r/biglaw • • 1d ago

Do you think junior hiring will decrease?

I feel like there is much less need for juniors even now. A lot of seniors and mid levels can get AI to do what juniors do much faster and more efficiently.

What's your prediction? Will we see same hiring rates and trends for class of 2030 and beyond?

34 Upvotes

38 comments sorted by

110

u/Lowl58 1d ago

Okay but where do those midlevels and seniors come from lol

17

u/Realistic-Claim-3686 1d ago

Firms care about profits now. They can just poach from others or figure it out. If juniors are useless nobody wants to pay them $300k a year for a few years to train them. Especially given the attrition rates.

64

u/sultav 1d ago

That's only a problem for people who care about the long term. Current partners don't necessarily care about planting trees for tomorrow's partners, but almost invariably care about increasing their own compensation

43

u/DapperAttorney2680 1d ago

This just isn’t true and half the conversations had behind closed doors are about successions at the big firms.

20

u/tryntafind 1d ago

I’ve sat in on some of those and it’s surprising how often lateral hiring is proposed as a solution.

3

u/Hounds29 23h ago

Retention of mid to good associates and junior partners is discussed constantly.

1

u/joan2468 18h ago

Even mid associates?

5

u/Hounds29 17h ago

Yes, it’s a numbers game. We need enough senior associates and junior partners to run cases. Some mid associates also become good partners—it’s a different skill set.

16

u/No_Host_8024 1d ago

Say they cut hiring by 50%. That still leaves them more than enough to fill their senior associate and partner roles if they retain more of them. And in 10 years AI is likely to be reducing the need for those attorneys too.

9

u/Confident_Yard5624 23h ago

Yeah this is what I think the logic is. My firm cut 25% and there will be enough good ones to stick it out to midlevel and between all the firms they’ll spread out. Without good mentorship there is no learning in the AI age, so seniors will just pick who to mentor to the midlevel and let the rest be Harvey supervisors. Tbh I don’t think this is that different from back in the day just having the juniors who did signature pages and doc duping until they were pushed out. We just need less of those when you add AI to the mix. 

Also I’m predicting a shift in specialty practices that I’m sort of starting to see. I think firms will start hiring pre-trained lawyers in IP, entertainment L&E, tax etc. who got their start in government or smaller firms and then just train them in “big law” when they’re already at midlevel knowledge 

7

u/Human_Giraffe_7282 22h ago

You hire the best 5 instead of the best 10. You get 2 seniors instead of 3-4. There is zero question there will be fewer associates. The only question is how many are cut.

2

u/Mundane-Living-3630 4h ago

Somebody else’s problem.

1

u/SpaceshipMan221 22h ago

Midlevel Farm and the Senior Tree

0

u/Same-Sand-3024 1d ago

We also need less of them and we can poach those. It’s not just that we need less associates—we need less lawyers up and down the hierarchy. It just so happens that the junior ranks are the most bloated and easily replaceable by AI

30

u/Big_Tax3271 1d ago

10 juniors make 3-4 mid to1 senior, so don’t think so unless it can do mid level works

5

u/Realistic-Claim-3686 1d ago

Exactly, but why would firms spend 300k/year training useless juniors given the high attrition rates. Just poach from other firms or something else.

22

u/napbrowsing 1d ago

...and when the water in the well gets scarce?

19

u/GOATEDgunner69 23h ago

That’s Claude’s water now.

4

u/napbrowsing 23h ago

I legit laughed out loud, damn I feel like an ass, you got me 😩

7

u/Much_Artichoke_3133 Associate 23h ago

Just poach from other firms or something else

a) that's been longstanding practice for most non–big firm legal employers. many corporate in-house depts, govt agencies, boutiques, nonprofits, etc., hire no juniors. this system works because big firms can make money off of juniors even while training them. I reckon a junior billing more than roughly 600–1000 hours per year (depending on realization rates, overhead costs, etc.) is making the firm money.

b) if all firms cut back on hiring juniors, lateral hiring / "poaching" no longer works. firms need some number of juniors to grow into the partners of tomorrow

1

u/Biglawlawyering 13h ago

We've basically never had as many associates as we do now. We've had much smaller associate ranks in the past (40-50%) and firms didn't wither and die. More than enough to fill the ranks of gov and corporate counsel. And this before AI

1

u/Big_Tax3271 20h ago

For real, I don’t think law firm cares. Junior spent 2 hours mean 1500 dollars. Senior using Harvey spent 10 mins means 200 dollars. Why not using juniors?

20

u/Goingbacktoboston 1d ago edited 22h ago

Yes. Few firms have already starting stealthing rising second years and third years over the last few months alone. The firing of rising second years used to be unheard of. I think adjusting for very large recent class sizes is at play here too.

So yes there is a trend and won’t exactly cease anytime soon unfortunately :/ … Shortsighted imo because the quality of these junior cohorts will undoubtedly suffer with greater AI use and reliance.

7

u/MealSuspicious2872 23h ago

It wasn’t unheard of. Trust me. I mean maybe it was unheard of to you in that you didn’t hear of it. But it happened. Always has, unless economic times are amazing. And while most of our juniors are amazing, there are a small handful that don’t understand what the job requires or just can’t hack it.

9

u/ComprehensiveLie6170 1d ago

Depends on the economy. When it happens, it will do so under the auspices of greater economic upheaval (meaning they will blame it on the economy while grabbing cheaper enterprise models that will be out by then). Everyone is in a wait and see posture currently and hiring on the conservative side of normal, with some firms expanding to meet the increased need due to partnership poachings.

9

u/Just_Negotiation_945 1d ago edited 1d ago

Of course it will, and in fact, it already has. My firm and peer firms have been gradually decreasing first year class sizes. I expect this to become a universal phenomenon.

12

u/AndreLeGeant88 Partner 1d ago

Yes we will and already are hiring fewer junior attorneys

4

u/rubbishindividual 23h ago edited 23h ago

A biglaw firm doesn't hire 200 first years because they need 200 first years. They do it because in 3 years' time, they'll need 80 4th years, and in 8 years, they'll need 20 new NEPs.

1

u/Biglawlawyering 13h ago

I get the distinct impression, most don't realize how much BL has grown their associate ranks over the past 15 years.

Or that average billables has been trending down for years. Profits continue to grow because law seems to be one of the few professional services where clients just eat 8-10% rate increases a yr.

It defies convention there wouldn't be some reversion, and this without a full accounting of AI.

1

u/Brisby820 7h ago

100%.  Summer classes will get smaller within a few years 

1

u/Longhornhomer 4h ago

For lit, no. For corporate, yes. There are already less lit associates. Most teams at my firm already only have one junior on a case. Not sure how you go down from there.

-6

u/Same-Sand-3024 1d ago

In my group (AmLaw 50) due to AI we have stopped hiring juniors for now. AI is faster, produces way more accurate work (even if not perfect), and is way way way cheaper. It’s true that AI isn’t 100% correct but it is always more correct than a junior associate. Just one group can’t speak to others

4

u/MealSuspicious2872 23h ago

What kind of “group”? Not trying to dox you, just hasn’t even been a possibility discussed in my group.

1

u/wvtarheeI 23h ago

ECVC?

2

u/MealSuspicious2872 23h ago

Oh that makes sense.

1

u/Same-Sand-3024 22h ago edited 22h ago

It’s actually a super complicated tax niche - but yes I can see ECVC being impacted too. In a lot of transactional groups if clients r gonna pay i can see trying to have a bunch of busy bodies to make money off of but really one junior can now do the work of 4-5. Issue is gonna be your competitors will be faster and cheaper so its hard to rent out a bunch of juniors when they’re not really needed. For some big clients maybe they don’t care idk. Fundamentally on a basic level AI is like giving mathematicians excel and a calculator, we can do a lot more a lot faster. The downvotes on all this stuff is exhausting people need to get with the program. It’s copium to think 60 years ago there were CPAs who stayed away from calculators—if they did they got put out of business

1

u/MealSuspicious2872 17h ago

How many juniors were you hiring before?

I agree firms will cut back but unless it’s clear there will be no more lawyers, it’s unclear if it will just never be like 2006 or 2021 again, or if it will actually dramatically shrink.