r/ausenviro • u/Niscellaneous • 1d ago
New Labor carbon credits a gift to big polluters
Jeremy Russell-Smith has long extolled the benefits of savanna burning for emissions reduction, and for its capacity to generate income for Indigenous communities.
Now he’s blowing the whistle.
The professor of fire ecology at Charles Darwin University is deeply concerned about how the federal government calculates the greenhouse gas impact of a new savanna carbon credit method rolled out this year.
He is among experts who believe it is vastly overestimating emissions reductions and allowing big climate polluters to buy offsets based on bogus emissions abatement.
“Calling it not fit for purpose is a polite way of putting it,” Russell-Smith tells The Saturday Paper. “The method that the Commonwealth is currently using is not conservative, it is not accurate, it’s non-credible.”
Fourteen years ago, the original savanna fire management strategy became one of the first carbon credit methods registered in Australia.
Russell-Smith helped adapt it, drawing on thousands of years of Indigenous land management. The idea is that intentionally lighting fires earlier in the dry season produces less intense burns, releasing fewer greenhouse gases and reducing the risk of massive bushfires later.
Projects that carry out this method, many managed by Indigenous businesses, earn carbon credits that are sold to major greenhouse gas emitters to offset their climate pollution. Collectively, they are worth tens of millions of dollars a year.
The new savanna methodology took effect in April. Like the original scheme, it issues carbon credits on the assumption that cooler fires early in the dry season avoid emissions by preventing more damaging fires later. For the first time, however, it also rewards projects for carbon stored in trees that survive the less intense fires.
The government is now giving existing projects that shift to the new scheme backdated credits for the extra carbon – handing them windfall gains for emissions reductions already made.
It’s slowly rolling out the backdated carbon credits, easing analysts’ concern they will flood the market. But critics still fear they will suppress prices and encourage businesses to keep buying cheap offsets rather than directly cut their greenhouse gas emissions.
Russell-Smith supports the new scheme in principle. However, he says the tool the Commonwealth is using to calculate the extra carbon “is demonstrably bonkers”.
“I’m privy to data which shows just how wrong the method is when applied at a project or local scale,” he says.
The problem is that the government does not require projects to measure or independently verify the amount of carbon they store. Instead, it estimates this using the national carbon accounting model “FullCAM”. A growing body of research suggests this is a flawed tool for assessing carbon credit projects and can overestimate their emissions reductions.
When it announced the new savanna fire management schemes, the government highlighted a CSIRO finding that they could reduce greenhouse gases by up to 180 million tonnes over 25 years.
It ignored the fine print.
The CSIRO paper specifically warns that while FullCAM works “at the scale for which its use was intended” – national greenhouse gas accounting – it can produce unreliable results at a local level.
The model’s key parameter could be out by 50 per cent in some savanna regions – risking heavy overestimation of projects’ ability to store carbon in the landscape and overstating emissions reductions.
When CSIRO scientists instead based their calculations on measurements from actual savanna sites, avoided emissions fell by about a quarter, while estimates of additional carbon stored fell by as much as 42 per cent.
“It could be a lot worse than that,” Russell-Smith says, citing on-the-ground measurements of carbon projects he has seen. “The FullCAM numbers are rubbish.”
Yet Russell-Smith says that “technically, it is quite feasible to actually measure carbon stock in a landscape”.
Researchers in the Northern Territory are doing just that, using a technology known as LiDAR, which emits high-frequency laser pulses to map the 3D structure of vegetation and biomass.
Combined with satellite imaging, Russell-Smith says it produces largely reliable estimates that can be compared over time. The results differ markedly from the government’s model.
The problem applies to future credits under the new scheme and retrospective, backdated carbon credits the government is allowing.
“Where does the Commonwealth get its backdating numbers from? This flawed FullCAM approach that is generating backdating numbers that have no basis in any sort of reality,” Russell-Smith says.
His concerns echo those first raised more than four years ago by another group of academics led by Australian National University law professor Andrew Macintosh, a former head of the Emissions Reduction Assurance Committee (ERAC), the statutory body responsible for assessing and approving Australian Carbon Credit Units methods.
Macintosh and his team found that the carbon market lacked integrity and that most carbon credits issued in Australia were bogus.
This week, they released new research. Macintosh says it confirms that the biggest scheme, accounting for about 40 per cent of all carbon credits, “is junk”.
It is supposed to be regenerating native forest but “by and large, there is minimal regeneration”.
He backs Russell-Smith’s concerns about the savanna carbon credits scheme and his call to shift to on-the-ground measurement. “The model assumes that all savanna projects result in a uniform increase in live tree biomass – irrespective of how the project is conducted, the ecosystems involved and what is actually happening on the ground,” Macintosh tells The Saturday Paper.
“To put it politely, this is a radical departure from what the science suggests should occur.”
Macintosh is involved in other work with another cross-disciplinary team that raises further doubts, questioning the core assumption that the savanna burning projects involve cool, patchy fires that produce less emissions.
Using satellite records, this team finds that the savanna carbon credit projects in the Northern Territory may have reduced the total area burnt in the dry season.
However, fires in areas managed for carbon credits have actually become more intense since the projects started, partly because a hotter climate is drying out the vegetation.
These fires were also more intense than in areas not managed for carbon. The researchers say that burning the landscape over and over again to earn carbon credits might be making it more fire-prone.
“Frequent burning is known to increase the abundance of flammable grasses in Northern Territory savannas, creating fuel beds that burn intensely,” their study notes.
It says the rules governing the schemes could create a perverse incentive to light fires when they might burn more furiously.
They rigidly define the early and late dry seasons, assuming any fire lit before August 1 is less intense, more patchy and releases fewer greenhouse gases.
According to their study, this could be encouraging managers to burn as late as possible to increase the extent of “early” dry-season fires that earn carbon credits – while reducing the risk of fires later in the season that don’t get rewarded.
Although it couldn’t say definitively, the study suggests “the emission reductions generated by the projects may be small” and that the number of carbon credits they receive may “significantly exceed the actual emission reductions”.
David Bowman, a professor of fire ecology at the University of Tasmania, was a co-author of the study.
“There is an irony that a scheme which is explicitly about climate change doesn’t consider that climate change, now manifest because of detectable higher temperatures, is changing the fire season,” he says.
Altering the rules to require burns earlier in the dry period is one possible remedy.
Russell-Smith disputes key findings of the research. “Our analysis shows that most early dry season fires are in fact of very mild severity,” he says.
But in his view, the issue underlines the need to base the carbon credit schemes on actual measurement rather than assumptions.
“We should be moving to measures of fire severity. There are technical challenges of doing that at scale, but ultimately we all agree that needs to happen.”
Russell-Smith says he and others have raised their concerns with Karen Hussey, the chair of the carbon credit scheme integrity body ERAC, and with a senior departmental official, as well as their ideas about how to address them.
ERAC did not respond to questions from The Saturday Paper.
There is no shortage of critics who are utterly cynical about carbon credits. Russell-Smith is not one of them. “It is fixable,” he says. “We are confident of that.”
It will cost money, though, and big businesses in Australia have become used to a ready flow of affordable carbon credits to offset their emissions.
“They’re wanting to generate all these cheap credits for offsets, you know, and there’s obviously political pressure to do so,” Russell-Smith says. “But at the end of the day, you’ve got to have credibility.”