I wasn't going to make another post about this. But I a comment under my last post saying that Rehmaan doesn't really take decisions himself, and is instead constantly manipulated by Hamza and the others.
And I honestly think this comes from misreading how screenwriting uses other characters to influence, reveal and develop a character.
In screenwriting, another character giving your protagonist an idea, information, an opportunity, or even pushing them toward a decision doesn't automatically mean the protagonist has been manipulated. The important thing is what the protagonist does with information, and what their eventual choice reveals about them.
Take Troy (2004). Odysseus tells Achilles that the Trojan War will be remembered for ages. Achilles knows from his mother that going to Troy will cost him his life. He still chooses to go because he values glory and immortality over a long, ordinary life.
Was Achilles manipulated by Odysseus?
No. Achilles made the choice.
Now compare that with Omkara (2006).
Langda doesn't simply tell Omkara that Kesu is having an affair with Dolly. He creates circumstances, plants false information and manipulates what Omkara perceives, so that Omkara reaches a conclusion he wouldn't have reached if he knew the truth. That's manipulation.
The same thing happens with Bhallaladeva and Sivagami in Baahubali 2. Bhallaladeva constructs circumstances and controls the information Sivagami receives so that she reaches the conclusion he wants her to reach.
That's fundamentally different from simply influencing a character's decision.
And this is where I think the Rehmaan interpretation falls apart.
When Hamza asks Rehmaan to kill Babu Dakait, Rehmaan isn't simply being “manipulated.” He makes a choice based on his own priorities. He chooses greater power and regional loyalty.
And that's exactly the kind of thing screenwriting is supposed to reveal through action.
The same applies to his decision to enter politics. That's his decision. And then we're shown another side of Rehmaan when he chooses to sell firearms and turn a blind eye to the ISI's activities in Balochistan.
These aren't merely instances Iqbal manuplating Rehmaan. Instead, we're revealed Rehmaan's arc. He chooses power and status over regional loyalty.
And this is why I think the popular interpretation misses something fundamental about the screenplay. They're looking at who gave Rehmaan the idea instead of looking at why Rehmaan accepted it and what his choice tells us about him.
Characters are constantly influenced by other characters in storytelling. That's normal. A scene can give a character information, challenge their beliefs, present an opportunity, provoke them, persuade them, or force them to make a choice.
But none of that automatically removes agency.