r/askislam • u/alifilalifilali • 10h ago
Support and Advice Is God Evil?
I had a question that eluded me for a long time, and I never really found an answer for it. I know this might not be a new or unheard-of dilemma:
- If God knows the future, and by creating a human, knowing that human will go to hell for eternity, isn't that act evil, and is it not a more virtuous act to either not create him or create everyone to go to heaven directly?
- The only answers I find for these types of questions are that God knows more than us, we cannot understand His wisdom, and for questions like these, we should just brush them to the side and not think about them; doing so is actually what faith is—blindly believing despite logical or moral inconsistency. This type of advice never sat well with me. Let’s imagine this: someone took a random rock and started worshiping it; you would tell him that what he is doing is illogical, but he would tell you that God's wisdom is beyond all comprehension and that the illogical act of worshiping a random rock is exactly the faith test He put for us.
What that random person did and what Muslims do when doubts arise is fundamentally the same thing: brushing aside logic and morality for blind faith. And if we return to a lesser extreme example, if a Christian, for example, got in contact with Islam and learned about it, and since we believe it is the right religion, we believe that he will see that as well, but he chose to have blind faith in his religion and remained a Christian. What he did and what a Muslim is asked to do is the same thing—blind faith—but one gets to go to heaven and the other to hell, just because they had different starting points that they both did not choose.
Also, can't God just answer all questions, since He is omnipotent? Then, by leaving no doubt or unanswered questions, we could clearly say that everyone who did not believe in Islam decided to do that out of spite, not just a lack of convincing.
So, going back to the first question, if the answer is just "believe because it's a test," I would say that just shows how unfair God is.
Lastly, I would like to say I am open to learning and hearing your thoughts; maybe there is something I do not know, but these kinds of questions and doubts cannot just be put to sleep. In my opinion, you have to have an answer to have real faith.