r/anime
•
u/AutoLovepon
https://anilist.co/user/AutoLovepon
•
29d ago
•
1
1
Episode Romelia War Chronicle • Romelia Senki - Episode 4 discussion
Romelia Senki, episode 4
Reminder: Please do not discuss plot points not yet seen or skipped in the show. Failing to follow the rules may result in a ban.
Streams
Show information
All discussions
| Episode | Link |
|---|---|
| 1 | Link |
| 2 | Link |
| 3 | Link |
| 4 | Link |
| 5 | Link |
| 6 | Link |
| 7 | Link |
| 8 | Link |
This post was created by a bot. Message the mod team for feedback and comments. The original source code can be found on GitHub.
•
u/AnimeMod myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan 29d ago
Source Material Corner
Reply to this comment for any source-related discussion, future spoilers (including future characters, events and general hype about future content), comparison of the anime adaptation to the original or just general talk about the source material. You are still required to tag all spoilers. Discussions about the source outside of this comment tree will be removed, and replying with spoilers outside of the source corner will lead to bans.
The spoiler syntax is:
[Spoiler source] >!Spoiler goes here!<All untagged spoilers and hints in this thread will receive immediate 8-day bans (minimum).
150
u/epicfail1994 29d ago
I really like how this anime emphasizes tactics and that Romelia’s skill is as a commander more than anything else- and that she’s good at it
149
u/froggyc19 29d ago
Man I'm really hating Ray. He's hot headed, weak, a simp, and doesn't listen. He's going to get more people hurt if he doesn't shape up.
125
u/djthomp https://anilist.co/user/djthomp 29d ago edited 29d ago
I love the focus on small military group tactics, it's not something I feel like I've seen much in the anime I've watched. Unfortunately for Romelia and her guys it was probably inevitable that they'd eventually run into something that they were not prepared for given the scale of the problem and the demon army invasion we saw start last episode.
Interesting detail of Romelia understanding what the demons were saying but her troops couldn't, probably for the better.
I wonder if this will be the sort of thing where Al or Ray's magic wakes up from the stress of the moment and helps him deal with the current problem. If so I somewhat hope it's
AlRay since he kind of needs a win, but he's also been so reckless I'm not sure he deserves one at the moment.90
u/happy-owls 29d ago
I really appreciate the amount of stakes this show has. Asides from Al throwing death flags left and right, I genuinely got chills just by the mere appearance of the first demon soldier showing up, thinking Romelia's cast is currently vastly under-leveled for that. Its a nice change from other recent shows where it feels the entire cast consistently has plot armor.
75
u/ObvsThrowaway5120 29d ago
Oh boy, I can’t wait to see Administrator Shitbag’s face when he finds out Romelia’s safe. I’m sure she’ll be fine. It’s the unit I’m worried about. Those greater demons aren’t like the other demons they’re encountered. These are trained soldiers in the demon lord’s army. The unit might encounter some casualties…
93
u/deynyel 29d ago
At this rate, Serbeck's gonna destroy everything in that room out of rage.
109
u/Obaruler 29d ago
Honestly? What's the local Administrators problem?
Yes, she demands supplies that he wanted to keep for himself, but ultimately, in the long run, if the villages keep getting destroyed there'll be no more income and even the Fortress City might get threatened at some point. She's doing him a solid by keeping revenues flowing with such a small party of soldiers.
I guess the inbred local nobility really isn't top tier material ...
49
u/SOdAchick 28d ago
As soon as we started spending so time with Al and his men were talking him up, I knew he was about to die. Hopefully he survives, but that extra time with a side character always means death
73
u/diacewrb 29d ago
Ray's horse :(
72
u/PhantomWolf83 29d ago
Ray and Al having their C-level support convo. Also the weapon triangle, axes beats lances!
"We'll have our fun with her." Ohhh shit, this is one of those works, huh?
56
u/D3k4s 29d ago
That smile that damn smile. She knows what's up.
I liked how they showed the Army repairing infrastructure, it's actually something that is quite common as far back as Roman legionaries. Usually it was more faced towards bridges and forts, but seeing as that town had fortifications and bridges it seems fitting.
Those battle formations were pretty satisfying to look at. However I don't think they'll get away without any casualties, especially considering they mentioned that Romelia's horse fled in a panic.
I'll have to say it again, the lack of any inner monologues ups the game so much. We are left to judge by ourselves how strong those greater demons are, so much so that when those other ones showed up I legit felt the threat. I suddenly lost confidence in Romelia's ability to defeat those enemies.
Solid episode.
52
u/LeonKevlar x2https://myanimelist.net/profile/LeonKevlar 29d ago
I got really excited when Romelia wanted to check if any of her men had magic aptitude. It's about time to upgrade some units! While I do like that Al and Ray have the capacity to use magic, I was hoping it would be someone else in the group.
Godfuckingdammit, Ray! You're gonna get yourself killed! He's so desperate to show Romelia that he's useful that he's putting lives in danger! I am glad that Romelia immediately reprimanded Ray for his rash actions.
It's cool to see other characters besides Al and Ray are finally getting some attention. The Twins especially have been really great with their teamwork, Otto is an absolute beast of a tank, and I feel like Kyle would be better as a scout unit with a bow instead of a spear.
So it turns out, even if Al and Ray both have magic aptitude, actually learning magic takes money and time, both of which they really don't have right now. Shit. Seems like Romelia might just need to win more battles and get some notoriety; maybe they can get a mage to join their unit to teach Al and Ray.
The fact that Romelia's entire unit is struggling against a single greater demon shows how powerful the demon lord's army is. No wonder the King can't spare any more units to guard the hinterlands. They need everyone they can on the front lines.
Please tell me I'm not the only one who absolutely loves seeing Romelia and the boys when they're in formation? Something about it is just so cool to me.
WHAT THE FUCK, RAY?! Not only did you get your horse killed, but you also got Al injured from trying to protect your ass! I'm really hoping Romelia's Grace kicked in with that gamble when she tried to lure the demons in to use bombs. I can't wait to see Serbeck's face when he eventually learns that Romelia survived.
14
u/AKAvenger 28d ago
“How did that little girl win?!” Uh…years of experience?
50
u/AceSoldia https://anilist.co/user/Acesoldia 29d ago
Damnit Ray you have literally one job!. Nobody got time for your high school crush on Romelia!
Although I understand 😂
30
u/FarCritical 29d ago
The amount of raw menace in Romelia's expression from being asked about magic though. Everything's still speculation when it comes to her but it makes sense for it to be one of her more blatant sore spots.
Genuinely unnerving how raw tactics barely work against a greater demon, especially after watching the squad's be on a roll because of it.
51
u/PeaceAlien https://myanimelist.net/profile/PeaceAlien 29d ago
Short 4 episode series, thanks for watching everyone. /s
Wonder if we're going to see Romelia's actual ability/strength now?
26
u/Technical-Question16 29d ago
So we had Ray fail in the first mission (excusable, the fighting was new to everyone), we do not know how the following missions proceeded, and now he ignored direct orders twice in two consecutive missions, both times putting others in danger without achieving anything. I do realize that his growth is supposed to be part of the plot, but we are deep within the court-marshal territory now.
20
u/thisisdropd https://myanimelist.net/profile/AsterZoro 29d ago edited 29d ago
Fourth time's the charm for Sherbeck, I guess. His tantrums grew larger and larger until he broke his own window. He could now revel in the schadenfreude of Romelia being MIA. Having said that, his joy would certainly be short-lived. I hope we get to eventually see his mood crashing down even harder when she survived the ordeal, and somehow he lost his position.
Yeah, this had been her unit's first real challenge with Al out of commission and a couple of his colleagues tasked with shielding him. Looking forward to seeing how they'd get out of this.
Love how Romelia's not some OP heroine and that her strength lied in her strategy and leadership. She openly demonstrated that she's got no magic affinity, yet her men's loyalty remain unwavering.
14
u/reaperow 28d ago edited 28d ago
Romelia and her team are performing very well, i really wouldn't be surprised if she turned out to the brains of the Hero's Party
Ray kinda has an inferiority complex but he should take some pride in knowing that his and everyone else's actions positively affected the Villagers' lives especially those kids,
I hope he can reflect upon himself now that his decision had serious consequences which lead to Al getting injured
Im genuinely enjoying this show so far and it's's one of my favourites of this season. Im looking forward to next weeks ep with this cliffhanger
19
u/Calenmir 29d ago
This is my most expected show each week. I really enjoy what they will be up to each week.
I guess they are trying to setup some redeeming arc for Ray but he is one of the most annoying characters in a while at the moment.
17
u/shad79 https://myanimelist.net/profile/shad79 29d ago edited 29d ago
It was a fun episode, especially thanks to Sebreck's reactions to Romelia and her unit's successes, lol...
Or at least it was until the end, when Romelia's unit encountered Demon King's army soldiers, and we cut to the report about their disappearance.
Damn, I was so annoyed when Sebreck got so happy upon hearing that news, but that will only make his reaction when he discovers that Romelia and her unit survived (and maybe even defeated all those demon soldiers) much better.
Here my screenshot albums from the episode:
EDIT. I added my screenshot albums.
25
u/VritraReiRei 29d ago
I appreciate that Administrator Serbeck is more of a passive Antagonist rather than a, "Oh you need supplies to repair the village?Ah... that's quite troublesome, I don't have any we can spare but I'll definitely order some 😅" (read: "Like HELL I'm helping!")
I'm sure they will all make it out and we will all revel at the Admin's crashout.
I'm just waiting for her [Lady Luck] to activate and see how it gets her out of this situation.
16
u/PerfectBeige https://myanimelist.net/profile/perfectbeige 29d ago
The greater demons appear to be lizards, so I hope Romelia starts employing anti-lizard techniques, such as baiting them with live crickets, and calming them down with heat lamps.
Look, I'm just trying to help. Spears didn't do squat, it's time to think outside the box.
20
u/tripleaamin https://myanimelist.net/profile/tripleaamin 29d ago
I think the contrast between the first and 2nd halves of the episode is that Romelia has been smart in choosing her battles. I think this shows she is very effective as a leading commander for her men. If you go into battles way above your weight class it doesn't matter how good your tactics are. Still curious instead of a bear them running into the Demon Lord's men. Curious if that was pure accident or if Serbeck's work is at play. Though he seems incompetent.
So Ray and Al have potential in magic. It's clear that Ray is the one that is going through a potential character arc. He wants to prove himself, but constantly him being reckless is an issue. In the 2nd instance Al got hurt to protect him. I think this is an important moment to show that reckless actions have consequences. I do hope with Romelia's luck that Al's wound isn't fatal at least.
Furthermore, I think it's clear that Romelia aims to retreat, but what is the plan now for her?
19
u/giantdancer 28d ago
I thought this was going to be a slop anime. I don't know about you guys but this is peak to me
15
u/Mr_Zaroc https://myanimelist.net/profile/mr_zaroc 28d ago
Well I am not surprised, Al was collecting those flags like free candy
At least he isnt dead yet, quite the cliffhanger they left us with, but I am sure they are somehow save
Ray really needs to get his shit together though
18
u/Raymond49090 29d ago
Of course it's the two most protagonist-like characters in her unit with the magic affinities.
Admin-san should stop malding and just be happy someone's doing his job for him.
A battle with giant boars is the fastest way to show the unit's growth, as well as Ray's teething issues.
Seriously, what's Admin-san's problem? Is he mad that he has to pay for repairs? Is he secretly working with the demons? Or is he just a natural-born hater?
Oof, a curveball on their fifth mission. That's rough. And Ray's issues with charging ahead rears its ugly head. And it's not just one, but an entire unit of demons. What happened to Romelia's minor plot armour?
... Man, f*** Admin-san.
24
u/Weak-Comfortable3765 29d ago
This is the anime of the season for me, pretty handily. Every week has been real solid.
10
u/Nicane__ 28d ago
perhaps ive seen too much anime but it was so predictable everything that happened this chapter... i mean didnt expect those soldiers at the end but everything prior that was obvious... blue hair guy is very annoyign and doesnt hear nor understands anything said to him, well about the fat dude at the castle well i hope he dies soon.
5
u/Past_Distribution144 28d ago
Ya.. was just wondering when Al was going to get killed/injured in some horific way, and what Ray was doing that would cause it. Knew it would happen, dude was too perfect, and Ray was too eager. Did not expect it this early though.
That fat lord is becoming a pain; he is so upset that he is being forced to do... the bare minimum at his job.
5
u/Shiririe 24d ago
Thank God the ending song is so Calming... Otherwise I'm malding over Ray!
16
u/Difergion 29d ago
Al kept on flashing all those death flags ever since their first mission, but looks like he’ll survive if Romelia still has the situation in control. I do hope he survives though, I’d rather see Ray overcome his insecurities without him dying.
Hmm seems like Romelia’s squad had most things within control until the demon soldiers arrived. I don’t think the administrator is colluding with them, right?
I wonder how they’ll survive this battle, especially without any help coming their way.
18
u/Myrkrvaldyr 29d ago
Damn these five minute episodes. Romelia's unit has made a lot of progress and they move fast and follow orders neatly. Ray is too hasty and is desperate to prove himself, which resulted in Al's serious injury. I appreciate that magic isn't easy to acquire and they can't make use of that yet. Despite the good formations and training, they found an enemy they couldn't beat.
Also, what's that shitty lord's dead? He's angry Romelia was stacking up wins and is now happy she failed. Maybe jealousy she's proven competent while he does nothing?
14
u/saumanahaii 29d ago
so she totally kept some sort of emergency weapon for when this inevitably happened, didn't she?
8
u/VedantaxBuddha 29d ago
Serbeck should be grateful.
I really hope nobody dies...
4
u/Rooby_VTuber 28d ago
Stop trying too hard and being reckless Ray, you are not useless with or without magic.
Thank goodness Al is around, a perfect leader who can motivate and encourage the others around him.
Those demons were really strong, what an unfortunate encounter.
Cliffhanger ending, now to wait to see if Romelia and her unit were able to escape or not.
4
u/catferret8 28d ago
This show is really good, I like the small scale human elements and I really hope they survive
4
u/zappingbluelight 28d ago
Not saying I see it coming, but it was obvious that Al will actually be Ray's growth. I hope he actually survive. And Ray's character growth even a little from this experience.
I'm happy there are actual tactic on retreating, rather than blind running in all the time. But it will be obvious, they are gonna need to learn magic to defeat the enemy.
7
u/hiimneato 28d ago
I'm enjoying this show a lot, but I keep noticing how inconsistent it is.
The story? Great. The character writing? Hit or miss. Performances? Sometimes tight and nuanced, sometimes comically clumsy. We love Romelia. Her father's restrained, conflicted noble dignity worked. The hero's party were... a joke, but it's not like we were supposed to respect them.
Art crisp and clean if uninspired. Character designs reasonably practical and decent-looking. Visual progression of the episode unremarkable, which means more or less successful. But the storyboarding and keys of the action scenes? An absolute shambles. I can't even criticize the choreography because there isn't any. As soon as there's any kind of action at all, the whole thing falls apart. That demon killed the dumb blue kid's horse out from underneath him with impeccable timing and superhuman strength and speed, and then just... stood there with his axe raised for several seconds while the stupid red kid ran all the way across the battlefield to jump in front of the blow. What? Why? How?
Romelia's sharp tactical command shows. She orders formations and the men she's drilled actually follow. That part works. But also for some reason one of her two commanders just fucking sulks all the time and keeps ignoring orders so he can run off and fail pitifully? Why is she good at command sometimes, but she won't bust Ray's dumb ass back down from bodyguard to footsoldier until he learns to fucking listen?
And then there's a dragon ball crater meme joke right in the middle of a dramatic action moment? Who... what... what are you even trying to accomplish rrraaaaaaaaaaaaghhhhh why
But then there's music, and it's great! As you'd expect from staff that worked on 86. The score isn't, like, Evan Call great, but it's good, and the musical direction has nice timing and well-chosen tone.
It can't decide what it wants to be. The parallelisms of the reports to the administrator? Funny running joke. But isn't he also supposed to be sinister? Is this a dramatic show or a goofy-ass comedy? Is it a war story or a slice-of-life visual novel where some backcountry soldiers go on scenic hikes and help out villages and once in a while there's an unconvincing slideshow fight where suspenseful framing and setup is completely undermined by a lack of any sense of weight to the threadbare action?
9
u/NonSupportiveCup 29d ago
Well, I think we could all see this turn of events coming as far as the Ray plot has been going.
Still very effective.
I understand why they keep flipping to the asshat ruler whose title I forget, but their is no way other people don't know he is lying if he is destroying things every time he gets good news.
Works as a gag, I guess. But hopefully it comes back as a plot point for the probable disobedient subjects arc I think will happen in the future.
8
u/goddessofthewinds :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/SpiritOfTheWinds 29d ago
Man, this show is a blast. We all know Ray is going to grow up since he's been quite in the forefront for a while, but wow, he's currently super annoying.
I love how Romey use strategy and command to fight her way. She has no aptitude for fighting, but she's a dang good commander. I just hope we get more details on her Grace skill.
3
u/MammonOftheMist https://myanimelist.net/profile/lordyuk1 28d ago
im just watching anime, why do I have to get reminded about my position 2 diving for kills which causes everyone to get killed.
3
u/Motor-Rich6283 28d ago
As expected of Ray. Being a naive boy in the squad will cause a lot trouble.
Otto was right. Al and Ray were too selfish since they were quite special. The difference Al was doing better than Ray.
3
u/IAmTheOldCrow 26d ago
As a long-time miniatures wargamer, this episode made me smile. So many *live action* stories completely ignore proper formations and just show a bunch of guys screaming and waving swords around.
Memories of watching Rollo Lothbrok in Vikings bellow "SHIELD WALL!" and me going "Yeah!" ;)
7
u/S627 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Spartan627 29d ago
Whelp, guess that answers my question about the Administrator, dude acts like he cares but for some reason has a massive stick up his ass.
7
u/noblegeas https://anilist.co/user/noblegeas 28d ago
I hope the resolution isn't about Ray having an awakening with his magic power. The show seems too smart for that so far, but it doesn't have my full trust because Romelia turned out to have a secret special power that clearly turned the tides for the hero party. On the other hand, the current losses show that the luck is pretty minor; it's pretty damn unlucky to encounter demons too strong for the party she was level grinding. Evidently it's not just the world aligning to support what she needs (because the demons and the seeds of Ray's issues existed before she encountered them), so everything she sets up that succeeds is actually caused by hard work. Since we see the report in the aftermath (indicating it's not resolved immediately) I'm looking forward to seeing it resolved with Romelia's tactics, but I'm still in "we'll see" mode.
I'm not actually as annoyed at Ray as I normally would be, probably because there isn't much time spent on listening to him whining about it. Instead I see it from a more distant view; yes, his actions are his fault, but Romelia is in charge. She knew he was becoming a problem, and she wasn't shown doing much to address it.
I really appreciated Romelia's moments of explaining everyone's contributions because I didn't catch all of it, in addition to showing that she is a good commander who can properly show appreciation for and motivate her troops. The tactics themselves seem pretty basic, but it's unusual that they're even used. Still, I'm not familiar with all of them so I'll rely on the threads to tell me what e.g. the formations are for, because the show apparently won't. It's cool that they have to use some level of tactics even against the weak monsters, and that they need prep work.
It seems that her experiences with the hero party wouldn't have given a lot of chances to get good at using these tactics, so I wonder how she learned all that. She's currently leading 20 human-strength normal soldiers with similar training (with a few being a bit stronger than the others) whereas it seems like she previously followed four superhumans with varied abilities who didn't need it and wouldn't have respected her enough to listen to commands.
5
u/eggplant_avenger 28d ago
Al’s horse is kind of a badass for being able to jump that extremely high barrier. But what else is new, Al is just like that
I like that Romelia has the soldiers digging and building, plus the scenes showing morale and unit spirit, etc.
5
u/Popular_Season2025 28d ago
Why are multiple people throwing in sand at the same time right next to each other? There would be no way to know who it is reacting to and they would have to do it again and waste the sand.
Why are they throwing in the sand with gloves on? Is the sand so magic it doesn't need skin contact and can detect who threw it through the gloves?
7
u/Nachtwandler_FS https://myanimelist.net/profile/Nachtwandler_21 29d ago
As a Warhammer fantasy fan. This is what you get than regular empire state troopers have to fight Saurus.
But I do hope Romelia had a plan to get the demons of them. Still, ending the episode on cliffhanger was criminal.
4
u/AlFlux 28d ago
So mad that this was the week I decided to start watching this one. Why did I land such a killer cliffhanger?
If this anime keeps up the quality, then this could be my AOTS for sure. Spears, small scale tactics, competent but not overpowered MC, threats that actually feel like threats; my I am positively pissed I have to wait a week to find out what happens.
Will our protag retreat or will she win the fight? I have high hopes that this author can make either happen intelligently, but I've seen too many anime start smart and finish dumb. If this fight resolves logically without OP power, I think I might just become a believer.
2
u/-whiteroom- 28d ago
Picked this one up late and am enjoying it.
Don't know if im crazy or not, but there seems to be a falling off of the animation since the first episode.
2
u/Feyascia 28d ago
Ray. You effing idiot. She is a brilliant commander, and she's going to do her best work if she doesn't have to keep looking over her shoulder. Guarding her is a position of A LOT of trust and importance. Al attacks; he's her spear. You protect; you're her shield.
2
u/RetroHero20 28d ago
Ray is rly ruining the show for me. The past 2 episodes have jst been everyone but Ray improving. The guy gets sweet talked by jst abt anything, it's annoying how Al jst treats him like some kid. The dude is either playing the white knight, being depressed over his inferiority complex, gaining an ego over nothing, or charging in like a untrained dog. I rly think he should jst be sent home alr, this dudes gonna get someone killed.
2
u/Player_One_1 27d ago
I was so exited about this show, my favourite this season so far. But this episode seems like "begging of end" for this show and starts to turn back into "regular" stuff. There is still plenty of room to recover, but my outlooks are not so great any more.
Soldiers helping village and being suspired by armed men approaching? Even at peace time a unit must have a lookout and not get approached so easily, even when helping villagers. But that is small misstep.
Big one is fucking Rey. I imagined Romelia as this perfect leader: pragmatic, efficient, thinking one step ahead. Good in a moral way, but at least knowing that understanding and forgiveness have limits. That limit should be endangering entire unit. Rey screwed up once. Ok, we can ask him to do better next time. Then he screws up again. And Again. And again. At this moment this is no leadership, this is pure stupidity. Romelia, you are not parenting this unit, you are leading it. Act like this.
6
u/Primary-Paint-1716 29d ago
this was the first episode of this show that I kinda did not like. it's not bad, but I put this show in a higher standard that I was kinda disappointed that it just did the conventional development. episode felt very predictable.
5
u/Ultramarinus https://anidb.net/user/kingsword 29d ago
I loved formations and consumable usage like everyone else but was especially fond of Romelia not being fazed by their crude threat. She even mocked them back.
With bombs thrown at the end, this time it reminded me Myth: The Fallen Lords! Hopefully they’ll at least manage to get away but it’s a tough spot indeed.
3
u/Dariat01 28d ago edited 28d ago
Ok, Ray is becoming a burden. He's making mistake after mistake and putting everyone in danger, at this rate he's gonna get the whole squad killed eventually. They have to do something with him
If they couldn't even defeat one demon soldier there's no way they can win this battle, maybe they had a chance if Al was still able to fight but not anymore. I'm guessing they used something like a flash grenade and managed to escape somehow, though I hope they're not gonna kill off Al
3
u/amourshipper_ 29d ago
What a cliffhanger that's crazy AND why this administrator is so obsessed over dying . Of .Romelia. ??? Isn't it better to not have any demon in his province???
2
u/Rude_Championship513 28d ago
Can Ray die already? I'm tired of this character.