Content Warning James Marsters on learning to trust Joss's character beats for Spike
James Marsters: I would have not gone into the Bermuda shorts. No, you see the thing is—if it was up to me, or any actor in LA, I would just be kissing girls or kicking butt. There would be nothing else to the character, right? That’s what I think would be the best idea at the time, but Joss id better than that so, really he is better. I would say take away the Bermuda shorts, but really that was important, that’s when he was at his low point so I learned a lot – I wouldn’t take anything away really. I would fight more, I would put more in.
platinumpenguin26: James- Do you find yourself ever way too immersed in your character?
James Marsters: Yes. In fact, when they put me in Bermuda shorts and a Hawaiian shirt, my character wanted to commit suicide, and I almost committed character suicide by whining about it. I also hated my wheelchair that I spent half a season in, so much so, that when they allowed me to kick it on camera I tried to break it entirely, hoping they wouldn't want to spend the money to buy a new one. I only bent it and had to wobble for the rest of the season. So much for acting out on set.
James Marsters: I used to answer that question, 'Whenever I was either kissing Buffy or kicking her.' Because you know you are like in the middle of things when one of those two things are happening. But I have to say after 'Fool for Love' last year after we went back in time and kinda met William. That is my favorite one now. (This is met by audience approval) It scared the absolute crap out of me. I got the script. I thought my career was over. I slammed things around in my the trailer. 'That's it, right. Flush the character down the toilet. Fine.' I want to say to Joss, 'OK, Wonder Boy. You write in this amazing world where all the great writers are. And you have sophisticated kind of plot lines. And your character development is three dimensional. And it's very sophisticated. But out there in the real world of Hollywood, how sexy you are is how rich you are. And you just cut down on my cool.' (Audience starts yelling "NO!") No, and I was wrong, and he was right. Surprise, surprise. I wish I could be right just one time. It will never happen. The whole Hawaiian shirt. I was all offended by that. It undercut my cool. What I didn't realize what they were trying to do is make Spike an underdog. They are trying to make him into someone you can root for and get behind. (Applause) That's a far piece from where we started. In 'School Hard,' it wasn't like 'Oh, I hope he gets the girl.' So, to take that character that is functionally a disposable villain and turn him into an underdog is just an incredible feat. And I'm amazed (from audience: "Yeah, but you play it) But I just say the lines until they come out right, and then I go home! It's so weird. There are two sides of every shot, guys. There's like 300 people standing manipulating the magic trick and we're all in on the magic trick. But like Spike is cool. I love myself, and I'm a nice guy. But I'm not Spike. I'm not cool like that. I'm a dork. (Lot's of "yays." James spreads him arms above his head and nods)
James Marsters: Well you know I think the original thing that made Spike more interesting than a normal villain was how was how can someone who was truly evil and a devil spawn have true love for his girl? And really want her to be safe and happy and secure… and that was the interesting dichotomy that I think is the reason I didn’t get staked.
....
Well that’s the thing, you know at first I just thought that Joss- he didn’t want me cool, he was what, jealous or something? But that’s not it. For him, cool is not interesting. For him badass is very easy to set up. It’s like [dismissively] ‘set him up as a badass, and take him down, it’s no problem..’. For him the human journey is more interesting. And that involves a lot more humiliation so I came to understand that he really was actually putting his hand in and really dealing with the character, and trying to make him something that was sustainable. If you notice, Buffy goes through humiliation after humiliation after humiliation—they all do. In Joss’ world that’s just life, you know. So it means- it actually means he likes me a lot.