r/Capitalism • • Jun 29 '20

Community Post

145 Upvotes

Hello Subscribers,

I am /u/PercivalRex and I am one of the only "active" moderators/curators of /r/Capitalism. The old post hasn't locked yet but I am posting this comment in regards to the recent decision by Reddit to ban alt-right and far-right subreddits. I would like to be perfectly clear, this subreddit will not condone posts or comments that call for physical violence or any type of mental or emotional harm towards individuals. We need to debate ideas we dislike through our ideas and our words. Any posts that promote or glorify violence will be removed and the redditor will be banned from this community.

That being said, do not expect a drastic change in what content will be removed. The only content that will be removed is content that violates the Reddit ToS or the community rules. If you have concerns about whether your content will be taken down, feel free to send a mod message.

I don't expect this post to affect most of the people here. You all do a fairly good job of policing yourselves. Please continue to engage in peaceful and respectable discussion by the standards of this community.

If you have any concerns, feel free to respond. If this post just ends up being brigaged, it will be locked.

Cheers,

PR


r/Capitalism • • 11h ago

How Socialism Would Destroy the World of Warcraft Economy

13 Upvotes

Imagine you’re playing World of Warcraft.

You’ve finally hit level 60, you’ve got your pre-raid BiS gear, and now you need everything enchanted before stepping into Molten Core.

There’s just one problem.

Enchanters are charging 100 gold for the enchant you want.

Players are furious.

“100 GOLD?! That’s ridiculous!”

“Enchanters are exploiting the working-class adventurer!”

“Nobody should have to farm for hours just to afford an enchant!”

Eventually, someone proposes a solution.

“Enchanting is a necessity, not a luxury! We need Blizzard to regulate these greedy enchanters!”

The proposal gains overwhelming support. After all, there are far more people buying enchants than selling them.

So Blizzard holds a vote.

The players overwhelmingly approve a new policy: All enchanting prices must be reduced by 70%.

That 100-gold enchant? Now legally capped at 30 gold.

The players celebrate.

Finally, someone stood up to the greedy enchanters!

But then something interesting happens.

An enchanter who previously charged 100 gold might have spent 60 gold acquiring materials, plus hours leveling the profession, obtaining rare recipes, and building their business.

At 30 gold, they’re losing money on every transaction.

So they stop selling.

Other enchanters do the same.

Some only enchant for guildmates. Others trade privately for favors or accept unofficial “tips.”

Suddenly, instead of paying 100 gold for an enchant whenever you wanted, you’re spending three hours in Stormwind looking for someone willing to do it.

The players complain again.

“These greedy enchanters are deliberately withholding their services!”

So Blizzard responds with another regulation.

“Any player with Enchanting must provide enchanting services when requested, and accepting payments above the regulated rate will result in penalties.”

Now players stop learning Enchanting.

Why spend hundreds of gold leveling a profession that you’re not allowed to profit from?

Meanwhile, fewer people are buying enchanting materials because fewer enchanters are operating.
Herbalists, miners, and dungeon farmers notice that certain materials aren’t selling profitably anymore.

They shift to other activities.

The supply chain begins to deteriorate.

But the players still want their enchants.

So Blizzard introduces another solution.

The Azeroth Enchanting Assistance Program.

Blizzard will now purchase materials, employ enchanters, and distribute subsidized enchants to qualifying players.

Of course, someone has to pay for this.

So Blizzard introduces a new 15% Auction House tax to fund the program.

Now everyone selling goods pays more.

Farmers raise their asking prices where they can, while others decide farming isn’t worth the effort.

The program becomes increasingly expensive.

  • There aren’t enough materials.
  • There aren’t enough enchanters.
  • Demand exceeds available supply.
  • So Blizzard introduces rationing.

Each player can receive one subsidized enchant per month, provided they meet the eligibility requirements.

Naturally, officers of influential guilds seem to get theirs first.

Everyone else joins a waiting list.

And somewhere in Stormwind, two players quietly exchange 200 gold for an enchant that supposedly costs 30.

Let’s look at what actually happened.

Before the regulations, an enchant cost 100 gold, and anyone willing to pay could generally find someone to provide it.

After the regulations, the official price is 30 gold.

But now you have shortages, waiting lists, unofficial markets, additional taxes, administrative bureaucracy, and fewer people willing to provide the service.

And the people with the best connections still get what they want.

The original problem was that players didn’t like how expensive enchanting was.

The proposed solution was to make enchanting cheaper by decree.

But passing a law that says something must be affordable doesn’t actually make the resources required to produce it any less scarce.

You cannot legislate away the cost of materials.
You cannot mandate that someone’s time has no value.

And you cannot eliminate supply and demand simply because the majority votes against it.

That’s the fundamental economic problem with socialist-style price controls and centralized allocation.

The policy looks wonderful when you’re the person voting to receive something cheaper.

It looks very different when you’re the person expected to provide it.

In the end, Azeroth didn’t run out of gold.

It ran out of people willing to do the work for the price the government decided they deserved.
And the funniest part?

The players would probably blame capitalism for the shortages.


r/Capitalism • • 55m ago

do you understand how luxuries become commodities?

1 Upvotes

in this thread the op wrote about how he received a bunch of hate when he shared on a plant forum that he spent $2700 on a rare plant. he asked for explanations of the hate. there were many responses, but not a single one of them mentioned anything about how luxuries become commodities, except for mine...

**************

please link to the thread. i only have pachypodium lamerei and pachypodium geayi. oh yeah, i also have pachypodium succulentum.

the explanation of the hate is painfully simple. people weren't taught how luxuries become commodities. they don't know that when you and others spend small fortunes for a rare plant, that this greatly encourages and motivates the few people who have the rare plant to propagate it, which increases the supply and reduces the price.

the solution is also simple, in theory. at the top of every nursery homepage should be the question, "what should we carry?" below it would be a list of suggested plants, sorted by donations to the nursery.

**************

on fig forums i often see people complaining about high prices. they say economically absurd things like, "anyone who is willing to pay ridiculously high prices for these rare figs is seriously stupid, especially since the prices always quickly drop." the only reason that the prices quickly drop is because the supply quickly increases. and the only reason the supply quickly increases is because the high prices strongly motivate propagation. so the only economically coherent comment would be something like, "i sure hope that plenty of people pay the high prices for these rare figs, because this will greatly encourage their propagation, so they will quickly become more abundant and affordable."

in case you missed it, this is not a fig forum. this is "a place to discuss capitalism and capitalist interests on reddit." everyone on here should thoroughly understand how luxuries become commodities. sadly this is really not the case, based on everyone's responses to the thread i linked to.

initially i was hopeful that ai would help eliminate basic economic ignorance. for example...

**************

The economic arc of Philodendron spiritus-sancti is a classic case study in extreme scarcity rents giving way to supply-curve collapse via biotechnological scaling:

  1. The Scarcity & Veblen Phase (Pre-2021): With fewer than a dozen known wild plants and strict export bans, supply was virtually fixed (Q ≈ 0). Collectors treated it as a Veblen status good, pushing prices to $10,000–$20,000+ per cutting.
  2. The Biotech Supply Shock (2021–2023): High prices acted as a massive profit signal, incentivizing commercial labs in Thailand, Ecuador, and the U.S. to crack its tissue culture (micropropagation) protocol. Tissue culture shifts propagation from slow, linear vegetative division to exponential cloning.
  3. Price Collapse & Commoditization (2023–Present): Once labs flooded the market with thousands of genetically identical clones, the supply curve shifted violently right. The price floor collapsed by over 99%—turning a five-figure luxury trophy into a $30–$65 mass-market houseplant.
  4. Ex-Situ Conservation Externality: Crucially, market forces achieved what regulation alone couldn't—by crashing the price of cultivated clones, the profit incentive to poach the remaining wild plants in Brazil vanished overnight.

**************

any ai can quickly explain the straightforward economic process by which a luxury becomes a commodity. and it can provide endless examples, from oranges to books to refrigerators to smartphones. so what explains the widespread persistence of ignorance regarding basic economic concepts? obviously not enough people are aware of their economic ignorance.

moderators, please sticky this thread. ignore all the downvotes.


r/Capitalism • • 4h ago

How do you explain to kids that trade isn’t zero-sum? We animated a 7-minute story about a lunch swap and a $10 watch spring vs a 10¢ wheel

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

Tobin thinks every trade is like arm-wrestling — if one person comes out ahead, the other must have lost. Mira sets out to prove voluntary exchange makes both sides better off, until she learns the hard way why market price tags can't replace personal consent.


r/Capitalism • • 1h ago

The wealthy deliberately closed all the doors so that you stand no chance

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/Capitalism • • 4h ago

Why Do People Hate Us, the Rich?

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/Capitalism • • 4h ago

Why Do People Hate Us, the Rich?

0 Upvotes

I bought a rare plant that cost $2700. A Pachypodium Gracilius. I posted it in a plant forum asking if anyone has spent so much on a plant. I got a LOT of hate, people accusing me of not supporting the poor (WTF?) etc.

My family had money while I was growing up and I did go to prestigious schools. But through shrewd investments and connections, I was able to retire at 29 - Im 32 now. On top of that, I was urged to invest in Anthropic and did with the bulk of my money. That has turned out spectacularly over the past few days and I have even retired the Mom of my childhood friend who passed away 5 years ago. Got her a house, healthcare, healthcare aide and all of it.

So, if ppl work hard and make their ideas come to life, like Jeff Bezos (who is a D-Bag because of the way he treats his workers) why do ppl hate them? Because those ppl didnt make the sacrifices that many ppl who become rich, have made?

Its perplexing.


r/Capitalism • • 1d ago

Tech or finance

9 Upvotes

I’m not sure if this hub is exclusively for debates on capitalism versus socialism, or if career-related ideas are also shared here, but I thought I’d ask anyway.

If you had to choose between the two industries, which one would you pick? Tech generates greater wealth in a much shorter time, whereas finance carries less risk.

And I know tech is currently more popular, but wouldn’t that lead to the sector reaching a point of saturation quite rapidly?


r/Capitalism • • 2d ago

And just like that, another multiple billion was made by the virtues of free enterprise.

Thumbnail
variety.com
33 Upvotes

The free market never disappoints.


r/Capitalism • • 1d ago

Can ethical music consumption exist in the age of capitalism?

Thumbnail
shado-mag.com
0 Upvotes

r/Capitalism • • 2d ago

capitalism’s biggest bottleneck: only seeing a fraction of the demand

0 Upvotes

capitalism works because demand is in the driver's seat. when consumers spend money, they dangle a carrot in front of producers, and producers scramble to build, grow, or invent whatever it takes to earn it.

consider the orange. centuries ago, oranges were ultra-rare luxuries reserved for kings and the ultra-wealthy. because rich buyers were willing to pay a small fortune, farmers had a massive financial incentive to plant orchards, improve shipping, and scale production. as supply exploded, prices collapsed. today, an orange costs pocket change.

that is capitalism working. it is also capitalism working painfully slowly.

it took generations for oranges to go from royal luxuries to everyday commodities. in the interim, billions of people lived and died without ever tasting one. why did the transition take so long? because standard market transactions suffer from three built-in signaling flaws that stunt the carrot:

  • zero signal for missing goods: you cannot buy what isn't for sale. if no store carries a product, your willingness to pay for it registers as $0.
  • truncated consumer surplus: you never pay more than the sticker price. if you value a rare fruit at $15,000, and a seller prices it at $10,000, that extra $5,000 of urgency stays locked in your pocket—invisible to producers.
  • unpooled partial demand: you don't buy what you can't afford. if a million people are each willing to pay $1,000 to bring a $10,000 product to market, none of them can buy it individually, so the market acts as if their massive collective demand doesn't exist.

because of these three bottlenecks, producers consistently underestimate how badly consumers want new or rare things. supply lags behind true demand for way too long.

the fix

imagine walking into trader joe's (tjs). every time you buy a bag of oranges, you are casting a dollar-weighted vote in a giant inventory survey: "keep stocking this."

now imagine you want tjs to carry something rare and exotic—say, fresh yangmei (chinese bayberry). since it isn't on the shelf, you have no way to put money behind your desire.

the fix is simple. at the top of tjs homepage would be this important question, "what should we carry?" below it would be a list of suggestions sorted by donations. it might be strange to think of donating money to a for-profit company. try thinking of the donations as public "bribes". not only could you help "bribe" tjs to carry a new product, you could help "bribe" tjs to continue carrying the old products you love the most.

tjs is notorious for discontinuing beloved products. if you're nervous about the possibility of tjs discontinuing your fav tamales, but your freezer is already filled with them, you can donate to elevate them on tjs homepage. but even if you and others "bribe" the tamales to the top of tjs homepage, this only guarantees that tjs and other shoppers will not overlook your love for the tamales.

normal shopping doesn't change at all. you still walk into the store and buy groceries off the shelf. all "donation ranking" adds is a parallel channel for consumers to voluntarily reveal the full intensity of their demand for any product, whether it exists or not.

why this actually helps the poor most

critics obsessed with wealth inequality will immediately hate this idea because billionaires could drop millions on the leaderboard to summon whatever exotic goods they want.

let them.

giving elon musk a direct way to elevate luxuries on tjs homepage doesn't make him richer—it gives him a logical opportunity to spend his money to make it harder for the rest of us to overlook what he loves. every historical luxury—from oranges and spices to antibiotics and smartphones—followed the exact same path: the rich paid to create a large dangling carrot, which encouraged the initial production that eventually made those goods cheap enough for everyone else.

if we give everyone, rich or poor, the opportunity to signal their full demand for the most useful luxuries, we make their carrots much bigger, which compresses centuries of progress into years—and turn yesterday's most useful luxuries into today's commodities.

conclusion

do you really want other people trying to guess what you truly love? socialism fails because planners are certain that they can do a good job of guessing what you truly love. hayek put it best when he labeled this as a fatal conceit. what hayek didn't fully grasp though is that traditional capitalism is also based on "planners" trying to guess demand. the difference is, the guesses are judged directly by consumers. musk correctly guessed that there would be considerable demand for electric vehicles that drive themselves, and consumers have rewarded him considerably. the fact is though, nobody benefits by toyota or ford wrongly guessing demand and allocating massive amounts of society's limited resources on bad bets. it might seem like musk benefits, but in reality he doesn't, because he's also a consumer.

in order for capitalism to work best, we need to minimize the guesswork. tjs shouldn't need to guess the love for yangmei. the love for yangmei should be on tjs homepage. whether its at the top, or bottom, or somewhere in the middle would be entirely up to each and every consumer to help decide with their own money.

demand should be in the driver's seat. but if you understand why this benefits everyone, then you should appreciate that, in order to drive from scarcity to abundance in the shortest possible time, we need to eliminate speed bumps and accidents caused by demand blindness.


r/Capitalism • • 2d ago

Why are we punishing people who work and rewarding people who don’t work? And why are people not doing anything about it ?

29 Upvotes

How is it possible than when we hit certain threshold almost everything reamaing goes to the government and I know it’s bcs we have “ good welfare system” ( I know I may be subjective here bcs of the insane corruption in my country ) but honestly if it works like this then there is no point in trying harder. And it is really taking out the motivation of working.


r/Capitalism • • 2d ago

Is Being Anti Union Actually Being Anti Freedom and Anti Capitalism?

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/Capitalism • • 2d ago

Why does our economy reward speculation more than the workers who actually create value?

0 Upvotes

Teachers, nurses and construction workers keep society running, yet many struggle while property investors grow rich from rising asset prices. We should reward productive investment with tax credits for building homes, factories, infrastructure and creating jobs, not give broad tax cuts that also reward speculation. Public investment can help private businesses grow. Why does our tax system reward owning and flipping existing assets instead of creating new wealth, better wages and a stronger middle class?


r/Capitalism • • 2d ago

What do most Americans think about the ultra-rich living vastly better lives than the average person?

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/Capitalism • • 4d ago

I really don’t get the hate on Capitalism and I’m afraid to talk about it because you are seen as right winged and contentious.

57 Upvotes

I believe that people worked hard to get wealthy, only to be called a capitalist as a derogatory is sad.

Why aren’t people held accountable for their own mistakes?

Why do people think big corporations are solely after profit when supply and demand exist? They say it as if these persons are monsters and don’t care.

Most of these ceo’s are humans and have done a lot of charitable donations but they don’t care, so let’s just raid Walmart and take everything because they are worth billions of dollars.

Do people think Large Corporations don’t have to make serious business decisions to stay afloat?

I agree that there should be some degree of social welfare within capitalism, but gosh, it’s exhausting when every single person thinks ‘Rich people are all about themselves and never try to help anyone’


r/Capitalism • • 3d ago

Where will capitalism be in the next few centuries?

0 Upvotes

People say socialism may be good in theory but always turns out bad because it goes to the extreme. They fight against any social programs or things that give something to someone who they don't feel is deserving. But capitalism is a newer concept & it seems that it is not as beneficial to average people as it could/should be because companies have slowly done everything they can to squeeze every penny out of people they can for profit. So prices go up while wages and quality go down. What will capitalism & society be like in 100 years? 200 years? Is the kind of unregulated capitalism that conservatives want really conducive to a good and prosperous society over centuries of time?


r/Capitalism • • 2d ago

Why do working families keep falling for the "billionaires will leave" scare tactic

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/Capitalism • • 3d ago

Abolishing Private Property: What Really Happens?

Thumbnail
reddit.com
6 Upvotes

What do you folks think?


r/Capitalism • • 3d ago

Why don’t we make like a practice economy with people

0 Upvotes

There a game call arc raiders that I play. What if each different server was merged into one or better yet an account of everything available in the game. So like bullets or metal parts you use to craft them is a set number. Know take that scenario and put it into a game like city Skyline where you have funds, people or anything other resource to manage. Can we do that for an actual real County or state in the U.S I’m getting people a chance to try and solve and economic problem?.


r/Capitalism • • 4d ago

Kevin O’Leary clashes with Gen Z worker over investing and wealth

35 Upvotes

r/Capitalism • • 3d ago

Without a 'timeless and universal' theory of 'man' why would capitalism be expected to serve human needs?

0 Upvotes

And if 'man' isn't timeless and universal then in what sense does it serve 'human' needs rather than the needs of particular persons?


r/Capitalism • • 5d ago

The Open-Source Economy

5 Upvotes

I think there could be a new type of economy - the open-source economy.

I was thinking about this while thinking about how Linux worked.

Linux is built with voluntary contributors, and it's so good that it's the background of many major computational systems in the world.

Linux is free, because it is built by unpaid volunteers. Even people who didn't participate in building it are welcome to use it.

So, why can't the whole world work like this? Because no one would volunteer to clean toilets, be a doctor, etc.?

A lot of people making the above argument also don't believe a group of people would voluntarily gather to form a software-building community for the betterment of the world (Linux).

The fact of the matter is that as long as people want clean toilets, the toilets will be cleaned by someone. As long as people need doctors, someone will end up being good at healing others.

It got me thinking, because the idea is neither a free-market nor communism. I mean... I guess it's more free-market, because it relies on voluntary contributions. But people have also told me I'm a communist for suggesting it as a possibility, lol.

But like, what are the biggest alternatives to Linux? Microsoft and macOS. They're both massive corporations that charge for their product, which is why their product is not open-source. I would also say that Linux is more powerful - it is used as the go-to for training AI, for building rockets, for just about everything.

What about an open-source economy?