r/classicwow • • 19h ago

Forever Small annoyance with how new quests are written

Post image

I have no idea who gave me this quest. I have no idea where to turn it in. It's sorted in the Undercity section of my quest log, fine, but just from a basic gameplay point of view the quest objective should include who to turn it in to. My Drowned City quests are the same, out of the three I have, none of them tell me who gave me the quest or who to turn it in to, and being sorted in the Drowned City section of my log doesn't help. I shouldn't have to turn on the in-game Questie to know. All my quests that are actually from vanilla say very explicitly who to turn the quest in to in the quest text.

Yes this is still playable, but come on, this is obviously a bad change in the new quests.

876 Upvotes

195 comments sorted by

90

u/TheClassicAndyDev 19h ago

I've encountered many similar issues as well.

Usually there will be a line somewhere like "PERSON at PLACE has asked for THING. Return to them at PLACE after you did THING."

11

u/Totally_man 8h ago

My biggest annoyance so far. It's easy to tell which of the quests is new, because they're so vague it's impossible to decipher.

No "Seafart Firetruck in bumblefuck wants you to collect 30 murloc taints", just what seems like more vague lore text.

•

u/HerrPotatis 1h ago

They're just so bland and forgettable, riverglades is in some ways a massive disappointment for me, and i think this is the big reason.

It's 50 or so almost completely disconnected quests and the vast majority is, go kill this thing or pick up these flowers and done. With the old zones, so much felt like the next thing down the road was a continuation of the narrative of what you experienced before.

Maybe this changes in the later portion, I'm only 42 after all. But it feels a little bit like they copypasted content from redridge, westfall, and the pirates in STV with zero care that anything should feel like it amounts to a journey.

240

u/TraditionalAd2521 18h ago

Leveling in Dun Morogh.

Classic quest: "Follow the road north, then turn west when you find the frozen river. Follow the river until you reach the lake. Brewnall Village is on the other shore. Southwest of Brewnall is the Frost Troll hold I want you to assault."

Nice.

New Quest: "Go find Brother Lightman of the Argent Dawn. He's set up home in the mountains."

Uh, what mountains? Hello? What mountains? The entire fucking zone is nothing but mountains?

Every new quest is written assuming you have the tracker on. I tried to play without the tracker as I like reading the quests and following the directions (something I've done every time having played Classic through around 8 times) and it's just impossible with Forever.

41

u/Bago579 17h ago

Hah I reported that quest in the beta and they changed the description to say hes at misty pine refuge.

•

u/Toprightcorner2 3h ago

DONT YOU HAVE ADDONS

48

u/Ok_Caterpillar5564 15h ago

It's really disappointing. I raised this during beta but it didn't really get any traction. I get it, most people play with the tracker on anyway, Blizz isn't wrong about that. Even during classic people used 3rd party trackers. But it's still really disappointing for a game mode where there so much emphasis put on "capturing the spirit of classic". This is such a small thing that would have made such a big difference in feeling authentic to classic, and they just couldn't be bothered. It's sad.

8

u/milkymoocowmoo 12h ago

It feels like cheating to me to turn those guides on, like why even play at all. I only do it when handing in those crafting writs that provide literally no information on who or where it's going to, other than clicking on the resulting quest providing you with the zone map. Reported in beta, nothing done about it.

There's also a starter quest in Tirisfal that wants you to go to the Undercity, and tells you to get there by heading north from Brill. Reported that one too, still in the game 🥲

•

u/Escolyte 56m ago

The worst part about the writs is that the quest text is taunting you "this writ includes a location" and you can't read it. 

3

u/waffels 5h ago

It’s a joke the devs were proud of all these new quests when they’re just bare minimum slop.

28

u/tethysian 15h ago

That's pretty damning. They want everyone to be questing, but not reading the quest texts? That is the spirit of the original game which they said they want to preserve. I always play without trackers or quest helpers.

8

u/Nuubio 12h ago

For real, I remember playing vanilla without addons or any quest indicators and being impressed with the accuracy and amount of signposting in old quest descriptions. 

7

u/Glebk0 15h ago

I thought everyone already knew that lead game designer is also part in the rested xp cabal? How did you miss the news?

2

u/jamesbongsixtynine 11h ago

wonder how much he makes on the side

•

u/EmmEnnEff 1h ago

Oh, it gets worse. The treasure quest in Dun Algaz literally gives you *coordinates* as the hint for where to look for it.

I didn't realize Azeroth had a GPS system.

•

u/Stable_Orange_Genius 57m ago

Coordinates existed long before gps but fair point

1

u/spookydooks 6h ago

Knew this was coming as when they added the Incubus quest years ago it was written just like these new quests with no directions.

1

u/This_is_opinion 5h ago

Where mankrik wife?

•

u/Escolyte 57m ago

It's definitely an issue, but there's no need to exaggerate the problem.

I quested the entirety of Riverglades without quest objectives and it was fine.

159

u/Ancheey 19h ago

Same goes for crafting order quests. It states "Deliver item X to a point marked on your map".. but if you play with quest POIs off, there's nothing pointing you to the destination.

30

u/Lich-Slapped 19h ago

Didn’t even think about those. They should almost include a map of the zone on the quest log tab with an x where the end is. Flavor of a physical map being given with an order for goods

10

u/GBPackers0480 18h ago

Even with it on I don't see who to turn it into on my map, I just know what zone but there is no "?" or anything on my map for it

9

u/jer31173 18h ago

If you make it the focus quest it'll show on the main map but not the minimap

3

u/GBPackers0480 18h ago

thank you for this! i've just been looking it up on wow-head for the specific one i have since it seems it always goes to the same npcs

1

u/ade889 14h ago

exactly! I wanted to pull my hair out. I only completed this one through shear brute stubbonness.

I have no intention on doing any more of them, unless there is an improvement on the descriptions.

1

u/moose184 17h ago

What's even the point of those. I did 2 and one gave me 50 silver and the other 20 silver. Didn't even cover the cost of materials to make the thing

6

u/DoesThyLikeJazz 16h ago

Rep for the crafting faction

3

u/geezerforhire 15h ago

Gives reputation to work towards the higher level crafting recipes.

•

u/EmmEnnEff 1h ago

If you do them for two weeks and dump 80g of mats into them, you will get enough rep to craft a level 50 BOP blue.

525

u/Caspus1 19h ago

Fair grievance for someone trying to level without quest addons/modern tools.

14

u/modytechnik 19h ago

no addons needed in forever, you have questie built-in. if this was written in context of vanilla or classic i would understand, but we've got tools built-in just for this.

148

u/YourREALdad330 18h ago

IF you want to play with the quest helper setting on. Some people prefer the slower-paced experience of reading their quest log. While I personally prefer to have the map markers, I still agree that the log should at least tell you who the turn-in is in the objective.

So instead of “Slay Stormheart in Thousand Needles and acquire its heart”, it could say “Zug Zug the peon in The Shimmering Flats wants you to slay Stormheart in Thousand Needles and acquire its heart”.

Very small change with a large payoff for the folks who prefer to toggle off the helper and do it themselves. I’m all for it

41

u/Maysock 18h ago

Yeah, that seems like a base requirement for a quest. It really does need to let you know who you should bring a quest back to. Usually, the text does.

1

u/46516481168158431985 18h ago

This is because they generate bunch of quests and then someone else decides where to put it. Just lazy.

17

u/UnoriginalStanger 17h ago

No, it's becasue they're designing them for a system that doesn't need directions in text because the UI does it for them.

3

u/Lemon_Phoenix 10h ago

This subreddit is obsessed with calling every flaw AI for some reason

2

u/jamesbongsixtynine 11h ago

again, totally missing the point of the thread lol

crazy how redditors talk right past eachother

2

u/Pinewood74 5h ago

The poster you replied to isn't talking past anyone. He's specifically addressing what was brought up in the parent comment.

Not every comment in a thread is going to relate directly back to the top level post.

0

u/Vexal 15h ago

the same problem existed in 2004 and there were no quest markers there. a lot of vanilla quests didn’t say who gave it.

5

u/XsNR 15h ago

It's a very generic issue with all the Forever specific quests though. They're not only poorly written compared to the original quests in their content, but missing things like this makes them confusing if you can't find the integrated markers, as often happens since they're frequently in weird sections.

1

u/SkipX 14h ago

[citation needed]

1

u/False_Snow7754 12h ago

Side-note: Zug Zug is my favourite Warcraft character, right above Dabu.

1

u/Antique_Impact_366 12h ago

Did you expect any less from a small indie company that’s just getting off their feet??

-4

u/Alexarius87 13h ago

If you don’t want to play with the basic setting of an inbuilt quest helper then you should accept quests more carefully and remember the npcs you talk to.

-8

u/SpitnTheCannonsMouth 17h ago

Right but then don't turn around and complain about the quest helper not showing you enough information if you're literally turning off those settings.

-10

u/Kiereco 17h ago

I'm not sure what you're actually complaining about.

You mentioned that the quest turn in is labeled under Undercity.

The quest tells you to go to an area to acquire the heart and return it back to Undercity. (Quest location tag in journal)

This is going to sound mean but if you can't put two and two of those together then I strongly suggest you download some sort of add-on that can assist you with quests.

If you toggle the tracker on in game you can click the quest on the left side of it and it will actually open up the map of where you turn it in.

This is not a problem at all. All you have to do is remember where you picked up a quest.

Like I mentioned above. Turn the objectives on or get some sort of quest add-on. Otherwise the quest expect you to read them and remember a little bit about where the NPC resides.

Reading isn't bad and can be fun.

10

u/fknsonikk 17h ago

By your logic which alludes to the delivery being that the delivery is at the location which is labeled in the quest log, the Drowned City quests mentioned in the OP should be delivered inside the Drowned City instance. That is not the case. How a quest is categorized in the quest log has little to do with where you turn it in.

8

u/SwampOfDownvotes 17h ago • Bravo

Undercity is a big place, and the game has a lot of quests. You could have picked it up dozens or even a hundred quests ago, I wouldn't blame someone forgetting where they picked it up at. 

Additionally, you are completely ignoring shared quests. How are they going to remember where in Undercity they picked it up if they didn't because someone shared it with them? If classic quests can give you the info you need without needing add-ons or built in questie, then its not unreasonable to expect new quests to work the same. It's just bad game design. 

6

u/UnoriginalStanger 17h ago

Classic quests don't do this though.

18

u/tethysian 15h ago

The quest helper they added is supposed to be optional.

•

u/EmmEnnEff 1h ago edited 1h ago

I think it's reasonable to expect Classic WoW to play well without turning on the built-in quest-helper. "Turn brain off follow the arrow" is fine for people who want to opt into it, but any game designed around that suffers for it.

14

u/Lich-Slapped 19h ago

If they didnt have a toggle for using their built in tool id say sure.

But they are giving the option of just no quest helper still. This quest would have been abandoned like crazy in 2005 with players holding a heart and losing track of the turn in lmao

11

u/SpunkMcKullins 19h ago

The tools are optional with a toggle in the interface, specifically for purists who don't like them and want to rely on in&game information.

3

u/jamesbongsixtynine 11h ago

you missed the whole point of the thread

10

u/Knetknight19 19h ago

Not really. Questie is infinitely better. Shows where you can pick up quests available to you. Things that start quests like the random bear and murloc in elwynn, and paths that mobs can take.

1

u/Slash-Gordon 5h ago

And the option to show objectives as something more useful than a series of overlapping transparent blobs

2

u/Vexal 15h ago

i play with quest markers off. also this exact problem was just as annoying in 2004 — it wouldn’t even always tell you what city you got the quest. it’s not just a problem with new quests.

•

u/kerenar 4h ago

Yeah, I prefer playing with the in-game tracker or any other trackers turned off. The issue is, quests from Vanilla are 95% designed with that in mind, so they are written so that you can figure them out without the tracker.

I've run into multiple quests in the first half of Mt. Hyjal alone where the quest gives zero context or description of WHERE they want me to go to complete their task. The way a lot of the new quests are written, you can tell that the writers are basically under the assumption that everyone will be using the in-game quest tracker, which really sucks, and this problem is the entire reason I was bummed to see them put in-game quest tracking in to begin with.

0

u/velianieli 11h ago

I've needed more addons in Forever than I did for era/hc because of how they've enshittified parts of the game.

0

u/_MrMeseeks 11h ago

I have 2 lvl 27 characters and have used zero add-ons

0

u/SeriousDude 15h ago

Well, the lead developer plays with RestedXP addon, is that mandatory as well?

-7

u/fjuuhhani 18h ago

In the vanilla client game map there is a drop down menu that has the option to turn quest objectives on. I played my first two days with that turned off, fun new player trap.

5

u/Aleph_Rat 15h ago

"New player trap", to be fair, it's designed for that to be an opt-in not opt-out because the intention is for you to read quest text and figure it out from there. That, though, means quest do need to have that information in the text lol

19

u/GBPackers0480 18h ago

"Vanilla" refers to the original game before TBC launched in 2007 and it did not have that. I assume you're talking about "classic" or "era"

12

u/fjuuhhani 18h ago

Oh I am talking about the WoW forever client without any addons, my bad. This is my first wow I have played.

7

u/Genghis_Sean_Reigns 18h ago

That’s very understandable, since vanilla in a lot of other games just refers to the game without mods.

3

u/GBPackers0480 18h ago

no worries, all the different types are confusing

4

u/moon-lesbian 15h ago

To give some additional context beyond what others said, quest helper wasn't added until 2008, 4 years after WoW released, so in the period of WoW Forever is set in there wasn't a quest helper. Because of this some people (like me) prefer to disable it and read the quests like back in the day, the gsme was designed to be played like that after all

But yea this doesn't really work with many of the newly added quests in Forever, as they were designed with this quest helper in mind. Thankfully most of the new quests have been doable some just take me really long, but occasionally you just run into one that has some serious missing information...

2

u/tethysian 15h ago

Yeah, stuff like that is what a lot of us like about classic. You get your directions and then get to explore the world and have a little adventure with every quest.

-6

u/TheWaggleLesbian 19h ago

There is no good modern tool for forever questing though :(

4

u/janemba617 19h ago

Questie?

0

u/TheWaggleLesbian 18h ago

Questie doesnt work properly in forever, it has tonnes of content missing and a bunch of broken map locations, it also highlights quests for the opposite faction, and quests I cant do yet

10

u/WoWSecretsYT 18h ago

It’s being updated daily… The devs of Questie can only use information that’s available to them. The only stuff they don’t have at this point is very endgame quests and some weird rate one-off drop quests that have low completion rates. Everything else is in there. So if you aren’t max level, Questie should be fully updated for your needs.

-1

u/TheWaggleLesbian 18h ago

I've used it for 1-30 and it was awful, barely functional, and kept pointing to locations that literally didn't have any quests for Alliance, I dont know why you are lying about its functionality when it barely works

3

u/collax974 18h ago

The only issue it has right now is that the new quest requirements aren't mapped well (outside of the level requirement) so they show quests that might not be available to you yet. Everything else is working properly.

2

u/KarlFrednVlad 18h ago

When did you use it?

1

u/TheWaggleLesbian 18h ago

Literally last week

1

u/eadenoth 18h ago

Do you update your addons daily? most wow players don’t for some reason but you should and maybe you didn’t have up to date questie as it has truly improved week over week. 1-30 was actually in a decent spot from beta tho tbh so not entirely sure what your experience has been tbh :/

1

u/WoWSecretsYT 17h ago

Well I used it 1-25 this week and it wasn’t missing anything. Because they are still updating things… even Dungeon Journal still doesn’t have perfect info. Every addon dev is in a fluster right now working overtime to get up to date information to everyone. Don’t swear off an addon just because it doesn’t have information with little data on it. If you don’t like the UI or functionality then go uninstall it. But if you want to use it, help update it by making reports to the addon dev. I’ve noticed no issues with Questie outside of the things I’ve named and maybe some missing follow-ups that also had no information on Wowhead. I’ve been giving my helping hand with Leatrix reporting some new flight times for the handful of new points, for example.

3

u/tobias_the_letdown 18h ago

I’ve not had an issue with it yet.

3

u/Dashyguurl 17h ago

Really? I’ve had no issues with it at 35 now. It’s constantly being updated so it may be much better than when you tried it

2

u/janemba617 18h ago

Only issue I've had so far is some quest being listed that aren't there yet because of chains or the quest being removed. Hasn't been a big deal at all. Have you updated it recently? Its been updated daily almost.

1

u/SwampOfDownvotes 17h ago

If you haven't done it yet, turn off dropped item quests on map. I found that makes up most of the not real quest markers. 

2

u/HoneyBeeHotHive 19h ago

Yes, but this ancient tool called “reading” is usually helpful.

14

u/Live-Habit-6115 17h ago

Bro that's LITERALLY the point of this entire thread. Lmao

The new quests don't give OP enough info to figure it out by "reading"

-2

u/MayhemPenguin5656 16h ago

Patrols the cliffs in 1k needles and bring friends...

It has a huge patrol route, what else does the quest need to tell you?

it's exact gps location?

4

u/Malinnus 16h ago

Dawg, read. Issue is about from whom the quest was taken/who to turn it into. Not what to do where

-2

u/MayhemPenguin5656 16h ago

Who is the only person in UC who works on abominations..

Who if you have been reading (like op says he ways) been working on an abomination in all of the quests he gives

1

u/Malinnus 15h ago

Ah yes i do keep a spreadsheet of who does what between sessions. Not to dismiss the world uilding aspect and no „yellow paint” approach, but we only human, we forgetful or we get interrupted by other responsibilities.

Altho i would add the info as openable drop down thingy, that u can check if u need not in plain text centre of screen, for people that prefer immersion like yourself, because it is cool indeed that the info is mentioned in other quests.

•

u/MayhemPenguin5656 3h ago

Then turn on the quest tracker, don't know what you want xD

Because its pretty obvious when he has the whole alchemical district to himself working on abominations its kind of a landmark, something to be remembered.

Not blizzards fault you all have the attention span of a iPad kid.

6

u/M4yze 18h ago

Not anymore it seems

34

u/SlarkeSSC 18h ago

My "favorite" example of this is the quest for the dead skyborne in EPL. Tells you to go search downstream for clues, you can whoever wrote didn't take 5 seconds to look at the river. The clues and turn in are upstream, by the waterfall that starts the river.

9

u/Groovychick1978 16h ago

That one drove me crazy!

32

u/VandelayyIndustries 18h ago

Agreed. Maybe i’m old fashioned or it’s habit but i frequently open the quest dialogue to find out where to go next. The new quests don’t say and i have to rely on an addon or wowhead. Very annoying.

30

u/antsindapants 19h ago

I’m explicitly playing my first characters without any questing addons (aside from Dungeon Journal to make sure I pick up all the quests before heading in)

This type of thing is infuriating, and it’s something that could be addressed in a PR - no testing to find interactions - just read the changes and realize the most basic information required to hand it in is missing.

14

u/Everdale 13h ago

It's also a clear indication that the devs don't play the game or design it to be played without supplementary tools or optional additions.

2

u/7se7 9h ago

More like that's just how quests are designed/written in modern Blizzard, with the assumption the user is playing the game with map objectives on, so they already have a way to know where they need to go.

Tangentially, this is also why a lot of "filler" quests that don't belong to chain are usually just one or two sentences. It's an entirely different mindset.

22

u/BIitzez 17h ago

if you actually read a lot of the quests/items that were added its VERY clear that AI wrote a lot of it. just go read diamond flask lol.

•

u/Devaz321 4h ago

Diamond Flask Item Level 52 Binds when picked up Unique Trinket Classes: Warrior Use: Restores 1120 Health over 5 sec. This healing is strongest at first. If finished, gain 20 Strength for 1 min. (6 Min Cooldown) "Served on the rocks."

6

u/Outofmana1337 16h ago

They can't even write for ppl without adons anymore

5

u/Turnspit 16h ago

Same with the Riverglades - I got like 4 or 5 quests that told me to search somebody in the Riverglades, or bring some supplies over to someone there.

None of these quests gave me single hint on how to get there though. And without Google, I wouldn't have known that there's a boat in Tanaris.

19

u/UnfairGerman 18h ago

Its written by the Retail-Scrubs who are used to everyone using Quest-markers.

11

u/Hademar 19h ago

This is not the case for all new quests btw, I have some new ones on me that do do this properly.

4

u/SanyaBane 15h ago

My goal was to level first character without using quest addons or internal tracker. It was shattered in a first few hours of playing.

4

u/ade889 14h ago

I pulled my hair out with the new writ of craftsmanship.

The quest name told me the item to get. The blurb stated it told me the item and the recipient. However there was no such details.

I dont use any quest trackers. I only knew the area of the world because when I clicked the quest on the log it opened to the darkshire map. From there about an hour of googaling vague and incorrect answers to discover it was a box. Deep in a crypt. But no further details online. I got lucky checking ravenshill first.

I hated it.

21

u/Frequent_Arm_3576 17h ago

Maybe because all quests are made by cheap Ai? Kinda obvious when you read them and pay attention to details.

25

u/five-pacer 16h ago edited 15h ago

I'm more inclined to believe they're being written by the horrid retail writers. AI can do a much better job than this. There must be some insane levels of nepotism going on at Blizzard to have the same clueless writers still hired after so many expansions.

7

u/Everdale 13h ago

Never one to advocate for anyone losing their job but I'm guessing there's gotta be a huge round of layoffs for the retail writing team if they don't somehow manage to miraculously stick the landing for their own "World Soul trilogy" fiasco in the next expansion.

2

u/False_Snow7754 12h ago

But don't you know that my dad works at Blizzard? I've worked there for 8 years!

1

u/Revenantzzz 10h ago edited 10h ago

"My dad works for blizzard, and I worked in QA for years".. shoutout that streamer guy, blizzard has been a family company for 20 years.. we like, 2 generations into nepotism

-1

u/twisty125 12h ago

Why would Forever quests be written by Retail writers, who are writing for Retail currently?

5

u/stevenbanthony4204 12h ago

they phone it in for retail, they must have plenty of extra time

-1

u/twisty125 12h ago

Ahh, the absence of proof based on vibes and "it's bad, therefore it's true". I gotcha.

8

u/stevenbanthony4204 12h ago

im saying the writers suck in retail. what do you need proof for? it's my opinion lol

1

u/Hackwork89 7h ago

Prove to me that you think retail writers suck.

7

u/Chibastion 13h ago

Vanilla quests were written by guys travelling the world and living in vans. That's why those seem to have a much stronger grip on life

•

u/Zestyclose_Remove947 4h ago edited 4h ago

Sometimes I feel like this sub gives me psychosis. As someone enjoying forever right now and taking my time, reading text etc. At least half of the quests are like "I need X, go get me X" and that's really it. There's no "grip on life" to be had/gleaned in the majority of quests at all.

Most of the npc dialogue outside of quests is actually written a lot better and is more interesting than the quests themselves. The goblin zeppelin masters, for example.

0

u/Nyzan 5h ago

Let's not pretend that the overwhelming majority of vanilla quests are not extremely lackluster. Most of the quest prompts are just "Hello. I am person. I no like thing. Go kill thing.". This is what happens when you have 10 000 quests in a game. The reason why you remember the good classic quests more than good retail quests is because classic forced you to read quest prompts, and you were much younger when you played classic so you more easily immersed yourself in the world. Not because the writers were Tolkien 2.0.

3

u/NorskKiwi 16h ago

Reads like AI tbh

5

u/thrillho145 18h ago

Yes it sucks and need to change.

2

u/Kittencab00dles 13h ago

Finally a complaint I agree with!

2

u/BioDefault 18h ago

For newer players this is definitely rough, and for everyone it's an insult to the design of the game.

To be fair, though, anyone familiar with Undercity would know where to go when the context is about making abominations and a giant stormy heart to go in one.

1

u/Vlisa 17h ago

I feel this may be a zone-by-zone issue. I felt Hyjal did a good job of directing players. (There were a few small hiccups.) But maybe I’m exclusive in that opinion.

1

u/DefinitelyNotATheist 16h ago

100% agreed. every first blurb section of the quest should say who or where to bring it to.

1

u/tethysian 15h ago

Really kind of crazy that they want us all to be questing, but presume no one is relying on reading the quest instructions. This is game is designed for leveling guides.

1

u/ghidawi 14h ago

I use an addon to add markers to quests without spoiling what to do and where to go, and it's pretty handy for marking where you got a quest

1

u/jormugandr 10h ago

Just a guess, but it's probably the guy with the Abomination parts in the Apothecarium?

1

u/7se7 9h ago

I noticed this whenever I tried playing MOP Classic. Practically none of the quests in the Panda starting zone guide you on where to go through the text. It seemed like there came a point where quest text was written knowing that the player is just going to go to where the map objective tells them to go, so why bother write out directions.

1

u/jack3moto 9h ago

This was how a lot of quests were in original vanilla… so personally I think this is fitting.

1

u/kah530 8h ago

lol get a load of this guy he out here reading quests

1

u/Careless_Author_2247 6h ago

This quest was Vanilla

1

u/Remidial 5h ago

One of the questions for dustwallow marsh dungeon told me that a group of people came passing by their village and he’s worried about them so go check on them. The. The quest description said something like go find their dead bodies. It’s just a straight up spoiler lol. Seems written by ai to me

•

u/CartoonistDismal2818 4h ago edited 4h ago

When you mentioned how they're "written" I actually thought you were going to point out the fact that many Forever quests often have double spaces after the period. Though that's technically the old quests, not the new ones.

Of course, that was still common in 2004. Reminds me of going back and looking at my college papers from that time, and how bizarre it looks to have two spaces after periods and other terminating punctuation! I guess technically it's been there all along had I gone back and done older quests at any point, even in Retail, but I really haven't. This is the first time seeing many of the older quests in decades.

•

u/Devaz321 4h ago

Not a quest but i like this:

Thick Hide Level 60 Talent Requires Druid Requires level 1 While in Bear Form, Cat Form, Dire Bear Form, or Moonkin Form, you gain 180 additional base Armor per level and another 0.80 base Armor for each point of defense skill beyond five times your level. This amount can be further increased by multipliers from those forms.

•

u/jacenat 4h ago

yes, this is a huge issue for immersion as you HAVE to have addons enabled to help you quest.

•

u/eer_00 2h ago

The new quests universally have terrible writing.

•

u/Shortlinec 1h ago

I have a gripe with the Craftsman's writ's quest as well. It should say in the quest log or on the piece of paper you get where roughly the drop off point is for the item. As far as I know it just says to check your map for the drop off location.

1

u/GBPackers0480 18h ago

this isn't just "new" quests this has been a problem since vanilla. I remember having this issue so many times before I used addons. Insane they don't all have a "turn into ___ when done" line somwehwere

2

u/tethysian 15h ago

Vanilla doesn't have quest objectives on the map so it had to tell you where to find things. I always quest without addons and it's generally not an issue.

1

u/Snorepod 13h ago

I love all these people acting like vanilla perfectly described everything because they have played it so much they know exactly what to do.

Vanilla has similar flaws with certain quests so idk what the issue is

1

u/O-Castitatis-Lilium 12h ago

Doesn't it say it at the bottom part that is cut off? I haven't had a problem with classic quests, then again, last time I played classic was a WHILE back.

2

u/Endiamon 8h ago

No, nothing is cut off

1

u/Bearspoole 5h ago

We’re talking about new quests in a new version of classic

-2

u/VirtU_Art 12h ago

It literally talks about abomination creation. The only place you could possibly think that'd be about would be in Undercity.

1

u/Endiamon 8h ago

What an insane assertion when one of the most famous quest chains in WoW revolves around creating an abomination in Duskwood

0

u/False_Snow7754 12h ago

I think the idea they went with, and thought was in the vanilla spirit, is that you should remember who gave you the quest, not rely on quest text to tell you where to hand it in.

I remember having a notepad on my desk because I kept forgetting where to turn stuff in.

-9

u/Different-Mall-8357 19h ago

but that’s the vanilla way. it’s what people are wanting.

back in the day we had to go to alahkazam to find that information at least you guys have addons now

9

u/CannonFodder_G 19h ago

Nah the vanilla quests directly had a part in there that told you who to return to, which is the OP's issue. Not finding the lizard, but figuring out who to go to after you find him.

It's definitely a new quest issue, and since we have 40 quests now I've run into that issue when my questie is so full I can't see the icons and want to puzzle it out myself. Nothing in the quest tells you who gave it to you in a way you can find them without a google search.

The difference of "Sir Ivan wants this heart" vs. "Sir Ivan in the Apothecary wing of the Undercity wants this heart". Vanilla did the latter. Forever quests are doing the former, and it's a problem.

2

u/Lokja 18h ago

Vanilla was all over the place. Some did, some didn't. If you couldn't remember there was always Thotbot

1

u/Different-Mall-8357 18h ago

they most certainly did not do that every time and not even routinely either.

3

u/hugcub 19h ago

OG vanilla didn’t have quest icons showing you where to go either you just had to figure it out by wandering all over the place. Had to actually read the quest text for clues about where to go and what to do.

2

u/Reanthe 19h ago

And it wasn't always correct!

-5

u/LordDShadowy53 19h ago

I think the description is very good. But yeah should say to turn in UC. But that alone doesn’t make it bad

6

u/SoVRuneseeker 19h ago

"I hear there is a thunder lizard there of impressive size"

What? Where? Why does it say this before telling us where to go?

Either the writer isn't great at english, or it's an AI script. The second "there" in the sentence is just word waffle.

0

u/czaxnet 17h ago

I mean, that was part of the original design, you were supposed to solve the mystery of what you're supposed to do first, then complete the objective. Old quests are written in the same manner and they definitely weren't written using AI.

You're not a new player as far as I can tell, so I'm surprised that you're complaining about the vagueness of quest text like it hasn't always been a thing in WoW.

4

u/SoVRuneseeker 17h ago

Most quests will have everything you need to know in the text? There's nothing vague here, and that's not my complaint.

My complaint is that the sentence makes no sense coming before the location. It's written by someone that either doesn't speak good English or an AI was my only point- nothing about quests being vague.

•

u/Pinewood74 4h ago

My complaint is that the sentence makes no sense coming before the location.

I mean... you didn't quote a sentence. You quoted a part of a sentence. And that sentence includes the location.

Personally, I think the sentence is written how people talk. That's why it's also got a comma splice. (Or is it even a comma splice? It's just an extra comma. So indicating a pause in speech, imo)

-2

u/LordDShadowy53 18h ago

It literally says down below in the thousand needles…. Such a small and little nitpicking y’all have.

6

u/SoVRuneseeker 18h ago

Yes, i mentioned that. But it's still written poorly and i never said it was a big problem? Such a small and little nitpicking shoulda been fixed during beta. This isn't a small indie company.

-2

u/LordDShadowy53 16h ago

I would prefer the focus on bigger bugs than your nitpicking tbh

3

u/SoVRuneseeker 15h ago

And i'd prefer that there were no bugs at all, big or small. But unless all these bugs both big and small have attention drawn to them they'll stay undetected.

My complaint is here to improve the game, even if it is only very slightly in a seemingly pointless place. Why are you complaining?

1

u/tethysian 15h ago

So they've narrowed it down to "somewhere in this zone"?

-3

u/Laggo 17h ago

I don't get it. This is in a quest chain where if you were paying attention you already know where to go?

-1

u/VirtU_Art 12h ago

You don't remember where the abomination creation lab is? Really?

-1

u/Gold-Cry-7520 9h ago

You know, I have a radical idea for you.

Ask.

Ask the person who shared it. With your words. You think Forever is just Classic+, right? Then interact with your fellow player and ask questions, like you would in Classic

-6

u/Entropy-037 18h ago

If you played the game like they thought you would, this wouldn't be a problem. Blizzard thinks you might actually pay attention to what you're doing. Obviously that's not a good assumption to make so knowing the name of the NPC involved would be useful, assuming you can't remember from when you collected the quest. You are asking blizzard to remember details for you though

1

u/tethysian 15h ago

If you played the game like they thought you would,

With rxp

-3

u/suture224 18h ago

Isn't this part of the long abomination quest line started around Ruins? Wouldn't it be silly to always include this guy's location for the turn in? 

Is this Netflix where they have to recap everything?

1

u/Endiamon 7h ago

The fuck is this nostalgia bait larp? The choice clearly isn't between memorizing every questgiver and being able to consult your quest log to see written directions for where they are, it's between being able to naturally follow a quest if you use your brain versus having to look things up online or follow an arrow because that's what the devs assume you'll do.

-3

u/Rohnur 16h ago

Read the quest when you pick it up, and remember who gave it to you.

Not everything is handed to you on a plate.

-15

u/greenegg28 19h ago

“I have no idea who gave me this quest”

Brother, this is a you not paying attention problem.

Like I guess they could’ve put it in the objective, but I also don’t think it’s unfair to expect players to pay some sort of attention, especially if they’re choosing to play with objective markers off.

6

u/Takseen 19h ago

I mean the point of a quest log is to...keep a log of this information. You might have picked up this quest 2 hours ago or 2 days ago or 2 weeks ago. It should function even with objective markers turned off

4

u/Caspus1 19h ago

This is a casual game not a memory game. When you have 20 quests scattered across multiple zones to do and none of the new quests give any clues to who gave it/where to take it to or back I highly doubt you're going to remember on the top of your head.

Otherwise why would all the oldschool classic quests give very clear directions if the player is expected to also memorize everything.

3

u/snukb 19h ago

When you have 20 to 30 quests in your log, are you going to remember who gave you each and every one of them, especially with how vanilla quest design would often do things like have you grab a Thousand Needles quest in Westfall at level 12 that it doesn't expect you to complete until level 30? It's not too much to ask to have basic info like "Human Enpeecee in Westfall wants you to bring her the still-beating heart of Stormheart."

2

u/Sarmattius 19h ago

no, all old quests state the objective clearly.

1

u/marcofifth 19h ago

I wouldn't say clearly.

There are many quests that require one to have further context and use their deductive reasoning, but I cannot recall any quests that leave you without a paddle.

-6

u/Cliepl 17h ago

I don't see anything wrong here

-12

u/onetwo3four5 19h ago

What's the annoyance?

11

u/Asthma_Queen 19h ago

read what OP wrote

6

u/Kaffe-Mumriken 19h ago

Read? I skip all quest texts

2

u/onetwo3four5 19h ago

I can't see anything but a screenshot of the quest text

3

u/Moose_M 19h ago

I have no idea who gave me this quest. I have no idea where to turn it in. It's sorted in the Undercity section of my quest log, fine, but just from a basic gameplay point of view the quest objective should include who to turn it in to. My Drowned City quests are the same, out of the three I have, none of them tell me who gave me the quest or who to turn it in to, and being sorted in the Drowned City section of my log doesn't help. I shouldn't have to turn on the in-game Questie to know. All my quests that are actually from vanilla say very explicitly who to turn the quest in to in the quest text.

Yes this is still playable, but come on, this is obviously a bad change in the new quests.

2

u/onetwo3four5 19h ago

Thank you!

0

u/AzraelTB 19h ago

I skipped it now I don't know where OP is to turn in my response.

4

u/Niclmaki 19h ago

The name of the NPC that gave the quest isn’t mentioned anywhere. Nor their location.

Most vanilla quests end with, “Return to X person after performing Y and gathering Z in W city.

0

u/Interesting-Luck3608 10h ago

Some of the old and new quests wrote their cardinal directions wrong which is a weird thing to get wrong.

-5

u/HoneyBeeHotHive 19h ago

There are games (Elden ring) that have no quest log and don’t tell you anything. You have to either remember or write it all down yourself.

At least this one tells you where to go and who to kill.

3

u/UnoriginalStanger 17h ago

Elden Ring quests are conceptually completely different from wow quests.

Elden Ring also has the worst quests of the soulsborne because there at too many places to go and check. I say this as a defender of their quests in general.

2

u/guimontag 18h ago

Bro is this the elder ring subreddit lmao? Why even bring that up or make that inane comparison lmaoooo. Like 99% of quests in vanilla told you where to turn in, half the new ones don't, obviously that's a fucking issue

-3

u/HoneyBeeHotHive 18h ago

This is how it’s always been. I’ve never used questie, so I’ve experienced this same shit back in 2019 era.

I brought up a different game within the RPG genre to tell you about quests and quest logs. You know, exactly the topic on hand. Was that really difficult for you to understand?? lol

This isn’t retail. We don’t want hand outs. Some games don’t baby their players at all.

1

u/guimontag 16h ago

lmao are you incapable of reading the text of the post that OP made? the issue isn't "this quest doesn't tell me exactly where to go and what to do" it's "this quest doesn't say who the giver was and where to return it" lmaoooooooooooooooo wow schools REALLY are this bad nowadays huh?

-2

u/Just_Breakfast6327 18h ago

Vanilla quests were written before quest tracking existed so you had to read the quest to know what to do. I remember getting very good at quickly parsing a quest text to identify the location of what I had to kill, and also several times I couldn't and wandered around aimlessly.

Obviously the people making these quests know everybody is using quest tracking, it's built into the game by default at this point. I hear what you're saying and I agree it could have done a better job but I guess it's probably not that big a deal, 99% of people don't read these anyway.