Mostly a rant to get some pain off my chest, but hopefully also a story that might help another ace person considering something similar.
I (37M) recently tried having an open relationship with an allosexual person. Sorry in advance, this is a bit of a long one. There's obviously a lot more to the story, and this is entirely my side of things. I'm using a burner account to protect everyone involved, so I probably won't respond to questions, but who knows. I've got a lot more time on my hands now and I'm interested in the discussions it might bring...
I found out I was ace kinda late (is 28 late?) when a relationship I was super invested in fell apart because I don't think about sex and she tied her self-worth to how attractive I found her. I'm sure a lot of ace people have that experience of not understanding people's obsession with sex or sex jokes or the entire culture behind it. Eventually I met a friend of someone I was dating who was aroace and her explaining it to me made everything click, like I finally understood the disconnect in my head.
I learned more about it and realized I was hetero-romantic but asexual. I love dating women, love snuggling on the couch during a rainy saturday, or going on adventures with the person I trust most in this world. I just don't want to have sex with them. And man is it hard to find someone who feels the same.
I work in a really creative but competitive field so growing my skillset, networking, and moving for work was my top priority for years. When I finally felt financially stable I decided to get back into dating again. Was feeling very lonely and touch starved so I started using dating apps. I did fairly well getting dates but despite how well they went, as soon as I mentioned I was ace I would get ghosted or it suddenly "isn't giving me the spark." And I get it, sex is important to a lot of people and I was probably the first ace person they had ever met (I live in blue city in a pretty red state). TBF, I'm not sex repulsed and am willing to have sex with a partner. To me it's like doing the dishes or cooking, I don't want to but it makes them happy. But after years of wasting time and money on dead ends I kinda gave up.
Enter one of my best friends (now 38f). We met through a dating app but it didn't click romantically for either of us but we loved being friends. She has her own struggles with dating but she is very much heterosexual. One day after hiking and lamenting about a recent bad date, the conversation led to how we both really want kids but we feel like we're running out of time. She asked if at some point we couldn't find anything, maybe we should do that thing where we become partners. She was one of my best friends who had a very stable job, a good heart, and highly intelligent. I said I'd call her bluff, if we don't find anything by this time next year let's talk about it.
The year passed, we didn't find anyone, so we talked about the partnership over dinner. I was still very interested but was worried because she's not ace. I mentioned maybe we should just have an open relationship. That way she could express her sexuality and have that part of her life fulfilled, I wouldn't have to have the pressure of performing for someone, and we could still build our lives as partners for our future kid. But, I had two hard boundaries for the relationship: 1 - I'm not interested in being in a thrupple or a polycule. I'm kind of a loner and more people in my life has never brought more happiness compared to the extra baggage. 2 - I don't want to meet the person who she's having sex with. Partly for the same reason as 1 but also if we have kids I don't want some random stranger around but I also didn't want to control who she sleeps with. Of course I want her to warn me if she's going to be out and I want her to be safe but I trusted her to chose the right guy. But I wanted her to come home after and help me build a life together without distraction.
We remained partners for a year but things started to come up and we drifted. I was really bothered by how unmotivated she was in her general life (if her work ever finds out how much she sleeps during work hours they will not be happy) and felt like nothing got done unless I managed it. She got tired of how stubborn I can be (she's not wrong, I need to look into that) and how messy I can be (in the same way she is so things compounded like crazy). But I always figured it was something I/we could work through with team work and compromise on both sides. We had a really hard time with how small of a space we were living in, the kitchen was too small and I couldn't play games or work on projects while listening to music because she hates my dad rock (valid, I wore headphones but they all hurt my giant ears). We upgraded to a bigger house after a long time searching but unfortunately one of her exes (28m) came back into our lives. She wanted to start seeing him and I was hesitant as I knew there were still some feelings left over from how they broke up previously. But, like I said, I didn't want to control that aspect of her life. I told her I was fine with it, but to "be careful."
In hindsight, that was probably not nearly as clear as I should have been.
Over a few short weeks she started prioritizing being with her ex. He came to our house every day and she invited him to our weekly sunday brunch.
He was going through some pretty serious life stuff and was losing his apartment because of some drama from his roommates. She has a kind heart that wants to help people like that, it's one of the qualities I loved most about her, but when she told him to move in with us (without consulting me) I was unhappy to say the least and clearly rule #2 was broken.
She also started referring to me as her partner and him as her boyfriend, initially as a joke. But eventually, she started telling other people that, too. There went rule #1.
While packing our stuff for the move I heard her talking to him on the phone and she ended it with "I love you" which is a phrase we never really got to. Never experienced that kind of jealousy and it made me realize I let things get too far.
That day we got burgers from a drive through and I brought it up, she was expecting the conversation. I told her she had crossed both of my hard rules, no throuples and I don't want to meet the other guy. She said she forgot. I believe her, but I told her intent doesn't really matter. You broke a clear boundary, and to me, that's about as close to cheating as you can get in an open relationship. I wasn't sure if I can trust her anymore.
We talked a lot, the TLDR is that I told her our partnership was still the most important thing to me. I was willing to let him stay with us through the holidays (nobody should be alone on Christmas, IMO) and we would be on something of a break. But by my birthday in early February, he needed to be gone. There's no world where we could repair things with that kind of distraction. Otherwise we were done.
She said she had too much resentment, the little things piled too high, and didn't think our partnership was going to work out. To me it sounded like it wasn't worth it to her anymore so we agreed to end it.
Now I'm trying to put my old life back together and relearn how to be independent again. Every day hurts less than the one before and I know I'll be fine but I dunno if I can go through heartbreak like that again. Not sure I can ever really make it work.
I envy you aroace siblings, you have an OP super power... This shit fucking sucks...