I've been around cats my entire life, & my ex-girlfriend had this cat that I used to constantly go rounds with. It eventually got to the point where she would take it to her parents' house whenever I came over because I was accused of bullying, hitting, & abusing it. In reality, I was just setting boundaries. I wasn't going to let a cat jump on the bed in the middle of the night, bite & scratch my head because it wanted food, & expect me to put up with that shit. I'd push it off the bed because I wasn't tolerating that behavior.
Anyway, I recently started seeing this girl who has an absolute Grade A, top-drawer asshole of a cat. This thing doesn't give a fuck about anybody. You can't pet it, touch it, or even approach it without it swatting, hissing, or trying to bite you. It's an absolute sack of shit. From my perspective, the only things this cat cares about are food, water, & shelter. The problem is that this girl is incredibly empathetic, & I think she projects a lot of her own emotions onto the cat.
She recently brought home a kitten, & I honestly find myself rooting for her to keep it simply because I know how much it pisses off her older cat. This thing is so territorial & such an asshole that seeing another kitten invade its space genuinely makes me happy. But she keeps saying things like, "I just know my older cat feels betrayed that I brought this kitten home," or "I see so much of my personality in her." She was even excited because the older cat had started following her into different rooms & sleeping in the same bed. And I'm just sitting there thinking, listen to yourself. You're getting excited because a cat occasionally follows you around the house.
This cat is genuinely an asshole, & I think she's giving it far more credit than it deserves. It follows her around because it wants something, usually food. The moment it realizes there's nothing to gain, it's gone. The only time this thing seems remotely interested in her is when there's food or water involved. She even thinks the cat greeting her at the door is some kind of affectionate gesture. No, the cat hears somebody walking into the house & pokes its head out to see what's happening. That's it. This thing spends most of its time hissing, swatting, biting, & acting like an absolute dick, yet she interprets these occasional moments of attention as signs of some deep emotional connection.
And here's where I think the biggest disconnect is. I don't believe cats form the kinds of emotional attachments that people like to imagine, & they don't experience the emotions that we do as human beings. They aren't sitting around contemplating betrayal, loyalty, love, or whether their owner has hurt their feelings in the same way a person would. She's projecting an entire range of human emotions onto an animal that, as far as I'm concerned, is primarily interested in food, water, comfort, territory, & sleep. I genuinely believe this particular cat could watch her get hit by a car & not give it a second thought. Yet she's worried that bringing home another kitten has somehow emotionally betrayed it. I just find that entire way of thinking incredibly difficult to understand.
And I know introducing another kitten is a separate issue because cats can be territorial, but I just don't know how to explain my perspective without sounding like an asshole. I really like this girl, but it seems like she has such a romanticized view of what this cat thinks & feels that we're practically looking at two completely different animals.