So I hadn't looked into ASMR for a couple of years, but I am reading a book that discusses it, so I decided to watch some tonight. I've stumbled on videos from some new creators, and it's making me feel deflated, like the golden age of ASMR is already behind us.
What stands out to me is the sexualized presentation by creators of both genders, and I just get an intuitive sense that some of these people don't actually "get" ASMR themselves, they're just being opportunistic. It makes a difference because I don't think people who don't feel it can recreate it for others intentionally, at least not predictably and consistently... Something as simple as the cadence of their speech gives it away.
By contrast, some of the OG creators look and sound like they are getting ASMR from the creative process, and it translates so differently.