INTRODUCTION:
This time I can’t say “I don’t post to this Reddit often”, and unfortunately I’m writing this crestfallen from what I have just experienced. This is my seventh review, for the most part I’m able to read other great posts from both experienced professionals and professional alcoholics and they perfectly articulate everything that’s needed to be said. However, I like a fruitful discussion and I think Midwinters Nights Dram Act 14 needs a definitive review showing the full perspective of what possibly went wrong with the liquid inside the bottle but also the repeated failures of this LTO from a marketing and production standpoint. It’s really gotten to a point where I have to constantly ask myself when should I stop making excuses for a premium whiskey that no longer lives up to the reputation it built.
I've been following A Midwinter Night's Dram since Act 4, and I still have bottles from those earlier releases in my collection. I've experienced some incredible Acts over the years, but I've also watched the series change considerably. So when High West announced Act 14 during its 20th anniversary year, featuring five different finishing casks, the addition of Sherry, and a reduced MSRP of $125, I was genuinely excited. This felt like an opportunity to win back enthusiasts who had become disappointed with the direction of the series. And what better occasion to make a statement than the distillery's 20th anniversary!?
So naturally, the question becomes whether Act 14 actually delivers on that promise. But with so many different finishes comes great responsibility ( or whatever Uncle Ben said). I found myself wondering where the line is between ambition and intention. I’m very interested in hearing everyone’s thoughts on ACT 14 so let’s talk about it.
As for my background, I’m a certified level 2 Sommelier with the CMS & WSET Level 3 Certified. Also, I was involved with the team who selected knob creek & Weller Antique 107 barrel picks, back in 2016-2018 with the company I worked for at the time.
______________________________________
High West A Midwinter Night's Dram — Act 14, Scene 4
Age: rye whiskeys aged 4–10 years before finishing
Proof: 98.6 (49.3% ABV)
Finishing: 4 months to 6 years
Filtration: Non-chill filtered
MSRP: $124.99 (lowered from $150)
Mash Bills / Distillate Sources:
MGP (Indiana): 95% rye / 5% malted barley
High West (Utah): 80% rye / 20% malted rye
Bardstown Bourbon Company (Kentucky): 64% rye / 30% corn / 6% malted barley
Five Finishing Casks:
Ruby Port
Tawny Port
Amontillado Sherry
Oloroso Sherry
Pedro Ximénez (PX) Sherry
______________________________________________________________________________
OK, LET’S GET INTO IT
(This was later tasted along side Act 5 & Act 8 for comparison, but was initially observed individually)
Nose:
Like all MWND releases, the aromas never leap from the glass immediately upon opening. It's almost as if they behave like the wines the whiskey is finished in, requiring substantial air to come to life, and Act 14 is no different in this regard. However, what I did find immediately apparent was how much darker the aromatic profile had become with all those oxidative and dried fruit characteristics. Those six year Port finished rye barrels and the additional Sherry casks have had a significant influence on this expression.
There's orange marmalade, fig, dried apricot, and golden raisin, transitioning into warm black fruit preserves. All of this is wrapped in a blanket of chocolate that I can only assume comes from the Pedro Ximénez Sherry influence. Then we find secondary notes of tobacco and rye spice, accompanied by softer nutty and floral accents, presumably influenced by the Amontillado finishing.
Behind all that, we eventually find familiar territory with dried red fruits that certainly remind me of the Port finishing, alongside that fantastic vanilla bean / crème anglaise character from the French oak that I associate with every MWND release, albeit more muted here. It almost gives me a berries and crème note but the berries are darker fruit and dried.
This is a sweeter aromatic profile that comes across as slightly disjointed while simultaneously offering greater depth from the heavy wine influence. Considering all the additional finishes, that isn't particularly surprising. However, what did surprise me was the noticeable tinge of youth when compared directly against Acts 5 and 8, despite the extensive finishing.
Act 14 is easily more aromatically complex than either of the earlier expressions I'm nosing alongside it, but I'm not finding it necessarily better. If anything, it feels as though some of MWND’s original identity has been lost beneath all those finishing influences; so take that how you will.
(One particularly interesting observation during the comparative tasting was the cinnamon character. Acts 5 and 8 have this beautiful, intensely aromatic oak spice reminiscent of Saigon cinnamon. Act 14 still has plenty of spice, but the cinnamon feels more generic and considerably less expressive. On the positive side, I did discover a lovely savory, almost saline character, possibly influenced by the Sherry finishing, that complements the wine sweetness surprisingly well. I also starting picking up a white chocolate note.)
Palate:
I'm concerned from the very first sip of this...
I'm sitting at a table with several people, all of us silently taking our tasting notes without influencing one another, but my mind immediately goes to wanting to ask the entire table, "What the hell was that?"
This drinks youthful. It's considerably less complex than the nose and noticeably hot for something bottled at only 98.6 proof. I was genuinely excited to taste this whiskey based on the aromas because I knew how different this expression was going to be. But I'd be lying if I said that first sip didn't immediately make my heart sink into my stomach.
The palate opens with substantial oxidative wine influences, although it's not nearly as dark or concentrated as I anticipated from the nose. There's plenty of jammy red fruit and sweet, oxidized dried stone fruit alongside 60% dark chocolate across the front palate.
The rye spice begins to swell as the mid-palate quickly builds with vanilla tinged French oak and aromatic brown spices. Unfortunately, the texture is surprisingly thin, lacking some richness and textural complexity which left me confounded given the documented finishing program. I find the intensity of the nose does not translate to the palate like you would expect, which left me wanting more concentration.
Finish:
The finish is rather short, with a lingering hit of sweet, wine drenched rye spice. And I mean a HIT! This is HOT as it moves toward the back of the palate and into the finish, bringing an aggressive rush of cinnamon, clove, and other brown spices.
Thankfully, that initial intensity eventually transitions into sweet fruit marmalade, chocolate, dried apricot, and a faint French oak and vanilla character. Those sweeter notes can't quite soothe the burn, but they certainly help, and they're gladly welcomed.
Ultimately, this doesn't drink remotely close to its stated 98.6 proof. The finish here lacks balance and the observed characteristics make me think this is a more youthful whiskey.
__________________________________________________________________________________
Overall:
Midwinter Nights Dram Act 14 (68/100 or 6 T8ke)
( I don’t particularly like the T8ke rating system as I think it lacks nuance but I’m going to start rating for both whenever I do a post to appease anyone reading )
Now I really wanted to love this whiskey. I think that's what makes Act 14 so frustrating for me personally. I was approaching this release hoping to find something creatively captivating and special. I have followed MWND since ACT 4, and I own many releases that I genuinely enjoy, so I was excited to see High West attempt something different for its 20th anniversary. I really believed they set themselves up perfectly to reconcile the majority of consumer complaints from the last couples releases. High West not only lowered the MSRP of their 20th anniversary offering but they decided to show ambition as well by adding multiple wine finishes that were up to 6 years old! So, on paper everything sounded incredible. But after tasting Act 14 individually and then comparing it against Acts 5 and 8, I simply cannot convince myself that the additional finishing components made this a better whiskey.
In fact, everyone at our table independently reached the same general conclusion that Act 14 was significantly worse than the two earlier releases. There were differences in preference between Acts 5 and 8, but not much disagreement about where Act 14 belonged.
Now after spending some time with it what I found particularly disappointing was the lack of concentration and depth on the palate compared to what the nose initially promises. The aromas suggest something rich, layered, and deeply concentrated, but that intensity simply doesn't translate into the drinking experience. Despite the oxidative wine influence and numerous finishing components, the palate feels underdeveloped and noticeably less cohesive than the nose. So there's a clear disconnect between the aromatic complexity and the actual drinking experience that I simply cannot ignore. Now compile this with the combination of a thin texture, aggressive spice, and a lack of concentration and it left me feeling that Act 14 lost balance and integration while presenting a surprisingly youthful character. Where I would like to be more forgiving I honestly will say it’s hard…. This is probably the most let down by a whiskey I’ve been where I personally loved and followed the LTO for years. So I write this to try and not only uncover what happened but open an educated conversation of possibly what went wrong.
This is a heavily researched and comprehensive review AKA it’s long…. but I hope you read through all my findings and are able to have a better understanding of the situation. So let’s talk about it!
After researching the history of A Midwinter Night's Dram, there's one quote from David Perkins that I simply cannot get out of my head.
Back in a March 2016 interview with Market Watch, Perkins was discussing High West's expansion and the future of the distillery. He explained that while they certainly wanted to grow, they weren't interested in becoming another Jack Daniel's. Instead, his philosophy was rather simple:
“The goal is to focus on quality, and the quantity will come.”
Well, I think that is quite a damming statement after a decade. I acknowledge Perkins sold the company in 2016 so it’s no longer his folly but High West has the quantity, the resources, and the production capabilities that he envisioned twenty years ago.
So let’s ask ourselves….has that expansion actually translated into better whiskey or similarly its value?
Well, let's look at how High West's flagship rye whiskey recipes have evolved over the years.
Double Rye! (2011-2018): The 2011 release originally blended two year MGP rye (95/5) with sixteen year Barton rye (53/37/10). In 2018, High West replaced the 16 year Barton component with its own 4 to 7 year pot-still rye (80/20), while retaining the younger MGP whiskey. Master Distiller Brendan Coyle confirmed that the proprietary rye initially represented a minority of the blend.
Rendezvous Rye (2007-2018-2021): In 2007 Rendezvous originally blended six year MGP rye (95/5) with sixteen year Barton rye (80/10/10). By approximately 2018, the recipe had transitioned to MGP's 95/5 rye alongside High West's proprietary 80/20 rye, with the overall blend reported as containing whiskeys aged four to seven years. The individual component ages and proportions weren't disclosed. But the changes didn't stop there. In 2021, Rendezvous remained the same Mashbilll but Isaac Winter subsequently confirmed another reformulation, stating that High West decided to incorporate “significantly” more proprietary rye. He described four to nine year old lots of its own pot still whiskey, while published specifications continued identifying the overall blend as four to seven years old. The exact proportions still remain unknown.
A Midwinter Night's Dram — Act 6 (2014-2018-2026): In 2014 Midwinter Nights Dram Act 2 officially debuted as a 6-16 year blend of MGP and Barton that was aged in Ruby Port wine barrels. In 2018 High West introduced its proprietary 80/20 rye into Midwinter Nights Dram Act 6 the first time, transitioning away from the original exclusively sourced recipe built around the mature Barton and MGP components. The age ranged from 5-19 years old and since 2017 began incorporating Tawny Port. Then in 2019 with Act 7 we see the removal of any sourced Barton, a significant drop in age (4-7 years), and the offical stated mash bill change of MGP (95/5) and High West (80/20). In 2021, Isaac Winter explicitly said High West was adding “significantly” more** **of its own rye to Rendezvous”, which based on evidence showing proprietary whiskey being more predominantly used in all their other products leads one to believe this followed suit with MWND. This brings us to Act 14 in 2026, the current release incorporated three different rye mash bills sourced from MGP, High West, and Bardstown Bourbon Company, with base whiskeys aged four to ten years before finishing.
Bourye (2009–2015–2018–2026): Originally introduced in 2009, Bourye combined ten year sourced bourbon (75/15/10), twelve year MGP rye (95/5), and sixteen year Barton rye (53/37/10). Following a three year hiatus from 2012–2014, during which High West offered the younger Son of Bourye, the original expression officially returned in 2015, incorporating nine year MGP bourbon (75/21/4), ten and sixteen year MGP rye (95/5), and sixteen year Barton rye (80/10/10). By 2018, Barton had disappeared from the published recipe entirely, with Bourye now consisting of five MGP whiskey components… eleven & twelve year bourbon (75/21/4), eleven year bourbon (60/36/4), and thirteen & fourteen year rye (95/5). Interestingly, by 2023, High West's proprietary 80/20 rye was documented in Bourye alongside MGP rye (95/5), MGP bourbon (75/21/4), and an undisclosed Kentucky bourbon (78/10/12), all aged at least ten years. High West later stated in a 2024 Bottle Raiders interview that it had been using its own pot still rye for the preceding two or three years, suggesting its introduction around 2021–2022, although the exact year remains unconfirmed. Finally, in 2026, Bourye's published formula contained four mash bills: MGP bourbon (75/21/4 and 60/36/4), MGP rye (95/5), and High West rye (80/20), with components aged ten to nineteen years and a substantial proof increase from 92 to 101. Bourye underwent several additional sourcing and age statement changes throughout its history, which I've documented in greater detail in the full History.
BLENDING AGE & INCREASED PROPRIETARY WHISKEY EXPLANATION:
What we see here is what began as a smaller, beloved craft Utah distillery blending six year Indiana with sixteen year Kentucky rye has evolved into a major whiskey producer with its own mature inventory, multiple mash bills, extensive finishing programs, and the financial resources of Constellation Brands behind it.
So needless to say twenty years later, High West has considerably more resources and blending options than it did when Rendezvous Rye first established the company's reputation. But despite all that what I see here is that Double Rye! Went from 2-16 to 2-7, then Rendezvous 6-16 to 4-7 and finally MWND 6-16 / 5-19 / 4-7 / eventually landing on 4-10 years old in 2025/2026. This on paper literally makes no sense… while we may not know the blend proportions there is no way going from 6-16 to a 4-7 year blend is remotely close age wise. The review comparisons online as well as my own taste buds allow this distinction to be made abundantly clearly. I looked for an explanation and I did find one…
“Since the column still whiskey is aged for a long time to develop the heavier character, we can replace it with our own younger, but very full and heavy-bodied pot still whiskeys to achieve the same effect in the finished product”
Brendan Coyle The Manuel 2018
“The importance of the component isn’t the age but the taste profile.”
David Perkins Entry Proof 2016
Perkins discussed experimenting with both thirty and fifty three gallon barrels, noting that the smaller barrels could develop additional wood sweetness that helped replicate the concentrated character of the older whiskey. So even back in 2016, the intention wasn't necessarily to replace sixteen year old whiskey as they were attempting to reproduce the desired sensory characteristics through different distillation and maturation techniques.
Next, Coyle's is saying that younger, fuller-bodied High West pot still whiskey could substitute for the mature column still component while preserving Double Rye's intended flavor profile in this statement. He was explicitly defending the replacement of older sourced whiskey ( 16 year Barton) with younger proprietary distillate on the basis of production method and flavor intensity rather than comparable maturation age. So the question is do you agree? Personally my triangle blind says otherwise. But this introduced another important question because as the Rye blends higher age ceilings came down I found it impossible to ignore how others have gone up!
WHY ISN’T THEIR OLDER WHISKEY BEING USED IN MWND?:
Bourye actually provides an important qualification to my theory because as High West shifted substantially toward proprietary distillate across its portfolio, Bourye showed that the company hadn’t universally abandoned sourcing mature whiskey.
As recently as 2026, High West was releasing Bourye with components aged as long as nineteen years, but also including its own rye no younger than 10 years old!
That's particularly interesting given the company doesn't showcase more mature proprietary /sourced rye whiskey in their flagships like Double Rye! and Rendezvous. It made me think… sure they may not be able to get 16 year old Barton but they could easily source older MGP so Rendezvous or MWND isn’t a disappointing 4-7 years old? At the very least this proves they could use older proprietary rye stocks. I did find this quote that explains some of the younger sourcing from a logistical standpoint but it certainly doesn’t excuse it since Bourye still exists as a product.
“Sometimes the challenge is logistical. When developing something like Bourye, all the whiskies are over ten years old, so there’s more evaporation. We might develop an amazing blend in the lab, but when we dump the barrels, we don’t have quite the proof gallons we expected. We’ve had last minute moments where we had to make it work. Our sensory team comes together and figures out how to put it together in a way that still exemplifies High West. It’s stressful, but satisfying once we finalize a blend. It makes us better blenders.”
- Tara Lindley (CSM 2026 Interview)
Talking about older High West whiskey brings me to my next theory about those older proprietary stocks being aged in Utah and the fact that High West is using more of this in its blends. We see a considerable increase in High West distillate used across every skew over the years and this is said by High West themselves.
“The addition of our own whiskey to our blends has always been part of our plan. As some of our sourced whiskeys get used up, we needed to make whiskey to hit the same taste profile; therefore, we have migrated into our own in-house whiskeys, which have the same effect in the overall blend” - Brendan Coyle The Bourbon Review 2018
“we have been so thrilled with our own High West rye component we decided to include ‘significantly’ more in this release.” - Isaac Winter (Whiskey Club 2021 email)
“We’re being liberal with our usage of our potstill because we finally have enough of it now”
- Brendan Coyle The Spirit Business 2023
“we started releasing our own spirit as a component of our blends.”
Isaac Winters Craft Spirits Mag 2026
“as our own whiskey has come of age, we’ve been able to incorporate it into our blends”
Tara Lindley The Whiskey Reviewer 2026
HOW IS CLIMATE AFFECTING THE BLEND?:
This introduces another factor that could possibly be affecting the profile and quality regardless of the age discrepancy. Let’s see what High West themselves along with others have said about how the climate affects their barrels of whiskey.
During a 2016 r/bourbon AMA, somebody specifically asked David Perkins about High West's maturation environment and how it compared with traditional whiskey producing regions like Kentucky. Perkins explained that he had compared Utah's average temperatures with Kentucky's and found them surprisingly similar. However, the significant difference was humidity. Utah's considerably drier environment meant water could evaporate from the barrels more rapidly relative to ethanol, causing the remaining whiskey to increase in proof.
“We won’t age the same, but it doesn’t mean our whiskey will taste bad, just different.”
He specifically explained that ethanol and water behave as different solvents, extracting different compounds from the oak as the alcohol concentration changes. Meanwhile, seasonal temperature fluctuations influence the movement of whiskey into and out of the oak, contributing to extraction, oxidation, and the overall maturation process. So naturally, whiskey aged for ten years in Utah isn't necessarily going to develop the same characteristics as whiskey aged for ten years in Kentucky or Indiana.
“But out here in Utah, we see very cold winters, very hot summers, but generally a very dry climate.” - Cayla Gaseau Ski Utah's Last Chair podcast
Sensory Manager Cayla Gaseau went into more depth on this very topic in 2024 through a podcast. Gaseau explained that Utah's maturation environment produces greater tannin extraction and deeper char-related barrel flavors in High West's whiskey compared with the Indiana aged whiskey she was discussing. She also explained that the Indiana whiskey tends to lose proof during maturation, resulting in a different balance of water soluble wood characteristics. Those differences can fundamentally influence a whiskey's structure. Tannins contribute bitterness and astringency, while deeper char extraction can influence the concentration of oak driven characteristics.
“We’re trying to combat all the evaporation we’re going to see.”
Isaac Winters
In a 2024, The Daily Pour interview Winter explained that High West generally enters new barrels at 110 proof, while used cooperage is filled at an even lower 95 proof. He identified Utah's dry conditions and hot summers as important considerations in preventing the whiskey from becoming excessively oak driven or alcoholic in character. I’m reading this thinking, here we have High West's own Master Distiller acknowledging that evaporation, barrel proof, and potentially excessive oak extraction are characteristics they actively work to manage. Then in a later interview with Beverage industry, Winter’s talks about finding success relocating barrels from the lower elevation warehouses to the cooler conditions surrounding the distillery, allowing the team to influence the development of the whiskey as it ages.
Having been to the distillery myself they told me the evaporation rate is three to four times that of what you’d find in Kentucky but Utah's climate is obviously not like Texas’s. High West doesn't necessarily experience the same degree of aggressive oak influence found in those environments. But It makes one still think that Utah’s more excessive extraction can also create a whiskey that feels drying, bitter, or possibly overly aggressive. So this begs the question… What happens when these proprietary rye stocks continue aging for eight, ten, twelve, or even fifteen years under those conditions? I mean we don’t have a stand alone proprietary High West bourbon or rye after 20 years that’s been older than 6!? Makes you wonder if this could be why? Are these whiskeys that should just be blended because they cannot stand on their own with an older age statement? Well, there is seemingly A lot of literature out there talking about the strange effects on whiskey maturation in dry climates and clearly High West has a sophisticated program to aid in mitigating the negative affects of its climate on maturation. I think this is an important consideration in what many have perceived as a drop in quality with regards to MWND, many even describing the last release (Act 13) as thin and dry.
AMBITION LOSING INTENTION:
Now this brings me back to the question I raised in my introduction. At what point does ambition stop serving the whiskey, and where exactly is the line between ambition and intention? One thing I want to make clear is that I'm not questioning the passion, dedication, or expertise of High West's blending team. In fact, after reading/listening to multiple interviews with Brendan Coyle, David Perkins, Isaac Winter and Tara Lindley, I've developed an even greater appreciation for how much thought and experimentation goes into these releases.
“as a team our sensory panel will pull out the last five or six of our mid winners night Dram releases and taste through them and well identify as a team collectively what to work towards and execute on what we can deliver in the flavor profile. For me personally act 11 was a big highlight for me. I really loved that year. I thought we really drove more of that Ruby, Port character and some of the brighter, cherry and strawberry notes behind the fig and the plum.”
Tara Lindley, Bourbon Lens Podcast 2026
“Blending for that objective makes us unique. With finishing barrels, we have great partners, especially our internal wineries with Constellation. We get the best wine barrels and have control over their treatment, bringing beautiful flavor profiles and fun experimental blends.”
Tara Lindley (CSM 2026 Interview)
The quotes above clearly display how much passion and thought are behind each release. But if the team is primarily tasting the previous five or six Acts, that means their reference points for Act 14 would be based off releases from approximately 2020 onward (Act 8-13). This is interesting because they're evaluating whiskeys developed after High West had already begun incorporating its proprietary distillate, rather than necessarily comparing against the original Acts that established Midwinter's reputation. That doesn't mean they never revisit the older releases (I know they’re available in the tasting room), but it certainly makes me wonder what standard they're ultimately trying to maintain? Act 8 is my favorite modern release but that is so different from Act 10 and both of those Acts are vastly different from Act 12 and 13 ect…. So what is it they are aiming to work towards? This seemingly demonstrates High West's blending objectives are gradually changing alongside the whiskey itself. This doesn’t make me believe they are attempting to preserve Midwinter's original identity, instead it looks like they established a new identity based on what the modern releases have become. This is clearly shown with how the sensory panel determines a profile direction and this makes me question what the intention truly is here.
But let’s bring this back to Act 14.
“So we have quite the range of finishing we really took this blend and this opportunity as our 20th anniversary to really push what we’ve been doing.”
Tara Lindley, Bourbon Lens Podcast 2026
This to me shows intention… Twenty years is a significant milestone, and ambitious creativity is what made High west famous! That creativity was on display with Act 10 via Encore through a separate White Port Release. However, when the team began experimenting, they discovered that the more assertive Ruby and Tawny finishes overwhelmed the character of the White Port. Therefore, instead of forcing another finishing component into the main release, they decided to bottle it separately. I actually tasted The Encore's White Port finishing at the distillery, and I found it wonderful! I completely agree with their decision. That brings me to Act 14’s anniversary release and I can’t help but ask why this also wasn’t released separately? This is where ambition loses sight of intention because why not preserve the traditional Port-forward identity of Midwinter while creating an entirely separate twentieth anniversary Sherry expression? That's exactly the sort of intentional experimentation and blending philosophy I could admire.
And I'm not suggesting that a separate Sherry expression would automatically have solved the shortcomings I identified in Act 14. The quality, maturity, and selection of the underlying rye would still be absolutely critical.
But it would have allowed High West to explore a completely different finishing philosophy without fundamentally changing the character of the main annual release. I don't think Act 14 suffers from a lack of thought or effort since High West clearly invested substantial resources into developing this whiskey, plus they lowered the MSRP. But intention during the production process doesn't necessarily guarantee its translation into the finished product.
As a sommelier and wine lover, I adore Sherry. I appreciate everything from the nutty, oxidative complexity of Amontillado to the richer characteristics of Oloroso and the incredibly concentrated dried fruit sweetness of Pedro Ximénez. So believe me when I say I was genuinely excited to see these styles incorporated into MWND, although I had to take a step back and look at the full picture. Anyone could see Incorporating five different finishes was abundantly ambitious as well as exciting. But High West's reputation was never built simply on how many different whiskeys or finishing barrels they could combine.
It was built on their ability to take those different components and create something exceptional. And for me, that's the fundamental distinction Act 14 failed to demonstrate. All that ambition seems to have lost sight while intention drifted away from its original purpose. Ultimately, it didn’t make a better whiskey… it just made a different one.
FINAL CONCLUSION:
Let’s put this all together because I think the chronology becomes particularly revealing. I'm looking at what I've actually experienced over nearly a decade of drinking Midwinter Night's Dram. And I think it’s clear at this point I'm not just speculating about how Utah's climate might influence whiskey maturation or how the blend compositions have affected the profile.
That said, Acts 4 and 5 were the releases that introduced me to this series, and to this day I consider them the finest examples of MWND I've ever tasted. Both were built around mature sourced MGP and Barton rye, before High West began introducing its proprietary distillate in 2018 with Act 6. As for a modern release I actually loved Act 8 in 2020! This incorporated High West's proprietary 80/20 rye, and its age ceiling had been significantly decreased to 4-7 years old but I thought it was great. After looking back, that is also the last Act I can confidently say I truly loved.
Then in 2021, Isaac Winter explicitly confirmed High West began incorporating more of its own pot still rye into Rendezvous. This was a documented change to the whiskey that serves as the foundation for MWND. And as High West's proprietary inventory continued maturing, the company increasingly had older stocks available for blending. By Act 10 in 2022, the MSRP had climbed to $150, and I wasn't the only person noticing a change in the whiskey. Bourbon Culture conducted a comparative tasting of Acts 5 through 10 and described Act 10 as noticeably more youthful, prickly, and drying, with more aggressive spice and less integration than the earlier expressions. Not to speak for everyone but I think most of us following MWND began to feel like we started paying more for less value at this point in the timeline.
Then we get to Act 13 in 2025, and we're still seeing similar if not more criticisms as the mature proprietary stocks increased as well as the age range, which was adjusted to 4-10 years. Credible independent whiskey journalist to review blogs like The Whisky Study specifically described the mouthfeel as thin and watery, lacking the rich, syrupy texture of earlier releases. The Whiskey Wash also identified a watery mouthfeel and a comparatively short finish. Now fast forward to Act 14 in 2026. I'm sitting at a table with several people, independently tasting this whiskey and comparing it against Acts 5 and 8. And what are our tasting notes?
A thinner palate, noticeably aggressive alcoholic heat, less concentration, and a lack of integration between the underlying rye whiskey and the finishing components.
It’s now starting to all sounds too familiar! This is what I find so frustrating. I’ve learned these aren't isolated observations from one persons palate over a disappointing bottle. I’m seeing similar sensory criticisms appear across multiple modern releases, and those observations deserve to be considered alongside the documented evolution of High West's blending program. And this brings me directly back to Utah’s climate discussion.
What happens when a distillery begins incorporating not only greater quantities of its own whiskey, but increasingly mature stocks that have spent years developing under an entirely different maturation environment than the sourced Kentucky and Indiana whiskey that originally built its reputation? Could it be that as High West's proprietary whiskey has become older and more prominent in its blending program, those maturation characteristics have become increasingly influential in the finished product? I believe this could possibly help explain why we're repeatedly encountering drying oak, aggressive spice, and a perceived loss of concentration in some of the more recent Midwinter releases. It also feels like instead of sourcing older rye, High West has become more focused on incorporating its increasingly mature proprietary inventory. So much so that it's changed the balance of the whiskey that originally made Midwinter exceptional. I think those are very legitimate feelings, observations, and questions.
Now, I can’t possibly establish exact percentages or the age of those proprietary rye stocks since High West hasn't disclosed the components or blending ratios. But I'm also not going to ignore what I'm seeing and tasting simply because I don't have access to High West's blending records. As a certified sommelier, I'm trained to evaluate aroma, concentration, structure, balance, and the development of flavor across the palate. And when I repeatedly identify differences in those characteristics, particularly through direct comparisons, I think those observations deserve serious consideration. The fact that independent reviewers are describing similar changes only makes the questions I’m presenting more compelling.
“Even when I joined the company over a decade ago, blends were put together essentially the same way we do now. Working with Isaac so closely, as we put these blends together and do sensory, we’ve learned so much along the way. With every year and every blend, I feel we’re getting better at what we do. I’m continually pleased and surprised by what we can accomplish together as a team”. - Tara Lindley (CSM 2026 Interview)
“I believe these releases are almost entirely their own stock, or at least the majority of the whiskey is now from the distillery. I recall the first few releases when they switched away from sourcing and things took a small dip.”
Charles Steele, The Whiskey Wash 2026
Considering all of this, I can't help but feel genuinely confused reading Tara Lindley’s Craft Spirits Magazine interview. From my own experience, to the criticisms I've encountered throughout the whiskey community, the perception of modern MWND is seemingly the exact opposite?! I can’t help but ask better at what exactly? This could be a concerning statement depending on how you want to read into it. But look… ultimately, I don’t want to suggest there's anything inherently wrong with High West's distillate. Quite frankly, I like their BIB Rye whiskey, which is entirely their distillate (its just 5 years old). I’m just questioning whether the way it's being matured, selected, and increasingly incorporated into these blends like MWND is producing the same caliber of whiskey that established the brand's reputation. Because I keep coming back to the fact that High West once built its reputation by taking exceptionally sourced rye whiskey and demonstrating how creative blending could transform it into something unique and delicious. The company now has more mature proprietary whiskey, more mash bills, more finishing options, and more resources than ever before. Yet still the best examples of MWND I've personally tasted (excluding Act 8 in 2020) remain the releases built around whiskey High West didn't distill.
“But it’s still a very fine whiskey, one I’m excited to sip on some cold winter nights. With a new finishing regimen and friendlier price point, perhaps A Midwinter Night’s Dram is finding its stride once again.” - Forbes’s David Tao
“Looking back at the last ten years, I’m confident we’ll learn just as much in the next ten. I genuinely believe our best whiskies are yet to come.” - Tara Lindley (CSM 2026 Interview)
As a final note, I know High West’s growth over the years has led to logistical impossibilities, so asking to recreate the whiskey of the past is completely unrealistic. That request would be unfair to any distillery and I don't want anyone thinking that's what I'm asking for. I simply just want MWND to live up to the quality that made me love it in the first place. For now, I can only take the people leading the future at High West at their word and hope they stay true to it. Isaac Winter is now the Master Distiller, and I hope his partnership with Tara Lindley continues to grow as they refine each blend. As a longtime fan of MWND, I'll be rooting for them. I'm also hopeful after reading Tara's final words in her Craft Spirits Magazine interview. Her willingness to keep learning, and the humility to acknowledge there's still more to learn, gives me hope for the future of High West.
I surely hope she's right.
__________________________________________________________________________________
**These whiskeys were observed and tasted over a period of 3 hours and subjected to two separate tastings that were 2 weeks apart. No, it was not blind. All notes were taken individually as tasted, and I used, what I consider to be my best glasses. They are always the same to guarantee consistency.**