r/betterCallSaul • u/thr0waway2435 • 18h ago
I never cared much for Werner Ziegler
Almost every time I see Werner mentioned, I feel like there are multiple highly cited comments about "poor Werner", "he didn't deserve that", "he's a good man", "I was so sad". Now, don't get me wrong, obviously he didn't deserve to die. But at the same time, I never cared much for him.
People like to say that he didn't know what he was getting himself into. But that's not because he was misled; that's because he was frankly stupid and reckless. There is just no way he didn't realize he was working on extremely illegal, dark stuff with dangerous criminals. Mike all but told him he cannot screw around with this job. Besides that, it's just so obvious. What type of legitimate job involves: exceedingly well-paid work, getting transported to the location with bags on your head, strict security where you cannot tell a single soul what you're doing, living 24/7 underground, secluded from society, surrounded by surveillance and armed security, timing dynamite explosions with noise from a truck so that it's not discovered.
There are only two options here. 1) VERY illegal, dangerous activity. 2) Top-secret government activity. That's it. And 2) is obviously impossible because the US government would never import foreign workers for such a thing.
Anyone with a brain can see the seriousness of the situation. And it's not cutely naive for Werner to think, "oh but Gus dresses nicely and speaks politely in German, therefore he won't harm me for risking his absurdly expensive top-secret illegal activities", it's just plain stupid.
After he willingly signed up for this clearly top-secret job, Werner still chose to talk to a stranger about his work at a bar, going as far as drawing out designs, while standing out like a sore thumb as a friendly German engineer talking about pouring hundreds of tons of concrete in a secret underground location in Albuquerque. He also obfuscates the degree of his security breach to Mike when first confronted, only later confessing that he made a mistake after drinking too much. Then he promises never to risk security again.
Only to, later on, be the first in his group to snap, running away to meet his wife. He violates Mike's trust, damages their property, is obvious enough about it that he quickly gets himself tracked by Lalo, and also pulls his wife into the entire dangerous mess, risking her life too.
What does he say to Mike after all this? "I thought I would come back and my friend Michael would be very, very angry. But in time, he would understand and forgive." He thought Mike would just cover for him. Even though, unlike his last screw-up, it's not something that Mike can even cover up - it's not a conversation only Mike saw, it's an escape everyone involved saw. Werner just expected Mike to throw himself under the bus for him.
Werner was insanely reckless, a little entitled, and not only was he reckless personally, he also risked two people he cares about - his wife and Mike.
I think what also bugs me about Werner is that we are really given no reason for why he's doing these stupid reckless criminal things. It seems quite unlikely that he grew up in a particularly poor or terrible environment, given he speaks fondly of his engineer father who worked on the Sydney Opera House. He has a wife he loves. As an engineer of such remarkable skill that perfectionist Gus is willing to fly him out internationally to work for him, I highly doubt he was incapable of supporting himself financially without getting involved in criminal activity. He never mentions any reason for his behavior to Mike, despite their fairly intimate conversations. Maybe he actually does have some secret tragic backstory, needs to get money to take care of a sick loved one or something, but given no hints of it at all, it doesn't seem unlikely he was just plain greedy.
And again, I'm not saying he deserved to die, because he obviously didn't. He also had some great traits, like his friendliness, his intelligence, his loyalty to his workers, his love for his wife, his dignified acceptance of the consequences for his mistakes. I get why Mike cared so much for him, they shared a lot of values. But as a viewer, I didn't really get why so many people seem to think that Werner was a good, nearly innocent man, and were so sad at his death. I honestly felt more sympathy for Combo and Nacho than I did for him. Even Gale, because while he was as amoral as Werner, he wasn't as stupid or reckless.