I think the story of me buying a guitar for the first time can be helpful for some people.
I had a guitar before like 4 years ago which was a gift and I only played very little because we then moved to another country and I gave the gift back
I have a asked a lot of questions in this community comparing a multiple guitars and I was really unsure. I kept looking in Facebook market place trying to find a good beginner guitar, something I would spend more than 250 Australian dollars. My original budget was maximum A$500 but then I decided I would go with a cheaper one so that I know whether I am actually into guitar, whether I would have time to practice or whether time management would be an issue. But, at the same time, i wanted something that sounds decent.
And then, one day my dad and I were going through items in marketplace and we reached a Valencia VC704 with case originally priced as 450 dollars but then at the time we found it it was 300 dollars. If it was me, I would have skipped it as it was outside of my budget range but my dad got curious and we searched it. Guess what, it is a solid spruce top.
my dad then looked for the same model brand new on early black Friday sale. the original price is A$300-360 but we found a website that would give it for $260 dollars after discount. we took a screenshot of it and sent it to the owner and we just simply typed "I don't think you can sell at this price" meaning she won't be able to sell her guitar for $300 when a brand new is $260.
She then reduced the price to 200 dollars. we messaged again and said we are interested. we travelled 70 minutes to her apartment. I played the few chords and melodies I knew on her guitar. I checked for misalignment on the neck. then I checked the surface back and sides for hits and scratches. then I played every note on every fret to see if there are any buzzes. Then, I started playing with the strings to see if they go out of tune too soon. everything was perfect. she took a good care of the guitar. In fact, she was a pianist and a composer. but guitar wasn't her thing. so she had taken good care of the guitar.
she bought the guitar with the case around A$500 but because she wanted to move to another country after the Christmas, she was selling everything. she was in a hurry.
for reference a new yamaha c70 is A$260 and after discount it would be A$225 before shipping fees and without case. the cheapest C40 gigmaker (c40 with a low quality bag and tuner) is A$180 after discount. these are laminated tops and I really didn't like how they sound especially c40
when I tried c40 in our local store it was like this. Imagine you say "listen to me" normally. you can hear it you can understand it. but then make an O with your mouth and then try to say "Listen to me" now you understand but there is less DEFINITION in your tone and it doesn't seem as natural. that was how c40 sounded to me, especially on treble strings. Because I have a musical back ground (violin for a long time) I understand phrasing, contrast etc. and I knew it wouldn't be a good choice for me and then this happened.
at the end before leaving the apartment, we asked her whether she was happy with the deal. she said yes and she said she is glad the guitar reached someone who understands music.
so moral of the story, don't rush into buying a guitar just because it fits your budget or because it's a popular beginner model. Do your research, explore the second-hand market, and most importantly, trust your ears. Sometimes, with a little patience, persistence, and luck, you can find something much better. Also don't be shy and negotiate. some people might be in different circumstances and not aware of the real prices out there.
about the valencia it sounds perfect. it is loud and clear with good definition. I also tried CG122MS and they are both very good instruments. I am very happy with the guitar that I have right now. it gives me the sound that would encourage me to play. So don't think about Yamaha or Cordoba only. there might be other brands and models that would suit you.
I hope my story helps people buying a good guitar.
cheers!