I don't expect perfection from C-Dramas. But I figure if they got the first three quarters of a show right it will end reasonably well. But every once in a while a show just completely falls apart and goes from being reasonably coherent to complete nonsense. So infuriating!
It's not that the ending is disappointing. It's worse than that. It's like the last 4 episodes were written by drunk hamsters. It's like they intentionally destroy the show and laugh in your face.
I just completed what was otherwise a compelling drama called REN YU. It's two stories in one.
Story One is about a high school girl Su Lin who is bullied down a local sewer and left for dead. Her dysfunctional Dad abandons her for payoffs to never mention which mean girl pushed her into that sewer. Su Lin befriends a crazy but kind homeless dude who also lives down there and finds a better 'family' than she ever hard in the real world.
(This young actress is Huangyang Tian Tian, who appeared briefly in RUYI'S ROYAL LOVE IN THE PALACE and REBEL PRINCESS, playing the kid versions of the respective leads. She was also terrific as a young Yang Mi in THE GREAT CRAFTSMAN, where she shined with many scenes.)
Story Two is that the city has a serial killer who dumps his young female victims into the sewers, so we of course fear Su Lin is living with the serial killer... and she might be next. The show then has a ball dropping red herrings everywhere and so it's both an engaging 'family' drama as well as a fun whodunnit.
This is an odd pairing but rather engaging set up.
The first sign that there was something wrong with the show is that characters refused to do obvious little things. You find yourself yelling at the TV. "Talk to the homeless guy!" "Tell your Mom what you saw!" "Tell the teachers what those bullies are doing!!" "Call the police!!!"
Sure, the show would provide decent reasons for characters to hesitate like this, but it knocked a 10 out of 10 show down to a 9. I call these hesitations 'fake tension', because although it engages you to show -- the characters aren't quite behaving normally.
At the end of this show, however, nothing made sense anymore. The writing made every last bad choice you could think of and destroyed everything they'd been working up to.
If you've seen the show I accuse them of chickening out from doing the hard work. I'm a writer and recognize these obligatory scenes would be hard to write, but tough -- that's your job. And this story was based on an existing story, and so if it was good how did you fools mess it up?!?
1. Su Lin had to have a final confrontation with her parents for abandoning her. The reason they avoided this was because of her innocent brother. If she reveals to her brother she's still alive, his heart breaks. And if her Mother found out she was alive, she'd want custody. So if Su Lin spoke to any of them, she'd be dragged back into her hellhole. If she doesn't, it's mean somehow to her Mom and Brother.
2. It was set up rather early that Old Gu would be an amazing Dad for Su Lin. And the series sets up Gu getting married to a nice lady who'd make a great Mom for Su Lin. Gu explicitly offers Su Lin a home and new life -- but she rejects it. Why? Because it's hard to write the scenes where she is adopted by Gu with her real parents still in the world. So they chickened out and went for a --
3. -- a revenge story. But here it makes no sense either. The actual serial killer traps and endangers Su Lin's nemesis, Ma Na. Here the audience wants Ma Na to change and realize Su Lin isn't her actual enemy. But that's difficult writing so -- instead -- the writing gets all lazy and dumps Ma Na on a shore where she soon conveniently becomes catatonic. For if she were to speak, you'd need excellent writing to complete her character arc.
4. Su Lin also decides to trap the serial killer, but the weird thing here is that he wasn't going after Su Lin but Ma Na. So, in a weird way, what exactly is Su Lin's beef with him? He liked her. Her beef is with how the killer treats Vincent, but that entire angle felt more forced than clever.At this point you're screaming at your TV, "Just meet with Gu, explain who the killer is, and he'll call all his lovely police friends!!!!!!!!!!!!!!" But no, that would make sense, and the show can't make sense at this point, now can it?
5. So if Su Lin accepted Gu's offer and became family with him, what happens to Vincent? A beautiful and challenging take would be to either have Vincent move in too, or have Vincent live in the streets but cared for, or have Vincent face he no longer belongs in the real world. But of course the show took the lazy route and had him hit by a car while running for his life.
6. The series had this thing about mermaids. The opening animation implies Su Lin will metaphorically evolve into one. But by the end of the story she instead evolved into an evil-ish girl and abandoned the entire idea, save for Gu who for no sane reason postulates that she's living as a mermaid in the ocean. As much as I like Dong Yong, even he couldn't pull of this bullsh!t.
7. One weird thing about this show was it's focus on supporting character Ting. Her story wasn't as important as Su Lin's, and in this way I felt the writers were avoiding the harder work of staying focused on Su Lin and Vincent, where this series shined.