r/classicwow • • 2d ago • Popcorn 1

Forever Please Blizzard, do not go all-in on "biome" gear. No one wants their BiS item to only be useful if you're fighting Murlocs in a Swamp on a June afternoon.

This comes from the podcast, where they said they are moving away from set bonuses and going in hard on what they called biome gear. If that's the idea for "horizontal" progression I seriously dislike it. And specially, no one wants the inevitable monetized Bag and Bank space that will come with it.

Every item will feel extremely unrewarding. Soon enough raiders will be told to put on their "Kill Badgers in the Underwater Cavern" gear that does not work anywhere else. That simply is not the way to go. I much prefer the traditional progression - you don't need to have overpowered set bonuses - but just gear that matters. Thank you.

2.8k Upvotes

1.9k comments sorted by

998

u/SoungaTepes 2d ago

It was a mid summer night, so I equipped my hip onion to do more damage during this time, which was the style at the time

227

u/Ok_Assignment_2127 2d ago

Blizzard saw how much tanks hated carrying 3 resistance sets and decided that everyone had to feel the pain.

A few extra bank slots will surely compensate having 6-7 extra sets of gear per raid!

30

u/Baptism-Of-Fire 2d ago

Bank slots?  No. Bag slots. Lol and potions need to stack to 20. 

→ More replies (8)

5

u/Glasse 2d ago edited 2d ago

It would be nice if they implemented some sort of armory tied to gear sets.

You can create up to idk like 10 gear sets and each set has its own armory slots that the gear goes in and doesn't take bag space, or just straight up an armor bag that has like 15 slots for every slot... or at minimum give us retail bag sizes...

It's painful enough only having 2 specs as a druid, struggling with bag space on top of it is awful.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (18)

26

u/lapetee 2d ago

So I then handled a nickel to the gold seller, which in thooose days, were called the early blackmaw farmers

→ More replies (2)

7

u/Katchooooo 2d ago

We didn’t have the white onions, because of the war.

27

u/ShoePsychological199 2d ago edited 2d ago

Good luck keeping track of this nonsense across one or more alts.

"Oh nice, underpants of sand papering my backside while riding the bus dropped! But wait, was it my mage or my warlock or my shadow priest that already had it?"

And then ring of calming mood while traveling on highways drops and you just roll need because you're not even sure if you're going to use it or which of your characters have it but you don't want to come back for it later so need roll it is.

These devs are SMOKING CRACK

12

u/SoungaTepes 2d ago

That’s actually a solid point I hadn’t considered, ALTs.

This is in fact an alt unfriendly design 

→ More replies (3)

5

u/Davimous 2d ago

Now I want there to be an onion trinket or a whole onion belt.

11

u/Trip-Trip-Trip 2d ago

if that's the implementation I can work with it.

→ More replies (7)

21

u/GlowyStuffs 2d ago

We really need 30 slot soulbound gear bags if we are going to carry sets of gear

4

u/TeaspoonWrites 2d ago

SoD had 32 slot bags and they said we would likely go bigger than that at some point.

→ More replies (3)

1.7k

u/AngryCrawdad 2d ago • Bravo

Can't really do horizontal design if you have an objectively best thing that outscales everything else.

Having alternatives that are contextually good seems like an obvious choice.

299

u/SmokingTheToesOfGod 2d ago

Right, and there’s design space between “BiS literally all the time” and “that weird piece of wood that’s been sitting in dad’s garage for 20 years on the off chance it might be useful someday”.

Blizzard just hasn’t established any amount of trust that they can pull off interesting horizontal progression without turning it into the latter.

186

u/Thunderkleize 2d ago

Blizzard just hasn’t established any amount of trust that they can pull off interesting horizontal progression without turning it into the latter.

Is the answer to just give up before it happens?

89

u/TurnipFire 2d ago

Look we need stuff to be mad about okay?

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (24)

33

u/jamesbongsixtynine 2d ago

“that weird piece of wood that’s been sitting in dad’s garage for 20 years on the off chance it might be useful someday”

LOL the bank really is like that

14

u/RJ815 2d ago

Just you wait, one day someone is going to use a Light of Elune to win a world first race when everyone but them is dead and the boss is at 1%

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Porbles 2d ago

Someday a boss is going to need me to have saved Shoni's Disarming Tool I swear

→ More replies (3)

33

u/Jakcris10 2d ago

I feel like there’s a real difference in expectations between people who have played OSRS and people who haven’t.

43

u/Cookie_Clicking_Gran 2d ago

This is a community that will never be happy to be completely blunt. The unfortunate truth is that wow fundamentally does not leave a lot of room for horizontal progression from a game design perspective, and any attempts blizz makes to try out things seems to have people frothing at the mouth regardless of the direction.

People ask for an engaging horizontal progression/itemization but never seem to articulate what that would look like to them, just that it's "not that"

→ More replies (14)
→ More replies (7)

9

u/underated_ 2d ago

I can't read this and NOT link the perfect video:

https://youtube.com/shorts/R7LsubMttMs

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (16)

74

u/Brassmoose 2d ago • Bravo

Horizontal progression is fun and works well when you have to make decisions to tailor your build to certain situations, just looking at a zone and matching its biome to your gear is not an engaging choice

16

u/Cookie_Clicking_Gran 2d ago

What sort of circumstances would you want to have to tailor your build around?

34

u/DragonAdept 2d ago

Fights where you move a lot, or move a little. Very long or very short fights or fights where you need a lot of burst. Fights where you need to be at particular ranges. Fights with lots of raid damage. Fights where you switch targets a lot or where you tunnel-vision one thing. Fights against swarms of adds. Fights where you definitely do one thing or might need to switch between things.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (10)
→ More replies (23)

19

u/smang12 2d ago

I love having 7 different sets of BIS

12

u/InZomnia365 2d ago

In other words, you dont have a BIS.

Best in Slot literally means the best overall item for that slot, not the best item for every single fight in the game. Even a BIS piece can be outperformed by something else on one fight. Thats the entire point here.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (3)

17

u/Glittering-Star-3495 2d ago

Here me out, horizontal can be things that aren't gear as well

10

u/burkechrs1 2d ago

But WoW is inherently designed around acquiring gear. It's the primary goal of the overwhelming amount of players and every ounce of content has been designed around that objective.

Sure, you can design horizontal progression around professions, and exploration, and achievements but the majority of players don't care about that. They want content that gives them better gear and don't care about the rest.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (7)

23

u/_GrimHiker 2d ago

The obvious choice is the ARPG design model where you have build enabling items that dont make you "better" than other builds, it just makes certain things more functional.

You can have items that change how abilities work, modify ability trees entirely, give certain perks or bonuses your class otherwise doesnt have access to, etc...

In my opinion getting the "staff of murloc slaying" seems basic, boring, and awful to manage. Theres a reason most players ignore that kind of items in games that let you do them, because nobody wants to keep track of all their "slaying" items, which is all this is.

For example the BIS trinket for many classes right now is basically "dragonkin slaying". YAWN.

12

u/ademayor 2d ago

As VERY long time ARPG player, so called “exotic items” that change the way your skills work requires very large set of skills and talents to choose from (which WoW will never have). And even then it leads to “garbage exotics” and actually usable ones, where usable ones will become BiS because they are mathematically better for PvE/PvP. Then another thing, you would have loot tables filled with every classes exotic items so farming them would be pain. Or you make it that you get it from quest which makes it too easy to obtain.

And after they nerf either the skill or the item, it becomes worthless over night. These things work in ARPG where everything resets once in 3 months, not in MMO.

5

u/AngryCrawdad 2d ago

That's a fun idea. Having trinkets that essentially work like talent points might be fun though you'd essentially end up with a lightweight version of the rune system from SoD - which could be a positive or negative depending on implementation.

4

u/RookYourself 1d ago

Yeah, you want to be excited to wear a different set of gear not feel like you have to manage a bunch of different gear sets now just to stay competitive. It also doesn't really affect PvP if it's only good against murlocs, and PvP players will have no reason to raid. That's a huge part of why raiding is fun for me - because it gives gear that helps me PvP.

→ More replies (4)

6

u/Separate-String5205 2d ago

The problem with items that buff certain abilities, give certain perks or bonuses your class doesn't otherwise have access to, etc is that we have sims and can find the mathematically optimal choice for every scenario, which just leads back to BiS itemization.

8

u/gravygrowinggreen 2d ago

At a certain point, you're going to have to accept that you can't want a new BiS thing to be made every few months without having vertical progression. If you want horizontal progression, you're going to have to be okay with players using gear that is "good enough" because it's fun and novel, rather than best in slot.

→ More replies (18)
→ More replies (11)

12

u/Lochen9 2d ago

Making a new raid where enemy types or what biome it is in the only difference and gear is completely replaced is just current retail seasons, without the scaling. I also suspect it will not drive the interest to want to go out and get the gear if its the same thing the 6ths time, but now in a swamp

5

u/El_Rey_de_Spices 2d ago

Exactly this. It's going to have the opposite effect, where I just stop caring about gear.

I've still yet to see an explanation of what 'horizontal progression' is supposed to be like besides "like GW2!", whatever that means. If this is it, I suspect it's going to mostly fall on its proverbial face with the majority of the playerbase.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (3)

12

u/Odd_Common_452 2d ago

They’re not doing horizontal gear design.

11

u/InnerLet5057 2d ago

Linear desgin is horizontal if you go 90 degrees.

→ More replies (10)

19

u/ElectricRinku 2d ago edited 2d ago

They have said over and over again that horizontal design does not apply to gear and gearing will still be very much vertical.

10

u/Riokaii 2d ago

what they said was that vertical will still occur to some extent, but they want the vertical to be 1.03x per increase, not 1.2x jumps per tier

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (55)
→ More replies (75)

82

u/Salsasp11 2d ago

Guys you're missing the point here, if you want horizontal progression you can't have items that are just the objectively best option in any scenario. If you want to not think about minmaxing you can still take a small hit to dps, but this gives the true min maxxers reasons to farm all content to fill out their situational gear.

→ More replies (9)

182

u/BuddyCanadian 2d ago

I would rather take a dps hit than maintaining equipment for each different biome.

49

u/FakeSafeWord 2d ago

Which is exactly what will happen again. People will theory craft out the exact minimum recommended gearscore and stat (ig resistance) for a given boss/raid and that's what people will work towards and then when they surpass those values they begin swapping back to the higher dps/healing/tank general scenario gear, replacing the zone specific gear as soon as possible.

25

u/BuddyCanadian 2d ago

As long as its like the Runescape system then I wont care. I.e. Items that are slightly more efficient to use against certain monsters, but not impossible to do without.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (4)

18

u/trogger93 2d ago

ya, I can't be assed. I already dislike the hinterlands trinket that gets a bonus in 'forests'.

10

u/Senes_ 2d ago

oh boy did you see briarwood reed? one of the most iconic pre raid caster trinkets

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

13

u/TeamRedundancyTeam 2d ago

Which is exactly what blizzard said they expect.

I don't know why everyone here just ignores the actual design and uses any excuse to bitch and moan.

No one has to carry tons of different sets. You don't have to "parse" either. This game isn't designed around end game raiders parsing being the most important design focus. People need to realize and accept that and go play classic era/tbc/wotlk or retail instead.

→ More replies (2)

8

u/kunair 2d ago

yea even osrs doesn't have this level of granular bs lol

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (8)

173

u/peanut-britle-latte 2d ago

I don't understand how else horizontal progression is supposed to work.

I've played MMOs that have item enchants that boost resistance/attack vs. specific monsters/elements/whatever and it encourages gear set swapping based on content, not one sized fits all.

BiS becomes something that is context dependent and not simply "BiS for everything".

35

u/poesviertwintig 2d ago

WoW is a bit restrictive because it was never built around it, but there are ways to do it. Things like:

* Introduction of a new gimmick/stat (e.g. Lifestealing) or more gear with rare stats (armor/spell pen)

* Gear that interacts with an existing stat, such as a weapon that converts Spirit into Spellpower, or Armor into Attack Power. This shakes up the value of old gear and creates new "BiS" lists, making old raids interesting again.

* Enemies with specific strengths/weaknesses to build around. Viscidus is an example of that, though its implementation can feel a bit clunky. This can also make previously unwanted gear suddenly become valuable, and it can be a cleaner/less forced way than the "biome gear" solution. A boss with high armor makes armor penetration more valuable, but armor penetration remains useful elsewhere.

* New playstyles, like the battlemage blade they introduced. These are difficult to balance though, since you're essentially creating a subclass if you go deep enough in this.

I'm not saying horizontal progression should be exactly like the above, but I can see it work even in WoW.

10

u/Majestic-Coat3855 2d ago

Every one of these is more interesting than a flat you do X amount of damage more in a forest. 

→ More replies (1)

29

u/FlaminarLow 2d ago

They should introduce a stat that reduces the damage you take, but only in PvP. Something that makes you more resilient. People will love that

30

u/vlee89 2d ago

That stat will feel bad cause it’s completely useless in PVE. We need something more versatile.

→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (6)

5

u/Gorganov 2d ago

The battle mage blade is exactly the type of item they need to use for inspiration. But something that looks quirky on the surface , but you discover other pieces of loot to make it come online. Like an offhand that changes frost bolt to frost strike, 6 sec cd melee attack that works with the blade. Then the burning needs to trigger another thing , etc

→ More replies (1)

4

u/idungiveboutnothing 2d ago

New playstyles, like the battlemage blade they introduced. These are difficult to balance though, since you're essentially creating a subclass if you go deep enough in this.

This is where I thought the best direction would be. Just add all kinds of new items and let the players figure out builds and weird things to do with them. Go the route of ARPGs with interaction based builds. Oh a new trinket is out that lets Guardian Pets be considered real pets impacted by your talents? Time for the BM hunter zoo build!

Definitely adds some quirks to balance but also it shouldn't be that hard to have Claude tear through your code and come up with a simulation that lets you keep things in line.

3

u/Malohn 2d ago

Or stuff like Edgemasters allowing usage of swords even if you cant use swords so shamans can use swords

3

u/RoosterBrewster 2d ago

Maybe they could have kiss-curse type gear. The bis would be what you can handle either mechanically or spellwise, so it could be different for everyone. 

→ More replies (9)

15

u/gonkdroid02 2d ago

I come from destiny, where there is practically no such thing as BiS, there might be a weapon or armor piece that is top of line for a specific encounter or activity, but there is always another set up that is almost if not just as good. The games design however heavily leans into this being possible and I think WoW would need to lean into gear that gives interesting effects or allows for unique build crafting for good horizontal progression, tbh I think just having gear give bonus vs certain enemies or in certain areas is just lame

→ More replies (17)

4

u/Cavthena 2d ago

Guild Wars seems to have done a good job at it. The better question is how do they do horizontal progression on a ancient engine that's held together with scotch tape?

→ More replies (16)

2

u/Practical-Monk5151 2d ago

you introduce new content outside of combat.

2

u/DontCareTho 2d ago

It should be equipment that encourages different builds, something that changes how you play. Not just "I do slightly more damage to X enemy type" which is incredibly bland

2

u/CourtMoney5842 2d ago

A piece of gear that changes the functionality of one of your skill that is not mecessarily bis in all scenarios, for example

16

u/DM_ME_KUL_TIRAN_FEET 2d ago

Honestly sounds terrible to me. Just sounds like inventory management simulator hell. If they’d what forever turns out to be, I don’t know how long I’ll stick around

5

u/SnooPeppers7482 2d ago

as an engineer i trust blizzard to add a bank bot for me to craft so i dont have to stuff my bags all the time.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (57)
→ More replies (79)

35

u/Automatic_Mix6583 2d ago

Well I like the idea a lot. I want to chase items forever, and this seems like a neat way to do that.

→ More replies (3)

596

u/Cardslinger69 2d ago • Bravo

Something tied to a biome is a new idea that sounds immersive and tied to the world, I fucking like it. I want them to try new stuff and not take the game down a generic retail direction.

108

u/ezrpzr 2d ago

I wouldn’t mind it if inventory management wasn’t already such a hassle. Carrying all that extra gear around with the current inventory limitations just feels like a real chore.

12

u/MenBearsPigs 2d ago

If it's effective for an entire dungeon/raid, then it could work fine imo. You wouldn't be juggling gear except before heading out.

19

u/kaw_kaw_kaw_kaw 2d ago

In the podcast they said the raid will have 3 biomes and additionally there will be anti enemy-type gear so you will need a set for each biome/enemy-type pair.

→ More replies (9)

31

u/BootyAndTheHoePhish 2d ago

During the podcast they also said theyve experimented with up to 96 slot bags. Bag space won't be an issue at endgame 

26

u/Lukas1433 2d ago

Lemme sort my 400 items real quick brb

→ More replies (4)

48

u/Necessary_Outcomes 2d ago

Jesus that sounds like a nightmare

→ More replies (12)

13

u/Zestyclose_Way_6607 2d ago

cool a gameplay element that can only be reasonably managed entirely by using an addon

500 slots of gear swapping, fuck me

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (18)

5

u/Saraphite 2d ago

It may be that you could get a leatherworker or a tailor to introduce fur linings to your equipment so you can use less specific parts of your gear and more generalised pieces with some modifications.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (21)

33

u/LEDKleenex 2d ago

Redditors are convenience-addicted manchildren that demand every game be turned into retail WoW, even though they can't stomach the game anymore and can't quite figure out why. Oddly enough, many of them tried to whine MnM into WoW:EQ edition a month before WoWF launched.

QOL/convenience creep is a disease and people aren't introspective enough to realize it. You know what would make these vegetables better? If you could order them through DoorDash and they were actually a Quarter Pounder with cheese meal instead, these farmers should really get their sh!t together.

3

u/ForKnee 2d ago

In the end retail wow in its current state of seasonal bis ilvl gear treadmill exists for a reason. I do hope this game won't follow the same path and let people who don't like friction or horizontal progression quit.

21

u/DM_ME_KUL_TIRAN_FEET 2d ago

Either it’s underpowered and doesn’t feel worth gear switching, or it’s op and you’re compelled to be on a constant gear treadmill of new biome gear for new places and stuck in inventory hell.

I don’t see the appeal?

→ More replies (23)

17

u/Cookiecrisp_Bandit 2d ago

It also might be a way to keep progression horizontal with a slight incline

19

u/Fozes 2d ago

Its not new they tried it in SoD and was unpopular

13

u/Lochen9 2d ago

It also was done to a heavy extent in New World. Chopping set, Mining set, versus undead set, versus humans set etc etc. All were basically required to do content.

They removed it all. It was awful and finicky

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (6)

12

u/trogger93 2d ago

I honestly hate shit like this. I just want to equip one set of gear, I hate having 27 random items in my bags that I need to dig through before every boss.

8

u/rusty5545 2d ago

It’s all the exact same +1% damage crap, just split up. How does this make the game more interesting?

It’s not like I’m making strategic choices to wear old gear because it has attributes I care about. I’m just unequipping one set for another to keep my boost

→ More replies (1)

6

u/Razzmuffin 2d ago

And pray that you don't accidentally vendor the wrong item

5

u/trogger93 2d ago

yep I accidentally vendored my thrash blade, luckily was able to buy it back later but it's an easy mistake to make with so many items in your bags. Also doesn't help that such a large source of endgame gold is in fact vendoring blues.

10

u/Pale-Supermarket3217 2d ago

Naw, the way they described it during the podcast today is a fucking nightmare. Each wing of a raid has a different biome, so on a three wing raid you'd want three different gear sets to swap around and then specific gear for each boss depending on if its a murloc or a beast, demon etc.

Possibly the worst itemization intent in the history of MMOs, and it's not even up for interpretation, the fucking dev opened his mouth and this diaper-filling came out of it.

→ More replies (2)

13

u/BIitzez 2d ago

anything against the grain of retail doesnt automatically make it good. this is some of the worst game design ive ever seen. having to swap gear every boss is aids. what if you forget on a pull and all of the sudden youre doing 40% of your expected damage?

this is against the grain of classic too, you know, the base game that is so good but just missing a few things that brought us all back for forever?

7

u/Odd-Understanding386 2d ago

You'll notice that the new zone Riverglades has been very well received. That's because it's a retail zone with worse graphics.

Friction for the sake of friction is just plain bad game design.

→ More replies (26)

9

u/shaunika 2d ago

You wont like it once you have to juggle 15 gearsets

→ More replies (7)

4

u/LivingBowler1041 2d ago

Explain how a sentence of green text dictating what you use is immersive

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (61)

144

u/Hviiiid 2d ago • Popcorn

No one have mentioned Diablo 4? Which launched exactly with these niche stats, everyone hated it and it is now gone. I guess blizzard should talk internally more?

17

u/ClassicKrova 2d ago

Diablo 4 is a different game whose only purpose is to "number go up" so that you can make your difficulty "number go up" so that you can find more gear to make "number go up" to make the difficulty "number go up again".

It makes sense that the ARPG genre that can only exist in the infinite ascent of power would not like this.

This game is supposed to be a sandbox with lasting evergreen systems.

→ More replies (5)

9

u/jntjr2005 2d ago

Hands down this^

→ More replies (21)

119

u/BoggsMcMuncher 2d ago edited 2d ago • Bravo

Alright for the next pack everyone put on your +14 damage gear while underwater to demons that have a ranged attack and their name contains the letter X and Z

Edit: exaggerated yes, but even in classic it became a hassle carrying multiple equipment sets (frost set, trash mob set, HER vs lionheart, tanking set, undead set, etc) and even remembering to swap trinkets (phylactery, badge etc), looks like they doubled down hard, tripled down even

2nd edit: fwiw I am a fan of resistance based raids and getting a certain resistance set for certain encounters. I just don't find getting a murloc battle set very rewarding, feels too niche. Resistance sets at least have the idea that they could be used for additional or upcoming raids, duels against certain classes, or if a certain spec is taking over a BG you could bring a resistance set to help

6

u/Nac_Lac 2d ago

They literally have a gear manager build into your character sheet.

→ More replies (14)
→ More replies (31)

51

u/LegendaryHotPear 2d ago

Where does this “no one” come from? I don’t recall filling in a survey or being asked.

→ More replies (1)

40

u/jacksev 2d ago • Bravo

You literally just exhibited the whole point in your post title. They don’t want people to have a “BiS.” They want you to constantly have something to chase that works better in different scenarios. Not required to stay competitive, but something different that will keep you from ever being “done.”

6

u/rusty5545 2d ago

This sounds less horizontal and more like side-by-side vertical loot treadmills though. Does old gear actually have stuff I want or is it all just conditional boosts?

→ More replies (5)

17

u/GrumpyJabroni 2d ago

Can't wait to see the population drop off in a few months

7

u/Tricky-Reindeer-2141 2d ago

It sounds awful and tedious

→ More replies (1)

18

u/MysticalCyan 2d ago

It reminds me of dnd, using gear for specific situations.

Also they reallt help a lot lol

The vs murlocs/beasts/worgen stuff are absolutely fantastic and really do shine as specialist items.

That being said, I hope they bring more bank slots or larger bags. Cause having them all on hand is a literal handfull

→ More replies (15)

10

u/AcanthaceaeJumpy697 2d ago

BORROWED POWER

41

u/Akava2005 2d ago • Bravo

I disagree, I want to see how it plays out

6

u/Scurro 2d ago

It already played out. They did this in SoD and it was hated. It meant you had to carry multiple sets of gear and RIP your bag space if you were a tank or healer.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (8)

7

u/guiz28 2d ago

I would not mind having niche items such as a special ring for X fight or things like that, for instance the ZG trinket for 4horseman tanking.

A BIS ring or trinket across everything is indeed boring. A BIS ring for the cave raid is going to be as much boring as the generic one. A BIS ring for X encounters simply because of more stats is also going to be boring. Unique effects like immunity to bleeds would be more fun than +12 AP in a cave.

Boss/Encounter specific items are cooler IMO. I am a fan of resistance gear for that reason as it also adds something to work towards/prepare for which is a fun thing to do in WOW.

68

u/yellingaboutsports5 2d ago

“We need to make non-current content stay relevant” - most of this sub in the buildup to this release. Ya’ll are exhausting.

→ More replies (2)

23

u/Rdhilde18 2d ago

Horizontal progression would mean you have multiple gear sets probably..

20

u/GeneralBucknaket 2d ago • Bravo

I do want that. Horizontal progression gear is cool.

What exactly are you proposing as an alternative. Be specific, because your post is vague.

→ More replies (7)

15

u/cosbybartender 2d ago • Bravo

What’s crazy is blizzard is going to mess this up in a way that will make everybody unhappy. Calling it now

3

u/InZomnia365 2d ago

And eventually we will end up at what should've been the starting point for Forever in the first place; taking lessons from Wrath of the Lich King.

4

u/HeyItsJosette 2d ago

The idea itself is the mistake that is going to make most people unhappy rofl. Resist gear makes 100x more sense and people already fucking hated that.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/polyoddity 2d ago

I probably already vendored some BiS item that is quest only bop

3

u/Searscale 2d ago

The ONLY way I see this working is if we get a bag for gear separate from our almost-full inventory. Quest Item bag would also help with that too. There's just too much I am expected to carry - especially with Camping system (which I love). Bank is also full of mats.

Top it off with all the hidden items required for secret quest/Legacy advancements. We legitimately dont have enough slots for everything.

3

u/DemonDeacon86 2d ago

If theyre going all in on biome gear then imma need at least 5 different gear load outs that dont take up bag space

3

u/BouttaKMS 1d ago

Damage on tuesdays coming to a wow forever near you.

91

u/Proxnite 2d ago • Bravo

Speak for yourself, I very much want that to be the case and having a reason to chase one-off pieces instead of having universally BiS items like before.

8

u/phoen1x09 2d ago

I agree with you. I think people who want to chase one BiS set of gear are living in the lazy past and holding back this version of the game from greatness. The saltwater/freshwater murloc people are making outlandish takes to highlight unrealistic extremes to try and prop up their point.

→ More replies (3)

6

u/MenBearsPigs 2d ago edited 2d ago

I think it can work fine as long as the specialized gear is made so that it works for an entire dungeon. Switching between fights over and over seems like a pain.

But gearing up for a specif dungeon or raid could work fine.

3

u/skinnysnappy52 2d ago

D imagine standard gear is enough to clear. But the extra items help you clear faster or have better parses

→ More replies (2)

6

u/Unexplainedrage69 2d ago

Having a few different sets is fine. Needing 20 different sets is tedious, ruins the fluidity of the gameplay and is an insane tax on bag space.

It negatively impacts game experience for a not very satisfying ‘I do 3% more damage to orcs’.

The game would be far better if these chase items influenced the way your rotation works or modified your spells/attacks in fun and creative ways, more similar to sod runes.

→ More replies (18)

5

u/MrPuttblugger 1d ago

but just gear that matters

Yeah.. explain to me how you'd achieve that with 5-10 years of content down the line.

I've been saying this for years, long before C+ was even announced, that WoW players are literally unable to comprehend how a long-lasting progression system should be the designed.

If you actually want a game that lasts LONG TERM, you'll have to let go of your "ilvl goes up" type of progression. These two are 100% mutually exclusive.

I'm not saying this biome gear is the best or only way of doing it btw, but if not for that, we will have to come up with something else. It just cannot be purely vertical again, you know where that leads.

18

u/Longjumping_Hawk9105 2d ago

I think it sounds fun and they shouldn’t listen to people who don’t design games 👍 all you guys do is complain

18

u/Failgh0st 2d ago

You’d think they’d learn this lesson from Diablo 4. Damage on Tuesdays is a god-awful concept.

3

u/Lazie_Writer 2d ago

I would gladly damage you on Tuesday for a heal today.

10

u/idkmanfiller 2d ago • Bravo

The Forever devs have shown time and time again that they think any sort of game design philosophy from the past 20 years is bullshit, and shockingly they're just going to step on all the same rakes while the community cheers because the community also hasn't played another video game in the past 20 years.

5

u/Higgoms 2d ago

That's just blizzard as a whole. Diablo 4 was riddled with issues that I kept thinking "didn't we literally solve this in 3? Or even 2?" Retail WoW does the same thing to itself every expansion, sometimes even patch to patch. Probably the most frustrating part of enjoying blizzard titles is knowing that every release is going to spend the first couple months or even couple years catching up to the level of quality we had a patch/game ago

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (11)

10

u/milkman_eyeballs 2d ago

L take let them cook you probably have no idea what you even want lol

11

u/Plastic-Lemons 2d ago

I love the idea. It sounds bad when you are leveling because you are experiencing so many different zones in the same janky gear set that slowly changes. It sounds good when you realize at 60 you’ll be spending your time across 3-5 different zones and will have time to accumulate the gear useful for each biome/mob type you encounter.

3

u/Drasha1 2d ago

I was surprised how many zones counted as forests once I got my forest based trinket. I was basically leaving it on all the time.

9

u/ErikRedbeard 2d ago

You can't have horizontal progression without having gear be both obsolete and not at the same time.

Increasing ilvl is not horizontal progression.

Those who seem to dislike, I don't think wow forever design philosophy fits you then.

6

u/Senes_ 2d ago

who said I want this kind of horizontal progression? I was completely fine with them having it horizontally in a world expanding context. I wouldnt raid for horizontal progression, because thats not progressing.

If I miss 4 IDs worth of loot and still am on the same level as everyone else, I might not even care

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (2)

4

u/SizeMcWave 2d ago

I do not think that having fire resist gear for a season and nature resist gear for season is bad, with generally similar stats otherwise, that is horizontal progression imo.

4

u/qrt7 2d ago

If they actually try to do horizontal gear progression everyone is going to fucking hate it.

Horizontal progression means that gear is not the goal. Look at the only real horizontal MMO in existence, GW2. BiS gear takes a couple days to get and NEVER gets replaced. Everything you grind for is purely cosmetic and QoL, and fun of course.

They will not be doing that, dont worry. The devs arent stupid, they know that the gear treadmill is why WoW players log in, and they will be powercreeping you guys nice and slow, so it feels gentle and the babyraging is kept to a minimum.

22

u/ElectricRinku 2d ago

Yes I can't believe they actually think this is good item design to nerf perfectly good 60 items just to add some 90% worthless flavor passive.

→ More replies (7)

7

u/Crits_for_all 2d ago

Feels like I’m taking crazy pills. This is a cool system and I welcome it. I don’t really get the bag space argument because in my experience level 60 is when you have the most bag space + bank access. Are people running around with full bags at 60? What could possibly be in there? Flasks, potions, reagents, off set. What am I missing that you are all so pressed over?

2

u/Parking-Dig8066 2d ago edited 2d ago

You ever tanked, healed, used dualspec, played a hybrid class, played druid? For example, on turtle we had 36 slot bags and were still pressed for bagspace if we had gear for multiple specs. Truth be told, we had up to 4 specs there, but no way i will carry shit around, that will only be applicable in one specific scenario with 14 to 18 slot bags.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

5

u/Jakcris10 2d ago

If you want horizontal progression you’re probably going to have to let go of the concept of BiS

12

u/kudles 2d ago

How else are they going to do horizontal progression? IMO it makes a lot of sense ...

→ More replies (1)

13

u/lordosthyvel 2d ago

I mean before all this gets blown out of proportion (who am I kidding, you guys absolutely will), it was just one example of how he thought about itemization!

He said he didn't want static BiS items which sounds like a good thing. He also gave other examples like an item that does more damage when you have full bags. It doesn't sound like ALL gear will be biome dependant at all.

They said they want to focus on the fantasy and not the BiS stats on items which sounds great. I'm optimistic.

10

u/DM_ME_KUL_TIRAN_FEET 2d ago edited 2d ago

Item that does more damage with full bags is fun flavor but does not sound like an effect that will ever be good. Flavor is important obviously but I don’t like that I haven’t heard an idea for this that appeals to me yet. We will see.

→ More replies (8)

10

u/Oedipus_TyrantLizard 2d ago

I mean. Everyone always references OSRS as good horizontal progression.

This is how OSRS does it. You have different kits that are better for different jobs & they all build on one another. But they aren’t stronger than each other in many cases, they are just more specialized

13

u/trogger93 2d ago

OSRS is always a rough comparison to wow because in OSRS you play every single 'class' on one character.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/BIitzez 2d ago

awful example. its apples and oranges. theres a huge difference between using a crush-based weapon on araxxor vs using slash based on vardorvis.

and the game was built for that over the years and it had HUGE issues for like TEN YEARS (e.g. zero crush weapons being good forever, until literally a month ago scythe was still your best 'crush' weapon).

2

u/nickpaz21 2d ago

Can we get some sort of system to disenchant set effects and apply them to knew armor? once per item so you have to get the item again to reapply or something. This will keep old content relevant but also allow them to create interesting effects

2

u/chincerd 2d ago

I honestly imagine something like. Onyxia dropping a spear that deals more damage to ghosts, ghost filled raid dropping a helmet that deals more damage to murlocs, murloc dungeon shoes that make enemies not resist frost, frost enemies in Another raid dropping a dragon hunting glove which is good for onyxia fight.

So no matter where you starts in the "equally good endgame raid" you would make another one easier.

Add to that smaller items with similar effects but that drop from special rooms in dungeons.

For example, oh you need that mage item drop that makes enemies not resist your frostbolts? You gonna need the special item from a dungeon that makes fire spells turn green, this makes an enemy in X dungeon drop the anti resist for that mage.

2

u/Zhelthan 2d ago

Maybe they are gonna make something like monster hunter item progression ? Which I know may be annoying to some degree but is cool

2

u/OSRS_YeeHaw 2d ago

But what about generic 'beastslaying' gear? Or 'plague' gear that's good against disease, poison, etc? You all are using such hilarious examples of this being taken too far.

2

u/TrifleDifficult9928 2d ago

All in on, no. But i think that kind of stuff is neat.

2

u/Zealousideal_Lake186 2d ago

Hard agree, especially some of the stupid early level ones, like here is a staff that will increase the walking speed but only in the zone your leaving.

2

u/ForKnee 2d ago

I want specialized gear actually. Combination of resistances, biome and enemy type bonuses that work well in certain raids sounds great.

6

u/squirrelnestNN 2d ago

biome gear isn't great

but mob type gear, +damage to quillboars is cool because even after the quillboar raid, you could still have a quillboar boss now and again making it a optional neat item to farm across multiple tiers

but if is only good in one place? that would suck, just borrowed power all over

2

u/koolex 2d ago

I assume if you got swamp gear there would be other raids and dungeons with swamps?

5

u/BroForceOne 2d ago

I think not chasing one BiS item is kind of the point. Maybe biome gear isn't the best implementation but the concept of BiS is vertical progression.

6

u/Gloomy_Trade_619 2d ago

I certainly don’t want to have the same “best for all” equipment as in Retail 

4

u/twothe 2d ago

Biome gear has already been tried by other MMOs and it usually killed them.

7

u/mudcrabberoni 2d ago

Is it weird that i loved everything the itemization guy said and i want to collect tons of different gesr sets?

I dont see the problem - storage is the inly concern but i imagine blizzard will have a solution there if it becomes too bad

I think of this like an OSRS slayer task, each task i go in with different gear based on the monster and i love that

2

u/June-Bird 2d ago

No, its not weird, this to me was the most excited for what is in store I have been yet. I really enjoyed his vision and perspective and I hope the complainers on reddit dont make them backtrack. They just want to look at a BiS list and get the best drop without thinking and that be the same endless treadmill that retail has. This actually sounds fun and engaging. He even said you dont HAVE to collect all the bis for every situation, but you can if you want

→ More replies (3)

13

u/aGoodforce 2d ago

The whole point of this is to not have BiS. Forever is supposed to be different and avoid the issues that expedited raid logging with Classic. Traditional progression is available on the Era servers.

26

u/Hanza-Malz 2d ago

Biome oriented gear moves the issue of "having to collect that one BiS" to "having to collect 5 different pieces of BiS" because you'll have a BiS for every situation.

11

u/aGoodforce 2d ago

I struggle to see the issue here. Bag space? They've already mentioned they are aware of that. More time playing the game so you can collect more gear and do better at certain encounters? That's the point.

→ More replies (19)
→ More replies (50)

7

u/Saucynachos 2d ago

It's probably one of the worst ways to do it though. Set bonuses or items that change the playstyle would be much more interesting. Sets from newer raids could have a similar stat budget to avoid making older raid gear irrelevant, but have a set bonus that opens up a new playstyle.

Choosing gear goes from "okay we're fighting boars so gotta go through my 18 sets of gear to find my boar fighting gear" to picking the specific set bonus you like. Maybe a druid set could reduce their direct healing done from things like healing touch or the non-hot portion of regrowth, but cause the Bloom talent to be an AoE. Nifty things like that.

→ More replies (5)

8

u/DM_ME_KUL_TIRAN_FEET 2d ago

There is always bis unless every item is identical

17

u/Sepplord 2d ago

Yeah but the solution to “no BIS gear” being “let’s just have different BIS gear for each biom/enemy” shows a severe lack of creativity and vision and really isn’t “no BIS gear”

4

u/Jules3313 2d ago

it alsot doesnt mean thers no bis gear itjsut means there EVEN MORE bis gear now. it just makes the sweatiest players have an even bigger gap in power since they have the time to get it all lol

→ More replies (17)

3

u/HawksBurst 2d ago

My problem with all this talk of "forever is supposed to be different" is that the game is pretty much the same, it has barely changed enough to deserve to be treated differently.
If this was leaning more towards SoD, then more power to you, Im fine with experimenting with sets and such

→ More replies (6)

3

u/Mosaic78 2d ago

The slavery to BiS is a wonder to behold

3

u/jamesmess 2d ago

Sorry OP but this is exactly the sort of thing WoW Forever needs to stand apart from retail as a horizontal progressive mmo. If you want that gear treadmill power spike and cap, it’s already a major part of the main game.

10

u/Syl3nReal 2d ago edited 2d ago

Wrong this is fucking awesome if handle well. Of course you won’t have a gear only for murlocks and another one for bears.

In top of that, if we can get gear with amazing procs that would be amazing too.

7

u/Bristle_Licker 2d ago

This is so half-assed. They want to do this with the classic bag and bank space they gave us?

It’s almost hilarious.

3

u/Mooide 2d ago

There’s nothing stopping them adding gear set qol, the game is under active development

3

u/Senzafane 2d ago

Ya my bank is already full of crafting materials and I have one bag dedicated to my OS healing set.

Where am I going to keep five more sets of stuff?

→ More replies (14)
→ More replies (6)

7

u/Praetor192 2d ago edited 2d ago

If it wasn't already obvious, they keep demonstrating that they don't know what they are doing and have no true direction for the game, and are just floundering and flailing about. And also the game was released far before it was ready.

→ More replies (4)

6

u/PhoenixInvertigo 2d ago

Sorry but you're wrong. Biome gear sounds awesome and is exactly what people were after when they heard horizontal progression, completely revitalizing the game

4

u/Thelmara 2d ago

I much prefer the traditional progression - you don't need to have overpowered set bonuses - but just gear that matters.

Hey, I don't know if you know this, but there are two whole other Worlds of Warcraft with traditional progression.

4

u/Puckett52 2d ago • Bravo

New World did this. And it SUCKED ASS and everyone hated it

3

u/Chillzey91 2d ago

Yeah how many bop pieces of gear do they expect me to hold on to? This my Thursday night after 7pm but before 9pm gear that adds damage to red dragons that’s name starts with one of the letter A-O in the alphabet.

3

u/Volitar 2d ago

damage on tuesday.

3

u/_GrimHiker 2d ago

Its actually stupid tbh. I dont want to manage all these different sets of gear and keep them in my bank and so on.

4

u/bizcliz6969 2d ago

BIS list babbies panicking

13

u/ElectricRinku 2d ago

You're still gonna have a bis list bud

→ More replies (8)

3

u/Drewbtube7 2d ago

I think that’s great. Maybe your item set could be more effective towards dragons or more effective towards demons or more effective towards beasts. That’s where they could go with it too. It’s not just locked too, the Tuesday afternoon frog killing adventure

→ More replies (1)

3

u/AggravatingBrain69 2d ago

It sounds cool. Better than following a bis list on a google doc

5

u/HawksBurst 2d ago

You'll still follow a google doc, it'll just have multiple sections now

2

u/Spedunkler 2d ago

Yes, think about how you will be able to plan about the biome you want to fight PVP in. It's going to make options and decisions much more critical to feeling like we are connected with our characters as we make decisions that actually matter.

2

u/Bunkerdunker7 2d ago

At the very least I’m going to need a lot bigger bags

2

u/NerdfestZyx 2d ago

They did this in vanilla with AQ (nature resist) and BWL (with fire resist) , and in WotLk with ICC (cold resist).

I tanked The Curator in Karazahn as a holy priest in an arcane resist set built from the tailoring patterns (Soulcloth) that drop in the raid and AH greens

2

u/Fun_Description_385 2d ago

"no one"

Bro thinks he's speaking for me lmao 

1

u/rainywanderingclouds 2d ago • Bravo

the devs are lost in the woods and don't know the audience as well as they think they do, unfortunately.

14

u/Pre_cooked 2d ago

you might be living in an echo chamber man. forever is massively successful so far and every decision they've made so far has been met with resounding applause in my social circles. you might be in the minority that this game is not designed for.

6

u/Eyelemon 2d ago

I think most players are so used to the gear treadmill they can only see the game in those terms. Not to put too fine a point on it, but they really are not prepared.

→ More replies (8)

5

u/Brochodoce 2d ago

Brother you just spend too much time here

→ More replies (2)

2

u/Mindless-Mulberry404 2d ago

I agree with this, it will become maddening to track all this crap and its just a lazy way to make gear unique

2

u/gunrad95 2d ago

thats literally the only way you're gunna get horizontal prog in a game like wow

→ More replies (4)

2

u/GirthxLength 2d ago

I couldn’t disagree more

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Mephisto__ 2d ago

I disagree and I want them to try this. I'm not going to down vote just because I disagree, but I should say that just because some "biome" gear exists it doesn't mean "normal" gear will be useless. You'll probably clear everything with normal raid gear at a slight cost to effectiveness compared to raid gear +biome gear.

If I had to guess, there might be 2-3 items per "biome" set max so you can mix it in with other gear. We'll never know till it and the more difficult content is out though.

2

u/KappuccinoBoi 2d ago

I think it's a nice idea. Like let's be real, you'll be able to clear any T1 raid with some half decent prebis. The biome gear is going to be chase items for parsers so they can get their shiny numbers. It also gives people reasons to go back and farm older raids to maybe get some biome gear for upcoming raids which will absolutely help the PUG scene.

2

u/Time-Ad6360 2d ago

Please Blizzard, go all-in on "biome" gear

→ More replies (1)

1

u/WaywardWanderingOrc 2d ago

I like the idea of gear that isn't necessarily better at everything. Like a set that's good against magic vs a set that's good against phys.