Please help me settle this debate, oh great tree people of the internet. The first photo is the tree from 2014, around when I believe it was planted—a beautiful Freeman maple. The rest of the photos are current. Person A and Person B have lived in the house for about two years, and the tree has grown a LOT in that time.
Person A believes this is the wrong tree for the spot and the wrong spot for the tree. They believe it should be removed within the next year while it's still a relatively simple removal and before the root system does serious damage. Person A is concerned that the tree and its root system will soon destroy the retaining wall it's already pressing against, and likely start heaving the concrete and pavers of the nearby driveway and sidewalk. Person A wants to plant something smaller, like a Japanese maple, in its place after removal.
Person B believes the tree is fine where it is and should be left alone. They believe the tree will only get a little bit bigger and might do minor damage to the surrounding structures, which would be simple to fix and even simpler to prevent. Person B thinks the retaining wall and driveway could easily be moved or modified as the tree grows into its space.
What does the hivemind have to say?
Reposted as to not doxx myself this time. Thanks for pointing that out.