I was partially inspired by Tony Vuong's pitch in Quora, though I have not seen anyone suggesting this idea before, so I decided to do this little write-up.
Looking back to the "Reclaimer Trilogy" whatever that meant, people debate where it went wrong. I'd argue the original sin was bringing back Master Chief in the first place. When I first beat Halo 3, I kind of accepted it as the series' ending. Chief sacrificed himself, accomplished his mission, and drifted into the endless darkness of space, and might be picked up... I don't know, a million years later? That is, if he gets picked up. I always thought that that was the end of him, remaining as a legend for humans, who hold a funeral. Halo 3 was the perfect send-off point.
So when I saw the E3 2011 teaser of Halo 4, I was completely befuddled. Wait, Master Chief is back? Halo 3 came out only 4 years ago! And indeed, the game does say that only 4 years have passed from the events of Halo 3. Really? Didn't literally 2/3 of humanity get extinct in the last war? Didn't Earth get glassed? The Holy Roman Empire lost 20%-40% of its population in the Thirty Years' War, and it took 50 to 100 years to recover its pre-war demographic and economic levels. I know that was pre-industrial society, but we are talking about that on the galactic scale. Do they not have a civilization to rebuild? They are in an end-time apocalypse, and the UNSC bounced back somehow, pumping out a bigger fleet and Spartans like a factory... for what, exactly?
Instead, the story is about the Forerunners doing evolutionary planning and implanting instructions for humanity’s technology to do a "chosen one" bullshit. It delves into the ""lore"" that you have to read a book, some audio logs, and a PHD in Halo Mythology to understand. That is, if you read them, you will know that the Prometheans spit in the face of everything that used to be established about the Forerunners. And you have Chief going through an emotional arc, but the appeal of Master Chief is that he is an empty vessel, who shares more similarities with the classic silent FPS protagonists than someone like Harry Potter or Luke Skywalker. In fact, the whole destiny and fate nonsense is directly criticized in Bungie's trilogy, with the Covenant being obsessed with it. Ultimately, what wins the war is the human force of will. Halo 4 didn't look like, sound like, play like, or feel like Halo.
The less said about Halo 5 and Infinite, the better. 343 couldn't make up their mind about what kind of story they wanted to tell for the new trilogy. Not that Halo ever had a good story. While there may be good stories in the Halo EU, it’s not in the games and never has been. The story ranged from decent enough to embarrassing. However, it had a direction and worked as a power fantasy. With Halo 1-3, it was about fighting the alien race that wages a religious war against humanity. Aura and vibe. It works. With Halo 4-6... what is it about? Is it about Chief's personal arc of grieving and going AWOL, or Cortana becoming the Skynet, or the Didact, or the Covenant civil war, or whatever Infinite's story was? They didn't even figure out if Chief was the last Spartan. Telling us that Chief is no longer special in the age when the Spartan program is back, only to unceremoniously kill them off in the next game just to say Chief is the last of his kind... all over again... What is this, The Force Awakens?
I thought about what the 343 trilogy should have been if they inevitably had to exist. When I read any rewrite of Halo 4-6 that doesn't remove Master Chief, I stop caring because the ending of Master Chief will always be escaping from the exploding station and him staying asleep. It ended on such a definite note. There didn’t need to be anything after for him. I choose to believe Chief is still floating around space, and anything that pulls him out of his sleep is a fanfic. Write anew back to that point. Scrap everything after.
So if Chief is not the center of the new trilogy, who should be? Surely, Chief is the face of Halo. Well, Halo 3 ODST and Halo Reach exist, which tells me that Bungie saw the appeal of Halo was more about the universe and not an individual character. If you insist that they are spin-offs, okay. I will say that Master Chief is not the sole protagonist of Bungie's mainline Halo games. There was another...
Remember how playing as a Covenant in Halo 2 was a shock? Because I was when I first played it. I wonder if Halo 2 was inspired by Metal Gear Solid 2. Up to that point, you were playing as Master Chief, defending Earth from the Covenant, until there was a sudden bait and switch to put you in the eyes of the enemy commander who was fighting against you on the first Halo. We are suddenly thrown into the Covenant's internal politics and religion. Arbiter? He was not in the advertisement, took time away from Master Chief, and generated a fan backlash. What am I even doing? Fighting some random Covenant rebels? I want to play as Chief! Arbiter's arc is even similar to Raiden's arc, as he gradually turns against his masters, who have been manipulating him all along, and eventually joins Master Chief. Looking at his progression from Halo 2 to 3, I wonder if Arbiter was supposed to be the new Chief. He has the same moveset, becomes Chief's sidekick, and was even a coop partner by the time of Halo 3.
Arguably, there is a wealth of materials to explore after Halo 3 on the side of the Covenant. Halo Evolutions published a series of short stories, and one of them, The Return, gave an insight into what the situation was after the Human-Covenant War. The Elites were disenfranchised with the Covenant, though many of them still search for spiritual guidance, and they were at war with the Brutes. After the religious order that has been putting them together collapsed in Halo 3, how did the Covenant society react? It wouldn't be a peaceful transition. It would be a complete shitshow--revolution, rebellion, rebuilding, ethnic conflict...
I imagine Halo 4 taking this direction, similar to Metal Gear Rising: Revengeance, in which Raiden fights the villains who seek to revive the war economy from MGS4. Now, we have one coherent direction. We mostly saw the point of view from the human fighting the Covenant in Halo 1-3, and the next trilogy should have been Arbiter, trying to rebuild a new society, while the remnants of the old cult would wage a civil war. Halo 5 hinted at this, and... why is this not the whole game in the first place? The UNSC-Sangheili Coalition is formed, so the player could use the human weaponry, AI companions, and vehicles, and they are fighting the Brutes (not Jul ‘Mdama’s Covenant nor the Banished) in the civil war. If you want to bring the Forerunner stuff into the narrative, have the Brutes searching for the Janus Key, which provides the location of Forerunner technology in the galaxy.
This way, it can still retain desperation, which is the core idea of the Bungie games. In those games, humanity is always pushed to the corner, and only you have the power to save humanity. You could still generate a similar kind of power fantasy with Arbiter by emphasizing how desperate their situation is in building the new society. At the same time, you could still add a more emotional arc that would work better with Arbiter because he is the dynamic character.
With this reimagined Halo 5, this is the perfect opportunity to have "a new Spartan protagonist hunts down the old protagonist" plotline by tying it with the conflict between humanity and Elites. Maybe the UNSC doesn't trust the Elites since, obviously, the Elites were on the side of the Covenant and slaughtering humans. The UNSC creates a new Spartan team and orders it to chase Arbiter's Elite team. As the plot progresses, it is revealed that the Brutes are behind the AI revolt (not Cortana), leading the UNSC Fireteam and Arbiter's team to work together. The theme is to bring the two species together for the greater good.
With Halo Infinite, again, remove the Banished--the space pirates who randomly get introduced in Infinite and never gets properly explained. Apparently, they were introduced in Halo Wars 2, which most players didn't play. We replace that faction with the Brutes, who now have the power of AI on their side, seizing control of the galaxy. Arbiter learns the Brutes plan to take control of another Halo and use it as a weapon. It is sort of a role reversal since Arbiter was ordered to protect the Halo in CE, and now, he is put in the situation to destroy it. The player should have been a part of the massive conflict at the start of the game, where the protagonist lost, which would have been reminiscent of Halo 1. We should have seen what was stored within the Ring, besides the boss, and at least defeated a portion of it and sealed it away again instead of just being teased with hints of what it might be. No "Endless" sequel tease. Make it a definite conclusion of the trilogy.