is a blank canvas of a character. But to quote Mike Redmond: “I do not trust a single soul inside Disney and/or Lucasfilm to touch his baby, figurative or literally”.
r/andor • u/Dear-Yellow-5479 • 1d ago
General Discussion ‘The Axe Forgets’ (1.05) rewatch thoughts
One of my favourite episodes of season 1. Entirely ‘build-up’, one could argue, but the character and relationship building via top-tier dialogue and thematic connections makes it a winner. Apologies for the length but it’s a long and densely packed episode.
- Syril begins and ends his day thinking about Cassian. In the opening shot, he lifts his head into the brief reflection of sunlight from a window many levels above, and then it’s gone. Then in the final moments, he’s seen back in his bedroom at the close of day obsessively staring at Cassian’s image. In retrospect, all excellent setting up of what’s to come.
- This is continued in the first Cassian and Skeen scene, where Skeen is going through “Clem”’s things, supposedly on Vel’s request. The title drop comes in this scene, and one interesting connection comes when Skeen picks up the PreMor blaster - Syril’s - and asks “Whose did you say this was?”. Cassian’s reply is : “I didn’t get a name”. It sounds badass, of course, but it’s also quite literal - Cassian is already forgetting the man who is now completely obsessed with him. “The axe forgets but the tree remembers”, in another context.
- Eedy and Syril… the first of the cereal scenes has a particularly revealing moment. Telling him off for slouching, his mother tells Syril “You might as well wear a sign that says, ‘I promise to disappoint you’”. Syril had been staring at a piece of cereal but at this his gaze snaps towards Eedy, implying she’s hit a nerve. Of course it’s an incredibly toxic relationship but I think he genuinely wants to make her proud in a ‘proving her wrong’ kind of way. The parallels and contrasts with the Cassian and Maarva relationship are fascinating.
- The revelation that Cassian has had three years in youth prison from the age of 13 connects with the fact he has a prison record… but we won’t know the reason why he was sent there for another two episodes. Yet again, Clem Andor will be on his mind there. A new real life detail for me: Ebon-Moss Bachrach reveals not just prison tattoos on his bare chest but also - if you have a screen with sharp resolution - goosebumps. The poor guy must have been freezing.
- Another great part of the Cassian and Skeen relationship is when Skeen yet again takes his stuff and there’s a brief scuffle. Cassian (snarling “Don’t ever!” like a teenager) comes over very much as if he’s been a victim of bullying before, and even the absence of prison gang tattoos (in contrast to Skeen) might feed Skeen’s suspicion that Cassian is more of a genuine loner. “Working with other people is never easy” says Cassian. Skeen replies “Yeah, I didn’t mark you for a team player”. All very ironic considering the events at the end of the next episode.
- The ‘bullied in an institution and really hating being reminded of that’ vibe with Cassian continues when his training involves Taramyn attempting to physically correct him. “Don’t touch me!” contrasts nicely with when Nemik lays a comforting hand on Cassian’s shoulder after the TIE buzzes them. “Surprise from above is never as shocking as one from below” is another banger of a line.
- Nemik in general is so likeable that watching this episode is especially moving, considering his pending fate but also knowing the impact that he is genuinely having here on Cassian - who will end up spreading his message by taking the manifesto, even though he’s not quite ready yet to absorb the contents. Here, Nemik is genuinely full of the enthusiasm and optimism of youth and is so disappointed to hear that Clem is a mercenary. Wise move of Cassian to reveal that though.
- The Chez-Mothma breakfast scene is still deeply uncomfortable to watch. Visually stunning, but the strained relationships create a powerfully unhappy atmosphere. Perrin looks used to riding out what he no doubt views as his wife being over-dramatic.
- Vel’s jealousy re Clem with Cinta is a nice bit of humour in the episode, but I think her insecurities are real. More connected with the mission itself, but Clem is an easy target to deflect these too. Cinta meanwhile is largely inscrutable but there’s a genuine smile when she’s feeding the drays (and i in real life, Varada Sethu adored the sheep) and when listening to Nemik being adorably nerdy.
- The score in this episode features three absolute masterpieces: If I was Them when Dedra and Heert’s late session segues into when the team leave the camp (hooray that they released the drays!) and then the double bill of The Valley and Tomorrow at the end of the episode. All are tracks I can play daily and never tire of.
- Kleya’s concern over Luthen’s nervousness this night before the heist connects really well now to season 2 when she loses her own composure when he loses his (in 2.05). Here, she’s the calm anchor who steadies him. You can also read concern for her specifically when he asks if she’s checked her walk-away pack.
r/andor • u/reyansh6759 • 1d ago
General Discussion What is the single greatest 60 seconds of pure dialogue in all of Star Wars?
r/andor • u/GargantaProfunda • 1d ago
Articles & Links Dave Filoni (Lucasfilm president) poses with Tony Gilroy and Pedro Pascal to celebrate 'Behemoth!,' Gilroy's first project since 'Andor'
https://www.instagram.com/p/Df8KDeutl5t/
I have friends everywhere.
BEHEMOTH!’s Pedro Pascal & Tony Gilroy were joined by Dave Filoni to celebrate the upcoming film, in theaters December 4.
r/andor • u/Financial_Photo_1175 • 1d ago
General Discussion There’s no way this person actually watched the show
Also Imperial backstabbing has been a staple of Star Wars media for so long now. Idk how they can say this. Found this comment on this sub actually.
r/andor • u/MetallicaDash • 2d ago
Meme Why didn't Keef just comply with the Officer's instructions in this scene and obey the law if he didn't want to go to prison?
r/andor • u/Dear-Yellow-5479 • 2d ago
General Discussion ‘Aldhani’ (1.04) rewatch thoughts
- As I noticed when doing the ‘first scene’ posts there is a huge number of new characters introduced in this episode including several major ones and a lot who are central either to this arc or to the whole series going forward. Once again I’m thinking that it’s not only possible to rewatch Andor and enjoy it more but that it’s practically demanded, because I remember being pretty overwhelmed with all the new faces.
- Aldhani is so very obviously the Scottish Highlands for anyone who’s been there but it’s so beautiful and wild I don’t blame them for not making it look more ‘alien’. I love that you can easily see how cold and damp it is in most of the shots. The fact that the multi-horned sheep are a genuine breed particularly delights me.
- I think Luthen was genuinely surprised by what a tough time Cassian gave him during the attempted recruitment. I don’t think he was expecting to have to offer money, but it shows his desperation for Aldhani to work. The offer of the Kuati Signet felt like a genuinely spontaneous statement of faith in Cassian this time; before season 2 I had a more cynical view of Luthen’s motivations here. “You appeared when I needed you” indeed.
- Luthen suddenly bellowing “Look at me!” at Vel still makes me jump. He plays her masterfully in that conversation but you can see how committed she is too with her eventual acceptance of this mercenary, despite knowing she’s in for a tough time back at camp.
- The Vel & Cassian scenes are a great reminder now of how much both characters change and grow over the next five years. Vel’s obvious irritation and resentment makes the mutual suspicion between Cassian and the others seem particularly realistic. According to the BTS ‘declassified’ mini docs on the blu-ray, Diego Luna didn’t rehearse with either the Aldhani team actors or the Narkina table 5 crew, so he would more realistically feel like an outsider coming to an existing group.
- Cassian choosing ‘Clem’ as his alias is really poignant.
- Cassian’s utter horror at the news about the previously unmentioned garrison that they will be “taking on” is the first in a bit of a running motif right through to Rogue One. He’ll have taken on quite a few garrisons by then. His incredulity at the news that it will be “Seven against a garrison?!” will eventually convert to “Make ten men feel like a hundred”.
- The Dedra-Blevin-Partagaz and ISB scenes in general are a delight. Who would have thought that the office politics of the Empire could be so riveting?
- Never has the galaxy far far away felt less glamorous as when Syril plods back to his mother’s apartment. The music score plods down the scale too as he descends in the elevator into the dingy grey world of his childhood home. The CGI reimagining of the real life London location (Brunswick House) is incredibly well done.
- Ditto the first Mon & Luthen scene where both Skarsgård and O’Reilly masterfully slip in and out of character. Such a fantastic scene on every level.
Any favourite moments from this episode?