Just as many of you here I went through genuine grief when I learned about the closure of Bioware and cancellation of ME4. The feeling was compounded by the leak of the internal Mass Effect trailer which looked good as a starting point especially the return of an older Liara. At the same time I also couldnt help but feel a little relief at the thought that they would not be able to ruin another franchise with endless reboots and sequels. I found comfort at the thought that the legacy of the franchise would not be ruined by a half hearted sequel like what happened to Dragon Age. The Mass Effect trilogy was perfect. It is one of my favourite franchises in gaming and ME3 in particular is one of 3 games that defined my identity as a gamer. Andromeda too was a capable enough evolution of the formula and had a decent story setup for a new arc that was sadly derailed by complicated development and low sales. I am so thankful they managed to release the Legendary Edition before the buyout and subsequent closure. All that is to say I love Mass Effect and they will never take that away from me. This is a love letter to the franchise.
My journey with Mass Effect began when a friend of mine got me a copy of ME3 for my 12th birthday. I remember to this day it was a pirated disc that had ME3, FlatOut 3 and James Cameron's Avatar burned on it. I was not familiar with the franchise at that point and was most looking forward to playing the Avatar game. It was fun but since I had it, I also decided to try out the Mass Effect game and I instantly fell in love. The scale, the enormity of the conflict, the depth of the story, the role play of a soldier inspiring his companions with his steadfast determination while falling apart inside. It truly was a love at first sight.
Ā
As I got older and got my own steam account I remember playing through the whole trilogy for the first time. It was astonishing to me that minor decisions I made in ME1 would snowball into major consequences by the time ME3 story unfolded. That probably was my first experience with this type of storytelling. I mentioned other franchises that defined me and these are Assassin's Creed and the Witcher games but this level of storytelling continuity was unique to Mass Effect in my eyes.
Ā
There was a popular general knowledge mobile quiz game that I believe has been delisted or became one of those ad filled subscription slop data mining malware masquerading as a mobile game these days. I remember they had a mass effect category and you could get globally ranked. Well I remember in my middle school years I used to be top ranked in my country and in Europe for a good while like at least 8-9 months. I would play daily answering trivia questions about mass effect even when I could not play the games because I did not have a computer at the time. Stories like these is why we love gaming. These are more than games to us, they form part of who we are.
Ā
Now Mass Effect is one of my top games by playtime on Steam. I probably had more than 30 individual 100% playthroughs of the trilogy and am doing another one now. My love for Mass Effect will never die and what these games have done for me will never be taken away.
Ā
The companions you would meet that would develop into genuine friendships. The real moral decisions. The impact of your actions all these made the game real. My headcanon actually shifted from renegade male shep to paragon male shep. I think Liara is my favourite romance option but I absolutely hate that they made Miranda surviving conditional on your romance status. Miranda deserves better! Curing the genophage has always been a no brainer for me because it is an inexcusable, heinous war crime and I am only disappointed you cannot make the Turians and Salarians repent more forcefully in game. It would have been cool to see the Asari and Humans compel Turians and Salarians to pay reparations to the Krogan and return their colonies. This only exists in my head epilogue. Peace between Geth and Quarians is slightly more complicated. I do not consider Geth living beings as even sentient AIs are not living but they would be incredibly valuable as tools in the fight against the Reapers so I also do not want to destroy them. I wish there would be a way to revert Geth back to their default settings and bring them back under Quarian control as machines taking away their intelligence. That would have been my preferred option. As true AIs are explicitly banned in Council Space it would be interesting to see how their equal peace would play out. The Rachni on the other hand I always let go. They are incredibly powerful and aggressive but they are living and had a sophisticated civilisation. What they did is not worse than whatever the Salarians and Batarians were up to in the past so I say let their civilisation be reborn.
Ā
Of course we cannot have a discussion about Mass Effect without talking about the ending. I was not personally involved with the Indoctrination Theory discussion but I am a fan of CleverNoobsā documentaries. I always had my own take in that the ending is real. The choices available to Shepard are as they are presented by StarChild but my view is that the only correct ending is the Destroy option. In my opinion, anyone that chooses anything other than Destroy for their headcanon does not understand the story of the franchise as a whole. Fundamentally the story of the trilogy is a conflict between freedom and control. Organic races are fighting for freedom to embrace chaos while Reapers are the enforcement mechanism for repetition and cyclical control. The only way to truly win that conflict is to rid organics of the technology laid out by the Reapers to dictate organic development path. Destroying the Citadel, destroying the Mass Relays destroying the remnants of Reaper technologies is the only way to guarantee freedom and victory for life in the Milky Way. That is clearly seen when you analyse StarChild's arguments. You need to keep in mind that StarChild is an explicitly unreliable source. It is the leader of the Reapers, It is not separate from them. It is the original program that came up with the cycles solution. When you realise this it becomes immediately obvious that the StarChild is biased towards Control and Synthesis. Control ending is essentially Shepard joining the intelligence and becoming the StarChild himself. It is shown that he at first uses the Reapers to help the galaxy rebuild but there is no guarantee that he would not end up at the same conclusion as the original program since he completely loses his humanity. Synthesis option is even worse and I essentially consider it a game over screen worse than the Refuse option. Synthesis is basically what the Reapers wanted all along. Permanent end of all organic life in favour of collective techno existence. It is the final perversion of the Leviathan directive to safeguard life. No wonder this option is most favoured by the StarChild who I once again remind you is the chief villain of the trilogy.
Ā
Another thing absolutely worth highlighting is the true originality of the universe and the depth of lore. Bioware are known for their unmatched world building but Mass Effect is their truly original universe. Baldur's Gate had the tabletop, KOTOR had the movies, Dragons Age had the established high fantasy literature. Clearly ME was inspired by and incorporates many of the existing science fiction tropes but the achievement of creating a truly new gaming-first universe with depth, complexity and potential for storytelling beyond the Reaper saga is worth praise.
Ā
Finally to touch on the Andromeda fiasco. Noone would dispute that Andromeda gameplay was top notch and its story had interesting seeds that could have been developed in sequels but it was brought down by development hell that led to repetitive quest design, uninspired world architecture and questionable writing. The crumbs of internal divisions in the Kett empire, the origins of the remnants, the Jardaan creators of Angara. These would have been interesting to explore and the cancellation of the Andromeda trilogy in favour of a ME4 reboot truly was the first sign of trouble for the franchise.
In the end this post is just a messy expression of my love for the franchise and for those stories that will stay with me forever. The IP is dead, the characters we grew to love live on. I am angry with the leadership, I am bitter with the industry, I am thankful Legendary Edition exists, I am relieved there will never be a Mass Effect Veilguard.